Former Employees File New Lawsuit Against CD Peacock
Like the previous suit, it accuses the jeweler of conspiring to sell Rolex watches on the gray market and firing whistleblowers.
![In a new lawsuit filed against C.D. Peacock, former employees have again accused the Chicago-area jeweler of conspiring to sell Rolex watches to gray market resellers and firing those who blew the whistle on the alleged scheme. (Image courtesy of C.D. Peacock’s website) 2022_CD Peacock.jpg](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/e878610c89cd521e0c43ddce181b7c7b.jpg)
In the suit, Olga Nelson, Suzana Krajisnik, and Giuseppe Di Lorenzo accuse the retailer and some of its employees of conspiring to sell Rolex watches to gray market resellers overseas and firing them for blowing the whistle on their activities.
Previously, Krajisnik filed a lawsuit against C.D. Peacock owner Seymour Holtzman and four of his employees in federal court in Illinois in February 2021, but the case was dismissed without prejudice in April.
In the initial lawsuit, Krajisnik claimed she was fired for being a whistleblower on the alleged conspiracy.
The suit included the names of two other terminated C.D. Peacock employees who also believe they were fired for notifying management of the situation and refusing to participate.
The new lawsuit, filed March 23 in the Circuit Court of Cook County in Illinois, reiterates these same claims and adds the two employees, Nelson and Di Lorenzo, as plaintiffs.
The defendants include C.D. Peacock, its location in the Old Orchard Mall, and Holtzman, who has since transferred ownership of the retailer to son Steven Holtzman.
Staffing and payroll company ADP and Tandem Professional Services have been added as defendants for their alleged roles in the firing of at least one of the former employees.
Illinois law allows for “respondents in discovery” to be named as well. These respondents can be converted to defendants.
The respondents are Rolex Watch U.S.A. and Chad Adams, a Rolex regional sales representative, as well as former CDP CEO Robert Baumgardner, employee Yingxue Duan, and store managers Christopher Croteau and Dyol Hill.
While it is not illegal to violate Rolex policies or to sell watches on the gray market, the lawsuit claims the defendants violated numerous federal and state laws, including money laundering, mail fraud, wire fraud, immigration fraud, credit card fraud, and federal income tax evasion.
“Our clients allege they were fired from C.D. Peacock after they refused to take part in a far-reaching scheme that involved a litany of illegal activities committed in order to profit by getting this merchandise into the hands of foreign gray market resellers,” said Haskell Garfinkel of Garfinkel Group LLC, whose firm is one of two representing the plaintiffs.
The complaint outlines several instances of Duan allegedly engaging in illegal behavior and violating store and Rolex policies and details an alleged scheme by C.D. Peacock to sell Rolex watches directly into the Asian market.
Di Lorenzo, the former Rolex manager of C.D. Peacock’s store in the Old Orchard Mall, claims in the suit that Duan was “making remote sales of Rolex products, on the phone and online, to heretofore unknown customers,” and “regularly engaging in forging signatures on credit card receipts” to sign for customers who had never visited the store.
Multiple watches also were being shipped out of state at one time to avoid sales taxes, also violating C.D. Peacock and Rolex policies, the suit alleges.
Krajisnik claimed in the suit that she friended Duan on Facebook and noticed she was posting Rolex products for sale in foreign countries, including on pages for jewelry resellers.
The suit shares details of Duan’s public social media posts, translated from Mandarin into English, in which she is allegedly negotiating Rolex sales with customers.
In one she wrote, “Official price is $75,000. If you are interested, I can take more pictures,” and, “I can ask my boss and then apply for a discount. I work at an authorized Rolex dealer.”
In another conversation, Duan allegedly said, “If you need detailed pictures with detail, I can take it for you. I work at [an] overseas authorized Rolex authorized dealer. Shipped directly from the store with stickers.”
The lawsuit also details a meeting former CEO Baumgardner had in September 2019 with Adams, the Rolex regional sales rep, to “discuss material violations of the distribution agreement, including but not limited to Rolex’s uncovering of the prohibited sale and ‘gray market’ resale of products online by Duan and defendants.”
After this meeting, Baumgardner allegedly released a memo to management-level employees, reiterating the company’s commitment to Rolex’s sales policies.
According to the lawsuit, the former employees shared the above details with management, including Holtzman, Baumgardner and store managers Croteau and Hill.
After speaking with management, the employees were fired in retaliation, said the suit, adding “the basis of their firings was false and pretextual.”
As per the filing, Nelson claimed she was falsely accused of, and fired for, sexual harassment after saying a member of management she believed to be complicit in the alleged scheme was “in bed” with an employee.
Krajisnik was said to be fired for poor sales numbers, though she claimed her low numbers were the result of Rolex sales being given to Duan.
Di Lorenzo was fired because he extended credit to a customer whose driver’s license was set to expire a few months after the transaction, as per court documents.
In a statement to National Jeweler, a C.D. Peacock spokesperson described the employees as “disgruntled” and said they were terminated for cause.
“The case was previously brought by one of these employees a year ago in federal court and then immediately abandoned when early rulings went against her in that action,” the retailer said.
“CDP intends to vigorously defend this action, as it did the previous one.”
Another well-known luxury watch brand, Patek Philippe, was mentioned in the original complaint. The new lawsuit, however, does not include Patek Philippe.
As of Jan. 31, C.D. Peacock ended its 30-year partnership with Patek Philippe, a C.D. Peacock spokesperson confirmed to National Jeweler.
“Demand from our customers exceeds availability which, in turn, creates disappointment when we are not able to fill all client requests,” the company said. “We continue to explore partnerships with luxury brands that we will announce this year because satisfying our distinguished collectors remains a priority.”
C.D. Peacock was founded in Chicago in 1837, making it one of the city’s oldest retailers, and has three locations in Illinois, with a new flagship in the works.
The Latest
![Direct-to-consumer retail brand Diamonds Direct has opened a store in the Atlanta neighborhood of Buckhead, an area known for its upscale malls. Diamonds Direct Atlanta store](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/2e6577afc9470ba1c1de327fad397366.jpg)
It’s the Signet-owned banner’s first location in Georgia.
![These “Double Loop” earrings feature a drop-cut amethyst sitting atop the lower hoop, totaling 1.60 carats between both earrings. The hoops are made of silver covered in “pistacchio” colored enamel, while 9-karat yellow gold holds the stones in place and connect the two hoops behind the earlobe ($1,770). Bea Bongiasca’s Double Loop Earrings](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/f338ef6b4603be3c97765f833b831ca0.jpg)
Commemorate “brat summer” with these green hoops.
![The skyline of downtown Providence, Rhode Island. Jewelers of America held one of its Multifacted Learning Workshops there on July 17 and National Jeweler Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff tagged along. Stock image of Providence, Rhode Island, skyline](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/4ec5b02d4cbaaaa2283bdcf6820950a4.jpg)
Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff returns from Rhode Island with thoughts about in-store shopping and a trends report.
![Untitled design.jpg](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/583fbcb2bb839782810080debef35d3c.jpg)
As the demand for lab-grown diamond jewelry may still be increasing, the most notable change we are likely to see is price stabilization.
Sponsored by Gemological Institute of America
![](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/99a46b30cc354962ac2e29ecd113587a.jpg)
![Earlier this month, online giant Amazon and the Better Business Bureau filed a joint federal lawsuit against ReviewServiceUSA.com for allegedly selling fake reviews, both positive and negative. Amazon package outside door](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/27fce4225a38900d54a5536ce523a22d.jpg)
They claim ReviewServiceUSA.com was selling both positive and negative reviews of products and businesses.
![A shot of the Venetia diamond mine in South Africa, owned by De Beers Group. The diamond miner and marketer saw revenue drop 21 percent and rough diamond sales decline 20 percent in a “weak” market for diamonds. De Beers’ Venetia diamond mine](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/a1f16ceaaba662e80385166060d192a7.jpg)
Lab-grown diamond sales in the United States and ongoing economic challenges in China are impacting natural diamond demand.
![1872 x 1052 Gemolite.jpg](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/9d60901b44425a53b9010301897a3bbc.jpg)
GIA®’s most advanced microscope has new features to optimize greater precision and comfort.
![A malachite and diamond bracelet from Pomellato’s “Pom Pom Dot” collection, launched earlier this year. Pomellato and Boucheron were bright spots for Kering in an otherwise underwhelming first half of the year. Pomellato Malachite Pom Pom Dot bracelet](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/3c237b62e009742fc52487097daf3c5a.jpg)
The gains come amid a tough time for parent company Kering, which saw sales slide 11 percent in the first half of the year.
![Volunteers and Shane Co.’s corporate team from all 22 locations of the family-owned jewelry chain have begun packing backpacks with school supplies for teachers to distribute to their students this school year. Shane Co. and the Kids in Need foundation logo](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/1c5abfb36ec775724f014f47bfbb47fc.jpg)
The fine jewelry retailer filled backpacks with back-to-school essentials for students in 13 states.
![A shot from the advertising campaign for LVMH-owned Bulgari’s “Eden the Garden of Wonders” high jewelry collection. LVMH’s jewelry and watch sales slipped in the first half of the fiscal year. Bulgari high jewelry campaign](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/c24eb75ca8cea44d2e9859648f4a98ee.jpg)
Tiffany & Co. is focusing on its “iconic” collections while the company has made changes at the top at TAG Heuer and Hublot.
![Chaumet, a Parisian jeweler owned by LVMH, has designed the Olympic and Paralympic Games medals. Chaumet Paris 2024 Olympics medals](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/7831b3a738baddfc7d783e6df0fbf796.jpg)
The Parisian brand is the first jewelry company in the history of the Olympic and Paralympic Games to design the medals.
![The acquisition of Union Life & Casualty by Jewelers Mutual will help strengthen both the pawn market and the insurance industry, said JM. Jewelers Mutual and Union Life and Casualty logos](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/195925667226ecfc51b4e1bb09607143.jpg)
Union Life & Casualty will join JM Insurance Agency Partners, expanding the provider’s pawnbroker coverage.
![The winner of this year’s Lonia Tate scholarship, Bradlei Smith will receive the opportunity to earn her Graduate Gemologist diploma from GIA and, following graduation, an internship at Ben Bridge Jeweler in Seattle. Bradlei Smith](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/996834935ae30a7a1195db8b9db6cb7d.jpg)
Los Angeles-based Bradlei Smith was selected for this year’s award.
![Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com. National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/bec7295a7f478778b1c196e6d81e7cd9.jpg)
In his latest column, Smith shares multiple reasons why people who look at the glass as being hall full often make better salespeople.
![De Beers Group mined 6.4 million carats of diamonds in the second quarter of 2024, down from 7.6 million in the same period last year. (©De Beers Group/Photo credit: Ben Perry @ Armoury Films) De Beers rough diamond display](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/80cd02b1c8384f4b2efda0bcdf6a75e1.jpg)
The company also reported the $150 million sale of an iron ore royalty right, part of its ongoing effort to divest “non-core” assets.
![L.A.-based flower designer, Sophia Moreno-Bunge models Guzema’s “Hidden Beauty” collection in front of a garden in Rustic Canyon in Santa Monica, California. Sophia Moreno-Bunge of Isa Isa modeling Guzema’s Hidden Beauty collection](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/6f3822623eb7fd2f6468f82825194cb1.jpg)
The ad features three celebrity florists creating floral sculptures while wearing jewelry by Guzema.
![The Entrepreneurship Grants program supports winners with financial aid to scale their businesses and increase their societal impact, said Diamonds Do Good. Pictured here are three of the 13 winners, top right is Tresia Shituula, and bottom row left to right, are Monkgogi Moshaga and Mohamed Samu. Tresia Shituula, Monkgogi Moshaga, Mohamed Samu](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/a7c9b87301b76a9446f6522747ce5b95.jpg)
The grant provided a total of $100,000 to support 13 entrepreneurs from diamond communities in Africa and India.
![Ghazi Osta, better known as Gus, was the owner and president of Volusia Gold & Diamond, a store he and his wife, Leigh Osta, opened in 1986. He was shot and killed inside the store Friday afternoon after a brief argument with a regular customer. (Photo courtesy of Volusia Gold & Diamond Facebook page) Ghazi “Gus” Michel Osta](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/c8c1fa3df746cbd364915a98dcac9d21.jpg)
Ghazi Michel Osta, or “Gus,” was killed Friday by an 83-year-old man said to be a frequent customer at his store, Volusia Gold & Diamond.
![Elyssa Jenkins-Pérez (left) is the Responsible Jewellery Council’s new head of North American development, and Effie Marinos is its new specialist advisor for technical standards. Elyssa Jenkins-Perez and Effie Marinos](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/94332af0c7a776e7a8c36fabf76baa5f.jpg)
The organization also announced Effie Marinos as its new specialist advisor for technical standards, as well as four other appointments.
![Karen Rentmeesters, who joined the Antwerp World Diamond Centre in 2010, will take on the role of CEO. Karen Rentmeesters](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/3256fcc71cd43a399055c61f68486269.jpg)
Rentmeesters has served as interim CEO since April following former CEO Ari Epstein’s resignation.
![Longtime Washington, D.C., jeweler Brian Mann (right) with his wife Jessie Mann, an artist who custom-paints porcelain Limoges Boxes, at a 2016 Jewelers of America member event. Mann, the longtime co-owner of David Mann Jewelers, died June 21 at age 70. Brian and Jessie Mann](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/be4debc6e0b3198943a66ef0e2197c2c.jpg)
Mann, whose family’s jewelry store was located inside the Pentagon, is remembered for being a thoughtful champion of the industry.
![The 1916 Company recently opened a new Tudor boutique in Denver’s Cherry Creek Shopping Center. Tudor store in Denver](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/9f8600ea53ed731963331ebd28a10d16.jpg)
The 500-square-foot boutique is located in Denver’s Cherry Creek Shopping Center.
![This necklace from Messika’s “So Move Max” set is made of yellow gold with 19.18-carats of brilliant-cut diamonds and designed with circle motifs that move within the links (price upon request). Messika’s So Move Max Necklace](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/14c78af4a4e8c6b996a81bbb5a5bc69f.jpg)
Dance all night long with the “So Move Max” set’s necklace.
![On Sept. 1, Julien Tornare (left), current CEO of TAG Heuer, will become CEO of Hublot. Antoine Pin, now the general manager of Bulgari’s watch business, will take over Tornare’s role as CEO of TAG Heuer. (Images courtesy of LinkedIn) Julien Tornare and Antoine Pin](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/b24627b34ece895ddd254bae22751fb8.jpg)
Luxury giant LVMH is reshuffling the leadership in its watches division.
![A rendering of a billboard from Etsy’s new campaign. The campaign is designed to highlight the platform’s creators and how their products are made. Etsy billboard rendering in NYC](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/9a94f394f326b90dc1c9da6a711c5e09.jpg)
Sellers and shoppers have spoken out against a rise in mass-produced merchandise on the platform meant to highlight handmade goods.
![Ariana Grande said she cannot wait “to inspire others to embrace their own unique sparkle,” as Swarovski’s brand ambassador. (Photo credited to Mert Alas and Marcus Piggot for Swarovski) Ariana Grande Modeling in Swarovski Jewelry](https://uploads.nationaljeweler.com/uploads/adaa79dce0741a275427155078691611.jpg)
The celebrity will star in Swarovski’s holiday campaign.