MajorsFeb 01, 2019
Tiffany Is Now Telling Consumers the Origin of Its DiamondsSourcingApr 21, 2021
Why Inclusivity Is Important in Diamond Traceability
As the importance of mine-to-market grows, some worry about its feasibility for all the diamond industry’s players.
Companies in the diamond industry are increasingly putting programs in place to track rough diamonds all the way through the supply chain, but some worry these mine-to-market measures might have unintended consequences. (© De Beers Group, Photo credit; Ben Perry, Armoury Films)
New York—Traceability has become a central conversation in nearly all sectors of the jewelry industry’s supply chain amid growing interest about the origin of goods.
For the diamond market, it has led to a switch.
An industry that once tried to steer the conversation away from machinery and digging, lest it detract from the product’s sex appeal, is now talking non-stop about where diamonds come from and the good they do, and it is relying on technology like blockchain to document it.
For many, the idea of increased transparency in the supply chain is inherently a good thing.
“I think all of us, certainly anybody with any kind of a social conscience, understands that we need to take great care that the diamonds don’t come from sources that are bad actors,” said Jeff Fischer.
Fischer is president of manufacturing firm Fischer Diamonds Inc. and, among other roles, is a past president of both the International Diamond Manufacturers Association (IDMA) and the Diamond Manufacturers and Importers Association of America (DMIA).
A system has been put into place, he said, to create a safety net around “the vast majority of goods” and ensure those goods—and only those goods—are what make it through the system.
This includes processes to ensure diamonds and diamond mining are doing no harm, and stressing the importance of due diligence.
But from the good has arisen concerns about the possible unintended consequences of traceability for the market’s smaller players.
Small-Scale Miners and the Midstream
Since many processes and systems created for traceability rely heavily on technology, questions of capacity and feasibility arise.
It’s estimated that around 20 percent of the global diamond supply comes from artisanal and small-scale miners.
On one hand, the technology could provide an opportunity for some diamond-producing countries to learn more and increase their market share as they participate in the technological revolution, said Stephane Fischler.
A lifelong diamantaire, Fischler is a partner in Fischler Diamonds, as well as a founding member and former president of the World Diamond Council (WDC) and vice president at the Diamond Development Initiative (DDI), which merged with Resolve last year.
On the other, he notes: “Artisanal miners do lack most of the capacity to deliver on the technology to assure provenance. So while it’s good and it’s something that will grow, we do need to be very, very careful and very honest as to what the motives are and what the potential impact could be.”
He also pointed out that when the market pushes origin as the “holy grail” and creates conditions upon which consumers would or would not buy a diamond, it can make consumers risk-averse and push them to decide against buying diamonds from those who may need it most.
For the diamond market, it has led to a switch.
An industry that once tried to steer the conversation away from machinery and digging, lest it detract from the product’s sex appeal, is now talking non-stop about where diamonds come from and the good they do, and it is relying on technology like blockchain to document it.
For many, the idea of increased transparency in the supply chain is inherently a good thing.
“I think all of us, certainly anybody with any kind of a social conscience, understands that we need to take great care that the diamonds don’t come from sources that are bad actors,” said Jeff Fischer.
Fischer is president of manufacturing firm Fischer Diamonds Inc. and, among other roles, is a past president of both the International Diamond Manufacturers Association (IDMA) and the Diamond Manufacturers and Importers Association of America (DMIA).
A system has been put into place, he said, to create a safety net around “the vast majority of goods” and ensure those goods—and only those goods—are what make it through the system.
This includes processes to ensure diamonds and diamond mining are doing no harm, and stressing the importance of due diligence.
But from the good has arisen concerns about the possible unintended consequences of traceability for the market’s smaller players.
Small-Scale Miners and the Midstream
Since many processes and systems created for traceability rely heavily on technology, questions of capacity and feasibility arise.
It’s estimated that around 20 percent of the global diamond supply comes from artisanal and small-scale miners.
On one hand, the technology could provide an opportunity for some diamond-producing countries to learn more and increase their market share as they participate in the technological revolution, said Stephane Fischler.
A lifelong diamantaire, Fischler is a partner in Fischler Diamonds, as well as a founding member and former president of the World Diamond Council (WDC) and vice president at the Diamond Development Initiative (DDI), which merged with Resolve last year.
On the other, he notes: “Artisanal miners do lack most of the capacity to deliver on the technology to assure provenance. So while it’s good and it’s something that will grow, we do need to be very, very careful and very honest as to what the motives are and what the potential impact could be.”
He also pointed out that when the market pushes origin as the “holy grail” and creates conditions upon which consumers would or would not buy a diamond, it can make consumers risk-averse and push them to decide against buying diamonds from those who may need it most.
“Artisanal miners do lack most of the capacity to deliver on the technology to assure provenance. So while it’s good and it’s something that will grow, we do need to be very, very careful and very honest as to what the motives are and what the potential impact could be.” — Stephane Fischler, Fischler Diamonds
This works against what’s being done in the industry to derisk the ASM sector—groups like the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development and its due diligence framework, and projects like Resolve and DDI’s Maendeleo Diamond Standards for the artisanal mining sector.
Further downstream, traceability processes and systems also could have repercussions for those in the manufacturing link of the diamond supply chain.
Fisher raised concerns about the “untold amounts of merchandise that works its way through the system in a route that makes many more stops,” as well as the vast amount of material already in the pipeline, begging the question: What about those diamonds?
Not having their specifics locked in a blockchain already doesn’t mean they didn’t follow a fully viable and trusted path to market, especially given the regulations and stringent legislation linked to diamond trading.
Another obstacle is the tracking of melee, especially given the size of the diamond melee market and how much of it is used in jewelry.
While it might be feasible to follow larger polished stones, as they follow a more straightforward path from mine to market, smaller goods from various origins are often mixed together to create the required assortments.
This means that, “for 80 percent of the goods, I would say there is no way this thing of origin is feasible,” Fischler said.
In a recent editorial in the IDMA newsletter, however, consultant Ya’akov Almor presented a different point of view—that tracing melee can and should be done, to protect prices and, ultimately, the industry.
While acknowledging tracking melee would “demand increased investments in organizational structures, demand changes in work practices, and call for effective marketing and sales methods,” he argues the benefits of such changes would outweigh the obstacles.
The benefits include, Almor wrote, the industry’s ability to make origin and provenance part of its marketing activities, and creating more added value and, thereby, higher prices throughout the entire supply chain.
The Bigger Picture
The topics of sustainability and ethical sourcing tend to be whittled down to a single aspect, traceability—the ability to track a stone from where it was extracted from the earth to the showcase were it ultimately ends up.
But in reality, the conversation is much more expansive.
Ethical sourcing is not only about origin, Fischler said, but the stone’s whole story.
It’s about not only how the diamond was processed, but whether players involved have a positive impact on their communities and the people handling the diamonds did no harm in the process, among other similar questions.
Responsible Jewellery Council Executive Director Iris Van der Veken shared a similar thought.
“We cannot see sustainability in an isolated manner,” she told National Jeweler.
“It is important to have management systems in place that cover human rights, labor rights, health and safety, environment, product integrity and disclosure. In other words, all the processes involved in mining, cutting and polishing, casting, and setting into jewelry need to be in the scope.”
Feriel Zerouki, senior vice president of international relations and ethical initiatives at the De Beers Group and WDC vice president, said this is why programs like De Beers’ Best Practice Principles are “also such an important part of the equation” and why De Beers shares information about performance, impact and goals in the areas of sustainability and social purpose.
To help aid in the traceability, mine-to-market conversation, De Beers Group launched its own blockchain platform, Tracr, in 2018.
Zerouki said the company is currently registering about 15 percent of its production on the platform.
In addition, De Beers Jewellers, the company’s chain of retail stores, recently introduced its first collection using only diamonds fully tracked and registered on Tracr, called “1888 Master Diamonds.”
The world’s other main diamond mining company, Alrosa, joined Tracr in 2018 and introduced an “electronic passport” for its diamonds at the 2019 Las Vegas trade shows.
Beyond Traceability
The industry has myriad mechanisms in place designed to provide consumers and stakeholders with assurances their goods are responsibly sourced.
“The industry has to be inclusive. It’s really important when you look at our supply chain in jewelry; there are thousands of small family businesses that depend on that. Where the role of organizations like ours also comes in is to see that we bring the right stakeholders around the table.” — Iris Van der Veken, Responsible Jewellery Council
But as their importance continues to grow, the industry needs to make sure these systems are inclusive, rather than excluding smaller players because they are too cumbersome and/or expensive—concerns both Fischer and Fischler raised.
Van der Veken feels the same way.
“The industry has to be inclusive. It’s really important when you look at our supply chain in jewelry; there are thousands of small family businesses that depend on that. Where the role of organizations like ours also comes in is to see that we bring the right stakeholders around the table.
“And if we agree on what the processes are or how the standard is implemented with support of technology, then we need to see that those systems are practical and accessible.”
With the understanding that not every company has the time or money to become an RJC member, the organization has made resources available online for free, like video training sessions and online events, as well as guidance walk-throughs. It also is slated to launch a CSR toolkit next month.
And since traceability methods and the information companies will provide is an evolving area, “ensuring industry participants are able to access and participate in the programs that best suit their needs will be important,” Zerouki said.
She said De Beers will make this a key focus as it develops programs to provide the origin and pathway of every diamond it produces and sells by 2030, one of a dozen sustainability goals announced late last year as part of “Building Forever.”
Another vital component in the conversation—the retailer. The more information and assurance the retailers can provide, the better, Zerouki said.
“Ultimately, diamonds are a consumer-facing product, which means everyone in the supply chain has an ongoing role to play in meeting continually evolving stakeholder expectations.”
For Fischler, it’s about making sure that messaging in front of consumers is well-rounded and doesn’t detract from the “magic” of the product by throwing a lot of data their way.
“I see some starting to push a lot of information toward the consumer, whether it’s about origin, whether it’s grading provided by labs, and so on, for a product that is 100 percent emotion,” he said.
“And I’m a little bit skeptical about using this origin/provenance story to start to push a product toward the consumer, risking, I would say, diluting a lot of the emotional content.”
More on Sourcing
The Latest
IndependentsFeb 19, 2026
Bailey’s Fine Jewelry Co-Founder ‘Mama Ann’ Bailey Dies at 100Raised in an orphanage, Bailey was 18 when she met her husband, Clyde. They opened their North Carolina jewelry store in 1948.
ColumnistsFeb 19, 2026
Peter Smith: Happiness, Cavemen, and Jewelry SalesSmith encourages salespeople to ask customers questions that elicit the release of oxytocin, the brain’s “feel-good” chemical.
IndependentsFeb 19, 2026
Material Good Opens Third Location Material Good is celebrating its 10th anniversary as it opens its new store in the Back Bay neighborhood of Boston.
Brought to you by
The MJSA Mentor & Apprenticeship Program: Attracting & Training the Next Generation of Bench JewelersLaunched in 2023, the program will help the passing of knowledge between generations and alleviate the shortage of bench jewelers.
Events & AwardsFeb 19, 2026
The Original Miami Beach Antique Show Returns in MarchThe show will be held March 26-30 at the Miami Beach Convention Center.
Weekly QuizFeb 19, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Joanna Carson’s Jewels Head to AuctionThe estate of the model, philanthropist, and ex-wife of Johnny Carson has signed statement jewels up for sale at John Moran Auctioneers.
PodcastsFeb 18, 2026
Episode 2: Jewelry Trends & Does the Red Carpet Matter?Are arm bands poised to make a comeback? Has red-carpet jewelry become boring? Find out on the second episode of the “My Next Question” podcast.
Brought to you by
How Jewelers Can Fight Back Against Cell JammersCriminals are using cell jammers to disable alarms, but new technology like JamAlert™ can stop them.
MajorsFeb 18, 2026
Select Jewelry Inks Agreement to Distribute Lightweight Gold JewelryIt will lead distribution in North America for Graziella Braccialini's new gold pieces, which it said are 50 percent lighter.
Policies & IssuesFeb 18, 2026
Community for Ethical Jewelry Looks for Executive DirectorThe organization is seeking a new executive director to lead it into its next phase of strategic growth and industry influence.
Events & AwardsFeb 18, 2026
DCA to Host Gemstone Selling Education Session at IJO EventThe nonprofit will present a live, two-hour introductory course on building confidence when selling colored gemstones.
TrendsFeb 17, 2026
A Bit of Jewelry for the Year of the HorseWestern wear continues to trend in the Year of the Fire Horse and along with it, horse and horseshoe motifs in jewelry.
GradingFeb 17, 2026
Dr. George Rossman, Former GIA Governor, Dies at 81Rossman, who advised GIA for more than 50 years, is remembered for his passion and dedication to the field of gemology.
CrimeFeb 13, 2026
JSA Offering $10K Reward in Nancy Guthrie Case Guthrie, the mother of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie, was abducted just as the Tucson gem shows were starting.
IndependentsFeb 13, 2026
97-Year-Old New Mexico Jewelry Store To CloseButterfield Jewelers in Albuquerque, New Mexico, is preparing to close as members of the Butterfield family head into retirement.
CollectionsFeb 13, 2026
A ‘Rosebud’ Necklace for Valentine’s DayPaul Morelli’s “Rosebud” necklace, our Piece of the Week, uses 18-karat rose, green, and white gold to turn the symbol of love into jewelry.
MajorsFeb 13, 2026
JFC Announces New BeneficiariesThe nonprofit has welcomed four new grantees for 2026.
MajorsFeb 12, 2026
These 8 Saks Fifth Avenue Stores Are ClosingParent company Saks Global is also closing nearly all Saks Off 5th locations, a Neiman Marcus store, and 14 personal styling suites.
CollectionsFeb 12, 2026
British Museum Raises $5M to Keep Jewel Linked to Henry VIII, Katherine of AragonIt is believed the 24-karat heart-shaped enameled pendant was made for an event marking the betrothal of Princess Mary in 1518.
Events & AwardsFeb 12, 2026
Kering Opens Entries for 2026 Sustainability-Focused AwardThe “Kering Generation Award x Jewelry” returns for its second year with “Second Chance, First Choice” as its theme.
TrendsFeb 11, 2026
Halle Berry’s Retro Engagement Ring Is a Sapphire-Set StunnerSourced by For Future Reference Vintage, the yellow gold ring has a round center stone surrounded by step-cut sapphires.
MajorsFeb 11, 2026
Francesca’s Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy AgainThe clothing and accessories chain announced last month it would be closing all of its stores.
CollectionsFeb 11, 2026
Zales Turns Sweethearts Into Jewelry for Valentine’s Day CollectionThe “Zales x Sweethearts” collection features three mystery heart charms engraved with classic sayings seen on the Valentine’s Day candies.
TechnologyFeb 11, 2026
Gemvision Symposium 2026 Slated for AprilThe event will include panel discussions, hands-on demonstrations of new digital manufacturing tools, and a jewelry design contest.
Events & AwardsFeb 11, 2026
TJS Announces Roundtable, Launches New AppRegistration is now open for The Jewelry Symposium, set to take place in Detroit from May 16-19.
SourcingFeb 10, 2026
At Meeting in South Africa, Support for Natural Diamonds Picks Up Steam Namibia has formally signed the Luanda Accord, while two key industry organizations pledged to join the Natural Diamond Council.
TrendsFeb 10, 2026
Bad Bunny Wears Football-Shaped ‘Desert Diamond’ for Halftime PerformanceLady Gaga, Cardi B, and Karol G also went with diamond jewelry for Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl halftime show honoring Puerto Rico.
