Technology

Judge Rules Jeweler’s Lawsuit Against PNC Bank Can Move Forward

TechnologyApr 15, 2024

Judge Rules Jeweler’s Lawsuit Against PNC Bank Can Move Forward

Joyce’s Jewelry sued the bank after cybercriminals drained its accounts of nearly $1.6 million through a series of wire transfers.

Joyce’s Jewelry
A judge ruled that Joyce’s Jewelry in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, can move forward with its lawsuit against PNC Bank. The Pittsburgh-area independent sued the bank in 2022 after cybercriminals stole more than $1.6 million from its accounts via unauthorized wire transfers. (Image courtesy of Joyce’s Jewelry Facebook page)
Uniontown, Pa.—A preliminary ruling by a Pennsylvania judge will allow a jeweler who lost more than $1 million in a cyberattack to move forward with its lawsuit against PNC Bank and some of its employees.

The owners of Joyce’s Jewelry in the Pittsburgh-area city of Uniontown sued PNC in September 2022 after cybercriminals stole nearly $1.6 million from the retailer’s bank accounts through a series of wire transfers. 

The theft took place on the afternoon of May 12, 2022, when one of the jewelry store’s employees accidentally logged into a phony website made to look like PNC Bank’s website.

Using the employee’s login credentials obtained from the phishing website, cybercriminals emptied all four of the store’s bank accounts through 11 wire transfers sent over a period of 20 hours.

In the lawsuit, the store’s owners alleged that PNC Bank failed to keep its money safe, while PNC claimed it took the proper steps in regard to the transactions and the fault lies with Joyce’s Jewelry and its employee.

The jeweler claimed these transfers should have raised a red flag for PNC because the money was moved to accounts and businesses it had never sent money to before. 

The wire amounts also were far above the usual transaction amounts, by tens of thousands of dollars per wire. Joyce’s had never wired close to $1 million in a single day.

The wires also exceeded the funds available, leading to an overdraft charge of nearly $200,000, another abnormality that should have caught the bank’s attention. Joyce’s, to its knowledge, had never overdrawn on its accounts before, the lawsuit states. 

PNC did recover some of the stolen funds, and charged the jeweler for its recovery efforts, bringing the loss total down to $1.1 million.

The case brought by Joyce’s Jewelry initially went to the Court of Common Pleas of Fayette County, Pennsylvania, which is a state court.

PNC Bank asked that a federal court, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, take up the matter.

On Jan. 12, 2023, the federal court denied that request, ruling the state court should continue to handle the case.

Two weeks later, PNC filed a motion to dismiss, arguing against Joyce’s claims of negligence and breach of fiduciary duty, as well as the jeweler’s request for attorneys’ fees and punitive damages.

The bank also argued it could only be sued only under the state’s Uniform Commercial Code, which guides commercial business transactions, including wire transfers.

 Related stories will be right here … 

Earlier this year, the state court’s decision came back in favor of Joyce’s Jewelry.   

In a March 11 ruling, Judge Nancy D. Vernon said the court could not dismiss claims that PNC and individual bank employees acted negligently.

She also said the jeweler can continue to seek attorneys’ fees and punitive damages in the case.

In her ruling, the judge also noted that PNC’s duty to the jeweler goes beyond its contractual obligations and said the bank may still be liable for a tort, meaning an injury or wrong independent of an implied contract.

A spokesperson from PNC said, “PNC regrets that Joyce’s Jewelry was the victim of a crime and suffered financial losses. However, Joyce’s Jewelry could have avoided being defrauded had they taken the reasonable precautions recommended by PNC at any stage of this process.

“Although the court denied PNC’s requested relief at this stage, PNC expects the facts and law will ultimately establish that PNC is not liable for Joyce’s Jewelry’s losses.”

Howard Kaplan, partner at the law firm Kaplan & Grady and Joyce’s Jewelry’s counsel, shared some insight into the case and what it could mean for other small businesses in this situation.

The recent ruling is significant, he said, because that’s not usually how these cases play out.

“Usually, [these cases] are under a very narrow legal theory and individual bank employees are not put in the mixer. And punitive damages aren’t a question, nor is tort liability for negligence,” he said.

“Usually, disputes with bank customers are a creature of contract, as opposed to tort or negligence. So, the liability on a negligence theory is broader. The potential damages and liability are broader than on a contract theory,” said Kaplan.

If the bank was able to confine the lawsuit to the Uniform Commercial Code claim, it likely would have limited the damages it may have to pay. 

The judge’s March 11 ruling is “a really bad development for [PNC] because they don’t want their employees getting sued, and they don’t want to be exposed to open-ended damages,” he said.

The damages are, in part, for “gaslighting” the jeweler into believing the fault was solely theirs, and for sending the business into collections and risking its livelihood, Kaplan said.

As for how much, that’s a question for the judge and jury.

“What is it going to take to send a message to PNC that the way that they’ve treated their customer in this instance was unacceptable? And I would think that it would take a large number to send a message to them, likely a multiple of Joyce’s loss,” he said.

“The bank here is spending more on their defense than it would cost to pay Joyce’s back. They will spend more than a million dollars through trial to avoid doing right by their customer.”

Beyond the legal implications of the case, Kaplan said he wants people to understand the reality and relatability of the situation.

“They’re going to blame a 70-year-old woman for making a mistake on her computer and say what resulted—collection of all of Joyce’s cash into one account and then shipping that money out in 11 highly suspect wires over the course of 20 hours—is all fair and OK,” he said. “It’s really offensive from a common-sense perspective.”

“We didn’t say that Joyce’s did everything right. But PNC is required to have reasonable security and is required to follow those reasonable security measures in a reasonable way,” Kaplan said.

“And the facts of the case seem to show that one or the other isn’t true. Either you didn’t have the proper security in place, or you all were asleep at the switch, but it has to be one or the other because of what happened,” he said.

The case is in the preliminary stages, but Kaplan’s hope is that others in this situation can take the same approach.

“If we actually win the case, and I am confident that we will, then that roadmap will just be that much more useful and hopefully it will lead more broadly to better recoveries for defrauded customers, and there are many more out there,” said Kaplan.

The Latest

Stock image of a man’s hands in handcuffs
CrimeMay 08, 2025
Former NYC Jewelry Store Employee Arrested in 2017 Choking Death of Boss

Michel Desalles allegedly murdered Omid Gholian inside World of Gold N Diamond using zip ties and then fled the country.

2025 Met Gala jewelry
EditorsMay 08, 2025
5 ‘Superfine’ Met Gala Jewelry Moments

Associate Editor Lauren McLemore shares her favorite looks from a night of style inspired by Black dandyism.

instappraise-1.png
Supplier BulletinMay 08, 2025
Instappraise Introduces Game-Changing Trifold Appraisal Format

Sponsored by Instappraise

antique_Vegas_2024_by_headshot_stories_9454.jpg
Brought to you by
Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch Show: Showcasing the Most Collectible Merchandise from Across the Globe

Gain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.

Brilliant Earth three stone Sabine diamond engagement ring
FinancialsMay 08, 2025
Brilliant Earth Notes an Uptick in Engagement Ring Sales in Q1

CEO Beth Gerstein discussed the company’s bridal bestsellers, the potential impact of tariffs, and the rising price of gold.

Weekly QuizMay 08, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Exterior of Margot McKinney Beverly Hills Location
IndependentsMay 08, 2025
Margot McKinney Lands in the U.S. With New Boutique

The brand’s first independent location outside of Australia has opened in Beverly Hills, California.

Cathy Marsh
IndependentsMay 08, 2025
Verragio Announces New Regional Sales Manager

Cathy Marsh will lead the jewelry company’s efforts in the upper Midwest and western United States.

Supplier Spotlight -Recorded-Webinar.png
Brought to you by
Watch: The Winston Red: GIA Examines the Smithsonian’s Newest Addition

Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA

Pandora gold and silver charm bracelet
FinancialsMay 07, 2025
Pandora Posts Strong Q1, Plans for Tariffs

The company has multiple strategies for dealing with tariffs, though its CEO said moving manufacturing to the U.S. is not one of them.

Headshot of Smart Age Solutions CEO Emmanuel Raheb
ColumnistsMay 07, 2025
The Smart Lab: Building a Seasonal Marketing Strategy for Mother’s Day and Beyond

Connecting with your customers throughout the year is key to a successful holiday marketing push.

Gemfields rough emeralds
SourcingMay 07, 2025
Gemfields Says Emerald Sales Improved in Latest Auction

Its commercial-quality emerald sale held last month totaled more than $16 million, up from about $11 million in September 2024.

Harwell Godfrey Met Gala brooch with Mediterranean Blue diamond
AuctionsMay 06, 2025
Harwell Godfrey Reimagines 10-Carat Blue Diamond for Met Gala-Ready Brooch

Designer Lauren Harwell Godfrey made the piece as an homage to the 2025 gala’s theme, “Superfine: Tailoring Black Style.”

Jewelers of America 20 Under 40 for 2025
Events & AwardsMay 06, 2025
Here’s Who Made Jewelers of America’s New ‘20 Under 40’ List

Expanded this year to include suppliers, JA’s 2025 list honors 40 up-and-coming professionals in the jewelry industry.

Sissys Log Cabin Fort Smith Arkansas
IndependentsMay 06, 2025
Sissy's Log Cabin Opens New Store

Located in Fort Smith, it’s the Mid-South jeweler’s first store in Northwest Arkansas.

Gunderson’s Jewelers
IndependentsMay 06, 2025
Gunderson’s Jewelers to Be Featured on ‘World’s Greatest’ TV Series

The episode about the family-owned jeweler will premiere May 17.

Zadok Jewelers Austin store
IndependentsMay 05, 2025
Zadok Jewelers Opens Store in Austin

The Houston-based jeweler’s new 11,000-square-foot showroom will include a Rolex boutique.

Nancy Astor Cartier turquoise and diamond tiara
AuctionsMay 05, 2025
Nancy Astor’s Cartier Tiara Heads to Auction

The turquoise and diamond tiara hasn’t been on the market since it was purchased by Lord Astor in 1930.

David DeCook Crater of Diamonds State Park 3.81-carat brown Duke Diamond
SourcingMay 05, 2025
Crater of Diamonds Yields 4-Carat Brown Diamond

“The Duke Diamond” is the largest diamond registered at the Arkansas park so far this year.

Kraft Mac & Cheese x Ring Concierge Forever Macaroni Necklace
TrendsMay 02, 2025
Ring Concierge, Kraft Partner on Mother’s Day Macaroni Necklace

The childhood craft of making dried pasta necklaces for Mother’s Day is all grown up as the 14-karat gold “Forever Macaroni” necklace.

Angely Martinez emerald Promise ring
CollectionsMay 02, 2025
Piece of the Week: Angely Martinez’s Emerald Promise Ring

Set with May’s birthstone and featuring an earthworm, this ring is a perfect celebration of spring.

Stuller 2025-2026 bridal catalog
MajorsMay 02, 2025
Stuller’s New Bridal Catalog Is Here

“Bridal 2025–2026” includes popular styles and a dedicated section for quick pricing references of lab-grown diamond bridal jewelry.

Americut Gems
SourcingMay 01, 2025
Tariffs & Colored Gemstones: Relying on Stock, Considering the Ripple Effect

Though currently paused, high tariffs threaten many countries where gemstones are mined. Dealers are taking measures now to prepare.

Exterior of new David Yurman store in the Miami Design District
MajorsMay 01, 2025
Peek Inside David Yurman’s New Miami Flagship Store

Located in Miami’s Design District, the 4,000-square-foot store is an homage to David and Sybil Yurman’s artistic roots.

Oscar Heyman emerald and diamond necklace
TrendsMay 01, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: 20 Pieces of Emerald Jewelry for May

May babies are lucky indeed, born in a month awash with fresh colors and celebrated with one of the most coveted colored gemstones.

Jewelers of America logo
MajorsMay 01, 2025
Jewelers of America Opens Applications for 2025 Scholarships

The deadline to apply for the Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship is June 12.

Stock image of an empty clothing store
SurveysApr 30, 2025
Consumer Confidence Hits Pandemic-Level Low Amid Tariff Concerns

What’s really worrying U.S. consumers isn’t the present situation; it’s what the economy is going to look like six months from now.

2025 Instore Jewelry Show Graphic
Events & AwardsApr 30, 2025
Instore Show Debuts New Name, Look, and Focus

Now called The Instore Jewelry Show, it will include holiday-focused education, interactive workshops, and a window display contest.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy