Peter Smith: Is That All There Is? Have We Peaked?
Smith addresses fears about a plateaued market with a reminder that retailers who do it right always will have room to grow.

In addition to serving as a much-needed break from the daily machinations of doing our respective jobs, this trip has proven to be a wonderful catalyst for reflection and perspective.
We’ve had Premier League football (my wife Sherry’s first experience of “the beautiful game” in England) at Craven Cottage, home of Fulham FC, as they took on and, unfortunately, beat my brother’s favorite team, Leicester City.
We had a marvelous day in Oxford, imagining Harry Potter villains were watching us, perched atop and within the hallowed buildings of Christ Church, which counts multiple prime ministers and esteemed other foreign leaders amongst its alum … oh and, lest I forget, the author Lewis Carroll of “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland” fame.
I discovered that detail while enjoying high tea in the Alice Room at The Randolph Hotel and wondered aloud why the walls were adorned with cool and slightly funky oversized artwork depicting Alice and friends in their Wonderland.
We also loved a couple of trips to Portobello Road Market in Notting Hill (yes, the Hugh Grant and Julia Roberts Notting Hill).

On our second visit, absent the throngs of shoppers from our Saturday sojourn, we were enjoying lunch outside at a small Italian restaurant when our conversation turned to a familiar topic for us, the retail experience.
We loved the canopy of colored umbrellas we’d seen at Camden Market a couple of days earlier.
We laughed at the sight of a small Fiat car, sliced down the middle and serving (sorry for the pun) as brilliant window art in a pizza restaurant, and we had generally marveled at the assortment of fun and interesting retail theater in Soho and throughout our vacation in the Greater London area.

As we consumed the myriad sights and sounds, I was reminded of the power of fun retail experiences, and how, at its best, physical retail can be the most wonderful theater, emotionally engaging, experiential, and rewarding in and of itself.
In contemplating another fabulous year in independent retail jewelry here in the United States—as a strong August has the independents now tracking ahead of what ended up being a fantastic year in 2023—I was reminded once again that the spoils go to those who fully embrace the best of what retail can offer and execute well.
I know of retail jewelers who are outperforming the market and, regretfully, I also know far too many who are underperforming.
In a post-pandemic environment, where the rising tide of recent years allowed all-comers to jump aboard, the minimum requirement now is solid execution of retail fundamentals.
In recent weeks, I’ve had two industry colleagues ask me if I thought we had peaked; if, in one instance, perhaps his business had plateaued and, in the second instance, if we as an industry have begun to see a maturation of the market in the U.S.
In answer to the maturation of the market, I ask you to cast your memory back to 2019.
The jewelry business had come off a phenomenal year, and we were asking ourselves how we got there and how long the ride could possibly last. Had someone told us then that we would see more than 50 percent growth in the next two or three years, we wouldn’t have believed it.
But we did get there, and customers voted with their wallets and made it abundantly clear that jewelry and timepieces mattered, and they were glad to take discretionary dollars and spend them in jewelry stores when they couldn’t spend them elsewhere.
The abiding message of the period was that jewelry stores held great appeal to consumers, and they were happy to reward stores with bigger returns than we could ever have imagined.
As 2023 turned to 2024, the rising tide that rewarded everybody has become a lot more discerning.
Dysfunctional retailers are being found out. We are seeing, to paraphrase Warren Buffett, who was swimming naked when the tide went out.
It is easy to mask a multitude of sins when driving record sales.
That condition wasn’t specific to the events of recent years (if you look closely enough, you could see it all over our industry at retail and on the supplier side), but it was magnified beyond our wildest imagination.
It was, quite frankly, easy to believe you were a good retailer even though you were not.
Conversations about peaking, or maturation of markets, make sense off the back of superb execution, and superb execution can be as complex as Carroll’s rabbit hole.
What it must include, however, is an experience that excites the senses—scent, visual, sound, lighting, touch … perhaps even an old Fiat—and an attitude of “less not more” when it comes to product stories; don’t make your customers work too hard to decide what you are.
It should include technology that enhances the customer experience, data analysis (don’t get me started on the gut-instinct merchants) and hiring the right people (you not having a plan does not mean there are no viable candidates).
“It’s time to get busy being great.”
It also must surely include an ongoing training plan designed to influence consumer behavior (which does not mean loading up your sales team with so much product information that they become a danger to customers), and it should include a path to engage both career-minded employees, and those just looking for engaging work that aligns with their quality-of-life needs.
It should offer a compensation plan that reflects an improvement over what they can earn in less-taxing environments and the chance to work in a culture built on respect for all employees, one that affords them the opportunity to do good work with good people.
I am and will remain a staunch believer in great retail and great retailers. The numbers reflect that there are enough of them doing enough good stuff to see this remarkable journey continue for the foreseeable future.
For retailers who have regressed from the highs of recent years, this is not the time to assign blame or look for scapegoats in your organization, but to honestly reflect on your execution, identify what needs to change, and reach out to people who can help shine a light on missed opportunities in your business.
In short, it’s time to get busy being great.
Happy retailing!
The Latest

Bain & Co.’s latest report on the luxury market examines why the market’s customer base is shrinking and how to appeal to consumers in 2025.

Officers in Louisville seized 28 shipments of fake jewelry and watches that would have been worth more than $27 million if genuine.

The collection centers on the art of tailoring, inspired by designs that feature folded fabrics, such as a tuxedo lapel.

Colored stones are stepping into a jewelry spotlight typically reserved for diamonds—are you ready to sell color?

The trade show has added a new location to its fall line-up.


From the brand’s latest collection of lucky charms, the ladybird is seen as a bearer of good fortune and a ward against negative energy.

The moves come amid a prolonged period of lower demand for diamonds, particularly in China.

The new year feels like a clean slate, inspiring reflection, hope, and the motivation to become better versions of ourselves.

The workshop returns in March, along with the “Battle of the Benches” mini challenge series.

Two attorneys purchased Windsor Jewelry, which was set to close, and will retain all existing staff at the downtown Indianapolis store.

Adam Heyman joined the family business in 1965, just weeks after graduating from Columbia Business School.

The “Essence of Nature, Chapter One” collection echoes trees and roots, literally and figuratively, through three sets of high jewelry.

The fourth-generation, family-owned jeweler has given its Worth Avenue store a new look.

Luxury watch dealer Anthony Farrer pleaded guilty late last year to defrauding clients in a scheme with Ponzi-type elements.

In its full-year results, the retailer shared its 2025 outlook and an update on the global rollout of its lab-grown diamond collection.

Celebrate February birthstones and the gem shows in Arizona this month with a versatile stone like amethyst.

Scheetz has been with the nonprofit since 2007.

The agreement will allocate an increasing proportion of the country’s rough diamonds to the government of Botswana over the next decade.

“Cosmic Splendor: Jewelry From the Collections of Van Cleef & Arpels,” opens April 11 at the American Museum of Natural History.

Those celebrating Valentine’s Day this year are expected to spend a record $27.5 billion on jewels, flowers, candy, and more.

From Lady Gaga’s 1930s Tiffany & Co. necklace to Taylor Swift’s “T,” Michelle Graff recaps the night’s most memorable jewelry looks.

Layoffs will reportedly start next month as HSN plans to move into QVC’s location in Pennsylvania.

A group of creatives talked to Associate Editor Lauren McLemore about their approach to the annual Tucson gem, mineral, and fossil shows.

The auction also featured the sale of a Cartier necklace made when Egyptomania was sweeping Great Britain.

The “Blossom Rosette” blooms with love, beauty, and hope for the year ahead.

Rovinsky is remembered as a great mentor who made the employees of his stores feel like family.

For every jeweler who tries their luck, the company will make a donation to Jewelers for Children.