SourcingNov 01, 2024
Reena Ahluwalia Donates Diamond Painting to Benefit CJAThe artwork, titled “Pristine,” was raffled off at the Canadian Jewellers Association’s recent summit.
EditorsFeb 28, 2020
Where Victoria’s Secret Went Wrong
The once-mighty retailer’s recent struggles are a testament to the importance of listening to your customers, Associate Editor Lenore Fedow writes.
Victoria’s Secret has been called out for a lack of diversity in its advertising and offerings, and it may be too little, too late for the retailer to make a meaningful change. (Image courtesy of Victoria’s Secret)
The last time I entered a Victoria’s Secret store was a few years ago. My direct deposit had just hit my bank account, and I was ready to shop.
I bypassed a row of sequined bustiers and piles of frilly things to head into the more casual section of the store, where I found myself flipping through hanger after hanger, searching in vain for my size.
I knew I was at the very limit of the retailer’s size range and that not all styles were available in my size, but surely, I thought, there was something for me somewhere in the store.
Finally, I asked an employee where I could find something in my size. She pursed her lips and gave me a judgmental once-over.
“Online,” she spat.
I suppose my face gave away my disappointment, and she offered to check in the back for me.
You could’ve blown dust off the beige grandma-looking bra she brought back, and it had a $50 price tag hanging off it. I thanked her for trying and left empty-handed.
All of this is why when I heard last week that parent company L Brands was selling Victoria’s Secret amid declining sales, I was not surprised and, truthfully, a little giddy.
Putting my pettiness provoked by past experiences aside, here’s where Victoria’s Secret went wrong, and why all retailers should consider the comedown of this once-mighty retailer a cautionary tale.
It offered limited options.
After I parted ways with Victoria’s Secret, I began scoping out a new place to buy bras, and I found myself in Lane Bryant, a retailer that focuses on plus-sized clothing and, interestingly enough, once was owned by L Brands.
At a size 14, I’m at the low end of the store’s clothing offerings, but its in-store Cacique intimates brand was a treasure trove.
There was no boring beige here. Every color, print, size and style I could imagine was there for the taking, hung up neatly on a rack, not buried beneath a tower of extra-smalls or hidden away in the back, collecting dust.
The bras were beautiful and comfortable, and after seeing what the experience could be, I happily handed over my money, walked out with a full bag and never looked back.
The moral of the above bra-shopping anecdote is one retailers should already know: If you’re not providing me with what I want, I will go elsewhere.
Whether we’re talking about lingerie or jewelry, consumers are demanding more options.
In
fine jewelry, customization is a growing trend with an increasing number of customers looking to add personal touches, particularly in the engagement ring space.
A survey The Knot released late last year found that nearly half of new rings purchased for an engagement included some custom details.
With a slew of retailer options available to shoppers, the “take-it-or-leave-it” attitude toward customers just isn’t going to cut it anymore.
It refused to evolve, even in the face of increasing competition.
It seems I was not the only Victoria’s Secret shopper who went elsewhere.
The lingerie brand had a rough holiday season, with in-store sales down 8 percent year-over-year and same-store sales for both the in-store and online channels slipping 1 percent.
Parallel to the jewelry world, there were a ton of online brands, like Adore Me and ThirdLove, ready and willing to scoop up the customers Victoria’s Secret was leaving out by limiting its sizes and not stocking enough larger sizes in store.
Understandably, not every brand can cater to every shopper, but plus-size customers are not a niche.
The average American woman wears a size 16 to 18, according to data from Coresight Research, and the U.S. plus-size market is expected to grow to $24 billion in by 2020 with an annual growth rate nearly double that of the total clothing market.
In malls, where the vast majority of the retailer’s stores are located, foot traffic has been slowing, prompting retailers to think up creative ways to bring in customers and keep them coming back.
Victoria’s Secret is lacking in innovation at a time when it is needed most, offering customers only the occasional coupon and promotion.
New competitors, meanwhile, are thinking outside of the box.
Adore Me, an online lingerie brand, offers sizing from petite to plus, with the option to join a subscription service and receive a new bra and panty set every month, as well as a rewards program to earn free bras.
Victoria’s Secret has a rewards program, but it is available only to those who sign up for its store-brand credit card.
Even when the brand got it right, it found a way to go wrong.
The Victoria’s Secret swimsuit line, a noted favorite among fans of the brand, was discontinued in 2016, prompting an outcry for its return.
It was brought back in 2019, at a higher price point and in a narrow range of generic sizes—sizes XS to L rather than its previous sizing by bra size—and only available online, shutting out customers who prefer to try a swimsuit on in person, which could be an opportunity to boost foot traffic in its stores.
In terms of fashion trends, while Victoria’s Secret continued to push sex appeal, athleisure continued to grow in popularity, with more shoppers opting for comfort over sexiness.
Comfort and support, in fact, are the top priorities for U.S. women buying a bra for themselves while sexiness comes in eighth place, as per The Bra Evolution, a 2019 report from The NPD Group.
ThirdLove, another online intimates company, put the focus on comfort and offers 78 sizes, including half-cup sizes.
The company also answered the growing call for diversity in both representation and selection, offering its “nude” bras in a variety of earth tones to match a wide array of skin tones.
Victoria’s Secret, however, remained unbending in the face of change and committed a cardinal sin of retail—not listening to your customers.
It has a ‘you-can’t-sit-with-us’ problem.
While other brands were welcoming in more customers, Victoria’s Secret was giving off a less-than-friendly vibe.
Ed Razek, the brand’s former chief marketing officer, came under fire following a 2018 interview with Vogue in which he said that “no one had any interest” in plus-size models and that the brand’s annual fashion show would not include transgender models because “the show is a fantasy.”
For blogger Alysse Dalessandro Santiago of Ready to Stare, which shares her experience of being plus-size and a member of the LGBTQ community, the comments told everyone else what her communities had known for a while.
The unspoken message from the brand’s limited sizing and posters plastered with thin models had made it clear: You’re not welcome here.
Razek’s comments insulting consumers who couldn’t shop there anyway likely wouldn’t have hurt the retailer’s bottom line, Dalessandro Santiago observed, but the impact was greater than that.
It was standard-sized customers, who have many shopping options available to them, that were pushed away, she said. They became uncomfortable when the brand’s long-time exclusionary message—heard loud and clear by others a long time ago—was finally spoken out loud.
Competitor ThirdLove hit back at the retailer via a full-page ad in the Sunday New York Times, signed by co-founder and co-CEO Heidi Zak.
“How in 2018 can the CMO of any public company—let alone one that claims to be for women—make such shocking, derogatory statements?” the letter stated, while criticizing the retailer for pushing an outdated narrative on what “sexy” should be.
At a time when retailers across industries were promoting inclusion and feeling good about who you are and how you look, Victoria’s Secret continued to shut out potential customers.
A December 2018 article in The Atlantic by Amanda Mull titled “Victoria’s Secret Has a Mean-Girl Problem,” summed up the retailer’s vibe perfectly.
“For years, Victoria’s Secret has been the brand equivalent of the stereotypical cool-girls’ table in a high-school cafeteria: hot, unfriendly, and definitely not interested in bolstering your self-worth,” Mull wrote.
It failed to act when aspirational became exclusionary.
Most shoppers still want to sit with the cool girls, but they want to see some new faces at the table.
“There’s this ongoing idea that the beauty we see in advertising should be aspirational,” blogger Dalessandro Santiago said.
“If brands really listened to consumers, they would see that customers want advertising that is relational.”
To her point, my experiences at Victoria’s Secret and Lane Bryant were like night and day, and feeling welcomed made all the difference.
The models on the in-store branding looked beautifully normal and the mannequins curved at more than the waist.
I could see myself in its products, not how I’d look in a fantasy or after I dropped 20 pounds, but right there and now, just as I was.
“Having an ad that is representative of your customer is the most important thing in advertising,” Dalessandro Santiago said.
Victoria’s Secret built its business model on aspirational beauty, she added, and when the tides turned away from that ideal, instead of taking that opportunity to be inclusive, they doubled down.
When it did change it was too little, too late.
Retailers striving for diversity and inclusivity should be mindful of looking like they’re just riding the wave.
“As consumers, it’s easy to tell when a brand is being diverse or inclusive for the purpose of just looking diverse or inclusive,” Dalessandro Santiago said.
People in underrepresented communities are wary of pandering, and it’s easy to suss out, she added.
This was arguably the case when Victoria’s Secret hired its first transgender model, Valentina Sampaio, and its first size 14 model, Ali Tate Cutler, only after public outcry.
When you compare Victoria’s Secret model lineup to, for example, Rihanna’s Savage X Fenty lingerie runway show last year, which featured women of all sizes, races, ethnicities as well as transwomen and disabled women, there is no comparison.
Victoria’s Secret’s annual televised fashion show, known for featuring almost exclusively thin, white models, was cancelled in 2019 due to dwindling audiences and growing public criticism while Rihanna’s show was well-received by critics and social media.
The lesson here, for all retailers: There is a difference between throwing one or two diverse models into a campaign and making a concerted effort to do better, and consumers can tell who means it.
How Independent Retailers Can Get Onboard
Small businesses are better at authenticity, Dalessandro Santiago said, and there’s less overhead in the way of projecting a message of inclusivity and diversity.
In addition to her blog, Dalessandro Santiago has experience as a small business owner, previously selling her own designs on her website.
“I was the CMO, CEO, CFO, I was everything. It’s not that hard to put a casting call out and find hundreds of people.”
For retailers looking to avoid pandering, she said, it’s crucial to make an ongoing effort to be more inclusive.
Show through action how you are investing in the communities, such as by casting LGBTQ models or hiring plus-size workers, she said.
In terms of diversity, it’s usually smaller businesses that set the tone, with larger businesses taking notice and following suit, she added.
Victoria’s Secret squandered that opportunity, remaining loyal to an outdated beauty ideal instead of to its customers.
With strong name recognition and a global presence, it was Victoria’s Secret’s market to lose, and it did indeed cede a huge chunk of business due to its unwillingness to change.
Though the brand still holds the largest slice of the $13 billion U.S. lingerie market, its share fell to 24 percent in 2018 compared with 32 percent in 2013, as per Euromonitor data.
Meanwhile, American Eagle’s Aerie brand, which is known for not retouching its models, doubled its piece of the pie during that same time period.
Victoria’s Secret fell to No. 13 on investment firm Piper Jaffray’s semi-annual Taking Stock with Teens survey in fall 2019 from its No. 5 spot in spring 2018, while American Eagle was in second place.
The lesson to be learned by retailers in any industry—remaining stubborn in the face of change will cost you market share and customers.
A survey The Knot released late last year found that nearly half of new rings purchased for an engagement included some custom details.
With a slew of retailer options available to shoppers, the “take-it-or-leave-it” attitude toward customers just isn’t going to cut it anymore.
It refused to evolve, even in the face of increasing competition.
It seems I was not the only Victoria’s Secret shopper who went elsewhere.
The lingerie brand had a rough holiday season, with in-store sales down 8 percent year-over-year and same-store sales for both the in-store and online channels slipping 1 percent.
Parallel to the jewelry world, there were a ton of online brands, like Adore Me and ThirdLove, ready and willing to scoop up the customers Victoria’s Secret was leaving out by limiting its sizes and not stocking enough larger sizes in store.
Understandably, not every brand can cater to every shopper, but plus-size customers are not a niche.
The average American woman wears a size 16 to 18, according to data from Coresight Research, and the U.S. plus-size market is expected to grow to $24 billion in by 2020 with an annual growth rate nearly double that of the total clothing market.
In malls, where the vast majority of the retailer’s stores are located, foot traffic has been slowing, prompting retailers to think up creative ways to bring in customers and keep them coming back.
Victoria’s Secret is lacking in innovation at a time when it is needed most, offering customers only the occasional coupon and promotion.
New competitors, meanwhile, are thinking outside of the box.
Adore Me, an online lingerie brand, offers sizing from petite to plus, with the option to join a subscription service and receive a new bra and panty set every month, as well as a rewards program to earn free bras.
Victoria’s Secret has a rewards program, but it is available only to those who sign up for its store-brand credit card.
Even when the brand got it right, it found a way to go wrong.
The Victoria’s Secret swimsuit line, a noted favorite among fans of the brand, was discontinued in 2016, prompting an outcry for its return.
It was brought back in 2019, at a higher price point and in a narrow range of generic sizes—sizes XS to L rather than its previous sizing by bra size—and only available online, shutting out customers who prefer to try a swimsuit on in person, which could be an opportunity to boost foot traffic in its stores.
In terms of fashion trends, while Victoria’s Secret continued to push sex appeal, athleisure continued to grow in popularity, with more shoppers opting for comfort over sexiness.
Comfort and support, in fact, are the top priorities for U.S. women buying a bra for themselves while sexiness comes in eighth place, as per The Bra Evolution, a 2019 report from The NPD Group.
ThirdLove, another online intimates company, put the focus on comfort and offers 78 sizes, including half-cup sizes.
The company also answered the growing call for diversity in both representation and selection, offering its “nude” bras in a variety of earth tones to match a wide array of skin tones.
Victoria’s Secret, however, remained unbending in the face of change and committed a cardinal sin of retail—not listening to your customers.
It has a ‘you-can’t-sit-with-us’ problem.
While other brands were welcoming in more customers, Victoria’s Secret was giving off a less-than-friendly vibe.
Ed Razek, the brand’s former chief marketing officer, came under fire following a 2018 interview with Vogue in which he said that “no one had any interest” in plus-size models and that the brand’s annual fashion show would not include transgender models because “the show is a fantasy.”
For blogger Alysse Dalessandro Santiago of Ready to Stare, which shares her experience of being plus-size and a member of the LGBTQ community, the comments told everyone else what her communities had known for a while.
View this post on InstagramA post shared by Alysse Dalessandro Santiago (@readytostare) on Feb 18, 2020 at 3:01pm PST
The unspoken message from the brand’s limited sizing and posters plastered with thin models had made it clear: You’re not welcome here.
Razek’s comments insulting consumers who couldn’t shop there anyway likely wouldn’t have hurt the retailer’s bottom line, Dalessandro Santiago observed, but the impact was greater than that.
It was standard-sized customers, who have many shopping options available to them, that were pushed away, she said. They became uncomfortable when the brand’s long-time exclusionary message—heard loud and clear by others a long time ago—was finally spoken out loud.
Competitor ThirdLove hit back at the retailer via a full-page ad in the Sunday New York Times, signed by co-founder and co-CEO Heidi Zak.
“How in 2018 can the CMO of any public company—let alone one that claims to be for women—make such shocking, derogatory statements?” the letter stated, while criticizing the retailer for pushing an outdated narrative on what “sexy” should be.
At a time when retailers across industries were promoting inclusion and feeling good about who you are and how you look, Victoria’s Secret continued to shut out potential customers.
A December 2018 article in The Atlantic by Amanda Mull titled “Victoria’s Secret Has a Mean-Girl Problem,” summed up the retailer’s vibe perfectly.
“For years, Victoria’s Secret has been the brand equivalent of the stereotypical cool-girls’ table in a high-school cafeteria: hot, unfriendly, and definitely not interested in bolstering your self-worth,” Mull wrote.
It failed to act when aspirational became exclusionary.
Most shoppers still want to sit with the cool girls, but they want to see some new faces at the table.
“There’s this ongoing idea that the beauty we see in advertising should be aspirational,” blogger Dalessandro Santiago said.
“If brands really listened to consumers, they would see that customers want advertising that is relational.”
To her point, my experiences at Victoria’s Secret and Lane Bryant were like night and day, and feeling welcomed made all the difference.
The models on the in-store branding looked beautifully normal and the mannequins curved at more than the waist.
I could see myself in its products, not how I’d look in a fantasy or after I dropped 20 pounds, but right there and now, just as I was.
“Having an ad that is representative of your customer is the most important thing in advertising,” Dalessandro Santiago said.
Victoria’s Secret built its business model on aspirational beauty, she added, and when the tides turned away from that ideal, instead of taking that opportunity to be inclusive, they doubled down.
When it did change it was too little, too late.
Retailers striving for diversity and inclusivity should be mindful of looking like they’re just riding the wave.
“As consumers, it’s easy to tell when a brand is being diverse or inclusive for the purpose of just looking diverse or inclusive,” Dalessandro Santiago said.
People in underrepresented communities are wary of pandering, and it’s easy to suss out, she added.
This was arguably the case when Victoria’s Secret hired its first transgender model, Valentina Sampaio, and its first size 14 model, Ali Tate Cutler, only after public outcry.
When you compare Victoria’s Secret model lineup to, for example, Rihanna’s Savage X Fenty lingerie runway show last year, which featured women of all sizes, races, ethnicities as well as transwomen and disabled women, there is no comparison.
Victoria’s Secret’s annual televised fashion show, known for featuring almost exclusively thin, white models, was cancelled in 2019 due to dwindling audiences and growing public criticism while Rihanna’s show was well-received by critics and social media.
The lesson here, for all retailers: There is a difference between throwing one or two diverse models into a campaign and making a concerted effort to do better, and consumers can tell who means it.
How Independent Retailers Can Get Onboard
Small businesses are better at authenticity, Dalessandro Santiago said, and there’s less overhead in the way of projecting a message of inclusivity and diversity.
In addition to her blog, Dalessandro Santiago has experience as a small business owner, previously selling her own designs on her website.
“I was the CMO, CEO, CFO, I was everything. It’s not that hard to put a casting call out and find hundreds of people.”
For retailers looking to avoid pandering, she said, it’s crucial to make an ongoing effort to be more inclusive.
Show through action how you are investing in the communities, such as by casting LGBTQ models or hiring plus-size workers, she said.
In terms of diversity, it’s usually smaller businesses that set the tone, with larger businesses taking notice and following suit, she added.
Victoria’s Secret squandered that opportunity, remaining loyal to an outdated beauty ideal instead of to its customers.
With strong name recognition and a global presence, it was Victoria’s Secret’s market to lose, and it did indeed cede a huge chunk of business due to its unwillingness to change.
Though the brand still holds the largest slice of the $13 billion U.S. lingerie market, its share fell to 24 percent in 2018 compared with 32 percent in 2013, as per Euromonitor data.
Meanwhile, American Eagle’s Aerie brand, which is known for not retouching its models, doubled its piece of the pie during that same time period.
Victoria’s Secret fell to No. 13 on investment firm Piper Jaffray’s semi-annual Taking Stock with Teens survey in fall 2019 from its No. 5 spot in spring 2018, while American Eagle was in second place.
The lesson to be learned by retailers in any industry—remaining stubborn in the face of change will cost you market share and customers.
More on Editors
The Latest
IndependentsNov 01, 2024
Gunderson’s Jewelers Opens New Location in NebraskaThe new store features a custom design studio and a bridal salon.
CollectionsNov 01, 2024
Piece of the Week: Sydney Evan Gets ‘Wicked’Designer Rosanne Karmes has created a collection to coincide with the release of the movie musical, which is expected to be a blockbuster.
Brought to you by
Navigating Cybersecurity: Essential Guidance for JewelersFrom protecting customer data to safeguarding inventory records, it's crucial to learn how to tackle cybersecurity challenges.
FinancialsOct 31, 2024
Charles & Colvard Faces Possible Nasdaq DelistingThe retailer said it will file the necessary paperwork to regain compliance as soon as it is able.
Weekly QuizOct 31, 2024
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
ColumnistsOct 31, 2024
Peter Smith: Nervous Flyers and Emotional SellingWhether you’re calming the jittery gentleman in seat 13B or selling a diamond ring to a hesitant customer, an empathetic approach is best.
Events & AwardsOct 31, 2024
WJA Will Celebrate 4 Award Winners at ‘Future of Forty’ GalaThe gala includes a red carpet, music from DJ Renata, an awards program, and “mystery boxes.”
Brought to you by
Enhance Your Expertise with IGI’s In-Person Courses in NYCThis fall, sharpen your skills in jewelry grading, quality control and diamond assessment.
Events & AwardsOct 31, 2024
The Instore Show Returns To Chicago AreaThe trade show, in its third year, will take place in late September at the Donald E. Stephens Convention Center in Rosemont, Illinois.
Lab-GrownOct 31, 2024
Q&A: Constance Polamalu on Selling Natural and Lab-Grown DiamondsThe jeweler shared her change of heart on lab-grown diamonds and why she keeps them separate from natural diamonds in her business ventures.
Events & AwardsOct 30, 2024
These Designers, Journalists, and Retailers Are Up for a Gem Award The 2025 Gem Awards are scheduled to take place March 14 at Cipriani 42nd Street in New York City.
MajorsOct 30, 2024
Peggy Grosz Leaves Assael After Company Is SoldGrosz had served as Assael’s senior vice president and creative director since 2017.
CollectionsOct 30, 2024
CD Peacock Honors Its Hometown of Chicago in First Bridal Collection“Love and Celebration” is the jeweler’s first in-house collection featuring engagement rings, wedding bands, and celebration rings.
SurveysOct 30, 2024
Consumer Confidence Rebounds in OctoberA more positive view of the labor market contributed to the strongest monthly gain since March 2021.
Events & AwardsOct 30, 2024
Mejuri to Award $50K in Scholarships to Jewelry Design StudentsThe funds will be distributed to schools in the U.S., Canada, and the U.K.
MajorsOct 29, 2024
Cybersecurity Expert Selected as President of Jewelers’ Security AllianceJennifer Mulvihill, the first woman to lead JSA in the organization’s 141-year history, takes over for the retiring John Kennedy.
Events & AwardsOct 29, 2024
The Can’t-Miss Events of 2024 New York City Jewelry WeekThis year’s festivities include more than 100 experiences, such as designer showcases, panel discussions, and even a treasure hunt.
AuctionsOct 29, 2024
Rolex Worn on Apollo 14 Mission Sells for More Than $2MThe GMT-Master “Pepsi” that belonged to astronaut Edgar Mitchell is one of two Apollo-flown Rolex watches ever sold at auction.
MajorsOct 29, 2024
Pandora’s Holiday Campaign, New Jewelry Celebrate Light and LoveThe ads star brand ambassadors Chloe and Halle Bailey and Pamela Anderson.
SourcingOct 29, 2024
De Beers’ Production Drops 25% as Demand Remains SluggishThe company combined two sights in Q3 due to the slowdown in demand, and said it is moving up the dates for sights 9 and 10 in Q4.
MajorsOct 28, 2024
Jewelers for Children’s Halloween Costume Contest RocksParticipants can buy five votes for $5 to decide which jeweler will dress up as an ‘80s rockstar for Halloween.
TrendsOct 28, 2024
Amanda’s Spooky Style FileThese 15 pieces of jewelry hand-picked ahead of Halloween appeal to the costume- and candy-loving child in all of us.
MajorsOct 25, 2024
This New Bulgari Boutique Is on a YachtStarboard Luxury is bringing the Italian brand aboard The Ritz-Carlton Yacht Collection’s newest yacht.
CollectionsOct 25, 2024
Piece of the Week: A Haunting Piece of Mourning Jewelry The pendant, circa the late 1700s, likely was commissioned to remember a loved one who died young.
MajorsOct 25, 2024
Artistry Releases Its 2025 CatalogIt features the brand’s products in the precious color, semi-precious color, pearl, diamond, gold, and sterling silver categories.
FinancialsOct 24, 2024
Kering’s Jewelry Brands ‘More Resilient’ Than Other Luxury Goods in Q3 Sales fell 15 percent for the luxury conglomerate in the third quarter, led by a 26 percent drop in sales for flagship brand Gucci.
Events & AwardsOct 24, 2024
JA New York Fall Show Announces Education LineupThe education offerings include a diamond cutting demonstration, a session with JVC President Sara Yood, and a seminar on AI.
