Editors

Notes on a Plenary

EditorsDec 20, 2017

Notes on a Plenary

Our editor-in-chief recaps the recent Kimberley Process meeting and looks at where the process goes from here.

2017_KP-logo.jpg

The biggest decision that came out of the Kimberley Process’s biggest meeting of the year was this: All participants voted to form an Ad Hoc Committee on Review and Reform, which will begin looking at ways to evolve the process next year.

The committee is chaired by India, with Angola as vice chair, and, according to a copy of the administrative decision on its creation, will present its conclusions and any draft decisions at next year’s plenary.

The biggest news was this: Impact, the NGO formerly known as PAC, decided to leave the process, citing a lack of progress on pressing issues--specifically, meaningful reform in a process it says is becoming “irrelevant”--and an increasingly hostile environment for members of the KP’s Civil Society Coalition.

It is the second NGO to exit the process, following the 2011 departure of Global Witness.

Impact’s decision to leave the process did not entirely shock me (and it didn’t shock many who are directly involved with the KP either, I’m told); it has been at least 12 months in the making.

Last year, Impact, along with the other 10 members of the Civil Society Coalition, boycotted the process over their objections to the chairmanship of the United Arab Emirates.

This year, Impact returned but made it clear what they wanted: reform in a reform year. (The KP is set up so that it, in theory, it overhauls itself every five years; the last reform cycle was from 2011 to 2013.)

Impact Executive Director Joanne Lebert told me in a post-plenary interview that they wanted to see the KP change the definition of what constitutes a “conflict” diamond to include diamonds tied to abuses by governments and/or security firms, not just those used by rebel groups to overthrow governments.

There also needs to be a strengthening of the KP’s internal controls, and more timely completion and release of reports from review missions, which are currently delayed by as much as two to three years, she said.

What they got was the formation of “another working group,” she said, meaning the aforementioned Ad Hoc Committee on Review and Reform.

During closing remarks Dec. 14 at the plenary in Brisbane, Lebert told KP members that her organization, in simplest terms, was done with the Kimberley Process, though it will remain engaged on the issues facing diamond-producing countries.

“They’re just making themselves irrelevant,” she said in the interview. “(The KP) keeps saying, ‘we’ve eliminated

conflict diamonds’ when, in fact, their definition is obsolete.”

Lebert and Impact are not alone in their view that the KP needs to change.

Following Martin Rapaport’s controversial proclamation earlier this year that the process had become “bullshit,” JCK published two editorials, one from Brad Brooks-Rubin and one from Ian Smillie, in which the authors called for reform.

And the fact that all KP member nations agreed to at least put together a reform committee tells us that even the process itself has come around to the fact that it’s due for a major overhaul.

But the question is: Will the KP be able to get everybody on the same page when it comes to reform and, if so, how many years will it take?

For those who are not aware, the KP operates under a consensus decision-making model. This dictates that all member countries have to agree to pass anything, which, on the flip side, means it takes only one country’s disapproval to block a proposal.

In his editorial in JCK, Smillie, a former research coordinator who worked on conflict diamond issues with PAC (now Impact) and is now president of the Canadian Association for the Study of International Development, talked about the difficulty of getting reform done under the consensus model, which he described as “unworkable.” He wrote that there will not be any “serious evolution” for the KP until that changes.

Lebert described the model to me as “instrumental in blocking any kind of meaningful reform,” while one individual who is a major player in the diamond industry called it “a recipe for not getting anything done.”

But a couple of other individuals with whom I spoke on this issue pointed out that the KP is not the only international mechanism that works this way.

Robert Owen-Jones, who represented chair nation Australia in the process this year, told me in an email that consensus is the “accepted model” in intergovernmental arrangements, and said he couldn’t imagine another system for the KP given that implementation rests on national legislation.

“Consensus does not mean you have to agree with the result in the final plenary, just not object,” he wrote. “Negotiators often say that the best result is where everyone is equally unhappy.”

James Evans Lombe, who attended the KP as the CEO of the U.S. Jewelry Council and a member of the World Diamond Council (WDC) delegation, also pointed out that the KP is not alone in its consensus approach.

He pointed to the World Trade Organization (WTO), the intergovernmental organization that regulates trade, as another example of a body that functions this way.

“It is a failing, but it is also a strength,” he said of the consensus model. “When something is agreed, no one can backtrack … it just means the KP can only go as fast as the slowest runner.

“Our issue, as an industry, is that consumers are moving far faster than governments. Luckily, most governments are now beginning to realize that.”

After touching base with Owen-Jones and Lombe, I circled back around to Smillie to get his thoughts on their viewpoints.

In addition to his role with the Canadian Association, Smillie is chair of the Diamond Development Initiative and attended the plenary to talk about the issues facing the artisanal mining sector.

He said while he understands the need for consensus on larger issues that involve money or governmental changes, he doesn’t understand why the process needs 100 percent agreement to make changes to improve its basic functions.

The monitoring system, for example, is weak and needs to be made more effective. He also expressed the same frustration that Lebert did over the long delays in submission of reports. Those need to be done in three months rather than two years, he said.

“What they (the KP participants) all should understand and appreciate is all the countries that are members benefit in one way or another from the diamond industry,” Smillie said. “It really is an industry worth protecting, but the Kimberley Process is not doing that. It’s failing.”

A few other notes from the plenary:
* The permanent secretariat, which the UAE tried to take credit for last year, still hasn’t been officially voted through. Yes, there is now consensus that the process needs one, but thorny issues remain, including who will pay for it and where it will be based. I am told that the UAE has said it will fund the permanent secretariat but under the condition that it be headquartered there, while the African nations would like to see it in Africa and the WDC is pushing for a neutral location. In a similar vein, the WDC is totally supportive of a DDI proposal that the KP has a conflict of interest rule.

The reform committee has the resolution of these issues surrounding the permanent secretariat on its to-do list for 2018.

* As agreed upon in Dubai last year, the European Union will take over as chair of the KP in 2018 with India serving as vice chair. (The countries served together as co-vice chairs this year.)

* The KP intersessional is set to take place in Antwerp while the scheduled location for the plenary is Brussels.
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

The 170-carat Lulo Rose pink diamond
SourcingNov 20, 2026
Company That Mined Angola’s Largest Diamond Has a New Owner

Dubai-based AV Group has acquired Lucapa Diamond Company, which holds a stake in Angola’s Lulo mine and has a diamond project in Australia.

Anabela Chan Canary Atlantis Earrings
TrendsNov 20, 2026
Anabela Chan’s ‘Canary Atlantis’ Earrings Enter The Hunger Games Arena

Actress Mckenna Grace wore our Piece of the Week to the London premiere of “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.”

 Woman wearing jewelry looking in the mirror
Events & AwardsNov 20, 2026
Registration Open for JIS Spring 2027

Registration for the trade show, taking place March 7-9, is now open.

05_11_26_Overnight Mountings Web Asset_71.jpg
Brought to you by
12 Ways Independent Jewelers Can Drive More Sales and Stronger Profits in 2027

These twelve tips can help retailers improve margins, convert shoppers, and make every dollar work harder.

1.png
Supplier BulletinNov 19, 2026
Every Color, Every Cut: AGTA GemFair Tucson Returns Jan. 31 to Feb. 4, 2027

Sponsored by American Gem Trade Association (AGTA)

Weekly QuizNov 19, 2026
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
The 176.29-carat Owishi diamond
SourcingNov 19, 2026
176-Carat Diamond, Second Largest Found in Namibia, Comes to US

The “Owishi” made its U.S. debut in Washington, D.C. on Monday and now will return to Namibia for planning, cutting, and polishing.

Fake Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl Championship rings
CrimeNov 19, 2026
Customs Seizes Fake Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl Rings

CBP agents in Houston have seen “significant seizures” of counterfeit watches, baby toys, and FIFA World Cup merchandise, the agency said.

LIM-1452_1872-x-1052_Jewelry-Services--Image-Resize-.jpg
Brought to you by
More Information. More Confidence. One GIA Jewelry Report.

The GIA Jewelry Report helps retailers answer customer questions with independent, science-based information from GIA—all in one report.

Moussaieff Spinel
AuctionsNov 19, 2026
52-Carat Red Spinel Sells for $2M to Moussaieff

The London high jewelry house, which bought the gemstone at Sotheby’s Geneva jewelry auction, has renamed it the “Moussaieff Spinel.”

Bench Jeweler Tools
Events & AwardsNov 19, 2026
Rio Grande Sponsors New High School Award at NYC Jewelry Week

The Here We Are High School award will gift a Future Jewelers Academy student with $750 and a Rio Grande tool kit with bench essentials.

Graphic for episode 11 of My Next Question podcast
PodcastsNov 18, 2026
Episode 11: Are Malls Making a Comeback?

Peter Smith and R.J. Hottovy of Placer.ai guest on this special pre-holiday episode of the podcast to discuss the status of shopping malls.

Michaels Jewelers Trumbull Mall
IndependentsNov 18, 2026
Michaels Jewelers to Close Mall Location After 15 Years

The jeweler is closing its store in the Trumbull Mall in Connecticut, citing a decline in foot traffic.

Paul Altieri Not For Sale book
WatchesNov 18, 2026
Paul Altieri Pens Book on Personal Rolex Watch Collection

In “Not For Sale,” the CEO and founder of Bob’s Watches showcases his collection of 134 rare vintage Rolexes and the stories behind them.

Stephen Webster Shaken & Stirred Bracelet Clasp
CollectionsNov 18, 2026
Stephen Webster Debuts a Bracelet Made for 007

The "Shaken & Stirred" clasp is one of seven designs in a new collection celebrating notorious male figures from the 20th century.

Winnie Park
MajorsNov 18, 2026
Signet Jewelers Appoints Five Below CEO to Its Board

Winnie Park was also previously the CEO of Forever 21 and Paper Source.

Blanca Miró and Emily Satloff wearing the Blanca Miró x Larkspur & Hawk Collection
CollectionsNov 17, 2026
Larkspur & Hawk Partners With Blanca Miró on New Collection

The collaborative collection features rivière necklaces, layered bracelets, drop earrings, and stackable rings in four vivid colors.

Stock image of handcuffs and a gavel
CrimeNov 17, 2026
1 Man Arrested, Another Sought in Murder of Ohio Jeweler

Tara Sinchuri was shot to death inside his store, Everest Jewels in Fairfield, Ohio, during a robbery last month.

Steve Quick Jeweler team
IndependentsNov 17, 2026
A Few Snaps From Steve Quick Jeweler’s 40th Anniversary Celebration

The Chicago jeweler celebrated its ruby anniversary in style.

The Retail Smiths Peter Smith
ColumnistsNov 17, 2026
Peter Smith: Hunting for Salespeople

Smith recounts notable interactions from his three-day shopping mission to recruit salespeople for a client.

Alexander Calder earrings
AuctionsNov 17, 2026
Jewelry Alexander Calder Made for Family Members Up for Auction

The five pieces on offer at Bonhams, together estimated to fetch $300,000, were made as gifts for the artist’s mother, sister, and niece.

Renovated Betteridge Jewelers store in Greenwich, Connecticut
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Step Inside Betteridge Jewelers’ Renovated Greenwich Store

Located on the main street in Greenwich, the renovation marks Watches of Switzerland’s most significant U.S. retail investment to date.

Pauline Karpidas: The Jewelry Collection
AuctionsNov 16, 2026
A Tour of Pauline Karpidas’ Jewelry Heading to Auction

Her eclectic collection, with jewels spanning several periods of the 20th century, could fetch up to $10 million at Sotheby's next month.

Kerry Feldmann
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Kendra Scott Taps Former John Hardy, Tiffany & Co. Exec as CMO

Jewelry industry executive Kerry Feldmann has taken on the role.

American Gem Society Conclave 2027 speakers
Events & AwardsNov 16, 2026
AGS Announces 2027 Conclave Keynote Speakers

This year’s lineup includes a chief executive optimist, “The Iron Cowboy,” a Peloton executive, and The Second City comedians.

Romanov Sapphire
AuctionsNov 13, 2026
Historic ‘Romanov Sapphire’ Achieves $4.9M at Sotheby’s

The 197-carat Russian Crown jewel was the leading lot of Sotheby's white-glove Royal & Noble Jewels sale this week.

Maison Marcelle Équation Bracelet
CollectionsNov 13, 2026
Maison Marcelle’s Bracelet Flows Like Fabric

The “Équation” bracelet, our Piece of the Week, was built via 24 gold modules assembled into a piece that feels like fabric on the wrist.

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont Texas
IndependentsNov 13, 2026
Texas Jeweler to Close After 111 Years

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont, Texas, is closing as Brian and Lori Alter retire to spend more time with family.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy