CrimeDec 20, 2022
The Biggest Security Mistakes Jewelers Are Making Right NowCrimeJan 04, 2023
How a Jeweler Lost $1.6M in Less than 24 Hours
Joyce’s Jewelry in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, is suing PNC Bank after cybercriminals emptied its accounts through a series of wire transfers.
Joyce’s Jewelry in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, is suing PNC Bank after cybercriminals stole more than $1.6 million from its accounts via unauthorized wire transfers. (Image courtesy of Joyce’s Jewelers Facebook page)
Uniontown, Pa.—The owners of Joyce’s Jewelry in the Pittsburgh-area city of Uniontown are suing PNC Bank after cybercriminals emptied its accounts of nearly $1.6 million through a series of wire transfers.
The retailer filed the lawsuit in October accusing PNC Bank of failing to keep its money safe. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette covered the suit in a story published Monday.
The theft took place on the afternoon of May 12, 2022.
According to court documents filed in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh, a jewelry store employee accidentally logged into a phony website made to look like PNC Bank’s website.
She noticed the website wasn’t loading properly and called the customer service number she found on the spoofed webpage. She was advised to be patient as the website was slow that day, something she said PNC had told her before, court documents state.
Soon after, the store’s internet service went down. Then the employee and Joyce’s Jewelry CEO Brandon Katzeff experienced a “subscription attack,” meaning they started receiving hundreds of emails every hour making it difficult to tell which are genuine.
That night, PNC sent Katzeff an email, alerting him to “two small but suspicious charges” on one of the store’s credit cards. He called PNC’s fraud prevention service line and canceled the credit card.
In the lawsuit, Joyce’s claims no mention was made of any other suspicious activity or the multiple wire transfers made that day.
The next morning, after IT services restored the store’s internet service, Katzeff realized the company accounts had been hacked and he reached out to PNC Bank.
Using the employee’s login credentials obtained from the phishing website, cybercriminals had emptied all four of the store’s accounts through 11 wire transfers over a period of 20 hours.
In total, around $1.6 million was transferred from the jeweler’s PNC accounts to the hackers’ accounts at JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America.
Later that day, a PNC cyber fraud analyst emailed Katzeff about an attempted wire transfer of more than $105,000. It was the last of nearly a dozen unauthorized wire transfers and the only one flagged by the bank, the lawsuit claims.
The analyst told Joyce’s the bank held no responsibility for the losses and advised Katzeff to contact law enforcement and the beneficiary banks.
PNC Bank has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit and, through a spokesperson, said it believes it took the right steps in regard to the transactions.
“While PNC regrets any losses incurred by a customer, we disagree with the allegations in this case and believe we acted appropriately with respect to the transactions,” a PNC Bank spokesperson said in a statement to National Jeweler.
Related stories will be right here …
The retailer filed the lawsuit in October accusing PNC Bank of failing to keep its money safe. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette covered the suit in a story published Monday.
The theft took place on the afternoon of May 12, 2022.
According to court documents filed in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh, a jewelry store employee accidentally logged into a phony website made to look like PNC Bank’s website.
She noticed the website wasn’t loading properly and called the customer service number she found on the spoofed webpage. She was advised to be patient as the website was slow that day, something she said PNC had told her before, court documents state.
Soon after, the store’s internet service went down. Then the employee and Joyce’s Jewelry CEO Brandon Katzeff experienced a “subscription attack,” meaning they started receiving hundreds of emails every hour making it difficult to tell which are genuine.
That night, PNC sent Katzeff an email, alerting him to “two small but suspicious charges” on one of the store’s credit cards. He called PNC’s fraud prevention service line and canceled the credit card.
In the lawsuit, Joyce’s claims no mention was made of any other suspicious activity or the multiple wire transfers made that day.
The next morning, after IT services restored the store’s internet service, Katzeff realized the company accounts had been hacked and he reached out to PNC Bank.
Using the employee’s login credentials obtained from the phishing website, cybercriminals had emptied all four of the store’s accounts through 11 wire transfers over a period of 20 hours.
In total, around $1.6 million was transferred from the jeweler’s PNC accounts to the hackers’ accounts at JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America.
Later that day, a PNC cyber fraud analyst emailed Katzeff about an attempted wire transfer of more than $105,000. It was the last of nearly a dozen unauthorized wire transfers and the only one flagged by the bank, the lawsuit claims.
The analyst told Joyce’s the bank held no responsibility for the losses and advised Katzeff to contact law enforcement and the beneficiary banks.
PNC Bank has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit and, through a spokesperson, said it believes it took the right steps in regard to the transactions.
“While PNC regrets any losses incurred by a customer, we disagree with the allegations in this case and believe we acted appropriately with respect to the transactions,” a PNC Bank spokesperson said in a statement to National Jeweler.
Joyce’s Jewelry disagrees.
The transfers should have raised a red flag for PNC, the jeweler said in its lawsuit, noting the money was moved to accounts and businesses it had never sent money to before.
The wire amounts were also far above the usual transaction amounts by tens of thousands of dollars per wire. Joyce’s had never wired close to a million dollars in one day.
The wires also exceeded the funds available, leading to an overdraft charge of nearly $200,000 for a customer that, to the best of Joyce’s knowledge, had not overdrawn on an account before.
“The bank’s failures here are stark and should shock and frighten small business customers who believe their accounts and accumulated savings are secure with PNC,” court documents state.
“PNC’s failures allowed substantially all the liquidity that Joyce’s had managed to accumulate over decades to be stolen in less than 24 hours.”
The bank has also not provided the jeweler with information about how to recoup its losses, said Joyce’s, and allegedly kept the owners in the dark about what was being done to recover the money.
The jeweler was also directed to a third-party collection agency to demand repayment of the overdraft fees and could be billed for “corporate analysis charges” as PNC looks into the theft.
The family-owned business was founded by Joyce Katzeff in the early 1970s. It began as a small store in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, later expanding to a 7,000-square-foot location.
The company has banked with PNC and banks acquired by PNC since its founding and implemented the recommended security features on its “Pinacle” online and mobile banking platform.
The wire procedures and security protocol for Joyce’s requires multi-factor and dual-control authorization to send wires, the jeweler said in the suit, but the thieves got into their accounts using just one employee’s login information.
The suit notes that some of the money has been recovered, including an anticipated, unspecified “partial” recovery from Bank of America and more than $224,000 from JPMorgan.
However, PNC withdrew around $192,000 to pay itself for the overdraft, interest, and fees.
Joyce’s losses stand at around $1.1 million as of October 2022.
In addition to the financial loss, Joyce’s said it has struggled to run its jewelry store with minimal cash and frozen accounts.
Its employees and vendors were also unable to cash or deposit their paychecks and payments.
The retailer has had to change its purchasing practices, the suit states, causing it to lose out on discounts from trade show purchases.
And Joyce’s senior management has had to shift focus from the business to its financial issues.
The jeweler is asking the court to order PNC Bank to refund all of its stolen money and overdraft fees as well as award it damages.
More on Crime
The Latest
Supplier BulletinJan 26, 2023
JA New York Spring Brings the Industry TogetherFor over 100 years, JA New York has played an integral role in facilitating the evolution of our industry, while also honoring past traditions.
TrendsJan 26, 2023
At Vicenzaoro, Paola De Luca Gazes Into Jewelry’s FutureThe trend forecaster and her guests explored unconventional jewelry designs, NFTs, AI art, and more during her Trendvision presentation.
CollectionsJan 26, 2023
NDC and Lorraine Schwartz Announce New ‘EDDI’ ClassThe Emerging Designers Diamond Initiative provides diamond credit and mentorship to young brands helmed by BIPOC designers.
Brought to you by
Bringing Over 130 Years of Diamond Expertise to Modern GradingDe Beers Institute of Diamonds provides the very best in diamond verification, education and diamond services.
IndependentsJan 26, 2023
Lee Michaels Fine Jewelry Set to Open 10th StoreIt will be located in San Antonio’s Alamo Quarry Market and will be Lee Michaels’ third location in the city.
Weekly QuizJan 26, 2023
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge with this short test.
Policies & IssuesJan 26, 2023
Diamonds Do Good Names 10 to Board of DirectorsStephanie Gottlieb, Jewelers Mutual’s Mike Alexander, and Craig Rottenberg of Long’s Jewelers are among the new board members.
WatchesJan 25, 2023
These Were 2022’s Top-Selling Watch Brands, Chrono24 SaysRolex remained No. 1 while a brand known for its pilot watches slipped into the No. 5 spot.
Brought to you by
De Beers Institute of Diamonds Expands to Offer Education De Beers is sharing over 130 years of experience and expertise through the De Beers Institute of Diamonds with a selection of courses.
MajorsJan 25, 2023
John Hardy Names New CEOLuxury retail executive Frédéric Levy has taken on the role.
Events & AwardsJan 25, 2023
Couture DAC Accepting Applications for Mentorship ProgramJewelry designers have until early February to apply to take part in Couture's Diversity Action Council program.
CollectionsJan 25, 2023
Stephanie Gottlieb Announces First President, CCO HireMorgan P. Richardson joins from La Perla.
Policies & IssuesJan 25, 2023
PGI’s New Portal Wants to Teach You About PlatinumThe new portal will share information on responsible platinum sourcing and how it’s used beyond jewelry.
SourcingJan 24, 2023
Tiffany Buys 35 of the Last Diamonds Recovered From Argyle Purchased directly from Rio Tinto, the collection consists of pinks, purples and one red, none larger than 1.52 carats.
ColumnistsJan 24, 2023
On Data: Here’s How Independent Jewelers Did in 2022 Sherry Smith breaks down retailers’ performance last year, including how natural diamonds fared vs. lab-grown.
GradingJan 24, 2023
GIA and AGS Launch Diamond Light Performance Supplement ReportThe AGS Ideal Report by GIA is a digital-only addition to GIA diamond reports.
MajorsJan 24, 2023
WJA Announces New International Board MembersThe seven newcomers include executives from David Yurman, De Beers, and GIA.
EditorsJan 23, 2023
Designers to Watch in 2023: Aurelia DemarkThe designer finds the modernity in classic motifs and family heirloom jewels.
Policies & IssuesJan 23, 2023
Melanie Grant Named Executive Director of RJC She has more than 20 years’ experience in watches and jewelry, and says sustainability is the “greatest single issue” facing the industry.
Policies & IssuesJan 23, 2023
AGTA Forms Committee to Standardize Industry ‘Sustainability’ TermsIts focus are words like “sustainability,” “ethics,” and “responsible sourcing.”
IndependentsJan 23, 2023
10 Jewelry News Stories You Might Have MissedAnother “Designer to Watch” and Kim Kardashian’s auction purchase were among our most-read stories.
MajorsJan 20, 2023
Quality Gold Acquires Herco Herco President Reuven Itelman is retiring and selling the company, which will relocate to Ohio from California.
Lab-GrownJan 20, 2023
Siobhán Duffy Promoted to Chief Executive of Element Six She was previously the executive director of sales and marketing for the De Beers Group-owned company.
TrendsJan 20, 2023
Piece of the Week: Loquet London’s Lunar New Year CharmIt’s from a new collection of charms designed to go in the brand’s signature lockets.
IndependentsJan 20, 2023
Edge Retail Academy Announces Annual Award WinnerLonnie Iannazzo of Vincent Anthony Jewelers is the 2022 William (Wag) Wagner Business Excellence Award recipient.
Lab-GrownJan 19, 2023
GIA Rolls Out Less Expensive Report for Lab-Grown DiamondsThe revised Laboratory-Grown Diamond Report-Dossier still includes the four Cs but doesn’t list growth method or post-growth treatments.
SurveysJan 19, 2023
Inflation, Rising Interest Rates Put a Damper on Holiday SalesHoliday sales fell short of the National Retail Federation’s expectations, rising only 5 percent year-over-year.
AuctionsJan 19, 2023
Kim Kardashian Bought Princess Diana’s Amethyst CrossThe businesswoman and reality TV star paid nearly $200,000 for the “Attallah Cross.”
