Former Employees File New Lawsuit Against CD Peacock

IndependentsApr 06, 2022

Former Employees File New Lawsuit Against CD Peacock

Like the previous suit, it accuses the jeweler of conspiring to sell Rolex watches on the gray market and firing whistleblowers.

2022_CD Peacock.jpg
In a new lawsuit filed against C.D. Peacock, former employees have again accused the Chicago-area jeweler of conspiring to sell Rolex watches to gray market resellers and firing those who blew the whistle on the alleged scheme. (Image courtesy of C.D. Peacock’s website)
Chicago—A new lawsuit was filed against Chicago-area jeweler C.D. Peacock last month as part of an ongoing dispute with former employees.

In the suit, Olga Nelson, Suzana Krajisnik, and Giuseppe Di Lorenzo accuse the retailer and some of its employees of conspiring to sell Rolex watches to gray market resellers overseas and firing them for blowing the whistle on their activities.

Previously, Krajisnik filed a lawsuit against C.D. Peacock owner Seymour Holtzman and four of his employees in federal court in Illinois in February 2021, but the case was dismissed without prejudice in April.

In the initial lawsuit, Krajisnik claimed she was fired for being a whistleblower on the alleged conspiracy.

The suit included the names of two other terminated C.D. Peacock employees who also believe they were fired for notifying management of the situation and refusing to participate.

The new lawsuit, filed March 23 in the Circuit Court of Cook County in Illinois, reiterates these same claims and adds the two employees, Nelson and Di Lorenzo, as plaintiffs.

The defendants include C.D. Peacock, its location in the Old Orchard Mall, and Holtzman, who has since transferred ownership of the retailer to son Steven Holtzman.

Staffing and payroll company ADP and Tandem Professional Services have been added as defendants for their alleged roles in the firing of at least one of the former employees.

Illinois law allows for “respondents in discovery” to be named as well.  These respondents can be converted to defendants.

The respondents are Rolex Watch U.S.A. and Chad Adams, a Rolex regional sales representative, as well as former CDP CEO Robert Baumgardner, employee Yingxue Duan, and store managers Christopher Croteau and Dyol Hill.

While it is not illegal to violate Rolex policies or to sell watches on the gray market, the lawsuit claims the defendants violated numerous federal and state laws, including money laundering, mail fraud, wire fraud, immigration fraud, credit card fraud, and federal income tax evasion.

“Our clients allege they were fired from C.D. Peacock after they refused to take part in a far-reaching scheme that involved a litany of illegal activities committed in order to profit by getting this merchandise into the hands of foreign gray market resellers,” said Haskell Garfinkel of Garfinkel Group LLC, whose firm is one of two representing the plaintiffs.

The complaint outlines several instances of Duan allegedly engaging in illegal behavior and violating store and Rolex policies and details an alleged scheme by C.D. Peacock to sell Rolex watches directly into the Asian market.

Di Lorenzo, the former Rolex manager of C.D. Peacock’s store in the Old Orchard Mall, claims in the suit that Duan was “making remote sales of Rolex products, on the phone and online, to heretofore unknown customers,” and “regularly engaging in forging signatures on credit card receipts” to sign for customers who had never visited the store.  

Multiple watches also were being shipped out of state at one time to avoid sales taxes, also violating C.D. Peacock and Rolex policies, the suit alleges.

Krajisnik claimed in the suit that she friended Duan on Facebook and noticed she was posting Rolex products for sale in foreign countries, including on pages for jewelry resellers. 

The suit shares details of Duan’s public social media posts, translated from Mandarin into English, in which she is allegedly negotiating Rolex sales with customers.

In one she wrote, “Official price is $75,000. If you are interested, I can take more pictures,” and, “I can ask my boss and then apply for a discount. I work at an authorized Rolex dealer.”

In another conversation, Duan allegedly said, “If you need detailed pictures with detail, I can take it for you. I work at [an] overseas authorized Rolex authorized dealer. Shipped directly from the store with stickers.”

The lawsuit also details a meeting former CEO Baumgardner had in September 2019 with Adams, the Rolex regional sales rep, to “discuss material violations of the distribution agreement, including but not limited to Rolex’s uncovering of the prohibited sale and ‘gray market’ resale of products online by Duan and defendants.”

After this meeting, Baumgardner allegedly released a memo to management-level employees, reiterating the company’s commitment to Rolex’s sales policies.

 Related stories will be right here … 

According to the lawsuit, the former employees shared the above details with management, including Holtzman, Baumgardner and store managers Croteau and Hill.

After speaking with management, the employees were fired in retaliation, said the suit, adding “the basis of their firings was false and pretextual.”

As per the filing, Nelson claimed she was falsely accused of, and fired for, sexual harassment after saying a member of management she believed to be complicit in the alleged scheme was “in bed” with an employee.

Krajisnik was said to be fired for poor sales numbers, though she claimed her low numbers were the result of Rolex sales being given to Duan.

Di Lorenzo was fired because he extended credit to a customer whose driver’s license was set to expire a few months after the transaction, as per court documents.

In a statement to National Jeweler, a C.D. Peacock spokesperson described the employees as “disgruntled” and said they were terminated for cause.

“The case was previously brought by one of these employees a year ago in federal court and then immediately abandoned when early rulings went against her in that action,” the retailer said.

“CDP intends to vigorously defend this action, as it did the previous one.”

Another well-known luxury watch brand, Patek Philippe, was mentioned in the original complaint. The new lawsuit, however, does not include Patek Philippe.

As of Jan. 31, C.D. Peacock ended its 30-year partnership with Patek Philippe, a C.D. Peacock spokesperson confirmed to National Jeweler.

“Demand from our customers exceeds availability which, in turn, creates disappointment when we are not able to fill all client requests,” the company said. “We continue to explore partnerships with luxury brands that we will announce this year because satisfying our distinguished collectors remains a priority.”

C.D. Peacock was founded in Chicago in 1837, making it one of the city’s oldest retailers, and has three locations in Illinois, with a new flagship in the works.

Lenore Fedowis the associate editor, news at National Jeweler, covering the retail beat and the business side of jewelry.

The Latest

De Beers CEO Al Cook
EditorsJun 17, 2024
Q&A: Al Cook on the Future of De Beers

The De Beers CEO discussed the Anglo American situation, natural diamond marketing, and why the future of lab-grown diamonds is technology.

Instore and Chicago Responsible Jewelry Conference Logos
Events & AwardsJun 17, 2024
Instore Show, Chicago Responsible Jewelry Conference to Co-Locate

The partnership, now in its second year, allows CRJC attendees to register for a free Instore show badge.

Bernd Munsteiner
SourcingJun 17, 2024
Fantasy Cut Inventor Bernd Munsteiner Dies at 81

Known to many as the “Picasso of gems" who modernized the gem cutting field, he is remembered by his family as going through life with open eyes.

Untitled design.jpg
Brought to you by
The End of an Era? Lab-Grown Diamonds' Journey Towards Price Stability

As the demand for lab-grown diamond jewelry may still be increasing, the most notable change we are likely to see is price stabilization.

Stock image of a gavel
CrimeJun 14, 2024
2 Men Sentenced to Life in 2022 Murder of Detroit-Area Jeweler

In court, Daniel Hutchinson’s loved ones remembered the jeweler as a giver, a role model, and a leader.

Weekly QuizJun 13, 2024
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Billie Bangle
CollectionsJun 14, 2024
Piece of the Week: Jade Trau’s ‘Billie’ Bangle

Take a walk along this bangle’s diamond “cobblestone” made from round-, pear-, and marquise-cut diamonds.

Graphic with headshots for My Next Question 2024 Las Vegas webinar
Recorded WebinarsJun 14, 2024
Watch: What Happened in Vegas in 2024

The National Jeweler editors discuss the hot topics, best jewels, and current trends that stood out during Jewelry Market Week.

1872 x 1052 Gemolite.jpg
Brought to you by
Meet Gemology’s Next Generation Microscope: GIA® Gemolite® NXT Professional Edition

GIA®’s most advanced microscope has new features to optimize greater precision and comfort.

Vera Wang Love True lab-grown diamond engagement ring
FinancialsJun 13, 2024
Signet Awaits Engagement Recovery as Q1 Sales Sink 9%

The company is expecting to see a 5 to 10 percent increase in engagements this year.

QVC HSN logo
MajorsJun 13, 2024
HSN, QVC Parent Company Faces Delisting

Qurate Retail is in the middle of a turnaround plan as it battles declining sales.

45.07-carat step cut fancy vivid yellow diamond
AuctionsJun 13, 2024
45-Carat Yellow Diamond Withdrawn from Phillips Auction

Signed jewels and period pieces stood out at the sale.

Marie Lichtenberg Scapular necklace
TrendsJun 13, 2024
Amanda’s Style File: For the Fathers

Showcase your dad’s personal style with a piece of fine jewelry for Father’s Day.

The Eden Rose Diamond
AuctionsJun 12, 2024
10-Carat Pink Diamond Sells for $13M at Christie’s

“The Eden Rose” is a fancy intense pink diamond that was appearing at auction for the first time.

Charles & Colvard moissanite ring
GradingJun 12, 2024
IGI to Grade Charles & Colvard Moissanite

The partnership follows the launch of the jewelry company’s B2B moissanite platform.

Bruce Cleaver
SourcingJun 12, 2024
Bruce Cleaver Is Gemfields’ New Chair

The former De Beers CEO will step into the role next month.

Rose cut arch cabochons Columbia Gem House
SourcingJun 12, 2024
State of Colored Stones: Why the Market Is More Colorful Than Ever

As prices of “The Big Three” skyrocket, supply dwindles, and focus on sustainability grows, an age of open-mindedness is dawning.

Greenwich St jewelers pride raffle
IndependentsJun 11, 2024
Greenwich St. Jewelers Is Hosting a Pride Month Raffle

Tickets to win a ring are for sale until June 13, with proceeds going to a trans care nonprofit.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
ColumnistsJun 11, 2024
Vegas Musings: Equal Parts Noise and Inspiration

Fresh off Jewelry Market Week 2024, Peter Smith separates the positive—retail and product innovation—from the positively annoying.

Katherine Jetter CASE Award winning ring
Events & AwardsJun 11, 2024
The 2024 CASE Awards Are Open for Entries

Submissions will be accepted now through July 17.

Swarovski New York City flagship
IndependentsJun 10, 2024
State of Retail: 4 Retail Design Trends for 2024

From lighter color palettes to the integration of AR, experts offer inspiration for jewelers in need of an aesthetic refresh.

Van Cleef & Arpels 1929 tie necklace
AuctionsJun 10, 2024
Van Cleef & Arpels Necklace From 1929 Sells for $3.6M at Auction

The rare piece went home with a Sotheby’s executive.

Woman shopping
SurveysJun 10, 2024
Consumer Confidence Rises in May Despite Anxiety About the Future

Expectations of a recession rose for the second consecutive month.

Sotheby’s watch executives Sam Hines and Geoff Hess
WatchesJun 10, 2024
Sotheby’s Makes Changes at Top of Watch Division

Sam Hines returns to the auction house as chairman, watches, while Geoff Hess moves up to the role of global head of watches.

Elephants wading in the Okavango Delta in Botswana
SourcingJun 10, 2024
State of the Diamond Industry: Botswana Beyond Diamonds

From moringa to ecotourism in the Okavango Delta, the country and its leaders are exploring how Botswana can diversify its economy.

Seymour Holtzman
IndependentsJun 07, 2024
Seymour Holtzman of CD Peacock Dies at 88

He was remembered by loved ones as “an authentic, original American entrepreneur.”

45 carat yellow diamond
AuctionsJun 07, 2024
Phillips to Auction 45-Carat Yellow Diamond

The stone features rare step-cut faceting and is estimated to sell for up to $3.5 million.

Tabayer Oera ‘Unity’ Ring
CollectionsJun 07, 2024
Piece of the Week: Tabayer’s Oera ‘Unity’ Ring

Crafted in Fairmined gold with a rainbow of agate, the ring is a joyful symbol of inclusivity, diversity, and solidarity.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy