Peter Smith: Is Your Comp Plan a Hiring Hindrance?
If you want to attract good salespeople and generate a stream of “sleeping money” for your jewelry store, then you are going to have to pay.

While the frustration is not new, what struck me was how, in these cases, the challenges were obvious, self-inflicted, and eminently fixable.
Some might prefer to believe otherwise, but sales is a competitive sport. It doesn’t have to be a “contact” sport, but it is competitive.
Failure to acknowledge that doesn’t make it any less so, but it often serves as a detriment to attracting (and retaining) talented salespeople.
Why some business owners choose to ignore the competitive nature of sales and choose to pay a base salary or hourly wage is not always clear, but one of the oft-cited excuses is they want to protect their culture.
“I don’t want my customers to be pressured into buying when they come in.”
OK, that’s an interesting one, but unless you are a not-for-profit entity, your business relies on customers making buying decisions.
Given the psychological research on how little we as humans know about our own motivations and drivers (it’s widely believed that our subconscious generates about 95 percent of our thoughts), we need talented salespeople to positively influence and inspire buying behavior.
I’ve also heard, “I don’t want an environment where people are climbing over each other to get to the customer.”
Again, interesting, but sort of like a global pandemic, that happens, but rarely.
If you have established a culture of respect and support for your team and customers, there is absolutely no reason you should have that kind of mayhem, regardless of the compensation plan you deploy.
If you do, that’s a management issue, not a comp issue.
We can all agree that there is absolutely no excuse for salespeople fighting with each other to get to the customer first. Again, not quite as rare as a pandemic, but not the sort of thing one often sees in retail environments, and easily stamped out if witnessed.
Refusing to have a compensation plan that is not commission and/or bonus based is like cutting your head off to avoid a toothache. It definitely fixes one problem, but at what cost?
“Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures.”— Peter Smith
That means they know what the scorecard looks like, they know exactly what they need to accomplish to be successful, and they have confidence that no one is putting a finger on the scale to curtail their success or pandering to their less motivated colleagues by having a comp plan that has mediocrity, not meritocracy, as its high watermark.
Instead of advertising an hourly wage, advertise that successful candidates will have an opportunity to earn six figures. Doing so is not a guarantee that they will make six figures, but it tells them that there will be a clear path to getting there if their performance merits.
Make sure the commission or bonuses align with the company’s best interests.
Pay for profitable dollars, not gross sales. That is important in all business, but critical in stores where discounting is permitted, or where an important brand is delivering short margins.
There’s an old chestnut in sales that says the best kind of business is when you have “sleeping money,” meaning subscription services, insurance, annuities, or any other streams of revenue that deliver repeat sales without you having to be present.
In retail, the best kind of “sleeping money” is top sales talent. When you and/or others are consumed with other aspects of the business, they’re making things happen. It’s how they are wired.
Hire that and compensate accordingly.
Happy retailing!
The Latest

The stone’s two zones, one pink and one colorless, may have formed at two different times, the lab said.

Hollywood glamour meets Milanese sophistication in the design of Pomellato’s new store in Beverly Hills, California.

The New York City store showcases a chandelier with 1,500 carats of lab-grown diamonds designed by an FIT student.

You deserve to know what you are selling–to protect your customers as well as your business and your reputation.

The Museum of Arts and Design's new exhibition features 75 pieces by the designer, best known for her work in the “Black Panther” films.


Making its auction debut, "The Glowing Rose" is expected to fetch $20 million at the November jewelry sale in Geneva.

They were attacked on Oct. 15, as approximately 40 miners without licenses marched on the mine’s gate.

The upcoming show provides savvy retailers with the opportunity to stock their cases with best sellers in advance of the holiday season.

It took the masked thieves less than 10 minutes to steal eight irreplaceable jewels from two display cases in the museum’s Apollo Gallery.

Gemologist Lauren Gayda has previously worked at The Clear Cut, Taylor & Hart, and Effy Jewelry.

In 2026, the jewelry retailer will celebrate a milestone only a small percentage of family-owned businesses survive to see.

The new showcase dedicated to Italian jewelry design is set for Oct. 29-30.

Take a gaze at the sky with this pair of platinum diamond-set star earrings with blue lace agate drops.

Jeffrey Zimmer's decades of leadership at Reeds Jewelers are defined by integrity, a love of sourcing gemstones, and a heart for community.

The new high jewelry design and production process takes 30 days or less from concept to completion, the auction house said.

The holiday catalog for 2025 features never-before-seen images of more than 100 one-of-a-kind masterpieces.

The brand has released a second installment of its collection of traditional and non-traditional commitment heirlooms.

Corey rescued New England chain Day’s Jewelers, preserving its legacy with strong people skills, pragmatism, and a “get-it-done” attitude.

Charles Robinson Shay was sentenced to life in prison plus 120 years while his accomplice, Michael James McCormack, got 75 years.

Timepieces at Luxury will take place at The Venetian and, like Luxury, will be invitation-only for the first two days.

The auction house named a new global head of jewelry, as well as a new head of the jewelry department for the Americas.

As chairman of Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers, Tom Dixon has been tasked with honoring the past and shaping the future of the family-run store.

Katty Villapando Lyte and Mica Rencher received a $10,000 grant for their business, Shimmer Culture LLC.

The parents of the Dallas Mavericks rookie bought their engagement ring at a Day’s store in Bangor, Maine, in 1997.

The UK-based brand sourced the gemstones, which are fully traceable, from an artisanal mining community in Tanzania.

The trio of Advent calendars include a version with 18-karat gold and lab-grown diamond jewelry in a red lacquer jewelry box.

Created in collaboration with Nymphenburg Porcelain, the lock is part of a four-piece collection that took two years to bring to fruition.