ColumnistsMar 04, 2025
The Smart Lab: Using Online Events to Supercharge Sales ColumnistsMar 18, 2025
Peter Smith: The Importance of Culture in Hiring
Smith explores why a qualified candidate might still not be right for the job.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
Is it my imagination or are we getting important hiring decisions wrong with greater frequency than ever before?
Just in the past few days, I’ve heard of a handful of people leaving positions after very short periods.
This includes employees who relocated for their new roles and within weeks or months were gone, leaving a trail of disappointment, dejection, and wasted financial resources.
Why is that? Why are so many companies getting it so wrong?
Or, are the candidates getting it wrong?
Bob Corlett, the founder and president of Staffing Advisors, wrote in the Washington Business Journal, “Most people are hired for skills but fired for ‘fit.’ People who don’t ‘fit in’ don’t last long in most organizations.”
If we assume that those candidates were appropriately vetted, their backgrounds checked, and their suitability for the positions satisfied, then the disconnect between performance and expectation, as evidenced by the hasty departures, clearly points to a problem.
Nobody wants to start a new job and find out in short order that they’ve made a mistake.
No employer wants to undertake the oftentimes stressful and time-consuming process of interviewing people, salary negotiations, potential relocations, and the deployment of resources for onboarding to have to unwind so quickly.
So, why does that continue to happen and what can we do about it?
Culture has sometimes been described as the water in which a fish swims. He doesn’t know it’s water, he has no frame of reference, and he couldn’t describe it to you even if you spoke fish and asked him (don’t spend too much time thinking about what fish sounds like; it’s a secret language).
If we take the fish and water metaphor to its next logical step, consider what happens when a fish is removed from water.
That image of a fish fighting for survival is not unlike the feeling one has when they find themselves in a culture that is fundamentally misaligned with who they are.
That awful realization that this is a mistake can be felt from the employee and the employer, and it can happen very fast.
The resolution can sometimes be dragged out as all sides try to find a solution, but it more often ends in separation because cultural misalignment is almost impossible to reconcile.
Related stories will be right here …
Just in the past few days, I’ve heard of a handful of people leaving positions after very short periods.
This includes employees who relocated for their new roles and within weeks or months were gone, leaving a trail of disappointment, dejection, and wasted financial resources.
Why is that? Why are so many companies getting it so wrong?
Or, are the candidates getting it wrong?
Bob Corlett, the founder and president of Staffing Advisors, wrote in the Washington Business Journal, “Most people are hired for skills but fired for ‘fit.’ People who don’t ‘fit in’ don’t last long in most organizations.”
If we assume that those candidates were appropriately vetted, their backgrounds checked, and their suitability for the positions satisfied, then the disconnect between performance and expectation, as evidenced by the hasty departures, clearly points to a problem.
Nobody wants to start a new job and find out in short order that they’ve made a mistake.
No employer wants to undertake the oftentimes stressful and time-consuming process of interviewing people, salary negotiations, potential relocations, and the deployment of resources for onboarding to have to unwind so quickly.
So, why does that continue to happen and what can we do about it?
Culture has sometimes been described as the water in which a fish swims. He doesn’t know it’s water, he has no frame of reference, and he couldn’t describe it to you even if you spoke fish and asked him (don’t spend too much time thinking about what fish sounds like; it’s a secret language).
If we take the fish and water metaphor to its next logical step, consider what happens when a fish is removed from water.
That image of a fish fighting for survival is not unlike the feeling one has when they find themselves in a culture that is fundamentally misaligned with who they are.
That awful realization that this is a mistake can be felt from the employee and the employer, and it can happen very fast.
The resolution can sometimes be dragged out as all sides try to find a solution, but it more often ends in separation because cultural misalignment is almost impossible to reconcile.
Organizational culture (whether it is by design or default) rarely, if ever, adapts to a new hire; it has to be the other way around.
There are exceptions, of course. A strong new leader can change the culture of an organization if they have a mandate to do so, and the necessary time and resources to make it happen.
Culture-fit is an intangible, but it has very tangible consequences when we get it wrong.
The candidate can have the requisite experience, the right traits and intellect, great work ethic, and a willing and excited employer ready to engage them, and yet we still get things wrong, even with the most important hires.
So why do we continue to make these mistakes despite the heavy cost to business, customers, and the existing teams?
In short, we continue to make hiring mistakes because we vastly underestimate the importance of culture fit.
In “Unleash Your Primal Brain,” author Tim Ash wrote, “If someone is not in accord with the behaviors and beliefs of the group, they are, by definition, a poor team member. Severe social sanctions will often fall on such people. They will either be forced to conform or removed from the group.”
That does not make them bad people. They could be great people but just not right for your group.
In condensing a solution to its most basic level, I would suggest that we document those behaviors and beliefs and then build a small portfolio of questions to be included in your interviewing process. (You do have a structured interview process, yes? Phew! Can you imagine not having one!)
Use the culture questions to fully explore the things the candidate holds dear and the things that matter most to the organization. Do they align? Are there significant disconnects?
Putting those questions together and adding them to the interview process is a critical exercise in helping the hiring manager, and the candidate, to better explore the things that could derail a relationship that otherwise checked all the boxes on talent, work ethic, experience, etc.
Some of the things that culture questions can reveal is a candidate who does not respond well to being micro-managed in an organization that is all about that.
A candidate who is excited about innovation and change in an organization that is resistant to change.
A candidate with aspirations to grow in a family business where the senior team are all related and not going anywhere.
A candidate who is most comfortable working at a deliberate pace in a company that operates at warp speed, or vice versa.
A candidate who needs a months-long ramp-up and all sorts of handholding in an organization that needs you to hit the ground running with the minimum amount of help.
There are literally dozens of reasons why someone might not work out. Sometimes it is as insidious as an incumbent employee in the organization who casts a large and destructive shadow and who the company isn’t willing to address.
In “For The Culture,” author Marcus Collins wrote, “People are looking to be a part of something just as much as you are looking for people to join you. You just have to find the right congregational fit.”
Amen to that!
More on Columnists
The Latest
EditorsSep 15, 2025
Skipping the Necklace, Embracing Snakes: The Best Jewelry From the 2025 Emmy AwardsAssociate Editor Natalie Francisco shares eight of her favorite jewelry looks from the 77th annual Primetime Emmy Awards, held Sunday night.
SurveysSep 15, 2025
Resilient Shoppers to Boost Holiday Retail Sales, Says DeloitteIt’s predicting a rise in retail sales this holiday season despite economic uncertainty and elevated inflation.
SourcingSep 15, 2025
Gemfields Achieves $32M at High-Quality Emerald AuctionIt included the sale of the 11,685-carat “Imboo” emerald that was recently discovered at Kagem.
Brought to you by
reDollar.com Is Rolling Out the Next Level Jewelry, Diamond & Watch Consignment ProgramWith their unmatched services and low fees, reDollar.com is challenging some big names in the online consignment world.
SourcingSep 15, 2025
AGTA Elects 8 Members to Board of Directors The newly elected directors will officially take office in February 2026 and will be introduced at the organization’s membership meeting.
Weekly QuizSep 12, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
EditorsSep 12, 2025
Out & About: Mining Sapphires in Rock Creek, MontanaAssociate Editor Lauren McLemore headed out West for a visit to Potentate Mining’s operation hosted by gemstone wholesaler Parlé Gems.
TrendsSep 12, 2025
Piece of the Week: Arunashi’s Fordite and Rhodolite EarringsFordite is a man-made material created from the layers of dried enamel paint that dripped onto the floors of automotive factories.
Brought to you by
Rallying Call for the Jewelry Industry on Tariffs and Other Key IssuesJewelers of America is leading the charge to protect the industry amidst rising economic threats.
Events & AwardsSep 12, 2025
Al Gilbertson Wins 2025 Robert M. Shipley AwardGilbertson has worked as a researcher, jeweler, lapidary artist, appraiser, and business owner throughout his decades in the industry.
Policies & IssuesSep 11, 2025
Supreme Court to Hear Tariffs Case in November A decision likely won’t come until January 2026 at the earliest, and the tariffs remain in effect until then.
MajorsSep 11, 2025
Tabayer Opens Nordstrom Shop-In-ShopLocated in the revamped jewelry hall at the retailer’s New York City flagship, this opening is Tabayer’s first shop-in-shop.
SourcingSep 11, 2025
Need to Sell More Natural Diamonds? De Beers Has an App for ThatThe new, free app offers accessible educational content, like games and podcasts, for U.S. retailers.
MajorsSep 10, 2025
Stuller to Swap Gold Scrap for Full Credit to AccountAs the gold price rises, the manufacturer is offering a 100 percent payout through Sept. 30 for gold clean scrap.
SourcingSep 10, 2025
Tech Meets Style in the New Loewe x Jacob & Co. HeadphonesJacob & Co. partnered with the German technology company on two pairs of headphones, one set with diamonds and the other with sapphires.
TrendsSep 10, 2025
Tiffany & Co. Archival Jewels Bring Life to ‘Frankenstein’Guillermo del Toro’s 2025 “Frankenstein” will feature 27 jewels and objects from the storied brand, including pieces from its archives.
MajorsSep 10, 2025
24 Karat Club of New York’s Banquet to Return to Waldorf AstoriaThe Waldorf Astoria New York’s grand reopening this past summer means a homecoming for the industry group’s annual event.
SourcingSep 09, 2025
Anglo American to Merge With Canadian Copper Miner Anglo plans to merge with Teck Resources Ltd. to form Anglo Teck. The deal changes nothing about its plans to offload De Beers.
AuctionsSep 09, 2025
‘The Mellon Blue’ to Return to Auction, This Time at Christie’s The 9.51-carat fancy vivid blue diamond, which set two world auction records at Sotheby’s in 2014, is estimated to fetch up to $30 million.
AuctionsSep 09, 2025
Phillips Names Dianne Batista Head of Jewels, New YorkThe industry veteran joins the auction house as it looks to solidify its footprint in the jewelry market.
MajorsSep 09, 2025
MJSA Education Foundation Announces 2025 Scholarship WinnersThe nonprofit awarded four students pursuing a professional career in jewelry making and design with $2,250 each.
IndependentsSep 08, 2025
Take a Look Inside the New Korman Store in AustinThe Texas-based jeweler has also undergone a brand refresh, debuting a new website and logo.
MajorsSep 08, 2025
MJSA Is Officially Now Under JA’s UmbrellaThe two organizations have finalized and signed the affiliation agreement announced in May.
AuctionsSep 08, 2025
Sotheby’s To Auction ‘Exceptional’ Collection of JAR, Suzanne Belperron JewelsThe single-owner sale will headline Sotheby's inaugural jewelry auction at the Breuer building, its new global headquarters, this December.
Events & AwardsSep 08, 2025
27 Can’t-Miss Converge Sessions, Events From sunrise yoga to tariffs talks, these are some events to check out at the upcoming inaugural event.
CollectionsSep 05, 2025
Piece of the Week: Jamie Turner’s ‘Victoria’ Necklace The “Victoria” necklace features a labradorite hugged by diamond accents in 18-karat yellow gold.
Policies & IssuesSep 05, 2025
Trump Takes Tariffs Case to the Supreme Court Two lower courts have moved to block the import taxes, which will remain in place as the legal battle continues.
WatchesSep 05, 2025
Patrick Mahomes Is the New Hublot Brand AmbassadorThe Kansas City Chiefs quarterback shares Hublot’s dedication to pursuing greatness, the Swiss watchmaker said.
