ColumnistsMay 21, 2025
Edahn’s Take: Analyzing the 2025 ‘$100 Million Supersellers’ List ColumnistsJun 17, 2025
Peter Smith: Is Your Comp Plan a Hiring Hindrance?
If you want to attract good salespeople and generate a stream of “sleeping money” for your jewelry store, then you are going to have to pay.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
I’ve had a few conversations lately with retailers who have become exasperated at their inability to attract quality sales talent.
While the frustration is not new, what struck me was how, in these cases, the challenges were obvious, self-inflicted, and eminently fixable.
Some might prefer to believe otherwise, but sales is a competitive sport. It doesn’t have to be a “contact” sport, but it is competitive.
Failure to acknowledge that doesn’t make it any less so, but it often serves as a detriment to attracting (and retaining) talented salespeople.
Why some business owners choose to ignore the competitive nature of sales and choose to pay a base salary or hourly wage is not always clear, but one of the oft-cited excuses is they want to protect their culture.
“I don’t want my customers to be pressured into buying when they come in.”
OK, that’s an interesting one, but unless you are a not-for-profit entity, your business relies on customers making buying decisions.
Given the psychological research on how little we as humans know about our own motivations and drivers (it’s widely believed that our subconscious generates about 95 percent of our thoughts), we need talented salespeople to positively influence and inspire buying behavior.
Related stories will be right here …
While the frustration is not new, what struck me was how, in these cases, the challenges were obvious, self-inflicted, and eminently fixable.
Some might prefer to believe otherwise, but sales is a competitive sport. It doesn’t have to be a “contact” sport, but it is competitive.
Failure to acknowledge that doesn’t make it any less so, but it often serves as a detriment to attracting (and retaining) talented salespeople.
Why some business owners choose to ignore the competitive nature of sales and choose to pay a base salary or hourly wage is not always clear, but one of the oft-cited excuses is they want to protect their culture.
“I don’t want my customers to be pressured into buying when they come in.”
OK, that’s an interesting one, but unless you are a not-for-profit entity, your business relies on customers making buying decisions.
Given the psychological research on how little we as humans know about our own motivations and drivers (it’s widely believed that our subconscious generates about 95 percent of our thoughts), we need talented salespeople to positively influence and inspire buying behavior.
I’ve also heard, “I don’t want an environment where people are climbing over each other to get to the customer.”
Again, interesting, but sort of like a global pandemic, that happens, but rarely.
If you have established a culture of respect and support for your team and customers, there is absolutely no reason you should have that kind of mayhem, regardless of the compensation plan you deploy.
If you do, that’s a management issue, not a comp issue.
We can all agree that there is absolutely no excuse for salespeople fighting with each other to get to the customer first. Again, not quite as rare as a pandemic, but not the sort of thing one often sees in retail environments, and easily stamped out if witnessed.
Refusing to have a compensation plan that is not commission and/or bonus based is like cutting your head off to avoid a toothache. It definitely fixes one problem, but at what cost?
“Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures.”— Peter Smith
However much we want to believe otherwise, sales is a meritocracy and the best salespeople, those folks who wake up in the morning already thinking about what opportunities they are going to make happen that day, need to be paid accordingly.
That means they know what the scorecard looks like, they know exactly what they need to accomplish to be successful, and they have confidence that no one is putting a finger on the scale to curtail their success or pandering to their less motivated colleagues by having a comp plan that has mediocrity, not meritocracy, as its high watermark.
Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures. Doing so is not a guarantee that they will make six figures, but it tells them that there will be a clear path to getting there if their performance merits.
Make sure the commission or bonuses align with the company’s best interests.
Pay for profitable dollars, not gross sales. That is important in all business, but critical in stores where discounting is permitted, or where an important brand is delivering short margins.
There’s an old chestnut in sales that says the best kind of business is when you have “sleeping money,” meaning subscription services, insurance, annuities, or any other streams of revenue that deliver repeat sales without you having to be present.
In retail, the best kind of “sleeping money” is top sales talent. When you and/or others are consumed with other aspects of the business, they’re making things happen. It’s how they are wired.
Hire that and compensate accordingly.
Happy retailing!
That means they know what the scorecard looks like, they know exactly what they need to accomplish to be successful, and they have confidence that no one is putting a finger on the scale to curtail their success or pandering to their less motivated colleagues by having a comp plan that has mediocrity, not meritocracy, as its high watermark.
Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures. Doing so is not a guarantee that they will make six figures, but it tells them that there will be a clear path to getting there if their performance merits.
Make sure the commission or bonuses align with the company’s best interests.
Pay for profitable dollars, not gross sales. That is important in all business, but critical in stores where discounting is permitted, or where an important brand is delivering short margins.
There’s an old chestnut in sales that says the best kind of business is when you have “sleeping money,” meaning subscription services, insurance, annuities, or any other streams of revenue that deliver repeat sales without you having to be present.
In retail, the best kind of “sleeping money” is top sales talent. When you and/or others are consumed with other aspects of the business, they’re making things happen. It’s how they are wired.
Hire that and compensate accordingly.
Happy retailing!
More on Columnists
The Latest
CollectionsSep 11, 2026
A Sapphire ‘Stardust’ Ring From Greenwich St. Jewelers The Latine-owned New York jeweler is marking two milestones this year: its 50th anniversary and the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks.
MajorsSep 11, 2026
The Wishing Place by JTV OpensThe jewelry retail broadcast network has sponsored a new space for Make-A-Wish East Tennessee on its campus in Knoxville.
Events & AwardsSep 11, 2026
The Edge Awards Scholarships to 2 Young Jewelry ProfessionalsThe recipients were recognized at the 24 Karat Club of the Southeastern United States’ annual banquet.
Brought to you by
Your Piece Could Be the One Editors Talk AboutSubmit your pieces for a chance to win in this year's competition.
MajorsSep 10, 2026
Lagos Founder Steven Lagos Steps Down as CEO Keith Rolfe, CFO and COO of Lagos, is now at the jewelry brand’s helm while Steven takes on the role of executive chairman.
Weekly QuizSep 10, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
CrimeSep 10, 2026
FBI Offers $50K Reward for ‘Most Wanted’ Fugitive in $1M Jewelry HeistAlberto Perez-Elias is one of four men charged in the armed robbery of a Cape Coral, Florida, jewelry store and remains at large.
AuctionsSep 10, 2026
Massive Matched Pair of Paraíba Tourmalines Head to Sotheby’sThe “Kat Florence Luminas” will be offered together as one lot and could fetch up to $637,000.
Brought to you by
Why More Jewelry Retailers Are Hosting Turnkey Estate Buying EventsRetailers are seeking new ways to attract customers, increase traffic, and create revenue – Estate buying events are a popular solution.
SourcingSep 10, 2026
AGTA Announces 4 Newly Elected DirectorsFour directors were elected to the AGTA board and will serve three-year terms beginning in February.
AuctionsSep 10, 2026
Former Sotheby’s, Christie’s Exec Appointed CEO of Julien’s Auctions Ken Citron joins the celebrity memorabilia-focused auction house ahead of its first week-long series of events in Abu Dhabi.
FinancialsSep 09, 2026
Signet Jewelers to ‘Double Down’ on Blue Nile Amid Strong SalesThe jewelry retailer said it sees opportunity at higher price points, particularly in natural diamonds for bridal and fashion.
IndependentsSep 09, 2026
Sarah Leonard Fine Jewelers Closes After Nearly 80 YearsThe Los Angeles-based, family-owned jeweler was founded by Lenny and Sunny Friedman in 1946.
SourcingSep 09, 2026
Fura Gems Notes ‘Remarkable’ Interest in Larger Rubies at Latest SaleThe auction, held in Bangkok, was 96 percent sold by lot, with nearly 411,000 carats of Mozambiquan rubies sold.
MajorsSep 09, 2026
Stuller’s Latest Catalog Includes Its New Demi-Fine CollectionFine Jewelry 2027-2028 has more than 900 new styles, including silver, gold-filled, gold-plated sterling silver, and vermeil jewelry.
Policies & IssuesSep 09, 2026
8 Key Changes the FTC Made to the Jewelry Guides: A Refresher Learn more about the new terms for lab-grown diamonds and composite gemstones, and the major changes in store for precious metals jewelry.
IndependentsSep 08, 2026
Ricky Bromberg, Longtime President of Bromberg & Co., Dies at 67 Bromberg is remembered as a Southern gentleman who always wore a suit and tie and treated others with kindness.
TrendsSep 08, 2026
Amanda’s Style File: A Hot Take on September’s Birthstone With high durability and a wide range of colors to choose from, sapphires may be the ultimate birthstone, Gizzi claims.
MajorsSep 08, 2026
Former Tiffany & Co. Exec Joins Exemplar Luxury GroupGretchen Koback Pursel is the new chief people officer at the company formerly known as Saks Global.
IndependentsSep 04, 2026
Orloff Jewelers Will Soon Unveil a Bigger, Better LocationThe California jeweler is renovating its store in Fresno, with plans to show off the new space in December.
CollectionsSep 04, 2026
Chelsea Gabrielle Transforms Pilates Reformer Springs Into Ring A lifelong practitioner of Pilates, Gabrielle looked to the springs’ tension and suspension when creating this ring, our Piece of the Week.
Events & AwardsSep 04, 2026
JCK Industry Fund Accepting 2027 ApplicationsThe deadline to apply is Nov. 13.
AuctionsSep 04, 2026
Christie's Names New Global Head of WatchesThe auction house has promoted Remi Guillemin, formerly its head of watches for the Americas and EMEA, to the role.
EditorsSep 03, 2026
Q&A: Simon G.’s CEO on Why He Won’t Use AI for Jewelry DesignZaven Ghanimian discussed the value of human craftsmanship and where the implementation of artificial intelligence does work.
Events & AwardsSep 03, 2026
Here Are the First Recipients of Nina Pugliese Memorial Scholarship Jewelers of America also revealed the recipients of the Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship and its own scholarship programs.
WatchesSep 03, 2026
Robert Pattinson Joins Jaeger-LeCoultre as Brand AmbassadorThe British actor, known for his roles in “Twilight” and “The Odyssey,” will star in a campaign for the Master Control Chronometre.
CollectionsSep 03, 2026
Sydney Evan Celebrates 25 Years With 4 New CollectionsThe “Confetti Disco,” “Champagne Cheers,” “Tuxedo,” and “Classic Punk” jewelry collections each capture a distinct spirit of celebration.
CrimeSep 02, 2026
CA Jeweler Gets 5 Years in ‘Phantom Rolex’ Ponzi SchemeNelson Holdo of Newport Beach pleaded guilty to multiple counts of felony grand theft and writing bad checks and was sentenced Monday.
