ColumnistsApr 22, 2025
The PR Adviser: Building Buzz Through Word of MouthColumnistsMay 20, 2025
Peter Smith: Leading Through Change
Communicating clearly with your staff is key to navigating turbulent times, writes columnist Peter Smith.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant and keynote speaker who teaches in-store sales psychology and hiring workshops. He is the author of "Hiring Squirrels," "Sell Something," and "The Sales Minute." Contact him at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com, via LinkedIn, or at 617-308-1580.
Editor’s Note: This story first appeared in the print edition of the 2025 State of the Majors. Click here to see the full issue.
Author and business guru Patrick Lencioni wrote of leaders, “Their top two priorities are to set the direction of the organization and then to ensure that people are reminded of it on a regular basis.”
Lencioni’s message, sublime in its clarity, has never been more apt than in the jewelry industry right now.
The evolution of retail has resulted in a significant contraction of stores, even as the total jewelry and watch business was stronger than ever from 2020 through 2024.
The reduction in the number of stores is not exclusive to jewelry and watch retail.
Coresight Research reported that 7,325 stores closed in 2024, and it predicts that 15,000 or more will shutter in 2025.
For all the changes in retail, two significant developments are undeniable.
First, retail has morphed into a hybrid model, where physical retail serves as the backbone of multi-tiered commerce that includes online and social.
The second development is that this seems to be giving way to a bifurcation of the retail landscape; price-driven on one end, and experiential/quality retail on the other.
The price model is best represented by Walmart and Costco while the experiential/quality model is best seen at stores such as Wegmans, Bass Pro Shops, Apple, Ulta Beauty, and Lululemon.
Customers identify with one or the other of the two models, and that is punishing stores in the middle, giants like Sears, Kmart, Kohl’s, and JCPenney,, which are already gone or on life support.
While some jewelry retailers choose to compete on the lower end of the price spectrum, the disappearing middle (where retailers attempt to be all things to all people) is getting hammered.
It is becoming increasingly difficult to carve out a competitive niche in that space and the model itself may need a complete rethink.
Generally speaking, we are unlikely to see an increase in foot traffic again.
If you remove auto and gas sales from the numbers, about 20 percent of all retail sales come from online sources. When you combine that with the decline in the number of malls, and mall traffic, smart retailers will evolve their strategy to meet the rapidly changing landscape.
Related stories will be right here …
Author and business guru Patrick Lencioni wrote of leaders, “Their top two priorities are to set the direction of the organization and then to ensure that people are reminded of it on a regular basis.”
Lencioni’s message, sublime in its clarity, has never been more apt than in the jewelry industry right now.
The evolution of retail has resulted in a significant contraction of stores, even as the total jewelry and watch business was stronger than ever from 2020 through 2024.
The reduction in the number of stores is not exclusive to jewelry and watch retail.
Coresight Research reported that 7,325 stores closed in 2024, and it predicts that 15,000 or more will shutter in 2025.
For all the changes in retail, two significant developments are undeniable.
First, retail has morphed into a hybrid model, where physical retail serves as the backbone of multi-tiered commerce that includes online and social.
The second development is that this seems to be giving way to a bifurcation of the retail landscape; price-driven on one end, and experiential/quality retail on the other.
The price model is best represented by Walmart and Costco while the experiential/quality model is best seen at stores such as Wegmans, Bass Pro Shops, Apple, Ulta Beauty, and Lululemon.
Customers identify with one or the other of the two models, and that is punishing stores in the middle, giants like Sears, Kmart, Kohl’s, and JCPenney,, which are already gone or on life support.
While some jewelry retailers choose to compete on the lower end of the price spectrum, the disappearing middle (where retailers attempt to be all things to all people) is getting hammered.
It is becoming increasingly difficult to carve out a competitive niche in that space and the model itself may need a complete rethink.
Generally speaking, we are unlikely to see an increase in foot traffic again.
If you remove auto and gas sales from the numbers, about 20 percent of all retail sales come from online sources. When you combine that with the decline in the number of malls, and mall traffic, smart retailers will evolve their strategy to meet the rapidly changing landscape.
One of the cornerstones of this new reality must be initiatives designed to ensure a higher average ticket.
Lower price points can create the illusion of customer accessibility but won’t help a business if the retailer doesn’t find a way to drive more foot traffic and/or improve conversion rates.
To that end, all retailers must have a robust and active customer relationship management (CRM) system.
I’ve seen data showing returning customers are 70 percent more likely to buy than new customers with an average retail ticket that is 30 percent higher.
Once you’ve decided on your direction for CRM, lean into it at every touchpoint. It ought to become a litmus test for every dollar spent, and for every important decision made, or not made.
Hire for it, train for it, compensate for it, and be prepared to make difficult choices if people or initiatives don’t align with your vision.
Have the humility to accept you don’t have all the answers and get a coach outside of your organization to keep you sane while you drive your business forward.
Before you make tough choices, invite debate to make sure your path forward doesn’t have unintended, damaging consequences.
However, once you’ve made the decision to move forward, be like Cortés and burn your boats.
Whatever direction a leader chooses to chart for their business, demonstrating the leadership qualities to clearly articulate that vision, and the commitment and communication acumen to keep that message top of mind, is critical.
As you double down or reinvent your model, your people will always be better for hearing the truth and knowing where the business is headed. There is nothing worse than ambiguity to kill morale.
Make sure you have a short-term scorecard, but a map for where you are going in the long term.
Focus on the things that will make the biggest difference in your business and control the controllables. You can’t impact the stock market, the weather, or the number of Saturdays in December.
Management expert John Kotter often talked about building a coalition for change. By that he meant hiring the right people, creating a trusting environment, and developing a common goal.
That seems like a reasonable plan to me.
Happy retailing!
Editors' Picks
Sponsored by
More on Columnists
The Latest
SurveysAug 21, 2026
These Are 2026’s Hottest Retailers, Says NRFThe retailers at the top of the list offer affordable products and fun, discovery-fueled experiences.
WatchesAug 21, 2026
Bremont Names Former Vacheron Constantin Exec CMODaniel Bing was formerly the marketing director for the Americas at Vacheron Constantin.
CollectionsAug 21, 2026
Bijules, Kamyen Serve Up ‘Topspin’ Tennis Bracelet Ahead of US OpenIn our Piece of the Week, the designers reimagine the tennis bracelet with green enamel wrapped around a strand of “Desert Diamonds.”
Brought to you by
Your Piece Could Be the One Editors Talk AboutSubmit your pieces for a chance to win in this year's competition.
PodcastsAug 20, 2026
Episode 8: Diamond Industry Update With David Bonaparte & Ronnie VanderLindenThe industry veterans join the podcast to discuss diamond marketing, the FTC Jewelry Guides, and lobbying for lower tariffs.
Weekly QuizAug 20, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
TechnologyAug 20, 2026
A New AI-Powered Gemstone Identification App Is HereFounder Vik Westermann said the app is a “starting point” to inspire people to work with appraisers and gem labs, not replace them.
AuctionsAug 20, 2026
Storied Unicorn Brooch Up for Auction Gallops to New Home The Verdura brooch, which belonged to the late Virginia Fortune Ryan Ogilvy, was sold to a private collector in Asia.
Brought to you by
Why More Jewelry Retailers Are Hosting Turnkey Estate Buying EventsRetailers are seeking new ways to attract customers, increase traffic, and create revenue – Estate buying events are a popular solution.
Events & AwardsAug 20, 2026
MJSA Education Foundation Names 5 Scholarship WinnersThe five students were awarded a total of $10,000 through the nonprofit’s 2026 “Future of Jewelry Making” scholarship.
MajorsAug 20, 2026
Plumb Club Elects 2026-2027 BoardSteven Lerche is now beginning his term as the youngest member to become president of The Plumb Club’s elected executive committee.
MajorsAug 19, 2026
Mike Alexander To Succeed Scott Murphy as Jewelers Mutual CEO Murphy will retire at the end of the year and Alexander, currently the company’s president, will take over at the start of 2027.
Policies & IssuesAug 19, 2026
Spinelli Kilcollin Embraces Dupes With Trade-In ProgramThe jeweler is encouraging customers who own lookalike rings to come into the store and trade them for credit towards an authentic piece.
MajorsAug 19, 2026
Zales Wants You to Wear Fine Jewelry Every DayThe new campaign, “You Are The Occasion,” discourages shoppers from saving their fine jewelry for special occasions only.
SourcingAug 19, 2026
Vasant Mehta, a Dedicated Diamond Industry Leader, Dies at 81Mehta led India’s GJEPC through the 2008 financial crisis and was respected worldwide for his wisdom, integrity, and knowledge.
CrimeAug 18, 2026
2 California Men Arrested in Fatal Vehicle Smash RobberyOne is the driver who allegedly crashed a car into a Sacramento jewelry store in April, striking a 71-year-old employee who later died.
CrimeAug 18, 2026
Thieves Snatch $1M in Jewelry From New Jersey Jeweler9lakha Jewelers in Iselin, New Jersey, was the target of a smash-and-grab robbery on Aug. 8.
Lab-GrownAug 18, 2026
Ring Concierge, Kendall Jenner’s Tequila Brand Collab on GiveawayThe jeweler has partnered with 818 Tequila to gift lab-grown diamond studs to a bride-to-be and their bridal party.
Events & AwardsAug 17, 2026
Exhibition on Louis Comfort Tiffany’s Studios to Open at The MetThe exhibition will feature more than 100 drawings of stained-glass lampshades, windows, and more, many created by women and émigrés.
CollectionsAug 17, 2026
Marquise Diamonds Dance in Spinelli Kilcollin’s ‘Wren’ CollectionMarquise-cut diamonds in drop charms are the center of the new collection, reflecting the movement of a dancer in modular styles.
Events & AwardsAug 17, 2026
There’s a New Jewelry Show Coming to FloridaThe inaugural Fort Lauderdale Jewelry, Antique, & Object Show will be held from Jan. 28 through Feb. 1, 2027.
IndependentsAug 14, 2026
Smyth Jewelers to Open Fourth LocationThe family-owned jeweler will open a new showroom in Bel Air, Maryland, this fall.
CrimeAug 14, 2026
Wife of Man Convicted in Jeweler’s Murder Sentenced for Conspiracy Amanda Ileana Hernandez is married to Carlos Hernandez, one of two men in prison for the 2024 murder of Michigan jeweler Hussein Murray.
TrendsAug 14, 2026
Paul Morelli’s Latest ‘Wavey Vine’ Earrings Embrace ColorThe reimagined jewel, our Piece of the Week, trades the diamonds in the original 1998 design for blue, pink, yellow, and green sapphires.
Supplier BulletinAug 13, 2026
Your Piece Could Be the One Editors Talk AboutSponsored by American Gem Trade Association
FinancialsAug 13, 2026
Pandora’s ‘Talisman’ Collection Shines, Lab-Grown Diamond Sales FallIn the United States, second-quarter sales were flat amid soft consumer sentiment and lower in-store traffic.
AuctionsAug 13, 2026
This Gold Cadbury ‘Conundrum’ Egg Set a World Auction RecordThe 22-karat gold egg, sold at Batemans Auctioneers in the U.K., was part of a 1980s treasure hunt ad campaign for Cadbury Creme Eggs.
SourcingAug 13, 2026
2,488-Carat Diamond, Largest Found in Botswana, Has a New Owner Lucara Diamond Corp., which recovered the “Motswedi” diamond from the Karowe mine, sold the stone for an undisclosed amount.
