ColumnistsNov 26, 2024
The Smart Lab: 7 Strategies for Refining Your Holiday Email Marketing CampaignsColumnistsDec 03, 2024
Peter Smith: How a Leadership Hire Can Make or Break a Company
In his latest column, Smith provides a list of questions every business needs to be asking their next potential leader.
Peter Smith is an industry consultant, speaker, sales trainer, and author. He can be reached via email at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com.
The recent news that Gina Drosos was departing Signet Jewelers got me thinking about the impact a single hire can have on the trajectory of a business.
While those effects are not confined solely to leadership, there can be little doubt that the top position in any company can define a business for years, either positively or negatively.
The Drosos story will, I expect, be better understood with the passage of time.
She appears to have righted a ship that struggled to navigate internal cultural challenges for years and must be given credit for the company’s outstanding performance amidst the global pandemic, when shopping malls contracted from 1,000 or so to a number fast approaching 400.
Whether it was a good idea for Signet to embrace lab-grown diamonds at a time when mall traffic is in decline (“lower average ticket” plus “fewer unit sales”) is a question worth asking.
With PetSmart’s J.K. Symancyk announced as Drosos’ replacement, it is also reasonable to ask, why was no succession plan in place? How does a company of that size not have a core base of executives from which a new CEO might emerge?
While the comings and goings of key personnel at $7 billion companies will always make headlines, there are, of course, less celebrated announcements that happen throughout the jewelry business on a regular basis.
To the companies making these hires, each one is just as important as the changes at Signet.
Every key hire brings with it the promise, or at least the hope, of a better path for the hiring company and a renewed optimism that the arriving leader can chart a better course.
In some cases, the new hire arrives because a once-relevant business has lost its way, perhaps even been passed by in the industry, and the seemingly Sisyphean task of getting things turned around lives and dies with a succession of executive hires and their attempted resuscitations.
In other instances, the business might be suffering from the “curse of the entrepreneur,” a condition in which the qualities that were so critical in founding the company (courage, creativity, innovation, risk-tolerance, etc.) give way to different needs as the business matures.
The founder continues to dream big when what’s really needed is a steady hand and the often-boring work of structure, discipline, and consistency.
While those effects are not confined solely to leadership, there can be little doubt that the top position in any company can define a business for years, either positively or negatively.
The Drosos story will, I expect, be better understood with the passage of time.
She appears to have righted a ship that struggled to navigate internal cultural challenges for years and must be given credit for the company’s outstanding performance amidst the global pandemic, when shopping malls contracted from 1,000 or so to a number fast approaching 400.
Whether it was a good idea for Signet to embrace lab-grown diamonds at a time when mall traffic is in decline (“lower average ticket” plus “fewer unit sales”) is a question worth asking.
With PetSmart’s J.K. Symancyk announced as Drosos’ replacement, it is also reasonable to ask, why was no succession plan in place? How does a company of that size not have a core base of executives from which a new CEO might emerge?
While the comings and goings of key personnel at $7 billion companies will always make headlines, there are, of course, less celebrated announcements that happen throughout the jewelry business on a regular basis.
To the companies making these hires, each one is just as important as the changes at Signet.
Every key hire brings with it the promise, or at least the hope, of a better path for the hiring company and a renewed optimism that the arriving leader can chart a better course.
In some cases, the new hire arrives because a once-relevant business has lost its way, perhaps even been passed by in the industry, and the seemingly Sisyphean task of getting things turned around lives and dies with a succession of executive hires and their attempted resuscitations.
In other instances, the business might be suffering from the “curse of the entrepreneur,” a condition in which the qualities that were so critical in founding the company (courage, creativity, innovation, risk-tolerance, etc.) give way to different needs as the business matures.
The founder continues to dream big when what’s really needed is a steady hand and the often-boring work of structure, discipline, and consistency.
“If you insist on equating tenure as a guarantee of competency, I’ve got a bridge I’d like to sell you.”— Peter Smith
In making senior hires, companies seem to have a default position that a given candidate must be qualified and competent based purely on the strength of them having served in a similar capacity with another organization in our space.
Experience and proximity somehow morph into perceived competency, often with little underlying justification.
So, if you find yourself thinking about making an important executive hire, don’t accept empty platitudes and euphemisms about their capabilities and accomplishments.
Challenge the default position that they must necessarily be good because they previously worked at company X or Y for years.
The possibility that they may have sucked in that job rarely enters the equation in our haste to see what we want to see. And if you insist on equating tenure as a guarantee of competency, I’ve got a bridge I’d like to sell you.
There are no shortcuts to understanding whether someone might be right for your business or not, but such an important decision ought to warrant a serious exploration of suitability in terms of both competence and cultural fit. The latter, I should point out, is no less important than capability.
A few questions to augment your work on assessing the candidate might include the following:
“What are you most proud of in your last position? Walk me through why that is and how you got there.”
In answering those questions, are they talking about the Big Rocks, the things that make the most difference in the business?
Are they pointing to something tangible that led to sales and profitability growth?
Do they give you examples of specifics that suggest veracity in their answers?
Another important question might be, “What is your vision for this brand? And can you give me a sense for what the roadmap might look like?”
Does the answer suggest the candidate has given real thought to what your brand is about?
Do they get the essence of what you believe your brand means, and does the answer promise a path that is feasible, or are they filling space with empty platitudes?
Don’t assume because they say “strategy” a lot, that they have a clue what strategy means. Former Southwest Airlines CEO Herb Kelleher once said, “Sure, we have a strategic plan. It’s called doing things.”
What does your candidate intend to do?
Ask them, “What do you imagine your first 90 days might look like? What will your priorities be if you were to be hired for this role?”
You’re not looking for a definitive GPS for those first 90 days, but you need to know that the candidate’s priorities speak to the things that are most important to the business, and they should credibly sound like they can execute around those key challenges.
Tell them what your single biggest issue is and ask them why they believe they are qualified to tackle that problem.
Ask them what they expect their biggest obstacles to be. Ask them if a year from now they have failed, why might that be?
Your next key executive may not have the seemingly herculean task of the Signet CEO, but to any given business, there is nothing more important than that leadership hire.
Stop rewarding tenure as though keeping your head above water was a good strategy for charting the critically important course for your business now.
Have a great holiday season and have fun planning for next year!
More on Columnists
The Latest
CrimeMay 08, 2025
Former NYC Jewelry Store Employee Arrested in 2017 Choking Death of Boss Michel Desalles allegedly murdered Omid Gholian inside World of Gold N Diamond using zip ties and then fled the country.
EditorsMay 08, 2025
5 ‘Superfine’ Met Gala Jewelry MomentsAssociate Editor Lauren McLemore shares her favorite looks from a night of style inspired by Black dandyism.
Supplier BulletinMay 08, 2025
Instappraise Introduces Game-Changing Trifold Appraisal FormatSponsored by Instappraise
Brought to you by
Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch Show: Showcasing the Most Collectible Merchandise from Across the GlobeGain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.
FinancialsMay 08, 2025
Brilliant Earth Notes an Uptick in Engagement Ring Sales in Q1CEO Beth Gerstein discussed the company’s bridal bestsellers, the potential impact of tariffs, and the rising price of gold.
Weekly QuizMay 08, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
IndependentsMay 08, 2025
Margot McKinney Lands in the U.S. With New BoutiqueThe brand’s first independent location outside of Australia has opened in Beverly Hills, California.
IndependentsMay 08, 2025
Verragio Announces New Regional Sales ManagerCathy Marsh will lead the jewelry company’s efforts in the upper Midwest and western United States.
Brought to you by
Watch: The Winston Red: GIA Examines the Smithsonian’s Newest AdditionSupplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA
FinancialsMay 07, 2025
Pandora Posts Strong Q1, Plans for TariffsThe company has multiple strategies for dealing with tariffs, though its CEO said moving manufacturing to the U.S. is not one of them.
SourcingMay 07, 2025
Gemfields Says Emerald Sales Improved in Latest AuctionIts commercial-quality emerald sale held last month totaled more than $16 million, up from about $11 million in September 2024.
TechnologyMay 07, 2025
Punchmark’s Latest Podcast Features a Very Special Guest National Jeweler Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff joined Michael Burpoe to talk tariffs, consumer confidence, and the sky-high price of gold.
AuctionsMay 06, 2025
Harwell Godfrey Reimagines 10-Carat Blue Diamond for Met Gala-Ready BroochDesigner Lauren Harwell Godfrey made the piece as an homage to the 2025 gala’s theme, “Superfine: Tailoring Black Style.”
Events & AwardsMay 06, 2025
Here’s Who Made Jewelers of America’s New ‘20 Under 40’ ListExpanded this year to include suppliers, JA’s 2025 list honors 40 up-and-coming professionals in the jewelry industry.
IndependentsMay 06, 2025
Sissy's Log Cabin Opens New StoreLocated in Fort Smith, it’s the Mid-South jeweler’s first store in Northwest Arkansas.
IndependentsMay 06, 2025
Gunderson’s Jewelers to Be Featured on ‘World’s Greatest’ TV SeriesThe episode about the family-owned jeweler will premiere May 17.
IndependentsMay 05, 2025
Zadok Jewelers Opens Store in AustinThe Houston-based jeweler’s new 11,000-square-foot showroom will include a Rolex boutique.
AuctionsMay 05, 2025
Nancy Astor’s Cartier Tiara Heads to AuctionThe turquoise and diamond tiara hasn’t been on the market since it was purchased by Lord Astor in 1930.
SourcingMay 05, 2025
Crater of Diamonds Yields 4-Carat Brown Diamond“The Duke Diamond” is the largest diamond registered at the Arkansas park so far this year.
TrendsMay 02, 2025
Ring Concierge, Kraft Partner on Mother’s Day Macaroni Necklace The childhood craft of making dried pasta necklaces for Mother’s Day is all grown up as the 14-karat gold “Forever Macaroni” necklace.
CollectionsMay 02, 2025
Piece of the Week: Angely Martinez’s Emerald Promise RingSet with May’s birthstone and featuring an earthworm, this ring is a perfect celebration of spring.
MajorsMay 02, 2025
Stuller’s New Bridal Catalog Is Here“Bridal 2025–2026” includes popular styles and a dedicated section for quick pricing references of lab-grown diamond bridal jewelry.
SourcingMay 01, 2025
Tariffs & Colored Gemstones: Relying on Stock, Considering the Ripple EffectThough currently paused, high tariffs threaten many countries where gemstones are mined. Dealers are taking measures now to prepare.
MajorsMay 01, 2025
Peek Inside David Yurman’s New Miami Flagship StoreLocated in Miami’s Design District, the 4,000-square-foot store is an homage to David and Sybil Yurman’s artistic roots.
TrendsMay 01, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: 20 Pieces of Emerald Jewelry for MayMay babies are lucky indeed, born in a month awash with fresh colors and celebrated with one of the most coveted colored gemstones.
MajorsMay 01, 2025
Jewelers of America Opens Applications for 2025 ScholarshipsThe deadline to apply for the Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship is June 12.
SurveysApr 30, 2025
Consumer Confidence Hits Pandemic-Level Low Amid Tariff ConcernsWhat’s really worrying U.S. consumers isn’t the present situation; it’s what the economy is going to look like six months from now.
Events & AwardsApr 30, 2025
Instore Show Debuts New Name, Look, and FocusNow called The Instore Jewelry Show, it will include holiday-focused education, interactive workshops, and a window display contest.
