What to Know About Consumers in 2023

SurveysFeb 06, 2023

What to Know About Consumers in 2023

From dwindling savings to the growing resale market, here’s what National Retail Federation experts want retailers to know about shoppers.

20230206_NRF Big Show 2023.jpg
At the National Retail Federation’s “Retail’s Big Show” conference, a panel of experts dove into what retailers should know about consumers this year. (Image courtesy of the National Retail Federation/Jason Dixon Photography)
New York—Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, retailers and consumers have had to adjust and re-adjust as they faced a barrage of headwinds, from inflation and rising interest rates to supply chain issues and geopolitical strife.

And yet, it’s been a good few years for retailers, especially jewelry retailers, as shoppers continue to spend.

Whether or not the good times will keep rolling was a hot topic at the National Retail Federation’s Retail’s Big Show conference, held last month in New York City.

A panel of experts from NRF and consumer purchase data platform Affinity Solutions held a press-only discussion to share their insights on the year ahead.

Here are the six biggest takeaways.

Consumer spending is shifting away from goods to services, but goods spending is still increasing.

At the start of the pandemic, when COVID-19 restrictions prevented shoppers from spending on services, more money was spent on goods.

The increased spending on goods was also a result of government stimulus programs, said Mark Mathews, vice president of research development and industry analysis at NRF.

“What we saw during the pandemic was a demand phenomenon. I know that there are other narratives out there that talk about supply chain challenges, but really, the government pumped $10 trillion into our economy via fiscal and monetary policy, and so consumers have been spending.”

Mathews defended the often-maligned supply chain, stating that it actually performed “heroically” considering how difficult it is for retailers to ramp up to meet fast-growing demand.

At the start of the pandemic, consumers spent around 31 percent of their expenditures on goods, he said, but that increased to 36 percent.

“That doesn’t sound like a big number, but that’s $600 billion a year,” said Mathews.

As restrictions have lifted, spending has shifted toward services, bringing the percentage of expenditures on goods closer to 34 percent, but that doesn’t necessarily mean consumers are spending less on goods.

“We’ve seen a shrink in the share of goods [as a percentage of expenditures], but the pie has grown,” explained Mathews.

“So actually, instead of taking away from spending on goods to spend on services, the consumer has decided to spend on [both]. While the share has shrunk, the actual amount spent on goods has been increasing the entire time.”

To continue to spend in both categories, many consumers have been relying on their savings and accruing debt.

Shoppers have been dipping into excess savings, but they may soon dry up.

The government stimulus program allowed many people to save money because their disposable income exceeded their expenditures.

The savings rate spiked to 34 percent during the pandemic, an “unheard of” rate, said Mathews, leaving consumers with $2 trillion in excess savings.

The wealth of disposable income allowed shoppers to spend, shelling out more than $1 trillion in savings in the last 18 months, but inflation is driving up prices and quickly eating into those excess funds.

“There’s still $1 trillion left of excess savings, but we’re burning through that at a pretty high rate,” said Mathews. “We’re going to get to a point in 2023 where, if inflation remains high, you are going to potentially see consumers running into a wall because they won’t be able to maintain that level of spending.”

Mathews estimated if spending continues at this rate, it will take a year to 18 months for these savings to dry up.

To stimulate the economy, Mathews advocated for pushing money toward lower-income households, like the stimulus program did, because that money tends to be spent rather than saved and goes right back into the economy.

Panelist Jonathan Silver, CEO of Affinity Solutions, echoed a similar sentiment. His company’s data was used by the U.S. government to determine the cut-off for round three of the stimulus checks.

Those under the $78,000 income level, defined by Silver as lower-income households, “spent it very quickly and that stimulated the economy that clearly needed it. It really does make a difference, putting money in the hands of low-income folks.”

As prices rise and savings dwindle, that raises concern about increasing debt levels.

“For those lower-income households, if wages aren’t keeping pace with inflation, where do they fund that from? Potentially debt, but that’s concerning because interest rates are rising,” said Mathews.

Consumer debt has increased by $200 billion over the last two years, he added.

Shoppers are looking for a bargain, giving resale an opening.

As savings wane and prices spike, consumers are on the lookout for deals and discounts.

Moderator Katherine Cullen, NRF’s senior director of industry and consumer insights, talked about how this is playing out in the retail space.

“We are seeing a return to a value-focused shopper across income groups, but that will play out differently for different income segments,” she said.

Though higher-income households tend to be the most worried about inflation, she said they tend to change their behavior the least because of their access to savings, which may not be an option for lower-income houses.

Shoppers may gravitate to off-price or discounted products, while others will turn to the resale market, particularly Gen Z shoppers.

While there are third-party resale sites, like Depop and TheRealReal, Cullen noted she’s seeing a lot of retailers introduce their own resale and recycling platforms, like H&M and Zara.

“To me, that signals that this is an underlying trend that will be around for a while, but rather than fighting it, retailers are participating in it and starting to build it into their business, so I think that’s something to watch going forward.”

 Related stories will be right here … 

Don’t presume all pre-pandemic behaviors will make a comeback.

“Just assuming that behavior will return to normal for the sake of it, I think is a dangerous thing,” said Mathews.

“There are some behaviors that we developed during the pandemic, like streaming as opposed to going to movie theaters, [that] could stick around a little bit longer than we expect and that’s going to be something that we’re watching very closely as we move forward.”

For example, Mathews noted when restaurants shut down, more people began to cook for themselves. They honed their cooking skills, made healthier food, and saved money in the process, so they may not be running back to restaurants at the pre-pandemic rate.

The pandemic also spurred on technological advancements, particularly in retail, turning features like online shopping, Buy Online Pick-up In Store, and curbside pick-up into mainstays.

NRF’s Cullen noted, “Even as we’re seeing renewed engagement around stores, the pressure on stores to be convenient, to be engaging, is certainly much higher because people have gotten used to online shopping.”

“These shifts will impact what the store looks like and how retailers adapt to this environment moving forward.”

As consumer behavior changes, economic indicators aren’t what they used to be.

Despite everything the last few years have thrown at consumers, they just keep spending.

If prices are rising and savings are falling, consumers should be spending less money and feeling less confident about the economy, but that hasn’t always been the case.

The disconnect left the panelists wondering if the tried-and-true economic indicators, like consumer confidence and the Consumer Price Index, are the best ways to predict consumer behavior.

“Everyone in the room tends to look at consumer confidence and consumer sentiment, but it’s not the leading indicator that it used to be,” said Silver.

“It used to be that there was a high correlation [between consumer confidence and spending],” he said. “People are getting signals that make them feel bad but they still want to take out their wallet and spend.”

That’s not the only disconnect between data and consumer behavior.

“You would expect that an increase in purchases of essentials should result in a decrease of purchases in discretionary and that’s not what we’re seeing. We’re seeing both grow pretty significantly,” said Silver.

Mathews talked about The Consumer Price Index, which has been used as a measure of inflation.

CPI measures the average change in prices over time consumers will pay for a basket of goods and services.

Since inflation hits individuals differently, it may not be the best measurement, said Mathews.

“Many times, we have people look at retail sales and say, well it grew 7 percent but CPI [inflation] is at 8 percent, so you’re not really growing. You can’t look at it that way,” he said.

What many people don’t realize, he said, is that one-third of CPI’s measurement accounts for shelter, which has been driving prices much higher.

“For the last three months, goods have been in deflation,” he said.

The outlook for the year is still promising.

Mathews and Silver had a fairly positive outlook on the year ahead, with a few conditions.

As for where consumer spending will land, that will come down to inflation compared to wage increase, said Silver.

Mathews said, “The saving grace here is if we see inflation easing and we see wages continue to be strong, then that gives you a little bit of a buffer to continue to spend. If we continue to see negative real wages, then that’s going to be a problem. We’re talking about sometime in the next year to 18 months or so, it all becomes unstable.”

Silver took a more conservative position, stating, “We’re bullish going into the first half of ‘23 and then we’ll see beyond that. But we also think that what [retailers] do is going to have a big impact on how the consumer behaves.”

Mathews noted how encouraged he was by the resilience of both the retail industry and consumers during the pandemic. 

“It leaves me feeling bullish because I know as we look ahead there are going to be some economic challenges. But we’ve been through those, so that gives me hope that as we move forward, we can overcome [them],” he said.

The Latest

Alexandra Rosier gold and opal Eternal Love Hands necklace
TrendsJun 02, 2023
Take a Peek at Couture’s Newest Design Talents

This year’s Design Atelier is full of gems.

Saboo Fine Jewels emerald and titanium earrings
CollectionsJun 02, 2023
Piece of the Week: Saboo Fine Jewels’ Emerald Earrings

They’re a testament to the power of excellent design.

Holly Wesche, Stan Razny, Ingrid Razny, Candy Udell
IndependentsJun 02, 2023
These Are the 2023 Retailer Hall of Fame Inductees

This year’s honorees include one of Florida’s largest independent jewelers and two multi-store independents in the Chicago and New York areas.

Brought to you by
The Next Step for GIA Diamond Reports

The most trusted diamond report, available in print or the GIA App.

Jane Taylor letter pendants
TrendsJun 01, 2023
See 50+ Jewels Debuting at Couture in Las Vegas

The industry’s most influential contemporary designers are showcasing their latest jewelry designs.

Weekly QuizJun 02, 2023
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge with this short test.
Take the Quiz
35-carat lab-grown diamond created by Maitri
Lab-GrownJun 01, 2023
35-Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Going on Display in Vegas

Created by Maitri Lab-Grown Diamonds and graded by IGI, it’s slightly bigger than the record-setting lab-grown diamond GIA just examined.

Bottom Line Marketing Chief Growth Officer Gus Garcia and CEO Jackie Brooks
MajorsJun 01, 2023
Bottom Line Marketing Announces Restructured Leadership, New Service Offerings

The marketing agency has integrated its first C-suite.

Brought to you by
Beyond Borders: Crucial Factors in Colored Stone Origin Determination

Navigate origin determination with Continuing Education seminars offered by the GIA Alumni Collective™.

Events & AwardsJun 01, 2023
Meet JCK’s 2023 Keynote Speaker

The jewelry trade show also will debut educational content centered around social media.

Lauren K gold and gemstone rings
TrendsMay 31, 2023
Here’s a Sneak Peek of New Jewelry to Check Out at JCK

Luxury kicks off today, with the full show in swing on Friday.

A pearl pendant and a pearl ring
CollectionsMay 31, 2023
Verragio’s Debut Fine Jewelry Collections Honor Company Heritage

One of the three new collections was inspired by the legend of a woman who traded her mansion to Cartier for two strands of natural pearls.

Rob Ballew
MajorsMay 31, 2023
Signet Jewelers Names New Head of Investor Relations

Rob Ballew will be tasked with communicating the jewelry giant’s plans and financial performance to investors.

Mobile mock-up screens of the new LUX Digital Vault app from Jewelers Mutual Group
MajorsMay 31, 2023
Jewelers Mutual Launches App for Retailers, Introduces New Brokerage

With the app, customers receive a 15-day insurance offer on new purchases while their coverage needs are being evaluated.

Rendering of Lightbox lab-grown diamond store in House of Showfields
Lab-GrownMay 30, 2023
Lightbox Is Testing Out a Trendy Concept Shop in Brooklyn

It is in House of Showfields, a bazaar-style retail space in the borough’s Williamsburg neighborhood.

Attendees at the JCK Las Vegas show
Events & AwardsMay 30, 2023
These Are the Can’t-Miss JCK Talks Education Sessions

From consumer trends to retail technology, these are the JCK Talks sessions that should be on attendees’ radar.

Constance “Connie” Barber Mellon’s David Webb Elephant Clip-Brooch
AuctionsMay 30, 2023
Sotheby’s to Auction Mellon Family Jewelry

Signature pieces from Cartier and David Webb will appear in the June jewelry auction.

Georgie Gleim, Shelly Sergent, and Molly Peterson
Events & AwardsMay 30, 2023
24 Karat Club of Southern California Recognizes 3 Honorees

They will be celebrated at the annual dinner dance and gala in the fall.

Historic and modern photos of diamond grading GIA
GradingMay 26, 2023
State of the Diamond Industry: AI and the Future of Diamond Grading

Gemologists have long used machines in diamond grading but technology has made it possible for them to “learn” how to do it on their own.

Supplier Spotlight Webinar John Pollard and Garry Holloway
Recorded WebinarsMay 26, 2023
Watch: Diamond Cut Quality: The Final Frontier Part 2

Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by IGI

My Next Question webinar series episode on selling lab-grown diamonds
Recorded WebinarsMay 26, 2023
Natural and Lab-Grown Diamonds: What It’s Like to Sell Both

Watch retailers Jeffery Bolling and Bobby Bengivengo discuss employee training, customer education and the sticky subject of future value.

Models wearing Calvin Klein watches and jewelry
FinancialsMay 26, 2023
Movado Sales Slip in Q1 Amid Inflation Woes, Tough Comps

The company has plans to revamp the Movado brand and offer less expensive watches this year.

Bulgari necklace set with 118.35-carat unheated Sri Lankan sapphire
AuctionsMay 26, 2023
Piece of the Week: A Bulgari Sapphire and Diamond Necklace

Set with a 118-carat unheated Sri Lankan sapphire, it just sold for $3.4 million at Phillips jewelry auction in Hong Kong.

Supplier BulletinMay 25, 2023
RAE Fine Jewelry Collection Debuting at JCK Luxury 2023

Sponsored by Noam Carver

Graphic of phishing scheme
TechnologyMay 25, 2023
State of Retail: Why Jewelers Need to Invest in Cybersecurity Now

As cybercrime incidents threaten the industry, jewelers need to know what they’re up against and the best ways to protect their businesses.

Louis Anthony Jewelers remodeled exterior
IndependentsMay 25, 2023
Louis Anthony Jewelers Is Remodeling and Expanding

The Pittsburgh jeweler is redoing the lighting and showcases, and adding a full hospitality bar as well as new shop-in-shops.

Yurman Family Crystalline Pass at American Museum of Natural History in New York City
SourcingMay 25, 2023
David Yurman Unveils Quartz Exhibition at AMNH

The Yurman Family Crystalline Pass is inside the museum’s brand-new Richard Gilder Center.

Stanley Zale new principal consultant Hill & Co.
MajorsMay 25, 2023
Stanley Zale Joins Hill & Co. as Principal Consultant

Zale has more than 40 years’ experience in the diamond industry, including 17 years as Stuller’s VP of diamonds and gemstones procurement.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy