Editors

5 Tips for Creating Fans from the Top (Savannah) Banana

EditorsApr 25, 2024

5 Tips for Creating Fans from the Top (Savannah) Banana

Jesse Cole, founder of Fans First Entertainment, shared the “five Es” of building a fan base during his AGS Conclave keynote.

Jesse Cole Savannah Bananas
Jesse Cole, founder of Fans First Entertainment and owner of the Savannah Bananas, was a keynote speaker at American Gem Society 2024 Conclave in Austin, Texas.
Jesse Cole, founder of Fans First Entertainment and owner of the Savannah Bananas, took the stage as the opening keynote speaker at this year’s American Gem Society Conclave, held April 15-17 in Austin, Texas.

He shared the story behind his team, which is akin to the Harlem Globetrotters of baseball, and how he managed to build a loyal fanbase, with sold-out games and a waitlist of more than 600,000.

The path to success was complex, but Cole’s driving motto was simple—fans first.

“It wasn’t about money. We are focused on long-term fans and not short-term profits,” said Cole.

The Savannah Bananas offer a lot for fans to love, from its singing and dancing players; its grandma dance team, “The Banana Nanas;” its “Dad Bod Cheer Squad;” and babies dressed in banana costumes.

“I believe the future of business is not based on how many customers you have, it’s based on how many fans you have. Customers are transactional, they come and go, but fans never leave,” said Cole.

Jewelers already establish the necessary emotional connection for fandom, he said, as they’re part of the milestones in people’s lives.

The key is to create “you wouldn’t believe” moments, moments that make your customer say, “you wouldn’t believe what they did for me.”

“If you get people saying, ‘you wouldn't believe,’ you’ll never have to worry about marketing or promoting because they will do it for you. Right now, we spend $0 on marketing, but we spend everything on creating a great experience,” he said.

In his keynote presentation, Cole delved into the five “Es” an everyday jeweler can use to build a fan base of their own.

Eliminate Friction
To eliminate friction in a business, Cole recommended retailers put themselves in their customer’s shoes, a tactic he learned from Walt Disney.

“Walt Disney was obsessed with going into customers’ shoes. He would walk the park when he first built Disneyland and say, ‘Every single part of the experience, how can it be better?’,” said Cole.

In baseball, for instance, Cole surmised that the game was too long, slow, and boring for a lot of people. People also disliked the convenience fees tacked onto the price of the ticket.

A Savannah Bananas game is capped at two hours and fans don’t pay added fees.

He also has a team member go undercover at games and experience them as a fan to spot friction points they may have missed.

“How often have you done that?” he asked. “Even going through your website, how easy is it to talk to someone? This isn’t the most fun but the starting point of all innovation is to eliminate the friction,” said Cole.

Entertain Always
For the second “E,” Cole looked to another mentor, P.T. Barnum, who is credited as saying, “the noblest art is that of making others happy.”

If the definition of entertainment is to provide enjoyment, then in a sense, aren’t all retailers in the entertainment business?

Cole and his team mapped out the customer experience and pinpointed seven “stages,” or seven opportunities, to entertain, including social media, the parking lot, the stadium, the seats, the field, the front plaza as guests exit, and then the final impression.

When a fan buys a ticket to a game, they receive a fun video thanking them for their purchase and getting them excited about the upcoming experience.

If Cole’s team can do that for a ticket purchase, jewelers can step it up for a likely more expensive purchase.

“When people are buying something that could be a couple thousand dollars to thousands upon thousands of dollars, how do we celebrate them? How do we make it bigger, larger than life?” he asked.

For the first few years, Cole’s employees would call every fan who bought a ticket, an impossibility now that the team sells more than 1 million tickets per year.

“Often in the beginning, you have to do the unscalable,” he said. “For instance, when you have a new product or an event, can you do something that’s a little unscalable?”

Cole encouraged jewelers to think about what the experience could be like in their stores.

“How do you really make it fun? This is unlike any jewelry store in the world. What would that look like?” he said. “It may cost more. It may take away some short-term profits, but what about those long-term fans? What if people said, ‘you just gotta go there and be a part of it’?”

Experiment Constantly
When building his company, Cole turned away from all things normal.

“Normal gets normal results,” he said. “If you are doing normal, people aren’t going to talk about it. They talk about things that are unique and different.”

When designing merch, his team came up with “Dolce & Banana” underwear, a pair of plain white briefs with a Savannah Bananas logo on the front.

“We sell hats. We sell shirts. But the crazy thing is, we’ve sold over 2,000 [pairs of underwear] in the last year. I don’t know who’s buying them or why they’re buying them,” he said.

The important thing is that the novelty item got fans’ attention.

Cole shared a story about an author who bought a bookstore and stocked it with one book, the one he wrote, garnering media attention worldwide.

“Attention beats marketing 1,000 percent of the time,” he said.

Creating attention is key when trying to create a fun, memorable experience.

“I've learned you either have a success or you have a story and sometimes both. And so everything we do, we think about how do we create attention and do something different?” he said.

Sometimes ideas don’t pan out, said Cole, but idea generation is important.

He advised retailers to sit down with their teams and discuss how to create a more memorable experience, encouraging retailers to incentivize creative stories over sales.

A team only needs one good idea.

The Savannah Bananas team is known, especially on TikTok, for its dancing, but the players didn’t start out dancing.

Cole was trying to convince an HR executive to bring her team to a game. Her team didn’t like baseball, she said, but Cole assured her it was more than a baseball game, they also danced.

The players, in fact, did not dance, and Cole had to bring in a choreographer before the HR executive and her team showed up.

It’s important to try things, he said, adding that he’s written down 10 ideas every day since 2018.

“That’s thousands of terrible ideas,” he said, “but we all have to work our idea muscle. I have plenty of bad ideas, but quantity leads to quality.”

 Related stories will be right here … 

Engaging Deeply
Jewelers have a unique opportunity to engage with customers as they help them celebrate life’s milestones but taking it to the next level requires something special.

“Do for one what you wish you could do for everyone,” said Cole, quoting Pastor Andy Stanley.

Cole recalled visiting the Magic Castle Hotel in Hollywood, a well-regarded hotel despite its location in an older apartment building, sans spa, gym, or restaurant.

The hotel staff was welcoming, he said, offering drinks, a snack bar, laundry services, and a free ice cream bar in the lobby.

While walking past the hotel’s small pool, he spotted a red phone with a sign above that read “Popsicle Hotline.” And, sure enough, soon after he picked up the receiver, an employee came out with a popsicle on a silver platter.

Inspired by his experience, Cole asked the hotel’s CEO how he managed to create it.

“Listen carefully, respond creatively,” the CEO replied, sharing how he instructed his staff to ask a lot of questions.

Cole, in turn, advised his team to do the same and look for opportunities to create special moments.

When a fan reached out to the team to thank them for being a bright spot during a dark time in her life, Cole invited her to a game and gave her the VIB (Very Important Banana) experience, even coordinating an on-field dance with one of the players.

Empowering Action
Stop standing still and start standing out, advised Cole.

As a child, he was shy and introverted, a far cry from the man in the bright yellow suit up on stage at Conclave.

His dad, who raised him due to his mother’s struggles with drug addiction, wanted to help him get out of his shell, so he entered him into a contest to be an honorary bat boy for the Boston Red Sox.

Cole wasn’t much of a baseball fan, but, after winning the contest, he gave it a try. And after a 20-minute talk with Hall of Famer Lee Smith, Cole loved baseball.

He recalled his dad taking him to his first T-ball game. As he went up to bat, he froze.

“Swing hard in case you hit it!” his father yelled, a mantra Cole has kept close to his heart.

He swung and missed a lot, but he made pretty good contact when he did manage to hit the ball.

Cole said he has taken the same approach to life and realized that those who “don’t” may just be afraid of missing.

He looked to the baseball greats for inspiration, like Reggie Jackson, who struck out more than anyone else but is best known for his three home runs in game six of the 1977 World Series.

“We’re not remembered for our failures. We’re remembered for our hits,” said Cole.

It’s important to empower your team to take a big swing and try things. If it goes wrong, that’s one step closer to something working, he said.

The Latest

3 natural diamond engagement rings by Marrow Fine, Stephanie Gottlieb, Single Stone, and Sylvie Jewelry
TrendsFeb 12, 2025
5 Engagement Ring Trends Expected to Rule 2025

From chunky bands to vintage diamond cuts and bezel settings, these are the trends experts are seeing take over the bridal market.

De Beers Jewellers Embrace Bracelet
CollectionsFeb 12, 2025
De Beers Jewellers’ New High Jewelry Pays Homage to the Beauty of Trees

The “Essence of Nature, Chapter One” collection echoes trees and roots, literally and figuratively, through three sets of high jewelry.

Shree Ramkrishna Exports (SRK) diamonds
SourcingFeb 12, 2025
SRK Announces Notable Reduction in Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Late last year, the India-based diamond manufacturer recorded emissions per carat that are 34 percent lower than the industry average.

Top Image.png
Brought to you by
3 Ways to Capitalize on America’s Newfound Love of Colored Gems

Colored stones are stepping into a jewelry spotlight typically reserved for diamonds—are you ready to sell color?

Peter Smith
ColumnistsFeb 12, 2025
Peter Smith: 9 Store Manager Archetypes

Smith details the types of store managers he’s encountered, with the goal of helping retailers find a person who’s a fit for their store.

Weekly QuizFeb 06, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
myGemma showroom
TechnologyFeb 12, 2025
MyGemma Now Offers Consignment Service

The secondhand reseller stocks pre-owned designer jewelry and watches, along with other luxury goods.

 Ghirardelli Chocolocket
CollectionsFeb 12, 2025
Ghirardelli Is Slipping Chocolate Into a Locket This Valentine's Day

The limited-edition “Chocolocket” fits a mini square of Ghirardelli chocolate inside.

Resolutions - 2025.jpg
Brought to you by
3 New Year’s Resolutions for Jewelry Lovers

The new year feels like a clean slate, inspiring reflection, hope, and the motivation to become better versions of ourselves.

Jewelers of America 20 Under 40 graphic
Events & AwardsFeb 11, 2025
JA Seeking Nominations for Its Next ‘20 Under 40’ Class

The program has been expanded to include a “20 Under 40” list for jewelry suppliers and is accepting nominations through Feb. 19.

Police cars with lights on
CrimeFeb 11, 2025
2 Men Charged With Selling Stolen Jewelry, Watches in NYC Diamond District

One of the men is said to be connected to the South American crew charged with burglarizing Cincinnati Bengals QB Joe Burrow’s home.

Bulgari x MB&F Serpenti watch
WatchesFeb 11, 2025
Bulgari, MB&F Launch Reimagined ‘Serpenti’ Watch

The brands immersed one of Bulgari’s most famous historical icons in MB&F’s ultra-mechanical universe of haute horlogerie.

Boucheron Power of Couture campaign
FinancialsFeb 11, 2025
Boucheron a Bright Spot as Kering’s Full-Year Sales Sink 12%

The luxury titan’s full-year performance was weighed down by struggling sales at its star brand Gucci.

Midas Chain Diamond and Gemstone Jewelry
MajorsFeb 11, 2025
Midas Chain Releases First Diamond Collection

The jewelry manufacturer has launched more than 100 pieces made with natural diamonds.

Tacori Stilla ring
SurveysFeb 10, 2025
Jewelry Resilient in 2024 Even As Luxury Sales Slipped, Says Bain & Co.

Bain & Co.’s latest report on the luxury market examines why the market’s customer base is shrinking and how to appeal to consumers in 2025.

Counterfeit Cartier “Juste Un Clou” bracelet
CrimeFeb 10, 2025
Counterfeit Jewelry Kept Kentucky Customs Agents Busy in January, CBP Says

Officers in Louisville seized 28 shipments of fake jewelry and watches that would have been worth more than $27 million if genuine.

Hearts On Fire Inside Out Collection Bracelets
CollectionsFeb 10, 2025
Hearts on Fire Flips Jewelry ‘Inside Out’ in New Collection

The collection centers on the art of tailoring, inspired by designs that feature folded fabrics, such as a tuxedo lapel.

JW Marriott Hotel in Nashville Tennessee
Events & AwardsFeb 10, 2025
Select Jewelry Show Heads to Nashville

The trade show has added a new location to its fall line-up.

Jade Trau Ladybird Charm
CollectionsFeb 07, 2025
Piece of the Week: Jade Trau’s ‘Ladybird’ Charm

From the brand’s latest collection of lucky charms, the ladybird is seen as a bearer of good fortune and a ward against negative energy.

Rough diamonds from De Beers’ Gahcho Kue diamond mine in Canada
SourcingFeb 07, 2025
De Beers’ Production Guidance Slashed, Anglo Anticipates Another Writedown

The moves come amid a prolonged period of lower demand for diamonds, particularly in China.

Stuller Bench Jeweler Workshop
Events & AwardsFeb 07, 2025
Registration Opens for Stuller’s Bench Jeweler Workshop

The workshop returns in March, along with the “Battle of the Benches” mini challenge series.

Windsor Jewelry in Indianapolis, Indiana
IndependentsFeb 06, 2025
106-Year-Old Jewelry Store Saved by New Owners

Two attorneys purchased Windsor Jewelry, which was set to close, and will retain all existing staff at the downtown Indianapolis store.

Two images of Adam Heyman in Sri Lanka
MajorsFeb 06, 2025
Oscar Heyman Employee Celebrates 60 Years With the Company

Adam Heyman joined the family business in 1965, just weeks after graduating from Columbia Business School.

Hamilton Jewelers Worth Avenue interior
IndependentsFeb 06, 2025
Hamilton Jewelers Revamps Palm Beach Boutique

The fourth-generation, family-owned jeweler has given its Worth Avenue store a new look.

Stock image of a gavel
CrimeFeb 05, 2025
‘The Timepiece Gentleman’ Sentenced to 5-Plus Years Behind Bars

Luxury watch dealer Anthony Farrer pleaded guilty late last year to defrauding clients in a scheme with Ponzi-type elements.

Pandora sparkling bow necklace
FinancialsFeb 05, 2025
Pandora Posts Double-Digit Growth After Strong Holiday Season

In its full-year results, the retailer shared its 2025 outlook and an update on the global rollout of its lab-grown diamond collection.

Seal & Scribe “Freedom Moon” Ring
TrendsFeb 05, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: Feeling Fabulous in February

Celebrate February birthstones and the gem shows in Arizona this month with a versatile stone like amethyst.

Diamond Council of America logo
MajorsFeb 05, 2025
DCA Promotes Kristen Scheetz to Director of Education, Membership

Scheetz has been with the nonprofit since 2007.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy