Independents

After 44 Years in Business, This Wisconsin Independent Is Closing

IndependentsDec 06, 2024

After 44 Years in Business, This Wisconsin Independent Is Closing

Mike Straub and John Treiber opened Treiber & Straub in 1980 with the goal of bringing Milwaukeeans the best jewelry brands.

Treiber & Straub store Brookfield, Wisconsin
Treiber & Straub Jewelers is located in Brookfield, Wisconsin, about 14 miles west of Milwaukee. John Treiber and Mike Straub opened the store in 1980, and Straub bought out his partner in the mid-‘90s. Over the summer, Straub made the decision to close his store and retire, for myriad reasons.
Brookfield, Wis.—After more than five decades in the jewelry industry, Wisconsin retailer Mike Straub is retiring and closing the store he opened in 1980, Treiber & Straub Jewelers. 

Straub, 74, said retirement is something he had been considering in recent years but only decided that 2024 would be the year after losing a key brand, bringing to a close a career that started with a borrowed suit.   

As a young man, Straub served in the U.S. Marine Corps. After he got out, he married, and his wife’s uncle, who was in the jewelry business, asked him if he’d be interested in a job in jewelry. 

“I’ll be honest with you, I didn’t know the difference between a ruby and a sapphire,” Straub said, but he was willing to give it a try.

He borrowed a suit from a friend, went for an interview at Brodnax Jewelers (then part of Zale Corp.’s Guild Division) in Memphis, Tennessee, and landed his first job in the industry. 

In 1974, Zale transferred Straub from Memphis to Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He stayed with the company six more years, eventually rising to the level of district manager for a group of Milwaukee-area Bailey, Banks & Biddle stores, also part of Zale’s Guild Division at the time.

In 1980, Straub branched out on his own, opening Treiber & Straub at the Mayfair Mall in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, with colleague John Treiber. 

Straub bought out Treiber’s share of the business in 1995, and in late 2000, the store moved west to its current standalone location in Brookfield. 

Interior of Treiber & Straub jewelry store Brookfield, Wisconsin
Treiber & Straub opened at the Mayfair Mall in 1980 and moved to its current location in Brookfield, Wisconsin, in 2000. Mike Straub owns and operates the business with his daughters, Kimberly and Tracy Straub.


When Treiber and Straub opened their store, the idea was to bring the finest brands to the Milwaukee area so Milwaukeeans did not have to travel to bigger cities like Chicago to shop for jewelry. 

A longtime American Gem Society member store, Treiber & Straub stocked brands like David Yurman, Gucci, Fope, Mikimoto, and, until recently, Cartier and Rolex. 

But, as any jeweler will tell you, a lot has changed in the business over the course of four decades, from the way technology has transformed consumer behavior to vendors’ relationships with independent jewelers.   

Straub said for the last three years, he’s been locked in a back-and-forth with Cartier about doing an expensive build-out in his store to expand the brand’s footprint. 

Ultimately, he decided that the investment Cartier was requiring outweighed the benefits, and he and the Richemont-owned brand mutually parted ways after four decades in business together. 

In February, shortly after ending his relationship with Cartier, the jeweler received a call from Rolex telling him that, after nearly 45 years of being an Official Rolex Retailer, the brand would be revoking his dealer status at the end of September. 

According to Straub, Rolex told him that he did nothing wrong but the watch brand was simply “going in a different direction,” meaning migrating its retail footprint to higher-profile markets and larger metropolitan areas, a trend Peter Smith discussed in a column published by National Jeweler earlier this year. 

Rolex also owns a chain of stores now. In August 2023, the company announced plans to acquire watch retailer Bucherer, the company that bought Tourneau in 2018.  

(Rolex did not respond to request for comment on this story.)  

Losing Rolex was a huge blow to Treiber & Straub.  

Straub said the watch brand accounts for 60 percent of his store’s annual sales and to sustain the business without Rolex would, “require me to take a step back to move forward.” 

“As I am turning 75, I am not willing to start at the beginning again. I envisioned my children taking over my business, but due to the recent industry changes, the risk is too high.”  

For Straub, it’s the perceived lack of loyalty that really stings—having an account closed in a single phone call after years of following all the policies and procedures Rolex requires.  

In his view, it’s not just a problem with Rolex but across the board, between the demands placed on independent jewelers to build out spaces for jewelry and watch brands and the fact that many independents now find themselves competing with their vendors for sales.  

“That’s the bottom truth about the whole thing. There’s no loyalty today to your jeweler. It’s all about [the brands],” he said.  

 Related stories will be right here … 

Treiber & Straub enlisted jewelry liquidation company Wilkerson to aid in closing the store. The retailer’s going-out-of-business sale began in mid-November and is continuing through the holiday season.  

Beyond that, Straub is unsure what retirement will look like for him.  

He has hobbies—he hunts, fishes and boats—and he has plenty of family, including six grandchildren he is eager to spend time with, but he also is a self-described “Type A” personality. 

Straub built his “little castle” after years of hard work, including putting in as much as 70 hours a week back in the days when he was working at mall jewelry stores. Not working is going to be an adjustment.  

“I will miss all that,” he said. “I’m not 100 percent sure, because this is happening so fast, really what I want to do. I for sure want to do something, because I have a type A personality. I need to do something.”  

And he is sorry to disappoint his longtime customers. 

“I feel very bad. I have a lot of very good, loyal customers, a lot of good friends I’ve established over the years. My sadness is leaving that. I have people coming in here crying. I can’t tell you how many people [are saying], ‘I can’t believe you’re doing this,’” he said.   

“But I’ve had a great business, and I’ve got to walk out of here with my head up. I feel like I always gave my customers a great value. I’m proud of that.” 

The Latest

Astrid & Miyu 2025 12-Day, 24-Day, Solid Gold Advent Calendars
CollectionsOct 10, 2025
Count Down to the Holidays With Astrid & Miyu’s Advent Calendars

The trio of Advent calendars include a version with 18-karat gold and lab-grown diamond jewelry in a red lacquer jewelry box.

Front of Marla Aaron porcelain Nymphenburg Lock
CollectionsOct 10, 2025
Piece of the Week: Marla Aaron’s ‘Nymphenburg Lock’

Created in collaboration with Nymphenburg Porcelain, the lock is part of a four-piece collection that took two years to bring to fruition.

Alisa Bunger Frederick Goldman
MajorsOct 10, 2025
Frederick Goldman Names New VP of Sales

Jewelry industry veteran Alisa Bunger has taken on the role.

ja_fall_2024_by_headshot_stories_6824.jpg
Brought to you by
JA New York Fall Is Right Around the Corner

The upcoming show provides savvy retailers with the opportunity to stock their cases with best sellers in advance of the holiday season.

Feriel Zerouki, De Beers Chief Trade and Industry Officer
SourcingOct 09, 2025
Feriel Zerouki Is Leaving De Beers

The company and industry leader’s two-decade tenure with De Beers will come to a close at the end of the month.

Weekly QuizOct 09, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Fabergé Imperial Winter Egg
AuctionsOct 09, 2025
This Fabergé Egg Could Crack $27M At Auction

“The Winter Egg” set the world auction record for a Fabergé piece twice at previous Christie’s sales.

Kessler watch battery recycling program
MajorsOct 09, 2025
Sy Kessler Buying Watch Batteries as Silver Hits Record High

The company will pay 1.5x silver’s current spot price for each pound of silver oxide batteries submitted.

gia-edu main image.png
Brought to you by
A Brilliant Future Is Here

Online education from GIA experts.

Katkim Men’s Collection Shadow Pendant Necklace and Anerise Signet Band
CollectionsOct 09, 2025
Katkim Launches First Men’s Collection

The line includes a “Shadow” series crafted exclusively for the new men’s offering and reimagined styles from the brand’s core collections.

Gemfields Rough Rubies
SourcingOct 09, 2025
Gemfields’ Mini Mixed-Quality Ruby Auction Garners $11M

The rough on offer was recovered from a newer area at the Montepuez mine.

“Storied Diamond Desert Sands of Eternity” engagement ring and wedding band
SourcingOct 08, 2025
In ‘Storied Diamond,’ Jared Jewelers Is Emphasizing the Journey

The retailer’s new collection of engagement rings and fashion jewelry is set with natural diamonds that are traceable via blockchain.

Emily P. Wheeler Ombré Collection Campaign
CollectionsOct 08, 2025
Emily P. Wheeler Shifts Into Neutral for Latest ‘Ombré’ Collection

The champagne colorway in her newest “Ombré” collection combines white and trendy brown diamonds, a departure from her usual vibrant hues.

MRK x MFA Tsuba Charm Necklace Collection Campaign
CollectionsOct 08, 2025
Tsuba Designs Inspire Monica Rich Kosann’s New Charms

Kosann partnered with the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, to create a set of necklaces inspired by the artwork on samurai sword handguards.

Stock image of a gavel and law books
CrimeOct 07, 2025
Men Who Posed as Utility Workers Found Guilty in Jeweler’s Murder

Carlos Jose Hernandez and Joshua Zuazo face life in prison for the October 2024 murder of 72-year-old Detroit-area jeweler Hussein Murray.

Zoë Kravitz Wearing Jessica McCormack Tempest Sapphire Pendant and Tempest Diamond Necklace
CollectionsOct 07, 2025
Jessica McCormack Looks to Sea Spirits for ‘Tempest’ Collection

The brand’s first high jewelry collection, “Tempest” plays with movement while calling to mind the folklore of the sea.

Lightning Ridge Rural Fire Brigade
SourcingOct 07, 2025
Columbia Gem House Announces ‘Opals for Outback Heroes’ Fundraiser

Proceeds from its jewelry raffle will go to a volunteer-run fire and rescue group in the Lightning Ridge area of New South Wales, Australia.

Stuller 2025 S.E.R.V.E. Star Awards winners
MajorsOct 07, 2025
Stuller Names Its S.E.R.V.E Stars for 2025

Stuller said the recipients embody the company’s core values, which include community participation and personal and professional growth.

All four models of Citizen’s new Rainell watch
WatchesOct 06, 2025
This Fall, Citizen’s Forecast Calls for Rain

Citizen’s new “Rainell” women’s watch has a raindrop-shaped case and is available with a silver-, gold-, purple-, or green-colored dial.

Mercedes Gleitze Rolex Oyster 1926
AuctionsOct 06, 2025
The ‘Rolex That Made Rolex’ Heads to Auction at Sotheby’s

The “Mercedes Gleitze Rolex Oyster,” named for the British endurance swimmer who made it famous, will go up for sale next month.

Amit Pratihari GIA India
GradingOct 06, 2025
GIA India Names Former De Beers Exec as New Managing Director

Amit Pratihari was previously the managing director of De Beers India and Forevermark India.

DCWC 2025 Board of Directors
SourcingOct 06, 2025
SoCal 24 Karat Club Integrates Into Diamond Club West Coast

Members of the Jewelers 24 Karat Club of Southern California will gain access to expanded services, resources, and connections, DCWC said.

Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco Wedding, Jacob & Co. Watch
TrendsOct 03, 2025
Selena Gomez, Benny Blanco Tie the Knot Wearing Diamonds, White Metals

Gomez’s jewelry included Tiffany & Co. drop-style earrings while Blanco stacked diamonds from Jacob & Co. on his wrist.

HRD Antwerp CEO Paul De Wachter
GradingOct 03, 2025
Grading Lab HRD Antwerp Names New CEO

Diamond industry banking veteran Paul De Wachter will take on the role in January 2026.

Taylor Swift Kallati sapphire ring
TrendsOct 03, 2025
Piece of the Week: Kallati’s Pink Sapphire Ring

Taylor Swift flaunts an Elizabeth Taylor-esque gemstone in promo for her new album, “The Life of a Showgirl.”

Boucheron Quatre Sand Collection
CollectionsOct 02, 2025
Boucheron Debuts Cuffs Crafted With 3D-Printed Sand

Its “Quantre Sand” capsule was made using a 3D sand printing technique borrowed from the automotive and aeronautics industries.

Stock image of crime scene tape
CrimeOct 02, 2025
$1M in Jewelry Stolen in Northern California Smash and Grab

Four individuals have been charged in the “takeover-style” robbery of Heller Jewelers last month, and additional charges are expected.

Neil Lane and Boucheron bow tie brooch
MajorsOct 02, 2025
Neil Lane Jewelry Exhibition Coming to Toledo Museum of Art

“Radiance and Reverie” will showcase more than 150 jewels from Lane’s personal collection by Tiffany & Co., Cartier, and more.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy