Columnists

Peter Smith: The Importance of Culture in Hiring

ColumnistsMar 18, 2025

Peter Smith: The Importance of Culture in Hiring

Smith explores why a qualified candidate might still not be right for the job.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
Is it my imagination or are we getting important hiring decisions wrong with greater frequency than ever before?

Just in the past few days, I’ve heard of a handful of people leaving positions after very short periods.

This includes employees who relocated for their new roles and within weeks or months were gone, leaving a trail of disappointment, dejection, and wasted financial resources.

Why is that? Why are so many companies getting it so wrong?

Or, are the candidates getting it wrong?

Bob Corlett, the founder and president of Staffing Advisors, wrote in the Washington Business Journal, “Most people are hired for skills but fired for ‘fit.’ People who don’t ‘fit in’ don’t last long in most organizations.” 

If we assume that those candidates were appropriately vetted, their backgrounds checked, and their suitability for the positions satisfied, then the disconnect between performance and expectation, as evidenced by the hasty departures, clearly points to a problem.

Nobody wants to start a new job and find out in short order that they’ve made a mistake. 

No employer wants to undertake the oftentimes stressful and time-consuming process of interviewing people, salary negotiations, potential relocations, and the deployment of resources for onboarding to have to unwind so quickly. 

So, why does that continue to happen and what can we do about it? 

Culture has sometimes been described as the water in which a fish swims. He doesn’t know it’s water, he has no frame of reference, and he couldn’t describe it to you even if you spoke fish and asked him (don’t spend too much time thinking about what fish sounds like; it’s a secret language). 

If we take the fish and water metaphor to its next logical step, consider what happens when a fish is removed from water. 

That image of a fish fighting for survival is not unlike the feeling one has when they find themselves in a culture that is fundamentally misaligned with who they are. 

That awful realization that this is a mistake can be felt from the employee and the employer, and it can happen very fast. 

The resolution can sometimes be dragged out as all sides try to find a solution, but it more often ends in separation because cultural misalignment is almost impossible to reconcile. 

 Related stories will be right here … 

Organizational culture (whether it is by design or default) rarely, if ever, adapts to a new hire; it has to be the other way around.

There are exceptions, of course. A strong new leader can change the culture of an organization if they have a mandate to do so, and the necessary time and resources to make it happen. 

Culture-fit is an intangible, but it has very tangible consequences when we get it wrong. 

The candidate can have the requisite experience, the right traits and intellect, great work ethic, and a willing and excited employer ready to engage them, and yet we still get things wrong, even with the most important hires. 

So why do we continue to make these mistakes despite the heavy cost to business, customers, and the existing teams?

In short, we continue to make hiring mistakes because we vastly underestimate the importance of culture fit.

In “Unleash Your Primal Brain,” author Tim Ash wrote, “If someone is not in accord with the behaviors and beliefs of the group, they are, by definition, a poor team member. Severe social sanctions will often fall on such people. They will either be forced to conform or removed from the group.”

That does not make them bad people. They could be great people but just not right for your group.

In condensing a solution to its most basic level, I would suggest that we document those behaviors and beliefs and then build a small portfolio of questions to be included in your interviewing process. (You do have a structured interview process, yes? Phew! Can you imagine not having one!)

Use the culture questions to fully explore the things the candidate holds dear and the things that matter most to the organization. Do they align? Are there significant disconnects?

Putting those questions together and adding them to the interview process is a critical exercise in helping the hiring manager, and the candidate, to better explore the things that could derail a relationship that otherwise checked all the boxes on talent, work ethic, experience, etc.

Some of the things that culture questions can reveal is a candidate who does not respond well to being micro-managed in an organization that is all about that.

A candidate who is excited about innovation and change in an organization that is resistant to change.

A candidate with aspirations to grow in a family business where the senior team are all related and not going anywhere.

A candidate who is most comfortable working at a deliberate pace in a company that operates at warp speed, or vice versa.

A candidate who needs a months-long ramp-up and all sorts of handholding in an organization that needs you to hit the ground running with the minimum amount of help.

There are literally dozens of reasons why someone might not work out. Sometimes it is as insidious as an incumbent employee in the organization who casts a large and destructive shadow and who the company isn’t willing to address.

In “For The Culture,” author Marcus Collins wrote, “People are looking to be a part of something just as much as you are looking for people to join you. You just have to find the right congregational fit.” 

Amen to that!

The Latest

Taylor Swift engagement ring Greenwich St
TrendsOct 22, 2025
The Taylor Swift Effect: Antique Diamonds Edition

The superstar’s August engagement put the stamp of approval on an already hot engagement ring trend.

Rahaminov Diamonds Emerald-Cut Diamond Bracelet
TrendsOct 22, 2025
Don’t Forget These Diamond Jewelry Trends When Stocking for the Holidays

Retailers should offer classic styles with a twist that are a perfect fit for layered looks, experts say.

Fancy vivid purplish pink diamond
AuctionsOct 22, 2025
Pink Diamond, Vanderbilt Jewels to Headline Phillips’ Geneva Auction

The nearly 7-carat fancy vivid purplish pink diamond could sell for around $9 million.

BTYB10.25_Header.jpg
Brought to you by
Are Earrings an Overlooked Category? What Retailers Need to Know Now

As the holiday season quickly approaches, consider stocking one category that sometimes gets overlooked: earrings.

“Storied Diamond Desert Sands of Eternity” engagement ring and wedding band
SourcingOct 22, 2025
In ‘Storied Diamond,’ Jared Jewelers Is Emphasizing the Journey

The retailer’s new collection of engagement rings and fashion jewelry is set with natural diamonds that are traceable via blockchain.

Weekly QuizOct 16, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Tiffany & Co. Bird on a Rock by Tiffany High Jewelry Lariat
CollectionsOct 22, 2025
Tiffany & Co.’s ‘Bird on a Rock’ Finds New Perch

Chief Artistic Officer Nathalie Verdeille has reimagined the iconic design in both figurative and abstract creations.

Jewelers for Children Halloween contest
Events & AwardsOct 22, 2025
JFC Kicks Off Halloween Costume Challenge

Five dollars buys one vote toward an industry professional you want to see dressed up as a hero, or a villain, this Halloween.

LIM-401 2024 National Jeweler Supplier Bulletin- iD100 Web and Eblast FINAL (2) (1).jpg
Brought to you by
Protect Your Customers and Your Business

You deserve to know what you are selling–to protect your customers as well as your business and your reputation.

Hillsborough show
Events & AwardsOct 22, 2025
Hillsborough Antique Show Gets New Owner

Recently acquired by KIL Promotions, the November edition of the public show in San Mateo, California, will be held Nov. 7-9.

Bicolor pink and colorless diamond
GradingOct 21, 2025
GIA Examines Rare Bicolor Pink Diamond

The stone’s two zones, one pink and one colorless, may have formed at two different times, the lab said.

Pomellato Rodeo Drive Flagship Exterior
MajorsOct 21, 2025
Pomellato Brings ‘Global Attitude’ to Rodeo Drive Flagship

Hollywood glamour meets Milanese sophistication in the design of Pomellato’s new store in Beverly Hills, California.

Grown Brilliance NYC Flagship Exterior
Lab-GrownOct 21, 2025
Grown Brilliance Opens First Flagship

The New York City store showcases a chandelier with 1,500 carats of lab-grown diamonds designed by an FIT student.

Douriean Fletcher Messenger Collection
Events & AwardsOct 21, 2025
‘Douriean Fletcher: Jewelry of the Afrofuture’ Opens at MAD

The Museum of Arts and Design's new exhibition features 75 pieces by the designer, best known for her work in the “Black Panther” films.

Sothebys the glowing rose pink diamond
AuctionsOct 20, 2025
Sotheby's To Auction 10-Carat Vivid Pink Diamond

Making its auction debut, "The Glowing Rose" is expected to fetch $20 million at the November jewelry sale in Geneva.

2025_Gemfields logo.jpg
SourcingOct 20, 2025
2 Mozambique Police Officers Killed at Gemfields’ Ruby Mine

They were attacked on Oct. 15, as approximately 40 miners without licenses marched on the mine’s gate.

Empress Eugénie’s pearl and diamond tiara
CrimeOct 20, 2025
See the ‘Priceless’ Jewels Stolen During Daytime Heist at the Louvre

It took the masked thieves less than 10 minutes to steal eight irreplaceable jewels from two display cases in the museum’s Apollo Gallery.

Lauren Gayda
SourcingOct 20, 2025
Pristine Gems Names New Director of European Sales

Gemologist Lauren Gayda has previously worked at The Clear Cut, Taylor & Hart, and Effy Jewelry.

Charles London, Mayer and Fran Udell, Mark and Candy Udell
IndependentsOct 17, 2025
From the Jazz Age to the Information Age: London Jewelers Turns 100

In 2026, the jewelry retailer will celebrate a milestone only a small percentage of family-owned businesses survive to see.

The Edit – A Gallery of Italian Jewelry Masterpieces Graphic
Events & AwardsOct 17, 2025
An Edit of Italian Jewels Is Coming to NYC

The new showcase dedicated to Italian jewelry design is set for Oct. 29-30.

Judi Powers Jewelry Stella Earrings
TrendsOct 17, 2025
Piece of the Week: Judi Powers Jewelry’s ‘Stella’ Earrings

Take a gaze at the sky with this pair of platinum diamond-set star earrings with blue lace agate drops.

Jeffrey Zimmer Reeds Jewelers
IndependentsOct 16, 2025
Retailer Hall of Fame 2025: Jeffrey Zimmer

Jeffrey Zimmer's decades of leadership at Reeds Jewelers are defined by integrity, a love of sourcing gemstones, and a heart for community.

Sothebys salon new bond street
AuctionsOct 16, 2025
Sotheby’s Introduces Custom Jewelry Service

The new high jewelry design and production process takes 30 days or less from concept to completion, the auction house said.

Oscar Heyman 2025 Holiday Catalog Cover
MajorsOct 16, 2025
Oscar Heyman’s Holiday Catalog Is Out, and It’s Spectacular

The holiday catalog for 2025 features never-before-seen images of more than 100 one-of-a-kind masterpieces.

Foundrae United in Love Campaign Imagery
CollectionsOct 16, 2025
Foundrae Adds To ‘United in Love’ Collection

The brand has released a second installment of its collection of traditional and non-traditional commitment heirlooms.

Kathy Corey
IndependentsOct 15, 2025
Retailer Hall of Fame 2025: Kathy Corey

Corey rescued New England chain Day’s Jewelers, preserving its legacy with strong people skills, pragmatism, and a “get-it-done” attitude.

Colorado jeweler Peter Damian Arguello
CrimeOct 15, 2025
Men Receive Lengthy Prison Sentences for 2023 Murder of Colorado Jeweler

Charles Robinson Shay was sentenced to life in prison plus 120 years while his accomplice, Michael James McCormack, got 75 years.

Logo for Timepieces at Luxury
Events & AwardsOct 15, 2025
JCK, Luxury to Debut New Watch Section in Vegas Next Year

Timepieces at Luxury will take place at The Venetian and, like Luxury, will be invitation-only for the first two days.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy