Sourcing

Analysis: The State of the Diamond Industry

SourcingOct 25, 2017

Analysis: The State of the Diamond Industry

Taking action to ensure it accurately differentiates between lab-grown diamonds and their mined counterparts is the biggest challenge the industry faces.

20171025_AMS-lab.jpg
A shot inside one of the laboratories operated by De Beers’s International Institute of Diamond Grading and Research. The workers shown here are using the first version of the Automated Melee Screener, developed to detect man-made diamonds in packets of small diamonds.
Although there is no way of knowing how many undisclosed lab-grown diamonds are circulating, analyst Chaim Even-Zohar estimates approximately $750 million worth of gem-quality man-made diamonds entered the supply chain in 2016. 

Click <a href="https://magazines-nationaljeweler-com.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/stateofthemajors/2017/index.html?page=1" target="_blank">here</a> to read the full story in the State of the Majors issue.
Click here to read the full story in the State of the Majors issue.

He describes the volume of undisclosed lab-grown melee—diamonds sized from a miniscule 0.001 carats to 0.18 carats used in every type of jewelry—entering the market as “staggering.”

Others also believe there is a reasonable likelihood of discovering undisclosed lab-grown stones in the pipeline.

“Based on our experience of testing jewelry and parcels, we suspect the risk of finding synthetics in the supply chain is reasonably high at the moment,” says Tom Moses, executive vice president and chief laboratory and research officer at the Gemological Institute of America.

Just one high-profile case of a consumer discovering the expensive ring they saved up for contained an undisclosed lab-grown diamond could have huge ramifications for consumer trust in an industry already working hard to stay relevant to millennials.

It is bound to happen before too long and, in fact, it probably already has.

David Skuza of DRC Techno, a Surat, India-based gemological research and development company founded by sightholder Dharmanandan Diamonds, says every customer who has used the company’s J-Secure Plus machine has found undisclosed lab-grown diamonds.

One customer recently tested a fancy diamond bracelet with rounds and baguettes. They discovered the baguettes to be lab grown, a big surprise.

“Every retailer, manufacturer, wholesaler and diamond company that has tested or bought our machine finds undisclosed lab-grown diamonds. High-end or mass-market, it makes no difference. The contamination is everywhere.”

“Every retailer, manufacturer, wholesaler and diamond company that has tested or bought our machine finds undisclosed lab-grown diamonds,” says David Skuza of DRC Techno of the company’s J-Secure Plus, pictured here. “High-end or mass-market, it makes no difference.”
“Every retailer, manufacturer, wholesaler and diamond company that has tested or bought our machine finds undisclosed lab-grown diamonds,” says David Skuza of DRC Techno of the company’s J-Secure Plus, pictured here. “High-end or mass-market, it makes no difference.”

He has endless examples of this “contamination.”

They include a gem lab, which Skuza will not publicly identify for confidentiality reasons, that quality controls more than 1,000 stones on a weekly basis for a major reseller and regularly finds more than 5 percent of its diamond products containing undisclosed man-made diamonds.

He also cites an example in which a customer checking a 5-carat parcel of 0.02-carat diamonds at the recent JCK Las Vegas show discovered that nearly 75 percent of the diamonds he had just purchased were man-made.

Taking Action
Although the battle against undisclosed lab-grown diamonds feels a bit like fighting terrorism—those who want to cause disruption are always one step ahead of those seeking to curtail it—the industry is far from powerless. 
Manufacturers and dealers should use all the means at their disposal to stem the flow of undisclosed lab-grown stones further down the supply chain. But, retailers must also do their part to prevent these stones from ending up in the hands of unsuspecting end consumers.

Jonathan Kendall, president of the International Institute of Diamond Grading & Research (IIDGR), a De Beers Group company, says the first piece of advice for retailers who suspect they might have received undisclosed lab-grown diamonds is not to panic.

The second is to review what safeguards they have in place regarding the products they sell, noting that, “Every individual business is responsible for the integrity of its merchandise.”

Retailers can try to ensure all the diamonds they buy and sell come with an objective grading report. However, not all goods have grading reports. In such cases, they can send out their inventory to any of the major labs for testing. However, this can add up in cost—both for the testing and the associated administrative costs—and time, putting a real strain on smaller businesses in particular. 

An alternative is to invest in one of the diamond detection machines geared toward retailers that allow jewelers to test their inventory, including mounted jewelry, on an as-needed and just-in-time basis. 

IIDGR’s SYNTHdetect identifies diamonds as natural, rather than looking for signs that the stone is man-made, which the lab’s Jonathan Kendall says is “a major step forward in technology.”
IIDGR’s SYNTHdetect identifies diamonds as natural, rather than looking for signs that the stone is man-made, which the lab’s Jonathan Kendall says is “a major step forward in technology.”

HRD Antwerp produces the D-Screen, a portable piece of equipment that distinguishes lab-grown stones from natural diamonds. The machine can also determine if a stone has undergone high-pressure, high-temperature (HPHT) treatment to improve or enhance its color.

The D-Screen can check all diamond cuts and can scan up to 200 stones, from 0.2 carats to 10 carats in D to J colors, an hour, with immediate results. 

IIDGR has just released the SYNTHdetect. Designed for back-office use by jewelry manufacturers and retailers, SYNTHdetect (and the second version of the lab’s automated melee screener, AMS2) works by identifying diamonds as natural, rather than looking for telltale signs of lab-grown origin. This, says Kendall, is “a major step forward in technology.”

IIDGR says it has the industry’s lowest referral rate, around 0.05 percent, compared with other screening products that can have a referral rate approaching 10 percent. The referral rate has to do with those diamonds that the machine cannot 100 percent verify as not being lab-grown and, therefore, must be sent to a gemological lab for further testing. The low referral rate of SYNTHdetect is designed to save retailers both time and money.

IIDGR also offers the lower-cost PhosView ($4,500 versus $16,250 for SYNTHdetect). This is a more basic machine that analyzes parcels of polished diamonds to determine if they contain potential HPHT-grown diamonds only.


GIA is already taking orders for its soon-to-be-released GIA iD100 (pictured above), an easy-to-operate desktop instrument that identifies mounted and loose natural colorless diamonds.

The instrument combines advanced spectroscopic technology and GIA’s extensive research into natural and man-made diamonds to uncover all lab-grown diamonds—made with both the HPHT and chemical vapor deposition processes—and all simulants. The lab is conducting further research to extend the capabilities of the instrument to identify pink diamonds and other gem material.

Finally, DRC Techno’s J-Screen Plus identifies CVD and HPHT lab-grown diamonds and can be used on loose or mounted stones as small as 0.003 carats in any shape. The easy-to-understand results mean that testing can be done by someone with no gemology training.

The company also markets the D-Screen Plus, which works on colorless or near-colorless HPHT and CVD lab-grown diamonds in all shapes and sizes from 0.003 to 10 carats (the machine can screen larger stones and fancy shapes with some mechanical add-ons). While it is primarily aimed at loose stones, D-Screen Plus can also scan set jewelry as long as the diamonds are visible.

The Melee over Melee
While retailers can check larger stones and small amounts of melee, checking large quantities of tiny stones requires more specialized equipment.

For self-testing melee, HRD Antwerp has the M-Screen. This super-fast, automated screening device checks round, brilliant diamonds from 0.5 points to 20 points to identify potential lab-grown diamonds, potential HPHT color-enhanced stones, and diamond simulants. Developed by WTOCD, the Antwerp Scientific Research Centre for Diamonds, it feeds, screens and sorts at least three diamonds per second, or 11,000 diamonds an hour. Depending on the size of the stones and batch, the machine can sort an astounding 15,000 diamonds an hour.


The GIA now has a Melee Analysis Service, which scans small stones to separate natural, untreated diamonds from simulants and potentially man-made or treated diamonds. The diamonds are returned in a sealed package, as seen above. Earlier this year, IIDGR launched the AMS2, the second generation of its automated melee screening machine. It is up to 10 times faster than the company’s first melee screening machine and has a substantially reduced referral rate. This minimizes the need for additional and expensive secondary testing. With a price tag of $45,000, it is primarily for those involved in polished diamond wholesale rather than retailers.

Retailers who deal in large amounts of melee can send parcels to the labs to be tested if they have suspicions about what they are buying.

And if their parcel gets flagged as containing lab-grown diamonds, they should not be surprised.

Earlier this year, for example, the GIA lab in Mumbai reported that almost a third of a parcel of melee screened using its Diamond Analysis Service were undisclosed lab-grown diamonds. Put another way, 101 out of the 323 diamonds were man-made.

Another equipment maker, Hong Kong-headquartered Diamond Services, recently announced its New York lab had detected multiple single-cut lab-grown diamonds sized from 0.0025-0.005 carats mounted in jewelry. (Single-cut stones have 16 to 18 facets, compared with the 57 or 58 facets of a full-cut stone.)

“To the best of my knowledge, this is the first time that a synthetic single-cut stone has been detected mounted in jewelry,” Joseph Kuzi, Diamond Services founder and managing director, said in a press release. “What this means is that almost no diamond can be taken at face value.”

A Cause for Optimism
While the number of undisclosed lab-grown diamonds being discovered is disquieting, the industry seems to be taking the right steps to make sure consumers get the products they want, which might mean lab-grown rather than mined diamonds. 

According to Moses, the use of lab-grown diamonds and their marketing to consumers makes accurate identification and disclosure even more important so buyers can make an informed decision about their choices.

Jonathan Kendall agrees. “With this also comes the added pressure of consumers becoming more aware on the topic of undisclosed synthetics. That’s why testing is so important—it becomes a valuable tool for any business to be able to provide that level of assurance and confidence. With millennials increasingly demanding greater levels of product information, the need to provide this guarantee will only increase.” 

One country taking the need for guarantees further is India. 

The chairman of the country’s Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council (GJEPC), Praveenshankar Pandya, recently announced the establishment of an “International Diamond Monitoring Committee” to eliminate supply chain infiltration of undisclosed lab-grown diamonds. The GJEPC said it will offer to pay half of the cost of detection machines for its members to help cut down on the number of undisclosed man-made stones traveling further down the pipeline. 

While there is no way to prevent every single undisclosed lab-grown diamond from entering the pipeline, the fact so many businesses are investing in detection machinery is a cause for optimism. 

But, it is important not to get complacent. The battle against undisclosed man-made diamonds will continue to be waged as long as diamond-makers find new ways to improve production and unscrupulous players insist on compromising the integrity of the industry.

The Latest

Graphic for My Next Question episode on lab-grown diamonds
Recorded WebinarsSep 29, 2023
The Lab-Grown Diamond Market: Where Are We Now?

Watch as Edahn Golan, Sherry Smith and Avi Levy join Michelle Graff to talk pricing and trends in this controversial corner of the market.

Sonya K. Taylor diamond tennis necklace with tourmaline drop
CollectionsSep 29, 2023
Piece of the Week: Sonya K’s Versatile Necklace

A classic diamond tennis necklace gets a whole lot cooler with a removable pendant.

Columbia Gem House Woz Cuts
EditorsSep 28, 2023
The Gemstone World Is In Its Unique Cut Era

Associate Editor Lauren McLemore recently spoke with Columbia Gem House’s Eric Braunwart about the uptick in non-traditional gemstone cuts.

BroughtToYou_Image_R02_V02_LK-01.jpg
Brought to you by
Top 5 Ways to Promote Safety and Security Awareness Among Your Staff

Awareness is essential to proactive protection. Learn how to promote and maintain safety and security awareness in your business.

Pre-Owned Luxury by Rocksbox logo
MajorsSep 28, 2023
Signet-Owned Rocksbox Now Sells Pre-Owned Fine Jewelry

“Pre-Owned Luxury by Rocksbox” offers secondhand jewelry from Kay, Zales, and Jared to members and non-members.

Weekly QuizSep 29, 2023
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge with this short test.
Take the Quiz
Gold Roman Bracelet from the British Museum
CrimeSep 28, 2023
Have You Seen Jewels Like These? The British Museum Wants to Know

The museum is asking for the public’s help in finding thousands of pieces of ancient gold jewelry and gemstones stolen from a storeroom.

Pam Waclawski The Kingswood Company
MajorsSep 28, 2023
The Kingswood Co. Names New VP, Wins Award

The company was recognized for one of its private-label, consumer-focused jewelry care lines.

Dialog Solutions
Brought to you by
A Conversation with Dialog Solutions

Do you always want the right diamonds at the right price in your store? Introducing Dialog, the world’s first diamond subscription service.

Chaumet diamond necklace, circa 1900
AuctionsSep 27, 2023
Antique Jewels Shine at Bonhams London

A rare Chaumet necklace and 20th-century sapphire ring sold for double their estimates.

Hands pushing a shopping cart
SurveysSep 27, 2023
Consumer Confidence Falls in September Amid Rising Recession Fears

Shoppers also expressed concern about rising prices, higher interest rates, and political uncertainty.

   Platinum Guild International logo
Events & AwardsSep 27, 2023
PGI to Dole Out $500K in Business Grant Program

Participants from the first round of grants saw up to a 900 percent increase in their platinum sales.

Citizen Tsuki-yomi A-T moon phase watch
WatchesSep 26, 2023
Citizen Launches the Tsuki-Yomi A-T Timepiece

According to the watchmaker, it features the first light-powered atomic timekeeping moon phase movement.

Sally Nelson Exclusively Diamonds
IndependentsSep 26, 2023
Sally Nelson, Founder of Exclusively Diamonds, Dies at 86

The former teacher, described as “a pioneer for women-owned businesses,” opened her own jewelry store in 1980.

Crescendo, a 147.96-carat golden citrine by John Dyer for Somewhere In The Rainbow
Events & AwardsSep 26, 2023
2023 Spectrum Awards Entry Deadline Extended

The contest is now open for submissions until Oct. 10.

Instore show logo
Events & AwardsSep 26, 2023
Instore Announces Dates for 2024 Show

The annual event will return to Rosemont, Illinois next August.

Gold holiday gift boxes
SurveysSep 26, 2023
Mastercard Makes Its 2023 Holiday Prediction

According to SpendingPulse, retail sales will increase in November and December but not necessarily for jewelers.

Stock image of hands in handcuffs
CrimeSep 25, 2023
Oregon Jeweler Accused of Selling Lab-Grown Diamonds as Natural

Police say Douglas Wayne Gamble also swapped natural diamonds for synthetic stones and failed to return customers’ repairs.

Neil Lane lab-grown diamond engagement rings for Kay Jewelers
CollectionsSep 25, 2023
Neil Lane’s Latest Collection Uses Lab-Grown Diamonds

The designer just launched a new bridal range at Kay Jewelers.

Yunjo Lee
MajorsSep 25, 2023
Hearts On Fire Taps Mejuri Exec as CCO

Yunjo Lee has also worked on collections for Tiffany & Co. with Paloma Picasso and Frank Gehry.

Steve Levine of Sylvie Jewelry
MajorsSep 25, 2023
Second Generation Takes On New Roles at Sylvie Jewelry

Steve Levine joins the family-owned company, while his brother Gary has a new position.

David Yurman Paris flagship
MajorsSep 22, 2023
David Yurman Alleges These Two Companies Copied Its Designs

The company has filed complaints against Royal Chain and Samuel B.

Yun Yun Sun toi et moi diamond Puzzle ring
TrendsSep 22, 2023
Piece of the Week: Yun Yun Sun’s ‘Puzzle’ Ring

The two-stone style benefits from two-toned metal.

Mineral display at HardRock Summit 2023
Events & AwardsSep 22, 2023
HardRock Summit To Relocate In 2024

The event is moving just outside of Denver.

Timex ReWound video screenshot
WatchesSep 21, 2023
Timex Wants Your Old Watch

The company just rolled out “Timex Rewound,” a new takeback and resale program.

GIA logo
GradingSep 21, 2023
Retailers Warned About Fraudulent Email Purportedly From GIA

The lab confirmed it did not send the message.

Reginald Brack
AuctionsSep 21, 2023
Hindman Appoints New SVP, Director of Jewelry and Watches

Reginald Brack has worked at StockX and Christie’s.

Natural Diamond Council brand ambassador Lily James
SourcingSep 21, 2023
Natural Diamond Council’s Latest Campaign With Lily James Is Here

The second installment of “To Treasure Now and Forever” is intended to emphasize diamonds’ versatility.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy

Additionally, paste this code immediately after the opening  tag: