ColumnistsJun 30, 2025
The Smart Lab: Why Q3 Is the Secret Weapon For Holiday Jewelry SalesColumnistsJul 08, 2025
Peter Smith: Why Jewelers Struggle With Premium Pricing
Luxury brands charge thousands for their shoes and handbags. Jewelers pricing diamond products should take note, Peter Smith writes.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
I saw a post on LinkedIn recently where someone from the trade was questioning the logic of natural diamond pricing.
He posited that since diamonds cost just “hundreds of dollars” to extract from the ground, and since they sell at retail for “thousands of dollars,” he wondered who was getting all the money, the implication being, “How can they sleep at night with all those profits!”
What he didn’t ask was how much it cost to make Louis Vuitton bags and why they sell for thousands of dollars, despite being crafted of materials that are decidedly less than rare.
He didn’t mention anything about the fact that LVMH CEO Bernard Arnault has become one of the richest people in the world off the back of those substantial profits from manufacture through retail.
He didn’t ask what Ferragamo shoes cost to make or why they sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars.
He didn’t even ask why Elsa Peretti open-heart pendants can cost thousands of dollars and why Tiffany & Co. (oops, back to LVMH again) commands so much money for such a basic product.
He posited that since diamonds cost just “hundreds of dollars” to extract from the ground, and since they sell at retail for “thousands of dollars,” he wondered who was getting all the money, the implication being, “How can they sleep at night with all those profits!”
What he didn’t ask was how much it cost to make Louis Vuitton bags and why they sell for thousands of dollars, despite being crafted of materials that are decidedly less than rare.
He didn’t mention anything about the fact that LVMH CEO Bernard Arnault has become one of the richest people in the world off the back of those substantial profits from manufacture through retail.
He didn’t ask what Ferragamo shoes cost to make or why they sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars.
He didn’t even ask why Elsa Peretti open-heart pendants can cost thousands of dollars and why Tiffany & Co. (oops, back to LVMH again) commands so much money for such a basic product.
“In a business where we command, in my view, appropriate price premiums for brands such as David Yurman, Roberto Coin, Marco Bicego, and even Pandora, we continue to tie ourselves in knots at the prospect of doing likewise with diamond products.”
— Peter Smith
I mean, have you ever even put those pendants on a scale?
In a business where we command, in my view, appropriate price premiums for brands such as David Yurman, Roberto Coin, Marco Bicego, and even Pandora, where the suggested retail pricing has virtually no bearing at all on the cost of materials and manufacture, we continue to tie ourselves in knots at the prospect of doing likewise with diamond products.
It’s as if even thinking about making margin on diamonds is crossing a moral rubicon.
Instead of asking ourselves what we should price the goods at, we gingerly tiptoe upwards from our costs and then, even after arriving at the minimum level of acceptable pricing, often allow discounting, further eroding essential margins.
Why do we do that? Why don’t we lean confidently into premium pricing and embrace the value proposition?
The science of pricing psychology is clear in showing that customers use prices as a proxy for quality. This is especially true when they don’t have a clear sense for the products or category in question.
The higher the price, the better the perceived quality. The higher the perceived quality, the greater the level of consumer satisfaction.
Do customers really care what your margins are or what you paid for a diamond or a piece of jewelry?
Do they know what the price of gold is before they visit their local jewelry store to mark a special occasion?
In “Unleash Your Primal Brain,” Tim Ash wrote, “If something is thought of as being cheap, our conscious mind will associate it with being less effective and substandard as well. Our brain can force us to undermine its objective qualities.”
It seems to me that retailers lose entirely too much sleep fretting over whether they are charging customers too much for product, instead of focusing on the most important task of inspiring customers to want to spend more.
Monsieur Arnault and Signore and Signora Ferragamo? They sleep just fine.
Happy retailing!
Editors' Picks
Sponsored by
More on Columnists
The Latest
AuctionsApr 27, 2026
12 Years Later, the ‘Ocean Dream’ Diamond Resurfaces at Christie’sThe largest known fancy vivid blue-green diamond could fetch more than $12 million at its second auction appearance.
IndependentsApr 27, 2026
Longnecker Jewelry Celebrates 30 YearsIn honor of the milestone, the Nebraska jeweler has debuted Leslie & Co., its new in-house jewelry brand.
MajorsApr 27, 2026
JBT Re-Elects Jeff Corey as Board ChairThe trade organization, which held its annual elections earlier this year, also added five new board members.
Brought to you by
Discover Timeless Treasures: A Showcase of Antique Jewelry & Timepieces in Las VegasGain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.
SurveysApr 24, 2026
Mother’s Day 2026 Jewelry Spending to Top $7B, NRF SaysNRF’s annual survey found that 45 percent of consumers plan to purchase jewelry for a loved one this Mother’s Day.
Weekly QuizApr 23, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
TechnologyApr 24, 2026
TwentyFour’s Digital-Age Locket Is a Virtual VaultThe “Vault” charm, our Piece of the Week, expands on the memories that can be stored in a locket by connecting to your phone.
Events & AwardsApr 24, 2026
Hamptons Jewelry Show to Return in JulyThe open-to-the-public luxury jewelry and timepiece show, in its second year, is slated for July 23-26.
Brought to you by
Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch Show: Showcasing the Most Collectible Merchandise from Across the GlobeGain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.
IndependentsApr 23, 2026
Meet the Real Moms of Day’s JewelersThe jeweler’s Mother’s Day campaign highlights the women who work there—mothers, grandmothers, women who want to be mothers, and dog moms.
Supplier BulletinApr 23, 2026
JM® Shipping Solution: Smarter Shipping for High-Value GoodsSponsored by Jewelers Mutual
Lab-GrownApr 23, 2026
Charles & Colvard May Sell Assets for $1.5MThe proposed agreement follows the moissanite maker’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection filing last month.
AuctionsApr 23, 2026
John Jacob Astor IV’s Titanic Pocket Watch Fetches $1MThe Patek Philippe for Tiffany & Co. timepiece Astor brought aboard the ill-fated ship sold for double its estimate at a Freeman’s auction.
CollectionsApr 23, 2026
Adam Neeley’s High Jewelry Collection Steps Into Salvador Dalí’s GardenThe “Dalí’s Garden” collection was inspired by a surreal dream Neeley had after cooking a recipe from Salvador Dalí’s 1973 cookbook.
IndependentsApr 23, 2026
Windsor Jewelers Names New Buying DirectorNatalie Feanny has been appointed to the role.
CrimeApr 22, 2026
New Mexico Couple Pleads Guilty to Selling Fake Native American JewelryThe pair falsely claimed their jewelry was made by Navajo artists, but it was imported from Vietnam.
AuctionsApr 22, 2026
Roberta Flack’s Jewelry Is Going Up for AuctionJulien’s Auctions is selling the musician’s fine and fashion jewelry alongside her clothing, gold records, and other memorabilia.
CollectionsApr 22, 2026
British Museum Curator Pens Book on ‘The Tudor Heart’Rachel King’s book dives into the history of the pendant believed to have belonged to Henry VIII and his first wife, Katherine of Aragon.
Events & AwardsApr 22, 2026
Here’s What Sy Kessler Has on Tap for Las Vegas The company will have deals on precious metals testers as well as the latest in lab-grown diamond detection technology and security.
WatchesApr 21, 2026
Coco Chanel Enters the Game with New Watch CollectionGabrielle “Coco” Chanel is a character in the “Coco Game” collection of watches and the queen in its first haute horlogerie chessboard.
IndependentsApr 21, 2026
Meet Jewelers of America’s 2026 ‘20 Under 40’ ClassThe annual list honors rising professionals on the retail and supply sides of the jewelry industry.
CrimeApr 21, 2026
Customs Nabs 1,500 Pieces of Counterfeit Jewelry Bound for NYCSeized in Kentucky, the packages include fake Cartier, Tiffany & Co., Chanel, and Fendi jewelry.
CrimeApr 20, 2026
Queens Man Convicted in Bludgeoning Death of Pawn Shop OwnerRodolfo Lopez-Portillo faces 25 years to life in prison after being found guilty in the March 2022 beating death of Arasb Shoughi.
TrendsApr 20, 2026
Beth Bernstein, Sonia Esther Soltani Pen New Jewelry Book“Jewelry Creators: Dynamic Duos and Generational Gems” highlights the relationships among 22 influential designers, brands, and gem dealers.
Events & AwardsApr 20, 2026
Atlanta Jewelry Show’s Spring Event Is Hitting the RoadThe AJS Spring 2027 show will be held in Savannah, Georgia, with future shows taking place in other Southeast cities.
MajorsApr 20, 2026
Kendra Scott Names New CFO, Chief Business OfficerThe jewelry retailer plans to open 20 new stores this year and expand into new product categories.
TrendsApr 17, 2026
New (Groundbreaking) Floral Jewelry for Spring 2026Flower motifs are the jewelry trend blooming amongst the new collections that debuted this spring.
MajorsApr 17, 2026
QVC Group Files for Chapter 11 BankruptcyThe retailer reported an 8 percent decline in annual sales as it struggles under the weight of billions of dollars of debt.
