Nirav Modi Case Is ‘Another Nail in the Coffin’

EditorsFeb 23, 2018

Nirav Modi Case Is ‘Another Nail in the Coffin’

A banker talks about what the billion-dollar bank fraud allegations against Indian diamantaire Nirav Modi mean for the industry as a whole.

A rendering of the Nirav Modi store at the Wynn Las Vegas, which opened in November. It is one of three stores the billionaire Indian diamantaire, who is accused in a billion-dollar bank fraud, has in the United States.

You’ve likely the seen the name Nirav Modi a lot in recent years, perhaps in one of the many stories about him supplying high-profile actresses with amazing pieces to wear on the red carpet, like the earrings Yvonne Strahovski wore to the SAG Awards.  He even won an award from Town & Country earlier this year for one of his red carpet looks.

Or maybe it was in one of the stories about the opening of yet another opulent store that bears his name. There has been a Nirav Modi store on Madison Avenue in New York since 2015 but last year, the brand opened two more stores in the same month, one in the Wynn hotel in Las Vegas and the other at the Ala Moana Center in Honolulu.

More recently, however, you might have seen Modi’s name in stories of a very different sort, ones that signal that the billionaire, much like Strahovski’s character in “The Handmaid’s Tale,” could end up living a future very different from the one you might have imagined.

Last week, news broke in India that Modi and his uncle, Gitanjali Managing Director Mehul Choksi, have been accused of colluding with employees of Punjab National Bank to swindle the second-largest state-owned financial institution out of about $1.8 billion.

Here’s the story so far, according to multiple news reports on the scam, which has been making headlines in India and worldwide and has generated hashtags like #FindingNiMo, a portmanteau referencing the ongoing search for the diamantaire, who has left India.  

WATCH: The Bank Fraud Case in Five Minutes

On Jan. 29, India’s Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) registered a case against Modi, his brother Neeshal, and Choksi.

They are accused of colluding with Punjab National Bank employees to have Letters of Understanding, or LoUs, issued to banks in Hong Kong in order to secure massive loans. LoUs are sent from one bank to another and basically say: Please loan this individual or company money for this purpose (in Modi’s case, for buying diamonds) for a specified period of time; we will be responsible for repaying you.

On the surface, there is nothing wrong or illegal about an LoU. What is problematic in this case, however, is that the LoUs were issued by PNB without proper authorization and/or oversight, and more importantly, the money was never used to pay for the diamonds.

Modi, through his attorney, has denied the allegations and hit back at the bank in a letter, claiming the amount he owes is much less, and that the publicity surrounding the case has damaged his businesses and, along with it, the bank’s ability to recover money. His businesses include Firestar International, which owns a company called Sandberg & Sikorski, better known to retailers as A. Jaffe. 

Choksi also denied his involvement through a regulatory filing made by Gitanjali, which, it is worth noting, owns Samuels Jewelers in the U.S.

I don’t want to rehash every development in this case, as it’s been widely covered by many media outlets closer to the situation with greater resources and contacts on the ground in India.

What I do want to focus on is what this case means for the diamond industry as a whole in terms of bank financing specifically; in other words, why it matters.

I spent a long time on the phone Thursday with an industry banker (who asked that his name be withheld) and asked him to help me find an apt idiom to describe this situation.

Can we say, to use a well-worn one, that this is “the straw that broke the camel’s back” when it comes to the diamond industry and financing?

No, he told me, because that camel’s already wearing a brace and taking painkillers. “This,” he said, “is just another really bad week for the camel,” or, to employ one more, it’s “just another nail in the coffin.” 

“It’s not the end of the world,” he allows. “But it is another stamp, another demerit that says, ‘Just stay away from this thing. Don’t go anywhere near it. It’s not reliable. Why would you want to do business with these people?’”

Consider cases such as M. Fabrikant & Sons, W.B. David & Co. and Winsome Diamonds, and the subsequent withdrawal of banks from the industry, one by one, like gamblers folding in a game of cards: Antwerp Diamond Bank, Bank Leumi and Standard Chartered.

Regulations have only gotten tighter, the industry hasn’t evolved enough to keep up and banks, as I wrote back in June 2016 when analyzing the exit of Standard Chartered, simply see too much risk for too little reward. 

“It's no longer a special club for men where you get to make nice to De Beers and you get your box of diamonds and everything stays behind closed doors,” the banker observed.

And yet, here we are.

The latest industry scandal will, presumably, make those few banks that are still financing the diamond industry pipeline even more vigilant and stringent about lending money, while giving those that aren’t involved another reason to stay out of it.

And it’s not going to be something the banks forget about in a year, or even five, my source said.

He said what’s going on in the industry with banks right now is a substantial change, a generational change that’s going to have effects in the short-term, yes, but also will be impacting how the diamond industry does business 30 or 40 years down the road.

“When you put bankers off of an industry, it’s going to take a while, at least a couple of decades,” to get them back on board, he said.

“Somebody has to figure out how to make these companies transparent, truly transparent, how to adopt it and how to test themselves.”

Are Consumers Following This Story?
What about consumer confidence in diamonds and the industry as a whole?

On Thursday morning, I arrived at work to find in my inbox a link to this column by Indian journalist Vinod Kuriyan, the chief editor of GEMKonnect and a highly respected colleague whom I’ve known for years.

Kuriyan linked to an article published that same day by the Times of India that indicates that the scope of the fraud extends beyond bank loans to include diamond companies in Surat setting the jewelry Modi and Choksi sold via their brands in the United Arab Emirates and Hong Kong with low-quality goods and, in some cases, man-made diamonds being sold as natural.

(The article does not say anything about any of the jewelry coming to the United States, and it is also worth noting that this Times of India article quotes an individual who said that there are no machines that can detect lab-grown diamonds once they are set in jewelry, which is incorrect.)

Kuriyan called the development a “knockout punch” as far as consumer confidence goes.

I don’t know if I’d go that far, but it will be interesting to see how this case develops in the coming weeks and months, as Mr. Kuriyan, who certainly understands the situation in India, notes that what started as a case of bank fraud is “snowballing into something much bigger.”
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

FinancialsDec 06, 2022
Signet Anticipates Solid Holiday Season, Raises Guidance

The jewelry giant posted a decline in same-store sales in the third quarter but is gearing up for a season of growth.

TrendsDec 06, 2022
Pantone’s 2023 Color of the Year Is A Lot Like Rubellite, Spinel, Ruby

“Viva Magenta” easily finds its colored gemstone counterparts.

AuctionsDec 06, 2022
Jewels from the Sunken ‘Ship of Gold’ Smash Auction Estimates

Holabird Western Americana Collections offered hundreds of treasures recovered from the S.S. Central America in its Dec. 3 sale.

Brought to you by
How To Buy Colored Gemstones

Give your customers the full gemstone buying experience by using the 6C's.

ColumnistsDec 06, 2022
The Smart Lab: 6 Holiday Email Marketing Strategies To Boost Sales

From creating catchy subject lines to retargeting abandoned carts, Emmanuel Raheb has a half-dozen pieces of email marketing advice.

Weekly QuizDec 01, 2022
This Week’s Quiz
Test your knowledge of the latest jewelry news with this quick test.
Take the Quiz
IndependentsDec 06, 2022
CD Peacock Names VP of Client Engagement, Experience

Qi Holtzman is a member of the second generation to run the family-owned Chicago area jeweler.

IndependentsDec 05, 2022
Holocaust Survivor and Jeffrey Mann Jewelers Matriarch Rena Mann Dies

Mann, who opened the Ohio jewelry store with her husband and son in 1984, was 95.

Brought to you by
Knowledge and Skills for Today’s Hot Topics

From laboratory-grown diamonds to design to country-of-origin, GIA's Alumni Collective™ has a seminar to suite your needs.

TechnologyDec 05, 2022
Timex Ticks into the Metaverse with Bored Ape Yacht Club

The watch brand will create 500 custom timepieces for holders of Bored Ape Yacht Club NFTs.

Events & AwardsDec 05, 2022
WJA Foundation Awards Nearly $60K in Scholarships for 2022-2023

Scholarship winners received awards in six different categories.

SourcingDec 02, 2022
Alrosa CEO Sergey Ivanov to Step Down, Report Says

According to Russian news sources, the sanctioned head of the diamond company is leaving to take a job with an investment group.

SourcingDec 02, 2022
Lucapa Sells 170-Carat Pink Diamond Unearthed This Summer

Said to be the largest pink diamond found in hundreds of years, “The Lulo Rose” was sold for an undisclosed sum.

AuctionsDec 02, 2022
Here’s How 2 Royal Jewels Performed at Auction in Denmark

A princess’s tiara fell within its pre-sale estimate while an Art Deco bracelet from a queen doubled it.

CollectionsDec 02, 2022
Piece of the Week: Foundrae’s Chain

A closer look at the bold links reveals a subtle, surprising detail.

Supplier BulletinDec 01, 2022
Take Your Jewelry Design Process Digital with the GIA Alumni Collective™

Sponsored by GIA Alumni Collective™

WatchesDec 01, 2022
Rolex to Certify Pre-Owned Watches

Retailers within its official distribution network will be able to sell the authenticated timepieces.

CollectionsDec 01, 2022
Kendra Scott’s New Collection is for Barbie Girls

The capsule collection combines the brand’s classic styles with Barbie’s signature pink color.

AuctionsDec 01, 2022
13-Carat Pink Diamond Withdrawn From Christie’s Auction

The auction house is not offering any details on why the fancy vivid pink stone was pulled from its upcoming “Magnificent Jewels” sale.

SourcingDec 01, 2022
Nomad’s Is Selling Its Stones to Raise Money for Ukraine Again

In the spirit of an advent calendar, “Gems to Help Ukraine” will sell a stone a day through Dec. 24 on the Nomad’s Instagram account.

GradingDec 01, 2022
PhotoScribe Granted Patent for Method that Verifies a Stone’s Identification

The secure mark combines an overt mark with a covert data set to provide assurance on a gem.

SurveysNov 30, 2022
5 Things Retailers Should Know About the Start to the Holiday Season

Plus, what a potential rail strike would mean for retailers.

WatchesNov 30, 2022
Watchfinder & Co. Will Launch a Marketplace Next Year

It will provide a place for select luxury watch retailers to sell their stock.

MajorsNov 30, 2022
Pomellato Buys Into Italian Goldsmith

The brand has purchased a minority stake in Costanzo & Rizzetto.

SourcingNov 30, 2022
Firestone Restarts Operations of Lesotho Diamond Mine

Liqhobong has been in a care-and-maintenance period since the start of the pandemic.

MajorsNov 29, 2022
LVMH Acquires Jewelry Manufacturer Pedemonte Group

The strategic acquisition will bolster the luxury titan’s production capacity in its watch and jewelry division.

CollectionsNov 29, 2022
Alex and Ani Founder Carolyn Rafaelian Has Launched a Fine Jewelry Line

The new brand, Metal Alchemist, focuses on unisex, classic jewelry designs.

IndependentsNov 29, 2022
Reinhold Jewelers’ Holiday Book Is an Ode to an Important Beverage

The 2022 edition of the retailer’s annual publication pays homage to the coffee farms and shops of Puerto Rico.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy