Columnists

Peter Smith: How a Leadership Hire Can Make or Break a Company

ColumnistsDec 03, 2024

Peter Smith: How a Leadership Hire Can Make or Break a Company

In his latest column, Smith provides a list of questions every business needs to be asking their next potential leader.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
The recent news that Gina Drosos was departing Signet Jewelers got me thinking about the impact a single hire can have on the trajectory of a business.

While those effects are not confined solely to leadership, there can be little doubt that the top position in any company can define a business for years, either positively or negatively. 

The Drosos story will, I expect, be better understood with the passage of time. 

She appears to have righted a ship that struggled to navigate internal cultural challenges for years and must be given credit for the company’s outstanding performance amidst the global pandemic, when shopping malls contracted from 1,000 or so to a number fast approaching 400. 

Whether it was a good idea for Signet to embrace lab-grown diamonds at a time when mall traffic is in decline (“lower average ticket” plus “fewer unit sales”) is a question worth asking. 

With PetSmart’s J.K. Symancyk announced as Drosos’ replacement, it is also reasonable to ask, why was no succession plan in place? How does a company of that size not have a core base of executives from which a new CEO might emerge?  

While the comings and goings of key personnel at $7 billion companies will always make headlines, there are, of course, less celebrated announcements that happen throughout the jewelry business on a regular basis.  

To the companies making these hires, each one is just as important as the changes at Signet.  

Every key hire brings with it the promise, or at least the hope, of a better path for the hiring company and a renewed optimism that the arriving leader can chart a better course.  

In some cases, the new hire arrives because a once-relevant business has lost its way, perhaps even been passed by in the industry, and the seemingly Sisyphean task of getting things turned around lives and dies with a succession of executive hires and their attempted resuscitations.   

In other instances, the business might be suffering from the “curse of the entrepreneur,” a condition in which the qualities that were so critical in founding the company (courage, creativity, innovation, risk-tolerance, etc.) give way to different needs as the business matures.  

The founder continues to dream big when what’s really needed is a steady hand and the often-boring work of structure, discipline, and consistency. 

“If you insist on equating tenure as a guarantee of competency, I’ve got a bridge I’d like to sell you.”— Peter Smith

In making senior hires, companies seem to have a default position that a given candidate must be qualified and competent based purely on the strength of them having served in a similar capacity with another organization in our space.  

Experience and proximity somehow morph into perceived competency, often with little underlying justification. 

So, if you find yourself thinking about making an important executive hire, don’t accept empty platitudes and euphemisms about their capabilities and accomplishments.  

Challenge the default position that they must necessarily be good because they previously worked at company X or Y for years.  

The possibility that they may have sucked in that job rarely enters the equation in our haste to see what we want to see. And if you insist on equating tenure as a guarantee of competency, I’ve got a bridge I’d like to sell you.  

There are no shortcuts to understanding whether someone might be right for your business or not, but such an important decision ought to warrant a serious exploration of suitability in terms of both competence and cultural fit. The latter, I should point out, is no less important than capability. 

A few questions to augment your work on assessing the candidate might include the following: 

“What are you most proud of in your last position? Walk me through why that is and how you got there.” 

In answering those questions, are they talking about the Big Rocks, the things that make the most difference in the business?  

Are they pointing to something tangible that led to sales and profitability growth? 

Do they give you examples of specifics that suggest veracity in their answers?  

Another important question might be, “What is your vision for this brand? And can you give me a sense for what the roadmap might look like?”  

Does the answer suggest the candidate has given real thought to what your brand is about?  

Do they get the essence of what you believe your brand means, and does the answer promise a path that is feasible, or are they filling space with empty platitudes?  

 Related stories will be right here … 

Don’t assume because they say “strategy” a lot, that they have a clue what strategy means. Former Southwest Airlines CEO Herb Kelleher once said, “Sure, we have a strategic plan. It’s called doing things.”  

What does your candidate intend to do?  

Ask them, “What do you imagine your first 90 days might look like? What will your priorities be if you were to be hired for this role?” 

You’re not looking for a definitive GPS for those first 90 days, but you need to know that the candidate’s priorities speak to the things that are most important to the business, and they should credibly sound like they can execute around those key challenges.  

Tell them what your single biggest issue is and ask them why they believe they are qualified to tackle that problem.  

Ask them what they expect their biggest obstacles to be. Ask them if a year from now they have failed, why might that be?  

Your next key executive may not have the seemingly herculean task of the Signet CEO, but to any given business, there is nothing more important than that leadership hire.  

Stop rewarding tenure as though keeping your head above water was a good strategy for charting the critically important course for your business now.  

Have a great holiday season and have fun planning for next year! 

The Latest

Black and white photo of Tony Bennett near a microphone
WatchesAug 07, 2025
Bulova’s New Collection Honors Tony Bennett

The first watch in the series commemorates his participation in the Civil Rights movement, marching from Selma to Montgomery in 1965.

Sapphire page in Chatham’s “Ultimate Lab-Grown Catalog”
Lab-GrownAug 07, 2025
Chatham Releases Catalog for Loose Lab-Grown Gemstones

The catalog contains a complete listing of all the loose gemstones in stock, as well as information about the properties of each stone.

Rembrandt Blue Jay, Hummingbird, Cardinal Bird Charms
TechnologyAug 07, 2025
Rembrandt Charms Debuts New Website, Bird Charms

The company added a retailer dashboard to its site and three new birds to its charm collection, the cardinal, blue jay, and hummingbird.

rio-article photo-diamond.jpg
Brought to you by
Taking the Moment Head On: How Rio Grande Champions the Present & Future of Fine Jewelry

As a leading global jewelry supplier, Rio Grande is rapidly expanding and developing new solutions to meet the needs of jewelers worldwide.

Shipping containers on a ship
Policies & IssuesAug 06, 2025
Tariff on India to Rise to 50%, Trump Says

An additional 25 percent tariff has been added to the previously announced 25 percent.

Weekly QuizJul 31, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Claire’s storefront
MajorsAug 06, 2025
Claire’s Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Again

The jewelry and accessories retailer plans to close 18 stores as part of the proceedings.

Smith & Son Jewelers storefront Springfield Massachusetts
IndependentsAug 06, 2025
Smith & Son Jewelers to Close 107-Year-Old Location

Its Springfield, Massachusetts, store is set to close as owner Andrew Smith heads into retirement.

an instructor and a student in a bench jewelry classroom
Brought to you by
Investing in the Next Generation of Bench Jewelers

The Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship from Jewelers of America returns for a second year.

Zahn-Z Beluga Spout Grey Spinel Ring and Beluga Spout Mandarin Garnet Ring
CollectionsAug 06, 2025
Zahn-Z Swims With Whales in ‘Beluga’ Collection

Designer Hiba Husayni looked to the whale’s melon shaped-head, blowhole, and fluke for her new chunky gold offerings.

Paola De Luca presenting Trendbook 2026+ at Vicenzaoro
TrendsAug 06, 2025
Paola De Luca to Release Trendbook 2027+

She will present the 23rd edition of the trend forecasting book at Vicenzaoro on Sept. 7.

Omar Roy mugshot
CrimeAug 05, 2025
Report: Suspect Arrested in 1992 Murder of Miami Jeweler

Omar Roy, 72, was arrested in connection with the murder of jeweler Dionisio Carlos Valladares.

Mignon Faget Beyond Katrina Pendant and Beyond Katrina Pin
CollectionsAug 05, 2025
Mignon Faget Commemorates 20th Anniversary of Hurricane Katrina

The New Orleans-based brand’s “Beyond Katrina” jewels honor the communities affected by the storm.

Jewelers of America Logo
Events & AwardsAug 05, 2025
JA Announces Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship Winners

The organization has awarded a total of $42,000 through its scholarship programs this year.

2026 Gem Awards logo
Events & AwardsAug 04, 2025
Gem Awards, David Yurman Introduce $50K Grant for Emerging Designers

The winner of the inaugural David Yurman Gem Awards Grant will be announced live at the 2026 Gem Awards gala.

Marlo Laz peridot and diamond Alexandra earrings
TrendsAug 04, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: August’s Bright Baubles

As summer winds down, celebrate the sunny disposition of the month’s birthstones: peridot and spinel.

Surveillance image of Watch King robbery suspect
CrimeAug 04, 2025
‘The Watch King’ Assaulted, Robbed in Queens

Moshe Haimoff, a social media personality and 47th Street retailer, was robbed of $559,000 worth of jewelry by men in construction outfits.

Xavier Dibbrell
MajorsAug 04, 2025
Borsheims Welcomes New Assistant Facilities Manager

Xavier Dibbrell brings more than a decade of experience to the role.

Signet Jewelers logo
MajorsAug 01, 2025
Helzberg President Julie Yoakum Moves Over to Signet Jewelers

The addition of Yoakum, who will lead Kay and Peoples, was one of three executive appointments Signet announced Thursday.

Mike Alexander
MajorsAug 01, 2025
Jewelers Mutual Names Mike Alexander as President

The insurance company’s previous president and CEO, Scott Murphy, has split his role and will continue as CEO.

 Gemfields rough rubies
SourcingAug 01, 2025
Gemfields’ Auction Revenue Drops 50% in H1

The nearly six-month pause of operations at its Kagem emerald mine earlier this year impacted the miner’s first-half results.

Hernsdorf Tears of Aphrodite Necklace
CollectionsAug 01, 2025
Piece of the Week: Hernsdorf’s ‘Tears of Aphrodite’ Necklace

The necklace uses spinel drops to immortalize the moment Aphrodite’s tears mixed with her lover Adonis’ blood after he was fatally wounded.

Stock image of a polished diamonds being held by tweezers
SourcingJul 31, 2025
De Beers Records $189M First-Half Loss

The diamond miner and marketer warned last week that it expected to be in the red after significantly cutting prices in Q2.

Lindsey Scoggins Studio convertible flower earrings
Events & AwardsJul 31, 2025
These Are the 2025 CASE Award Winners

Jewelers of America’s 35th annual design contest recognized creativity, artistry, style, and excellence.

Matthew Tratner, new president of Continental Buying Group
IndependentsJul 31, 2025
Matthew Tratner Takes Over as CBG President

Tratner succeeds Andie Weinman, who will begin stepping back from the buying group’s day-to-day operations.

Stock image of rough diamonds from the Kimberley mine
Policies & IssuesJul 30, 2025
Tariff on India Will Be 25%, Trump Says

The president made the announcement via Truth Social Wednesday, adding that India also will face a penalty for its dealings with Russia.

Pomellato Mini London blue topaz and diamond bracelet
FinancialsJul 30, 2025
Kering's Jewelry Brands Resilient As H1 Sales Slide 16%

The luxury titan’s star brand Gucci continued to struggle amid a "tough" environment.

Zadok Rolex Austin
WatchesJul 30, 2025
Peek Inside Zadok Jewelers’ New Rolex Showroom in Austin

Its opening marks the completion of the retailer’s new 11,000-square-foot store in the Texas capital.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy