Columnists

Squirrel Spotting: Life After Rolex

ColumnistsFeb 20, 2024

Squirrel Spotting: Life After Rolex

Peter Smith shares advice from independent jewelers who used losing this cornerstone brand as a catalyst for reinvention.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
It’s more ripple than tidal, more stealth than seismic, but there appears to be a shift in the tectonic plates that define the relationship between Rolex and independent jewelry retailers. 

As quietly as is feasible under the circumstances, some long-standing authorized Rolex dealers appear to be receiving the dreaded “Dear John” letters signaling the Crown’s intent to end their relationship at a level I have not witnessed before.  

The historical justifications (explicit or otherwise) that drove previous separations—not following the rules, misrepresenting the brand, unwanted creative pricing, transshipping, etc.—seem to have given way to something decidedly less tangible, less actionable, and that appears, to the untrained eye, to be your store’s address. 

Based on a random group of retailers who recently have been notified of Rolex’s intent to end their relationship, it seems to matter not a whit what a given retailer’s Rolex sales are, how committed they are to the brand, how impressive their Rolex environment is, how long they have carried the brand, or how ambitious their Rolex aspirations might be. 

If your castle is built on the wrong hill, there just might be cause for concern. 

For many current Rolex retailers, those in A markets, those with Rolex stores (distinct from Rolex environments inside their jewelry stores), those with neighboring stores named Chanel, Gucci, Louis Vuitton, etc., there should be no lost sleep. 

For others, however—especially those in B markets—they might want to pay attention to what is happening with recently closed Rolex retailers, and they might want to prepare a Plan B, just in case the unthinkable happens. 

Being prepared with a “what if” has nothing but upside. 

If you don’t get that letter, the impact of preparing for that scenario is that you will have improved an element of your business while continuing to execute your Rolex story. 

If, however, you do get the dreaded communication, your pre-emptive initiatives will help to mitigate a huge transition in your business. 

While there is no ready substitute for Rolex, there are other brands (and I don’t mean just timepieces) that can help your store recover the lost Rolex business. 

An important consideration is that you don’t have to replace the Rolex sales, you need to replace the lost gross-margin dollars. 

If you are looking to replace $3 million in Rolex sales, that becomes (assuming a 35 percent margin) a $1.05 million gross margin challenge. 

Again, not nothing, but a good deal more palatable than thinking about the loss as a $3 million hit.
 
I spoke to a few retailers to understand the experience of losing Rolex and how they moved on from it.

It’s a great lesson for any retailer facing the threat of, or dealing with the fallout from, the unexpected exit of a key vendor that brought them a lot of publicity, foot traffic, and sales.   

 Related stories will be right here … 

One of the things that stood out in my conversations with retailers was their absolute disbelief when the letter arrived. According to them, there had been no warnings, no inklings at all of what was to happen. 

These retailers, I should point out, were not amongst the most recent closures (those wounds are too raw), but their recollection and shock at what happened still resonates. 

Brad Hart from Hauser’s Jewelers in Newport News, Virginia, said, “Amy and I had a post-Christmas getaway, and we were talking about how proud we were about our Rolex sales. 

“Two weeks later, we got the letter. It was a gut-punch. We’d been an authorized dealer since 1977, and it was such an important part of our identity. They’d even told us that it was an honor for them to be in a family business like ours.” 

Natasha Henderson from Saxon’s Fine Jewelers in Bend, Oregon, said, “We had absolutely no idea. In fact, we had been in discussions with our Rolex rep and taking his lead on a planned Rolex remodel. We did everything they asked of us and never gave them any reason to be concerned about how we represented the brand.” 

Armando Gonzalez from Blue Marlin Jewelry in Islamorada, Florida, said: “We had just put the new Rolex environment in three or four years previously. We followed every rule to a ‘T’ and represented the brand well. Then one day I got an email from a private server telling me that we were losing the brand. 

“I thought it was some kind of bad joke, but when I followed up with Rolex they confirmed that it was true. I’m a small store and what they did almost put me out of business. Heck, they had just invited me to a training in February, and then I got the letter in April.” 

It is a matter of conjecture as to why these retailers, or any of the more recent Rolex closures are getting shut down, but overexposure for the brand was likely not one of the reasons. 

Saxon’s was a two-and-a-half-hour drive from the next Rolex dealer. Blue Marlin was a hard 60 miles (Southeast Florida!) from the next closest dealer, and Hauser’s, on the southeastern end of the Virginia Peninsula, was a solid hour from their nearest Rolex competitor. 

Henderson said she was sick to her stomach when she opened the letter. 

“I’m second generation, and my first thought was how am I going to break the news to my parents and to Bruce, our founders. It was our goal to have Rolex to help put us on the map, and now we were going to have to reinvent ourselves on the fly. I had a pity party for about a week, and then I got down to the hard business of what needed to be done. 

“We got ahead of things by contacting our customers before they heard the news elsewhere. We started looking at other brands that could step into the vacuum and replace those gross margin dollars, and we recalibrated our team to focus on increasing our average ticket and creating a culture on add-on sales.” 

Brad Hart said he didn’t want Hauser’s to be known as the store that lost Rolex. 

“We had a meeting with our team, and we literally set about reinventing the store. We focused on higher-margin products. 

“You know, there’s a certain freedom that comes with being able to chart your own growth, absent the dictates that were such a part of that relationship.” 

Gonzalez said, “We reached out to other vendors, brought in another watch brand, and we continued to do the very best we could do for our customers. It wasn’t something we expected or welcomed, but it wasn’t going to define us.” 

Losing Rolex was not on the agenda of things you’d expect to happen for any of these retailers, but once it happened, they used it as a catalyst for reinvention. 

As Natasha offered, “We had survived the recession of 2008, we had weathered those early uncertain weeks and months of COVID, and we got through this, too, with our business continuing to grow, and more profitable than ever before. 

“That said, we could really have used hearing from someone that this could happen.” 

As Armando said, “If you have Rolex, count your blessings, but know that it could end on a whim.” 

Happy retailing!

The Latest

Stock image of a gavel
CrimeDec 11, 2024
Former Tiffany & Co. Factory Supervisor Sentenced for Stealing Precious Metals

A federal judge gave Benjamin Preacher 59 days in jail, plus 10 months of home confinement and two years of supervised release.

Grader looking into microscope at IGI lab
GradingDec 11, 2024
IGI Set to Go Public Next Week

In a CNBC interview, CEO Tehmasp Printer discussed the IPO in India and what declining lab-grown diamond prices mean for the company.

Heuer Monaco Ref. 1133B
AuctionsDec 11, 2024
Sotheby’s Important Watches Sale Fetches $16.6M

The offering included vintage Rolexes, timepieces worn in “Titanic,” Steve McQueen's watch, and a special Citizen pocket watch.

ja nj btyb.jpg
Brought to you by
Advocacy and Excellence: How Jewelers of America Is Committed to Elevating Our Industry

For over a century, Jewelers of America has been the voice of the industry and valuable resource to jewelers across the country.

Stephanie Gottlieb, Anna Harman, Stephanie Gottlieb x Studs Collection
CollectionsDec 11, 2024
Stephanie Gottlieb Brings Natural Diamonds to Studs

The 13-piece “Stephanie Gottlieb x Studs” collection is the piercing studio’s first fine jewelry offering to feature the gemstone.

Weekly QuizDec 05, 2024
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Exterior of Sauer’s Madison Avenue Store
IndependentsDec 10, 2024
Sauer Opens First U.S. Store

The Brazilian jewelry brand made a home on New York City’s Madison Avenue with exclusive pieces only available at the location.

Person at keyboard holding credit card
SurveysDec 10, 2024
Jewelry Among Top Sellers on Cyber Monday, Says Adobe

An Adobe Analytics report explored the rise in mobile shopping, the popularity of Buy Now Pay Later options, and peak shopping hours.

undefined.png
Brought to you by
Protecting Your Sparkle: Why Screening Has Become Essential

While no reputable jeweler would knowingly sell lab-grown stones as natural, it's a growing possibility.

American Gem Trade Association and University of Arizona
Events & AwardsDec 10, 2024
AGTA Launches Scholarship for University of Arizona Geosciences Students

The inaugural Dick Greenwood Memorial Scholarship in Gems Science will cover the fall 2025 and spring 2026 semesters.

JA New York Show Entrance
Events & AwardsDec 10, 2024
JA New York To Debut 2 New Pavilions at Spring 2025 Show

A Piazza Italia pavilion will feature Italian designers and manufacturers while “MJSA Showcase” brings over a piece of the MJSA Expo.

Ray Griffiths and Ray Griffiths: The Works
CollectionsDec 09, 2024
Ray Griffiths’ First Coffee Table Book Spans 5 Decades of Design

“Ray Griffiths: The Works” tells the story of the master jeweler’s career, which started with an apprenticeship in Australia at age 15.

Grant Mobley and Thomas Davis
MajorsDec 09, 2024
Thomas Davis, Grant Mobley Join WJA Foundation Board

Davis is the director of business development at Select Jewelry Inc., and Mobley is the jewelry and watch editor at the Natural Diamond Council.

Movado campaign
FinancialsDec 09, 2024
Movado’s Q3 Sales Down 3% Amid ‘Challenging’ Environment

The retailer has been upping its marketing spend to drive revenue growth and brand awareness.

Treiber & Straub store Brookfield, Wisconsin
IndependentsDec 06, 2024
After 44 Years in Business, This Wisconsin Independent Is Closing

Mike Straub and John Treiber opened Treiber & Straub in 1980 with the goal of bringing Milwaukeeans the best jewelry brands.

Pantone Color of the Year Mocha Mousse
TrendsDec 06, 2024
Pantone’s Color of the Year Is a Delicious Mousse

The color for 2025, “Mocha Mousse,” embodies thoughtful indulgences and everyday pleasures.

Cocoerow Fine Jewelry’s Kokoro Ant Pendant
CollectionsDec 06, 2024
Piece of the Week: Cocoerow Fine Jewelry’s ‘Kokoro’ Pendant

The Yoruba word for ant, “Kokoro” embodies the strength of womanhood in ant society while highlighting responsible sourcing.

Roberto Coin jewelry
FinancialsDec 06, 2024
Roberto Coin Acquisition Gives Watches of Switzerland a Boost in H1

The retailer’s jewelry sales doubled, with branded jewelry performing especially well.

Gold rings
FinancialsDec 05, 2024
Signet Jewelers’ Q3 Sales Slide Amid Slow Engagement Ring Sales, Tech Issues

The jewelry retailer addressed the lab-grown diamond “disruption,” the price of gold, and its holiday weekend performance.

Hand holding shopping bags
SurveysDec 05, 2024
Consumer Confidence Rises Again in November

A more positive view of the current labor market boosted the Conference Board’s index last month.

Michael S. Krzemnicki
Events & AwardsDec 05, 2024
Michael S. Krzemnicki to Receive 2024 Bonanno Award

The director of the Swiss Gemmological Institute (SSEF) will be honored for his impact on gemology and dedication to advancing the science.

1.png
Supplier BulletinDec 05, 2024
Join Us For Color's Premier Show: 2025 AGTA GemFair Tucson

Sponsored by 2025 AGTA GemFair Tucson

Gwen Beloti, Lisa Bridge, Eddie Plein, Anna Samsonova
Events & AwardsDec 05, 2024
BIJC Announces 2024 ‘Rock the Jewels’ Awards Winners

At the annual event, in its second year, the organization honored those making remarkable contributions to the jewelry industry.

For Future Reference Vintage turquoise necklace
TrendsDec 05, 2024
Amanda’s Style File: A Blue, Blue, Blue Month

Celebrate December babies with 20 pieces of jewelry featuring this month’s birthstones—turquoise, tanzanite, and zircon.

People outside holding shopping bags
SurveysDec 04, 2024
In-Store Shopping Outpaced Online Over the Holiday Weekend, Says NRF

A total of 126 million consumers shopped in stores over the five-day period, about 5 million more than last year.

Stock photo of diamonds
Lab-GrownDec 04, 2024
GJEPC Says Indian Trade Will Use FTC-Approved Terminology for Lab-Grown Diamonds

The FTC’s Jewelry Guides require “clear and conspicuous” disclosure when advertising lab-grown diamonds.

Grandview Klein Diamond Group Staff
SourcingDec 04, 2024
Designer Saul Fraiman Retires After 55 Years

The fine jewelry designer, who came out of retirement in 2017, is putting down his sketchpad for good.

30.101-carat very light pink diamond
AuctionsDec 04, 2024
30-Carat Pink Diamond Fetches $2.6M at Bonhams

The Type IIa, very light pink colored diamond was the highlight of the recent Hong Kong jewelry auction.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy