Squirrel Spotting: Examining Retail’s Uneasy Relationship With Brands
Peter Smith understands retailers’ issues with brands but, he argues, brands work. Here’s why.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5e219/5e219bb8dd8f9130db4aeb5d06622ca567d5bd23" alt="Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com. 2022_Peter Smith.jpg"
One of the retailer members posed a question on the site recently and, not for the first time, it really got me thinking about the topic in question.
The retailer had asked what members’ opinions were regarding brands in their stores and went on to express his own view about why he wasn’t a fan. He is, of course, not alone in dismissing the relevance of brands.
To be clear, when we talk about brands in our industry, we are, with just two or three exceptions, talking about trade brands. Other than Rolex, Pandora, and David Yurman, there is virtually no unaided consumer awareness of even the best known brands in our space.
BusinessInsider’s list of the Top 100 Brands according to consumers includes Gucci and Chanel.
It even has Crocs and Dunkin’ (previously Dunkin’ Donuts for those not familiar with that brand’s evolution) but the only jewelry brand in the top 100 is Tiffany & Co.
With less than a handful of exceptions, given that we are talking about trade brands, should retailers bother with brands at all? That was the question asked by the retailer on the Facebook page.
The list of retailer grievances with brands (justified or otherwise) is long. It includes the following.
1. The brand does not drive customers into the store.
2. Demands for case space are often unreasonable.
3. The buy-ins can often be prohibitive.
4. There are ongoing demands to replenish sold goods.
5. New products are expected to be bought, with no returns if they don’t work.
6. Margins are often worse than on generic equivalents.
7. Rebalance terms can be unfair.
8. Brands often “change the rules” mid-game, frustrating the retailer.
9. Brands don’t always participate with co-op and marketing initiatives.
10. Some brands rarely send personnel and can fall short on training.
11. Certain brands regularly change personnel, making it hard to build relationships.
12. Many brands have their own direct-to-consumer efforts (online and/or stores) and are perceived to be competing with their own retailer partners.
“The fact your customers may not come in asking for a particular brand does not mean that they wouldn’t be better served by having that option.” — Peter Smith
The above list is hardly reflective of all brands in our space, and there are many companies that really care about their retailers and do many of those things well. It would take another column to discuss that list and provide a counter argument as to why some of those things might not feel right to the retailers but are, in fact, good business. I’ll touch on just two as examples.
Regarding No. 4 (replenishing bestsellers), what business argument can possibly be made for not replenishing bestsellers? They are the very products that drive the business and not replenishing them because other items with that brand haven’t sold well is a classic case of throwing the baby out with the bath water.
Regarding No. 12 (brands going direct to consumer), few if any trade brands can spend the kind of money necessary to create consumer awareness. To that end, thoughtful and well-placed branded stores can help to create awareness and set the tone for how that brand can live within its retail partner base.
If the best argument against such an initiative is that the brand is taking your customers, I might argue your view of the brand’s potential reach must be incredibly narrow. In that instance, perhaps your money would be better spent elsewhere?
Again, there are numerous points from the list that could be debated on both sides, but my objective was to just name some of them, not defend or invalidate them.
It seems appropriate to assert that even “trade brands” must adhere to the essential characteristics of branding, with quality, language, and presentation all elevated and consistently so. Simply putting a name on a range of goods and calling it a brand does not make it a brand.
The Question Itself Is Flawed
In many respects, whether retailers should carry brands or not is the wrong question. I have heard it asked hundreds of times in my career and, while it is reasonable on the surface, the real question should be, what does the buyer want?
I can hear the choruses of “our customers will buy what we sell” echoing as a I write this, but that is hardly the point. The fact your customers may not come in asking for a particular brand does not mean that they wouldn’t be better served by having that option.
Why Brands Work
Ming Hsu wrote in his piece, “Brand Equity,” in Consumer Neuroscience that, “Consumers that develop the habit of purchasing a particular brand, or product, from a specific channel may be less likely to search for information for alternatives, to deliberate about competing products, or to delay purchasing for the future.”
More so today than ever before, as the emergence of relevant brands that do not enjoy legacy status becomes more and more prevalent, brands serve as stories and can be thought of as such. One could even interchange the terms “stories” and “brands.” And stories are what move people to act, not a boring list of generic details that can be repeated (true or otherwise) by every jewelry store in the country.
Customers want their purchases to be a low-effort experience. Anything that lessens the cognitive burden will be given priority. Our brain craves automaticity beyond anything else, and it is essentially a lazy piece of meat that consumes only 20 percent of our body’s energy. It will take any shortcut necessary to lessen anxiety and stress, and to make the buying experience easier.
In “Buy-ology, Truths and Lies About Why We Buy,” Martin Lindstrom wrote, “There’s something about the ritual-like act of collecting that makes us feel safe and secure. When we are stressed out, or when life feels random and out of control, we often seek out comfort in familiar products or objects. We want to have solid, consistent patterns in our lives, and in our brands.”
Customers want to be engaged emotionally, not bored with a laundry list of generic boasts.
A brand, even a trade brand, ought to have a story, and that story is what resonates with customers. It is that story they repeat in their conversations with family and friends, and it is that story that makes it easy for them to come back again and repeat purchase the brand.
A brand’s effect on customers is literally chemical. As the customer experiences the brand (in wearing and telling), they enjoy the positive feeling of a dopamine rush in their brain. It is the best embodiment of how buying luxury makes you feel different, and not just look different.
Another solid consumer consideration for branding is what psychologists term the scarcity effect.
In essence, consumers are more apt to be drawn to a product if it has limited availability. That does not mean that no other retailers carry the brand, but that most other retailers do not. Within that, there may be added incentives, such as early previews on new products or limited numbers of a collection or item. This effect can work even if you have created a private-label brand, provided it behaves like a real brand.
Again, if you are trying to be all things to all people or deluding yourself into believing that the entirety of your generic offerings are, by default, your private label, I suspect few people will be convinced.
“People spend more on brands. They know they are spending more, and yet research shows they are happy to do so.” — Peter Smith
Why Branding Make Sense for Retailers
While there is much debate about the viability of brands in the retail jewelry environment, there can be little doubt that the vast majority of retailers do in fact carry some brands.
To quote branding expert Lindstrom again, “Expect anything and everything to be branded in the future because as our brain-scan study has shown, our brains are hardwired to bestow upon brands an almost religious significance and as a result we forge immutable brand loyalties.”
One of the best learning exercises in understanding the jewelry business is to get outside of it and view our world from a different perspective. To that end, if you are still uncertain about the viability of brands, ask yourself what other industries are largely non-branded? Better still, ask yourself what luxury products outside of our business are non-branded?
In a world where we are seeing declining foot traffic and probably will continue to for the foreseeable future, increasing your average ticket should be a core strategic initiative for every retail operator. As it happens, people spend more on brands. They know they are spending more, and yet research shows they are happy to do so.
In “Brainfluence, 100 Ways to Persuade and Convince Consumers With Neuromarketing,” Roger Dooley wrote: “On one hand, we know that the pain of paying kicks in when people perceive that a product is overpriced and makes people less likely to make a purchase. But now we have multiple studies showing that people enjoy a product more when they pay more for it.”
One of the arguments previously cited against branding is that people don’t come in often enough (occasionally, not at all) asking for a given brand. Again, that does not mean that it is not the best option for your customers.
Brands, especially trade brands, need to be championed from leadership. There needs to be clear communication about why a given brand matters to your business and a clear directive about why it should matter to your customers.
Because you can make it yourself, knock it off, or tweak your own generic or custom options does not mean that you should.
Absent the legal issues, the moral issues, or even the inefficiency of taking the time to build what can easily be ordered, it just might not be the best option for your customers.
We live in a branded world. And, thankfully, when we buy brands, unless and until they disappoint us, we are happy to continue buying them ongoing.
As Lindstrom wrote, “… branding as we know it is just beginning.”
The Latest
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3340e/3340e2b69bf11eee222cd6931734a246068a139d" alt="Jade Ruzzo Tennessee Drop Earrings"
Heidi Gardner, an SNL cast member, wore the smoky quartz earrings on the “SNL50: The Anniversary Special” red carpet on Sunday.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/55316/553167750c243f9393a40a73f25b38a1216e02dd" alt="The government of Zambia has once again suspended its 15 percent export duty on precious stones and metals. The country first introduced the export duty in 2019 but lifted it later that year, only to reinstate it in 2025. (Photo courtesy of Gemfields) Rough emerald mined by Gemfields"
The reversal comes less than two months after the Zambian government reinstated the tax in an effort to bring in more money.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2097a/2097a8a4975e7012a41812331383a7cec0877712" alt="The 24 Karat Club of New York has elected a new president as well as new directors and officers. From left to right, Jeffrey Cohen, chairperson; Steven Lagos, president; Michael Benavente, vice president; and Monica Elias, director. Jeffrey Cohen, Steven Lagos, Michael Benavente, Monica Elias"
The organization also announced its newly elected officers and directors.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d1c43/d1c430ff441fc0d88e60a71109284ae499525311" alt="Header Image.jpg"
This year will feature a new MJSA Showcase and partnership with Piazza Italia.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/917a7/917a7381c5c2257e93ac33f3024953e570edd3b6" alt="After taking a $1.6 billion impairment charge on De Beers Group last year, parent company Anglo American has written down the value of the diamond miner and marketer by another $2.9 billion. The move comes amid a challenging time for De Beers and the natural diamond industry. (©De Beers Group/Photo credit: Ben Perry @Armoury Films) A polished diamond in tweezers"
As anticipated, Anglo took another impairment charge on the diamond miner and marketer, which saw revenue sink 23 percent in 2024.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/695f8/695f8aa4a47f5adc257e52fc57ced1a02ce76e91" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fc59d/fc59d01990aaf38cd587ee39086f1353deea29fb" alt="The 2.33-carat “Winston Red” diamond is the centerpiece of a collection of natural colored diamonds that Ronald Winston, son of Harry Winston, has donated to the Smithsonian Institute. At 2.33 carats, it’s one of the largest fancy red diamonds in the world. (Photo credit: Robert Weldon/Photo courtesy of Ronald Winston) The 2.33-carat fancy red “Winston Red” diamond"
Ronald Winston is giving the 2.33-carat “Winston Red” to the Smithsonian, 67 years after his father donated the Hope Diamond.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e4476/e447680d820d412c793afa93d2fdb2e0f6888f01" alt="The Gem & Jewellery Export Promotion Council has named Kirit Bhansali as its new chairman. Kirit Bhansali"
Kirit Bhansali, a partner in Smital Gems and chairman of India Jewellery Park, will take on the role of chairman.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/59a98/59a98707aa7590e66c8d9f86ec43dc031718ebf1" alt="Top Image.png"
Colored stones are stepping into a jewelry spotlight typically reserved for diamonds—are you ready to sell color?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2696a/2696a55398528135b410f2d087e653a44bd3e88b" alt="IJO’s new board members are, clockwise from left to right, Alisha Cornett of Green Brothers Jewelers in Bay City, Texas; Nic Faini of Faini Designs Jewelry Studio in Sioux Falls, South Dakota; Eric Stevens of Stevens Diamond Jewelers in West Springfield, Massachusetts; and Seth Shipley of Shipley’s Fine Jewelry in Hampstead, Maryland. Alisha Cornett, Nic Faini, Eric Stevens, Seth Shipley"
Alisha Cornett, Nic Faini, Eric Stevens, and Seth Shipley have joined the organization’s board of directors for a three-year term.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0cd7/a0cd7fee7098b5349f867a8af8d233797702766c" alt="Brink’s Global Services USA Inc., the U.S. arm of Brink’s Inc. and The Brink’s Company, has agreed to pay a $42 million settlement after it admitted to operating an unlicensed money transmission business. Brink’s Truck"
The company has to pay the Justice Department and FinCEN for violating the Bank Secrecy Act, the U.S.’s main anti-money laundering law.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a933d/a933d180db30ab82ca113b693aeef8093f40feba" alt="Petra Diamonds’ CEO Richard Duffy resigned Monday as the company announced a steep decline in first-half sales. Petra operated four diamond mines, including Finsch in South Africa (pictured), but is offloading two of them in an effort to cut costs and shore up losses. (Photo courtesy of Petra Diamonds Ltd.) The Finsch diamond mine in South Africa"
Petra Diamonds Ltd. CEO Richard Duffy resigned as the diamond miner reported a 30 percent drop in sales to start its fiscal year.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0f292/0f29250ee550bccd7892454ffbe40f7fd3e52582" alt="Cartier’s Los Angeles International Airport storefront is adorned with champagne gold-colored panels with patterns inspired by waves from California’s beaches. (Image credit: Paul Vu, Here and Now Agency) Cartier LAX Storefront"
The boutique is the French luxury brand’s first airport store on the West Coast.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c83b6/c83b6c351c2b092b69d40e02ee52c025bdb96342" alt="The exterior of Swarovski’s New York City flagship is adorned with its logo and campaign images from its new capsule collection with “Wicked” star and brand ambassador Ariana Grande. Swarovski NYC flagship Ariana Grande collab"
The store’s facade now features the iconic swan logo and campaign images of the “Wicked” star.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c85cf/c85cfe9ad91f2fd63b4f807ad2ac12d08b477d99" alt="U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s recent announcement that it soon will require diamond importers to list country of mining when shipping goods into the United States seems to have taken the trade by surprise, and left many with questions. Stock image of loose polished diamonds"
Beginning in April, companies importing diamonds into the United States will have to list the country in which the diamonds were mined.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c9da1/c9da1e5810b4611f06536a4094eaf80741073870" alt="A selection of carved Fabergé animals from Castle Howard will appear in Sotheby’s “Fabergé, Gold Boxes, & Vertu” auction in Geneva on May 6, with part of the proceeds going to benefit the restoration of the estate’s tapestry drawing room, which was damaged in a 1940 fire. Fabergé Animals"
Around 30 whimsical Fabergé animal carvings will go up for auction at Sotheby’s Geneva in May.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/12cc7/12cc73dce18bce82bffe119b2e6dd0ea1540496c" alt="Celine Assimon, an experienced luxury executive who was hired as CEO of De Beers Jewellers in September 2020, will be leaving the company at the end of the month to “pursue other career opportunities.” Celine Assimon, departing CEO of De Beers Jewellers"
Assimon will be leaving at the end of February after nearly five years with De Beers.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/039ad/039ade7fe7e36b1fbdedd7977a4f5695e7fd79c7" alt="The new men’s jewelry selections feature Tabayer’s curving knot motif, the brand’s talisman for protection. Tabayer Men’s Oera Collection Selections"
Designs from the brand’s “Oera” collection have been reimagined with modern masculinity in mind.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fa7e5/fa7e509c811d8d153896ce5b1995449fbc4db4d4" alt="Navneet Gems and Minerals launched its sapphire collection at the recent GJX Tucson show, offering both calibrated and single stones. Navneet montana sapphire"
The wholesale collection features material from the Rock Creek mine in a variety of colors.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0e08/f0e088eb4f91bcc23e93d037a865d7d294c15ff7" alt="The new “Divinely Guided” collection is available through &Livy, a jewelry brand Carolyn Rafaelian launched in 2023. It is a collaboration between Rafaelian and Theresa Caputo, best known as the star of TLC’s “Long Island Medium.” Theresa Caputo &LIVY jewelry"
The “Divinely Guided” collection, created in collaboration with Theresa Caputo, features symbols that celebrate the power of connection.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d59c/1d59c2c56de74936f7894f02dc37f49abec6b003" alt="Lorraine West Diamond Open Heart Ring"
Show some love on Valentine’s Day with this 14-karat yellow gold ring that features pavé diamonds.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ab00f/ab00fd4c1f14731080af6a02f789fd9f8c1ce88d" alt="The suspect seen here attempted to steal $1.5 million worth of jewelry from a Macy’s store in Brooklyn, New York, but was thwarted by an employee. The thief is still at large and the New York Police Department is asking the public to help identify the suspect. (Image courtesy of the NYPD) Surveillance image of Macy’s jewelry thief"
The employee confronted the thief, causing the suspect to flee and leave behind the suitcases full of jewelry.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/970ae/970aeabdc2ed9a3ec93ac56b14a2ed109c3dfc61" alt="The board of Namib Desert Diamonds has suspended CEO Alisa Amupolo, Chief Operations Officer Uahoroka Kauta, and Security Manager Paulinus Sheyapo following the Jan. 18 armed robbery at its headquarters in Windhoek, Namibia. Namdia rough diamonds"
Namib Desert Diamonds also put its security manager on leave following last month’s robbery that left one employee dead.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28e12/28e121897a211e4de5aece211b3724e39c4cf1f0" alt="At the Spectrum Awards Gala, held Feb. 8 in Tucson, AGTA announced the winners of its Spectrum and Cutting Edge Buyer’s Choice awards—the “Whisper of the Ancestors” lapel pin (left) and a nearly 13-carat faceted rhodochrosite from Colorado (right). Spectrum and Cutting Edge Buyer’s Choice awards"
AGTA recently concluded its 2025 GemFair event in Tucson and is already gearing up for next year’s show, set for Feb. 2-6, 2026.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cd730/cd730661d4a21d6dcee07c97a805d921ffe6e519" alt="Seen here are Royal Chain’s new 14-karat gold fashion link pieces from the jewelry supplier’s spring 2025 collection. Royal Chain models in 14-karat gold fashion links"
More than 400 new pieces are featured in the supplier’s latest catalog.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fb397/fb3975ed1cd69785bcb009d3493e1ec4d1dfe7ff" alt="Azra Mehdi’s pink sapphire ombré heart dog tag necklace is one of 20 pieces featured in Amanda’s Style File for Valentine’s Day. Azra Mehdi pink sapphire ombré heart dog tag necklace in 14-karat rose gold"
This curation celebrates love with heart-shaped jewelry of all shapes and sizes.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cd876/cd87639f341a94f8b22aadba7fbd0ae3d194890c" alt="Jewelers of America and the Diamond Council of America’s Jewelers Relief Fund has been reopened to help jewelry business impacted by the Los Angeles wildfires. The fund was first launched in 2017 in the wake of Hurricane Harvey in Houston. Jewelers Relief Fund logo"
The fund is collecting money for jewelry businesses damaged by the wildfires in Los Angeles County.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c1f92/c1f929069d650a3b74a76bb92cea218d83f7db54" alt="From left to right, rings by Single Stone, Marrow Fine, and Stephanie Gottlieb Fine Jewelry, highlighting the diamond engagement ring trends expected to be ubiquitous this year. 3 natural diamond engagement rings by Marrow Fine, Stephanie Gottlieb, Single Stone, and Sylvie Jewelry"
From chunky bands to vintage diamond cuts and bezel settings, these are the trends experts are seeing take over the bridal market.