CrimeOct 07, 2025
Men Who Posed as Utility Workers Found Guilty in Jeweler’s MurderCrimeOct 15, 2025
Men Receive Lengthy Prison Sentences for 2023 Murder of Colorado Jeweler
Charles Robinson Shay was sentenced to life in prison plus 120 years while his accomplice, Michael James McCormack, got 75 years.
Peter Damian Arguello, who owned and operated Peter Damian Fine Jewelry & Antiques in Wheat Ridge, Colorado, for almost two decades, was shot and killed in his store in November 2023. The men convicted in the case earlier this year have been sentenced. (Photo courtesy of the Wheat Ridge Police Department)
Golden, Colo.—The two men found guilty in the 2023 robbery and murder of Wheat Ridge, Colorado, jeweler Peter Damian Arguello will spend a long time behind bars.
The Colorado First Judicial District Attorney’s Office announced that on Monday, Michael James McCormack, 51, was sentenced to 75 years in prison after being found guilty of felony murder and aggravated robbery, among other charges.
The other man charged in the case, 42-year-old Charles Robinson Shay, was found guilty in a separate trial of 10 counts in connection with Arguello’s death, including first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping, and aggravated robbery.
Jurors also found Shay, who has six prior felony convictions, to be a “habitual criminal” under Colorado law, a charge that can lead to longer prison sentences.
Shay was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole plus 120 years on Sept. 10, the DA’s office said.
Related stories will be right here …
The Colorado First Judicial District Attorney’s Office announced that on Monday, Michael James McCormack, 51, was sentenced to 75 years in prison after being found guilty of felony murder and aggravated robbery, among other charges.
The other man charged in the case, 42-year-old Charles Robinson Shay, was found guilty in a separate trial of 10 counts in connection with Arguello’s death, including first-degree murder, second-degree kidnapping, and aggravated robbery.
Jurors also found Shay, who has six prior felony convictions, to be a “habitual criminal” under Colorado law, a charge that can lead to longer prison sentences.
Shay was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole plus 120 years on Sept. 10, the DA’s office said.
Arguello, 64, was the owner of Peter Damian Fine Jewelry & Antiques, a store he opened in 2007.
According to the DA’s office, Arguello’s wife, Teresa Casillas, said during sentencing that after her husband’s death, they had to close their business because, “Peter was the reason customers came to the store.”
“He was committed to working at least 10 more years because he loved his little shop and took so much pride in its treasures. Unlike most of us, going to work was fun for him,” she said.
In a post on Facebook, the Wheat Ridge Police Department described the late jeweler as a friend, mentor, and father figure in the Wheat Ridge community.
“His shop was a welcoming, safe place where you were always greeted with a smile,” the post reads.
“Peter embodied the kind of optimism and compassion we try to exemplify in our community and in our police department … Justice will not bring Peter back, but we sincerely hope this outcome will allow Peter’s family to heal. They are part of our family now, forever and always. As we move forward, we honor his memory by living life with joy and kindness.”
Arguello was in his store on the morning of Nov. 29, 2023, when Shay and McCormack came in.
Prosecutors and Arguello’s family argued during trial that McCormack earned Arguello’s trust in order to gain access to the store and then target him, keeping tabs on the jeweler “like a lurking, cunning predator.”
During the robbery, it was Shay who bound Arguello with flex cuffs, assaulted him, and fatally shot him, the DA’s office said.
Both men were seen by witnesses fleeing through the back door and getting into a red Chevy Silverado—which police later determined had been stolen—that was found after it had been set on fire.
DNA found on the flex cuffs linked Shay to the crime, and he was formally charged in January 2024.
Police issued a warrant for McCormack on March 7, 2024, and arrested him on May 2 following a two-month search.
Editors' Picks
Sponsored by
More on Crime
The Latest
PodcastsAug 19, 2026
Episode 8: Diamond Industry Update With David Bonaparte & Ronnie VanderLindenThe industry veterans join the podcast to discuss diamond marketing, the FTC Jewelry Guides, and lobbying for lower tariffs.
MajorsAug 19, 2026
Mike Alexander To Succeed Scott Murphy as Jewelers Mutual CEO Murphy will retire at the end of the year and Alexander, currently the company’s president, will take over at the start of 2027.
Policies & IssuesAug 19, 2026
Spinelli Kilcollin Embraces Dupes With Trade-In ProgramThe jeweler is encouraging customers who own lookalike rings to come into the store and trade them for credit towards an authentic piece.
Brought to you by
Your Piece Could Be the One Editors Talk AboutSubmit your pieces for a chance to win in this year's competition.
MajorsAug 19, 2026
Zales Wants You to Wear Fine Jewelry Every DayThe new campaign, “You Are The Occasion,” discourages shoppers from saving their fine jewelry for special occasions only.
Weekly QuizAug 13, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
SourcingAug 19, 2026
Vasant Mehta, a Dedicated Diamond Industry Leader, Dies at 81Mehta led India’s GJEPC through the 2008 financial crisis and was respected worldwide for his wisdom, integrity, and knowledge.
ColumnistsAug 18, 2026
Peter Smith: The IKEA Effect and Bridal Branding In a new column, Peter Smith posits that people actually enjoy putting together IKEA furniture, and the same is true for engagement rings.
Brought to you by
Why More Jewelry Retailers Are Hosting Turnkey Estate Buying EventsRetailers are seeking new ways to attract customers, increase traffic, and create revenue – Estate buying events are a popular solution.
Lab-GrownAug 18, 2026
Ring Concierge, Kendall Jenner’s Tequila Brand Collab on GiveawayThe jeweler has partnered with 818 Tequila to gift lab-grown diamond studs to a bride-to-be and their bridal party.
Events & AwardsAug 17, 2026
Exhibition on Louis Comfort Tiffany’s Studios to Open at The MetThe exhibition will feature more than 100 drawings of stained-glass lampshades, windows, and more, many created by women and émigrés.
CollectionsAug 17, 2026
Marquise Diamonds Dance in Spinelli Kilcollin’s ‘Wren’ CollectionMarquise-cut diamonds in drop charms are the center of the new collection, reflecting the movement of a dancer in modular styles.
Events & AwardsAug 17, 2026
There’s a New Jewelry Show Coming to FloridaThe inaugural Fort Lauderdale Jewelry, Antique, & Object Show will be held from Jan. 28 through Feb. 1, 2027.
IndependentsAug 14, 2026
Smyth Jewelers to Open Fourth LocationThe family-owned jeweler will open a new showroom in Bel Air, Maryland, this fall.
CrimeAug 14, 2026
Wife of Man Convicted in Jeweler’s Murder Sentenced for Conspiracy Amanda Ileana Hernandez is married to Carlos Hernandez, one of two men in prison for the 2024 murder of Michigan jeweler Hussein Murray.
TrendsAug 14, 2026
Paul Morelli’s Latest ‘Wavey Vine’ Earrings Embrace ColorThe reimagined jewel, our Piece of the Week, trades the diamonds in the original 1998 design for blue, pink, yellow, and green sapphires.
Supplier BulletinAug 13, 2026
Your Piece Could Be the One Editors Talk AboutSponsored by American Gem Trade Association
FinancialsAug 13, 2026
Pandora’s ‘Talisman’ Collection Shines, Lab-Grown Diamond Sales FallIn the United States, second-quarter sales were flat amid soft consumer sentiment and lower in-store traffic.
AuctionsAug 13, 2026
This Gold Cadbury ‘Conundrum’ Egg Set a World Auction RecordThe 22-karat gold egg, sold at Batemans Auctioneers in the U.K., was part of a 1980s treasure hunt ad campaign for Cadbury Creme Eggs.
SourcingAug 13, 2026
2,488-Carat Diamond, Largest Found in Botswana, Has a New Owner Lucara Diamond Corp., which recovered the “Motswedi” diamond from the Karowe mine, sold the stone for an undisclosed amount.
CollectionsAug 13, 2026
John Hardy Infuses ‘Icon,’ ‘Heishi’ Collections with ColorThe expanded collections now feature hand-cut gemstones like topaz, tanzanite, chrysoprase, chalcedony, smoky quartz, and fire opal.
Lab-GrownAug 13, 2026
Jean Dousset Opens Third StoreThe lab-grown diamond jewelry brand’s newest boutique is in Westfield Valley Fair in Santa Clara, California.
SourcingAug 12, 2026
Eshed-Gemstar on the Painstaking Process of Cutting ‘The Legacy Emerald’The gemstone supplier and manufacturer acquired the remarkable 104-gram Zambian emerald at Gemfields’ auction in May.
CrimeAug 12, 2026
Elderly NYC Woman Targeted in Jewelry Swap SchemeTwo suspects offered to trade the woman a “winning” lottery ticket for her jewelry.
SourcingAug 12, 2026
Another Diamond Mine Poised to CloseFinsch has been in business rescue since May, and owner Petra Diamonds said it sees no viable path forward for the mine.
CrimeAug 12, 2026
Jewelry Store Employee Gets 20 Years to Life in Choking Death of BossMichel Patrick DeSalles was sentenced after pleading guilty to the 2017 murder of Omid Gholian, who owned a jewelry store in Manhattan.
MajorsAug 12, 2026
Frederick Goldman Names New SVP of SalesLongtime industry executive Beth Miller has taken on the role.
AuctionsAug 11, 2026
Verdura Unicorn Brooch With Royal Connection Up for Auction The brooch was owned by Virginia Fortune Ryan Ogilvy, who served as a lady of the bedchamber to Queen Elizabeth II for nearly 50 years.
