ColumnistsMay 21, 2025
Edahn’s Take: Analyzing the 2025 ‘$100 Million Supersellers’ List ColumnistsJun 17, 2025
Peter Smith: Is Your Comp Plan a Hiring Hindrance?
If you want to attract good salespeople and generate a stream of “sleeping money” for your jewelry store, then you are going to have to pay.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
I’ve had a few conversations lately with retailers who have become exasperated at their inability to attract quality sales talent.
While the frustration is not new, what struck me was how, in these cases, the challenges were obvious, self-inflicted, and eminently fixable.
Some might prefer to believe otherwise, but sales is a competitive sport. It doesn’t have to be a “contact” sport, but it is competitive.
Failure to acknowledge that doesn’t make it any less so, but it often serves as a detriment to attracting (and retaining) talented salespeople.
Why some business owners choose to ignore the competitive nature of sales and choose to pay a base salary or hourly wage is not always clear, but one of the oft-cited excuses is they want to protect their culture.
“I don’t want my customers to be pressured into buying when they come in.”
OK, that’s an interesting one, but unless you are a not-for-profit entity, your business relies on customers making buying decisions.
Given the psychological research on how little we as humans know about our own motivations and drivers (it’s widely believed that our subconscious generates about 95 percent of our thoughts), we need talented salespeople to positively influence and inspire buying behavior.
Related stories will be right here …
While the frustration is not new, what struck me was how, in these cases, the challenges were obvious, self-inflicted, and eminently fixable.
Some might prefer to believe otherwise, but sales is a competitive sport. It doesn’t have to be a “contact” sport, but it is competitive.
Failure to acknowledge that doesn’t make it any less so, but it often serves as a detriment to attracting (and retaining) talented salespeople.
Why some business owners choose to ignore the competitive nature of sales and choose to pay a base salary or hourly wage is not always clear, but one of the oft-cited excuses is they want to protect their culture.
“I don’t want my customers to be pressured into buying when they come in.”
OK, that’s an interesting one, but unless you are a not-for-profit entity, your business relies on customers making buying decisions.
Given the psychological research on how little we as humans know about our own motivations and drivers (it’s widely believed that our subconscious generates about 95 percent of our thoughts), we need talented salespeople to positively influence and inspire buying behavior.
I’ve also heard, “I don’t want an environment where people are climbing over each other to get to the customer.”
Again, interesting, but sort of like a global pandemic, that happens, but rarely.
If you have established a culture of respect and support for your team and customers, there is absolutely no reason you should have that kind of mayhem, regardless of the compensation plan you deploy.
If you do, that’s a management issue, not a comp issue.
We can all agree that there is absolutely no excuse for salespeople fighting with each other to get to the customer first. Again, not quite as rare as a pandemic, but not the sort of thing one often sees in retail environments, and easily stamped out if witnessed.
Refusing to have a compensation plan that is not commission and/or bonus based is like cutting your head off to avoid a toothache. It definitely fixes one problem, but at what cost?
“Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures.”— Peter Smith
However much we want to believe otherwise, sales is a meritocracy and the best salespeople, those folks who wake up in the morning already thinking about what opportunities they are going to make happen that day, need to be paid accordingly.
That means they know what the scorecard looks like, they know exactly what they need to accomplish to be successful, and they have confidence that no one is putting a finger on the scale to curtail their success or pandering to their less motivated colleagues by having a comp plan that has mediocrity, not meritocracy, as its high watermark.
Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures. Doing so is not a guarantee that they will make six figures, but it tells them that there will be a clear path to getting there if their performance merits.
Make sure the commission or bonuses align with the company’s best interests.
Pay for profitable dollars, not gross sales. That is important in all business, but critical in stores where discounting is permitted, or where an important brand is delivering short margins.
There’s an old chestnut in sales that says the best kind of business is when you have “sleeping money,” meaning subscription services, insurance, annuities, or any other streams of revenue that deliver repeat sales without you having to be present.
In retail, the best kind of “sleeping money” is top sales talent. When you and/or others are consumed with other aspects of the business, they’re making things happen. It’s how they are wired.
Hire that and compensate accordingly.
Happy retailing!
That means they know what the scorecard looks like, they know exactly what they need to accomplish to be successful, and they have confidence that no one is putting a finger on the scale to curtail their success or pandering to their less motivated colleagues by having a comp plan that has mediocrity, not meritocracy, as its high watermark.
Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures. Doing so is not a guarantee that they will make six figures, but it tells them that there will be a clear path to getting there if their performance merits.
Make sure the commission or bonuses align with the company’s best interests.
Pay for profitable dollars, not gross sales. That is important in all business, but critical in stores where discounting is permitted, or where an important brand is delivering short margins.
There’s an old chestnut in sales that says the best kind of business is when you have “sleeping money,” meaning subscription services, insurance, annuities, or any other streams of revenue that deliver repeat sales without you having to be present.
In retail, the best kind of “sleeping money” is top sales talent. When you and/or others are consumed with other aspects of the business, they’re making things happen. It’s how they are wired.
Hire that and compensate accordingly.
Happy retailing!
More on Columnists
The Latest
AuctionsDec 10, 2025
Francis Ford Coppola’s Watch Sells for $10.8MThe filmmaker’s personal F.P. Journe “FFC” prototype was the star of Phillips’ recent record-setting watch auction in New York.
WatchesDec 10, 2025
There’s A New Rolex Boutique in MiamiThe new location in the Design District pays homage to Miami’s Art Deco heritage and its connection to the ocean.
SurveysDec 10, 2025
Consumer Confidence Drops in November Inflations, tariffs, and politics—including the government shutdown—were among consumers’ top concerns last month.
Brought to you by
Impacting Tomorrow TodayHow Jewelers of America’s 20 Under 40 are leading to ensure a brighter future for the jewelry industry.
SourcingDec 10, 2025
NAJA Announces Details for 2026 ‘Ace It’ Winter Conference“Longtime favorite” presenters, as well as first-time speakers, will lead talks and workshops at the annual event in Tucson next year.
Weekly QuizDec 04, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Events & AwardsDec 10, 2025
MJSA Names 2025 Responsible Design Challenge WinnerSilas Smith of Meridian Metalworks won the challenge with his pendant that blends Australian and American landscapes.
AuctionsDec 09, 2025
‘Desert Rose’ Diamond Sells for $8.8M in Abu DhabiThe sale of the 31.68-carat, sunset-hued stone was part of Sotheby’s first series of events and auctions in Abu Dhabi.
Brought to you by
Roseco Releases New Full-Line CatalogRoseco’s 704-page catalog showcases new lab-grown diamonds, findings, tools & more—available in print or interactive digital editions.
TrendsDec 09, 2025
‘Once Upon a Time,’ Guzema Debuted Its Holiday CollectionThe collection features characters and motifs from Ukrainian folklore, including an enchanted mirror and a magic egg.
TechnologyDec 09, 2025
Gemvision Releases Updated MatrixGoldMatrixGold 3.11, the newest version of the jewelry design program, offers more flexibility, precision, and creative control.
Events & AwardsDec 09, 2025
MJSA Showcase Pavilion Returning to JA New York The pavilion will be part of the 2026 JA New York Spring show, scheduled for March 15 to 17.
MajorsDec 08, 2025
Juell Kadet, a ‘Lifelong Pillar’ of Rogers & Hollands, Dies at 96Kadet, a 1994 National Jeweler Retailer Hall of Fame inductee, helped grow the family-owned retailer in the Chicago area and beyond.
TechnologyDec 08, 2025
You’ve Heard of Smart Watches and Rings; Meet Smart EarringsBilled as the world’s smallest wearable, Lumia Health’s new smart earrings have a health tracker subtly embedded in the back.
TrendsDec 08, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: Celebrating December’s BirthstonesDon’t let those with December birthdays feel blue. Help them celebrate their month with blue zircon, turquoise, and tanzanite.
CollectionsDec 05, 2025
Piece of the Week: Robinson Pelham’s ‘Tsar Star’ EarringsThe new pink sapphire version of the piece dances with its wearer in the brand’s “Icons After Dark” holiday campaign.
TrendsDec 05, 2025
Pantone’s Color of the Year for 2026 Is … WhiteA choice that’s generated a lot of commentary, Pantone says “Cloud Dancer” marks a fresh start and encourages relaxation and creativity.
MajorsDec 05, 2025
Stuller Releases ‘Wrapped in Wonder’ CampaignThe manufacturer’s holiday campaign features a gift guide filled with trending designs and jewelry that can be personalized.
CrimeDec 04, 2025
Man Arrested After Allegedly Swallowing Fabergé Egg PendantThe man was charged with theft, accused of ingesting the necklace while in a jewelry store in Auckland, New Zealand.
IndependentsDec 04, 2025
Step Inside JR Dunn Jewelers’ Giant New Store The Florida independent expanded its store from 8,000 to 14,000 square feet, fulfilling the vision of its late co-founder, Jim Dunn.
Supplier BulletinDec 04, 2025
Introducing Shop Natural Day: A New Movement Celebrating Natural DiamondsSponsored by De Beers Group
WatchesDec 04, 2025
Casio Shrinks its G-Shock WatchThe classic 5600 series G-Shock has been scaled down to about a tenth of its size, becoming a fully functioning watch ring.
Events & AwardsDec 04, 2025
AGA Announces 2026 Tucson Speaker LineupThe association’s annual conference and gala will take place Feb. 4, 2026, during the Tucson gem shows.
Events & AwardsDec 04, 2025
CBG Announces Speaker Lineup for 2026 Miami Event The January show will include a workshop for jewelry retailers on implementing AI to strengthen their businesses.
TrendsDec 03, 2025
Miley Cyrus Debuts Edgy Engagement RingFellow musician Maxx Morando proposed to the star with a chunky, cushion-cut diamond ring designed by Jacquie Aiche.
Policies & IssuesDec 03, 2025
Costco Joins Growing Wave of Retailers Suing for Tariff Refunds The retailer, which sells billions in fine jewelry and watches, is suing the Trump administration and U.S. Customs and Border Patrol.
SurveysDec 03, 2025
A Record 202.9M Shoppers Turned Out Thanksgiving WeekendBlack Friday is still the most popular shopping day over the five-day holiday weekend, as per the National Retail Federation’s survey.
AuctionsDec 03, 2025
Fabergé’s 'The Winter Egg' Achieves Record $30MThe historic egg, crafted for Russia's ruling family prior to the revolution, was the star of Christie’s recent auction of works by Fabergé.
