Columnists

Peter Smith: When Top Talent Leaves and What It Says About You

ColumnistsJun 03, 2026

Peter Smith: When Top Talent Leaves and What It Says About You

Smith discusses how managers should handle a top performer's exit, warning that a poor response could have a lasting impact.

The Retail Smiths founder and National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
Peter Smith is a principal partner at The Retail Smiths, a consultancy for jewelry vendors and retailers. He can be reached at theretailsmiths@gmail.com.
As I left the building for the last time, my overriding memory is of locking eyes with one of my colleagues as we passed each other. 

He knew exactly what was going on. No words were needed. 

It was an ignominious exit, a dictate from the CEO who believed it best for the company and customers to keep my departure under wraps as long as possible. 

“Let’s tell them you’re going on vacation,” he said. 

After all, there was Christmas business to be done, and we couldn’t risk customers questioning the direction of the company if they found out one of its top people was leaving.   

I recall that moment whenever I witness the different ways companies choose to handle departures. 

Some organizations do the right thing, and others, alas, reveal themselves to be callous in ways they couldn’t begin to comprehend. 

There are myriad reasons why top talent leaves companies. 

Sometimes the employee believes a ceiling has been reached. 

Occasionally, it’s a family business with limited opportunities for non-family members. 

Sometimes it signals a desire to expand their resume by doing things not available to them at their current company. 

And, of course, let’s not forget the elephant in the room—people don’t leave companies; they leave bad managers. 

Like most adages, there’s truth in those words and, I suspect, that might just be the main reason why talented employees choose to seek greener pastures. 

It is impossible to determine the number of companies that hire and promote leaders who are ill-equipped for the role, but there are enough of them to echo one of Warren Buffett’s many great sayings, “When you combine ignorance and leverage, you get some pretty interesting results.”

Jeffrey Yip and Dritjon Gruda wrote in “How To Manage an Insecure Leader,” an article in Harvard Business Review’s March/April 2026 issue: “Research suggests about 36 percent of adults have an insecure attachment style.

“The 2024 Korn Ferry report found that 71 percent of U.S. CEO’s and 65 percent of other senior executives experience symptoms of imposter syndrome—the persistent fear of being exposed as incompetent.” 

I’m surprised the research Yip and Gruda referenced shows only 36 percent of adults as having an “insecure attachment style.” 

I would have guessed most, if not all of us, occasionally experience feelings of imposter syndrome.

The negative consequences of poor leadership, of course, can wreak havoc across organizations.

In “Thinking In Bets, Making Smarter Decisions When You Don’t Have All The Facts,”  psychologist and poker champion Annie Duke wrote, “When our self-image is at stake, we treat our fielding decisions as 100 percent or zero percent: right versus wrong, skill versus luck, our responsibility versus outside our control. There are no shades of grey.”  

Such polarized thinking is completely at odds with the emotional and cognitive intellect required to be an effective leader and manager of people.  

It also follows that having someone in a leadership role without the requisite skillset and wiring greatly increases the likelihood of poor judgement being exercised in managing top talent and in how they handle key departures.  

Weak leaders often take the resignations of top people as a personal affront, and the prevailing attitude can ignite conscious and unconscious retaliatory behaviors. 

A friend recently shared with me that when he resigned, his boss said they were cancelling his exit interview as they “had more important things to focus on.”   

This guy was a real talent and role model until he decided it was time to move on. 

The dismissive and disrespectful message sent to him—and, by default, to the remaining employees—was an indictment of that leadership and culture.  

 Related stories will be right here … 

Top performers don’t always noisily advocate for themselves. 

They’re often too busy making things happen to call attention to their concerns. 

They reasonably expect that their status, pedigree, and performance ought to warrant the manager having their back. Until they don’t. 

Very often, the first you know of the problem is when the employee tenders their resignation. 

This frequently follows a pattern of their concerns having been ignored or whitewashed with cheesy managerial platitudes and general indifference over an extended period. 

By the time the resignation arrives, it’s too late to do anything about it. 

As bad as missing or ignoring the signals that your top talent is becoming disengaged—a problem affecting four of every five employees, according to Gallup research—mismanaging the eventual departure exacerbates the problem internally, sometimes to the degree that it creates even more employee exits.   

Lisa Feldman Barrett, author of “7 ½ Lessons About the Brain” and one of the most influential researchers in psychology wrote, “There is a real biological benefit when people treat one another with basic human dignity. And if we don’t, there is also a real biological consequence, and it eventually trickles down to a financial and social cost for everyone.” 

Treating departing employees with disrespect has a tendency to reverberate throughout the organization.   

And, very often, the arriving karma can take the form of both killing morale and accelerating the departure of other team members who notice the excuse-making, rationalizations, and even the subtle smears. 

In “Build an A-Team: Play to Their Strengths and Lead Them Up the Learning Curve” Whitney Johnson wrote, “If you aren't being respectful of the people who work for you, something is wrong, including the possibility that this management curve is the wrong curve for you.”  

While there are dangers in ever pointing to one thing as a leadership panacea, you simply cannot underestimate the value of empathy.  

Leaders with the capacity to switch off their own internal soundtrack long enough to demonstrate kindness and decency for the departing employee, and for what they may have gone through that resulted in them making such a difficult choice, are more likely to handle separations with dignity and professionalism.  

Few companies welcome the loss of their top talent, but their departure should never diminish the work and accomplishments that preceded their decision to move on.  

And, critically, it should never be a license to impugn their character or integrity.    

Their separation is an opportunity to acknowledge, sincerely and appropriately, their body of work and to allow their colleagues to do likewise.  

It doesn’t need bunting, balloons, or champagne, but it surely warrants honest reflection, an appreciation of the person, and sincere good wishes for their next steps.   

Anything less reflects poorly on your company and culture.


Peter Smithis a principal partner at The Retail Smiths, a consultancy for jewelry vendors and retailers. He is the author of four books, including the recently released “Essentially Human, On Sales and Salespeople,” and he teaches sales behavior master classes. He can be reached at theretailsmiths@gmail.com.

The Latest

The 170-carat Lulo Rose pink diamond
SourcingNov 20, 2026
Company That Mined Angola’s Largest Diamond Has a New Owner

Dubai-based AV Group has acquired Lucapa Diamond Company, which holds a stake in Angola’s Lulo mine and has a diamond project in Australia.

Anabela Chan Canary Atlantis Earrings
TrendsNov 20, 2026
Anabela Chan’s ‘Canary Atlantis’ Earrings Enter The Hunger Games Arena

Actress Mckenna Grace wore our Piece of the Week to the London premiere of “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.”

 Woman wearing jewelry looking in the mirror
Events & AwardsNov 20, 2026
Registration Open for JIS Spring 2027

Registration for the trade show, taking place March 7-9, is now open.

05_11_26_Overnight Mountings Web Asset_71.jpg
Brought to you by
12 Ways Independent Jewelers Can Drive More Sales and Stronger Profits in 2027

These twelve tips can help retailers improve margins, convert shoppers, and make every dollar work harder.

1.png
Supplier BulletinNov 19, 2026
Every Color, Every Cut: AGTA GemFair Tucson Returns Jan. 31 to Feb. 4, 2027

Sponsored by American Gem Trade Association (AGTA)

Weekly QuizNov 19, 2026
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
The 176.29-carat Owishi diamond
SourcingNov 19, 2026
176-Carat Diamond, Second Largest Found in Namibia, Comes to US

The “Owishi” made its U.S. debut in Washington, D.C. on Monday and now will return to Namibia for planning, cutting, and polishing.

Fake Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl Championship rings
CrimeNov 19, 2026
Customs Seizes Fake Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl Rings

CBP agents in Houston have seen “significant seizures” of counterfeit watches, baby toys, and FIFA World Cup merchandise, the agency said.

LIM-1452_1872-x-1052_Jewelry-Services--Image-Resize-.jpg
Brought to you by
More Information. More Confidence. One GIA Jewelry Report.

The GIA Jewelry Report helps retailers answer customer questions with independent, science-based information from GIA—all in one report.

Moussaieff Spinel
AuctionsNov 19, 2026
52-Carat Red Spinel Sells for $2M to Moussaieff

The London high jewelry house, which bought the gemstone at Sotheby’s Geneva jewelry auction, has renamed it the “Moussaieff Spinel.”

Bench Jeweler Tools
Events & AwardsNov 19, 2026
Rio Grande Sponsors New High School Award at NYC Jewelry Week

The Here We Are High School award will gift a Future Jewelers Academy student with $750 and a Rio Grande tool kit with bench essentials.

Graphic for episode 11 of My Next Question podcast
PodcastsNov 18, 2026
Episode 11: Are Malls Making a Comeback?

Peter Smith and R.J. Hottovy of Placer.ai guest on this special pre-holiday episode of the podcast to discuss the status of shopping malls.

Michaels Jewelers Trumbull Mall
IndependentsNov 18, 2026
Michaels Jewelers to Close Mall Location After 15 Years

The jeweler is closing its store in the Trumbull Mall in Connecticut, citing a decline in foot traffic.

Paul Altieri Not For Sale book
WatchesNov 18, 2026
Paul Altieri Pens Book on Personal Rolex Watch Collection

In “Not For Sale,” the CEO and founder of Bob’s Watches showcases his collection of 134 rare vintage Rolexes and the stories behind them.

Stephen Webster Shaken & Stirred Bracelet Clasp
CollectionsNov 18, 2026
Stephen Webster Debuts a Bracelet Made for 007

The "Shaken & Stirred" clasp is one of seven designs in a new collection celebrating notorious male figures from the 20th century.

Winnie Park
MajorsNov 18, 2026
Signet Jewelers Appoints Five Below CEO to Its Board

Winnie Park was also previously the CEO of Forever 21 and Paper Source.

Blanca Miró and Emily Satloff wearing the Blanca Miró x Larkspur & Hawk Collection
CollectionsNov 17, 2026
Larkspur & Hawk Partners With Blanca Miró on New Collection

The collaborative collection features rivière necklaces, layered bracelets, drop earrings, and stackable rings in four vivid colors.

Stock image of handcuffs and a gavel
CrimeNov 17, 2026
1 Man Arrested, Another Sought in Murder of Ohio Jeweler

Tara Sinchuri was shot to death inside his store, Everest Jewels in Fairfield, Ohio, during a robbery last month.

Steve Quick Jeweler team
IndependentsNov 17, 2026
A Few Snaps From Steve Quick Jeweler’s 40th Anniversary Celebration

The Chicago jeweler celebrated its ruby anniversary in style.

Alexander Calder earrings
AuctionsNov 17, 2026
Jewelry Alexander Calder Made for Family Members Up for Auction

The five pieces on offer at Bonhams, together estimated to fetch $300,000, were made as gifts for the artist’s mother, sister, and niece.

Renovated Betteridge Jewelers store in Greenwich, Connecticut
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Step Inside Betteridge Jewelers’ Renovated Greenwich Store

Located on the main street in Greenwich, the renovation marks Watches of Switzerland’s most significant U.S. retail investment to date.

Pauline Karpidas: The Jewelry Collection
AuctionsNov 16, 2026
A Tour of Pauline Karpidas’ Jewelry Heading to Auction

Her eclectic collection, with jewels spanning several periods of the 20th century, could fetch up to $10 million at Sotheby's next month.

Kerry Feldmann
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Kendra Scott Taps Former John Hardy, Tiffany & Co. Exec as CMO

Jewelry industry executive Kerry Feldmann has taken on the role.

American Gem Society Conclave 2027 speakers
Events & AwardsNov 16, 2026
AGS Announces 2027 Conclave Keynote Speakers

This year’s lineup includes a chief executive optimist, “The Iron Cowboy,” a Peloton executive, and The Second City comedians.

Romanov Sapphire
AuctionsNov 13, 2026
Historic ‘Romanov Sapphire’ Achieves $4.9M at Sotheby’s

The 197-carat Russian Crown jewel was the leading lot of Sotheby's white-glove Royal & Noble Jewels sale this week.

Maison Marcelle Équation Bracelet
CollectionsNov 13, 2026
Maison Marcelle’s Bracelet Flows Like Fabric

The “Équation” bracelet, our Piece of the Week, was built via 24 gold modules assembled into a piece that feels like fabric on the wrist.

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont Texas
IndependentsNov 13, 2026
Texas Jeweler to Close After 111 Years

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont, Texas, is closing as Brian and Lori Alter retire to spend more time with family.

Christine Olowonira, K. Angelo Jones, Ivi Kyratzi, Aaron Mak, and Haley Kim
Events & AwardsNov 13, 2026
Tiffany & Co., CFDA Unveil Second Jewelry Designer Award Finalists

Five finalists have been chosen for the Tiffany & Co. x CFDA Jewelry Designer Award’s second cycle.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy