Technology

4 Jewelers on Navigating the World of Online Reviews

TechnologyDec 14, 2018

4 Jewelers on Navigating the World of Online Reviews

The retailers dish on Yelp vs. Google, approaching customers and what to do when a customer gives you a bad review.

2018_people_with_smartphones.jpg
How many consumers check reviews online before buying today? Almost everyone, according to review platform Podium. The company conducted a survey last year in which 93 percent of shoppers said online reviews impact their purchase decisions.

As anyone who shops online knows, customer reviews have become crucial to decision-making. They’ve also become a key factor in choosing where we go to shop.

“In the ‘90s and ‘00s, people would go to their preferred store and purchase,” said Ali Sima, owner of ABC Jewelry in Portland, Oregon, which comes up high in searches thanks to positive reviews. “The majority of customers who come to us now do a lot of research before they move forward with a purchase, whether they do it online or come to our store.”

According to a 2017 survey conducted by Podium, a review platform used by local businesses to send out requests for customer reviews at point of sale (POS), 93 percent of U.S. consumers said online reviews impact purchase decisions and 77 percent would be willing to leave an online review if asked.

The three most visible and trusted review platforms, according to the survey, are Google, Yelp and Facebook.

When John Carter took over Jack Lewis Jewelers in Bloomington, Illinois in 2011, he set his sights on the bridal market. That meant appealing to a younger customer who doesn’t make a move without reading online reviews and often posts them as well.
 
Carter began aggressively soliciting customer reviews. Three years ago, he signed on with Podium so customers get a pop-up at POS that reads: “Would you mind leaving us a review today?”

“It’s this millennium’s version of the golden rule: Do unto others as if they were to review you.” —John Carter, Jack Lewis Jewelers
These efforts have paid off.

Jack Lewis comes to the top of any search for jewelers in his area, due largely to 210 customer Google reviews averaging 5 stars and 167 reviews on Facebook averaging 4.8.

Podium helps with Google and Facebook, but Yelp doesn’t allow businesses to solicit reviews.

Jack Lewis has only seven Yelp reviews (but, still, a five-star average) so far, yet Yelp lists him at or near the top on the strength of the brand’s online reputation.

If customers ask these days about leaving his store a review, the jeweler usually suggests Yelp.

“Digital reviews on any platform are extremely important in influencing consumer behavior,” Carter said. ”In our business, it’s driving traffic to our door.”

Like many jewelers who have achieved critical mass with customer reviews, Carter has automatic requests set up at POS—he uses Podium for that—and requires
staff to ask for reviews after every transaction.

He tells staff to treat each customer who walks in the door as if that customer is going to review not only the store, but them specifically.

“It’s this millennium’s version of the golden rule: Do unto others as if they were to review you,” Carter said.

Hopefully, they will.

Google Gaining Momentum
In a recent survey, Podium found 81 percent of U.S. consumers used Google to research a local business in 2017, while 59 percent used Yelp and 49 percent utilized Facebook.

Of the top three platforms, Google and Facebook allow businesses to solicit reviews and anyone can leave them.

Yelp, on the other hand, uses an algorithm that baffles many jewelers, prioritizing reviews by certain customers who use their review system frequently while hiding others. (Some small business owners have accused Yelp of manipulating what reviews are seen based on whether a business pays to advertise on the site, an allegation the company denies. A documentary on Yelp’s alleged manipulation that National Jeweler wrote about in 2015, “Billion Dollar Bully,” has been completed and is seeking a path to distribution, according to the film’s website.)

Yelp’s crowd-sourced reviews began to impact local businesses soon after its launch in 2004. By the end of 2017, Yelp had more than 77 million unique visitors via desktop and 64 million via mobile with 148 million reviews posted, according to filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Because Padis Jewelers is in tech-savvy Silicon Valley and close to Yelp’s San Francisco headquarters, the retailer felt the review site’s influence immediately.

When Alexis Padis joined her family business in the early 2000s, she said that Yelp had “become this animal we had to pay attention to and manage and advertise in.”

Padis Jewelers harnessed Yelp’s powerful reach to build a strong following for their four Bay-area stores and plan to do the same for a fifth location, a Forevermark store, opening in Walnut Creek in the spring.

Even with Google coming on strong, Yelp is still the No. 1 review platform in the Bay Area, Padis said, and leaving reviews there is second nature to their customers.

“I can’t tell you how many clients walk in and say, ‘We found you on Yelp,’” she said. “From a marketing perspective, it’s something we can’t ignore.

“I see Yelp as a marketing expense but also a way to maintain a dialog with our clients. They need to be recognized and appreciated.”

Even Padis admits, however, that she doesn’t understand Yelp’s algorithm, something she believes the company keeps under wraps so businesses don’t game the system.

Every jeweler interviewed for this story said the same.
“Google is gaining momentum as the most trusted review platform overall.” —Nick Miller, Podium
So, how do retailers encourage reviews on Yelp when they can’t actively solicit them?

Emily Washcovick, manager of local business outreach at Yelp, suggested retailers make their Yelp business pages easier to find. One thing jewelers can do without paying Yelp a cent is to flesh out their profiles using keywords strategically, including in photograph captions.

Business pages with 10 or more photos see 200 percent more user views every day, she said. She advises jewelers to post professional photos and caption them using keywords.

“Those captions help images appear in keyword searches, but also when consumers do a search on Yelp, they’re going to see an image next to the business listing. If you don’t look legitimate, people are less likely to select you.”

Retail is the No. 1 most-reviewed category on Yelp, Washcovick said, and Yelp users are more inclined to write reviews on local businesses they spent money with.

And, as for Yelp’s formula for showing certain reviews and not others?

“Yelp tries to recommend the most reliable and trustworthy content,” she said. “We look into what we know about the reviewer, how active they are on the site and what IP address the review is coming from. We try to avoid business owners or consumers who are trying to bring down the competition.”

In 2014, Google launched Google My Business, where local businesses can put up a Yelp-like profile page with hours, contact info, a map, and Yelp-like gold-star review system.

These reviews now appear by default when consumers Google a business.

In May, Google added a dashboard to manage multiple locations and in August, improved its location filters and added product-related content (name, price, etc.) and URLs for reviewers’ profile photos.

“Google is gaining momentum as the most trusted review platform overall,” Podium’s Nick Miller said.

Podium partnered with Yelp for a while, but Podium’s review requests conflicted with Yelp’s no-solicitation policy so Podium now focuses on Google reviews.

Never Underestimate Customer Service
Look hard enough and you’ll find jewelers who have risen near the top in searches for local jewelers, amassing dozens of positive reviews without following the suggested online protocol.

If you search Yelp for jewelers in the Boston area, for example, Leo Carroll Jewelers often shows up in a crowded marketplace. It is a tiny, second-floor shop in Cambridge’s Inman Square that has been in operation since 1948 without even street-level signage.

While the retailer pays Yelp a nominal advertising fee, Leo Carroll has a modest marketing budget. It doesn’t use services like Podium, posts few images on its Yelp page, has no Facebook page, and rarely asks customers to leave reviews.

The store does virtually nothing to actively build their online presence, in other words, and yet Leo Carroll Jewelers has amassed 156 reviews on Yelp alone, averaging 5 stars.

What accounts for these impressive results?

Sean Carroll, who runs the business with his father, said it helps that the store is in the ultimate upscale college town, less than a mile from both Harvard and MIT. They sell a lot of engagement rings to a highly educated millennial population who, in turn, tend to post thoughtful reviews.

“Our store is small and very low key,” he said. “We don’t do anything amazing. We just try to do a good job, repair jewelry, and keep our prices as reasonable as possible.”

Old-fashioned customer service has worked wonders thus far.

“Even if we’re not in the best of moods, we always smile when someone walks in and take the time to chat,” Carroll. “We try to make the experience as pleasant as we can.”

ABC Jewelry, the Portland store, is another example of solid customer service.

Sima asks fewer than 10 percent of his customers to leave reviews, yet his store has managed to amass a five-star average on Google, Yelp and Facebook, enough to keep them visible in online searches.

“We are too busy at times, especially when we’re helping one client, and another is waiting,” he said. “It’s hard to ask people with their busy schedules.

“I know most people are online for hours daily but it takes time to go to Yelp and sign up and write a review. It may be a shortcoming of ours but we just try to provide an excellent service at amazing prices. What people write about us is essentially up to them.”

But experts say leaving reviews to chance and good customer service might not be enough to stay visible in a crowded online marketplace.

“We recommend asking all customers for reviews,” Podium’s Miller said. “I know it’s scary for jewelers to risk those one- or two-star reviews, but if you ask enough people, there will be enough four- and five-star reviews to drown those out.”

Padis agrees.

“Responding is probably the most important thing you can do, especially with negative reviews, but also with the positive ones. When people take the time to write the review, it’s important for the business owner to respond. It’s time-consuming but I think it’s worth every minute and every penny.”

Podium offers a service for sending out automatic requests for reviews but jewelers that specialize in engagement rings often opt out to avoid the risk of outing the proposer before the questions has been popped, when his (or her) photo appears next to a review.

For this reason, Padis uses Podium only for review management.

Navigating the Negative Review
First rule of thumb: No matter how wonderful your product and service, you will get negative reviews. The trick is to get enough positive ones to put them into perspective.

Miller recommends responding to every negative review.

“When other customers see that one-star review, they’ll see something bad happened but also that the jeweler did something to fix it.”

Carroll said negative reviews can be contagious. While his store has escaped them for the most part, he has seen other businesses get a bad rap.

“People tend to get on the bandwagon, whether someone is getting positive or negative reviews. So if you have some bad reviews, people chime in on that, whereas good reviews beget more good reviews.”

Sometimes a seemingly small, petty matter can get a store one star, he said. Also, “If a merchant is abrupt or disrespectful in some way, that’ll get you the one-star review pretty fast.”

A business owner’s first instinct is usually to try to refute what was said, Miller said, but the best way to respond to negative reviews is to respond in a proactive, timely manner while offering some sort of resolution. That should include a suggestion to take the conversation offline.

Carter, of Jack Lewis Jewelers, always answers negative reviews by taking responsibility if he can.

“Address your fallibility,” he said. “Accept the fact that you can be wrong and be willing to whatever it takes to correct the problem.”

In these cases, Carter introduces himself as the owner of the business and invites the disgruntled customer to contact him, listing his direct number at the store and personal email.

“The public does not expect any business to be perfect, but they do expect you to make it right when things go wrong,” he said. “Some people only look at the positive reviews because they want to reinforce their decision to buy. But others go right to the one-star reviews because they want to see how you address problems.”
 “We all benefit from a cool-down period when it comes to bad reviews.” — Alexis Padis, Padis Jewelers
A negative review also can supply insight into how a business is operating, Miller said.

“If there are certain employees not treating customers the way you want, it’s an opportunity to fix the situation.”

Padis warns against jumping the gun, however, when it comes to complaints about employees.

“I have an awesome staff. When I dig into the issue behind a bad review, nine times out of 10, my team did the right thing,” she said. “Automatically blaming them can do so much damage. So I always take the time to learn what happened.”

It’s easy for an owner to read a bad review, call the salesperson and let them have it, she said, but the negative review might have nothing to do with them.

“We deal with a lot of brides and there’s no wrath like that of a bride scorned. When you’re dealing with engagement rings, it’s often more about what’s going on in the customer’s life.”

When Padis’ store or salespeople get a bad review, she writes her initial response immediately in a Word document then sleeps on it and sends her response to friends in the industry asking for feedback on how it may be interpreted.

“I usually end up toning it down a bit, to a response that’s respectful and communicative, rather than immediately firing off a response that might be too personal or emotional,” Padis said. “We all benefit from a cool-down period when it comes to bad reviews.”
Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

Renovated Betteridge Jewelers store in Greenwich, Connecticut
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Step Inside Betteridge Jewelers’ Renovated Greenwich Store

Located on the main street in Greenwich, the renovation marks Watches of Switzerland’s most significant U.S. retail investment to date.

Pauline Karpidas: The Jewelry Collection
AuctionsNov 16, 2026
A Tour of Pauline Karpidas’ Jewelry Heading to Auction

Her eclectic collection, with jewels spanning several periods of the 20th century, could fetch up to $10 million at Sotheby's next month.

Kerry Feldmann
MajorsNov 16, 2026
Kendra Scott Taps Former John Hardy, Tiffany & Co. Exec as CMO

Jewelry industry executive Kerry Feldmann has taken on the role.

LIM-1452_1872-x-1052_Jewelry-Services--Image-Resize-.jpg
Brought to you by
More Information. More Confidence. One GIA Jewelry Report.

The GIA Jewelry Report helps retailers answer customer questions with independent, science-based information from GIA—all in one report.

American Gem Society Conclave 2027 speakers
Events & AwardsNov 16, 2026
AGS Announces 2027 Conclave Keynote Speakers

This year’s lineup includes a chief executive optimist, “The Iron Cowboy,” a Peloton executive, and The Second City comedians.

Weekly QuizNov 12, 2026
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Romanov Sapphire
AuctionsNov 13, 2026
Historic ‘Romanov Sapphire’ Achieves $4.9M at Sotheby’s

The 197-carat Russian Crown jewel was the leading lot of Sotheby's white-glove Royal & Noble Jewels sale this week.

Maison Marcelle Équation Bracelet
CollectionsNov 13, 2026
Maison Marcelle’s Bracelet Flows Like Fabric

The “Équation” bracelet, our Piece of the Week, was built via 24 gold modules assembled into a piece that feels like fabric on the wrist.

dsf antique jewelry ceylon intaglio sapphire .jpg
Brought to you by
DSF Antique Jewelry: Fine Jewelry, Signed Designers, and a World of Rare Discoveries

With over 50 years experience in the trade, DSF Antique Jewelry offers quality, craftsmanship, condition, and remarkable variety.

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont Texas
IndependentsNov 13, 2026
Texas Jeweler to Close After 111 Years

Alter’s Gem Jewelry in Beaumont, Texas, is closing as Brian and Lori Alter retire to spend more time with family.

Christine Olowonira, K. Angelo Jones, Ivi Kyratzi, Aaron Mak, and Haley Kim
Events & AwardsNov 13, 2026
Tiffany & Co., CFDA Unveil Second Jewelry Designer Award Finalists

Five finalists have been chosen for the Tiffany & Co. x CFDA Jewelry Designer Award’s second cycle.

Stock image of a gavel
CrimeNov 12, 2026
1 of 7 Men Charged in $100M Brinks Heist to Plead Guilty

Three of the other alleged perpetrators will stand trial next March, while two remain on the lam and one was deported late last year.

Bulgari Pink diamond
AuctionsNov 12, 2026
24-Carat ‘Bulgari Pink’ Diamond Sells for $14.8M

Unseen for more than seven decades, the fancy intense pink diamond was the star of Christie’s Geneva jewelry auction.

Zadok Jewelers Rolex showroom in Austin Texas
WatchesNov 12, 2026
Zadok Jewelers Now Offers Certified Pre-Owned Rolex Watches

The curated selection is available online and at its showroom in Austin, Texas.

Greenberg’s Jewelers family group photo
IndependentsNov 12, 2026
Greenberg’s Jewelers Welcomes New Fourth-Generation Members

The next generation understands what makes the 126-year-old retailer special, said CEO and Co-President Elise Greenberg.

GIA pink CVD diamond
Lab-GrownNov 10, 2026
GIA Examines Pink Lab-Grown Diamond Made to Look Natural

The 6-carat CVD-grown pink diamond was “deliberately modified” to mimic the appearance of a natural rough diamond, the lab said.

Screenshot of Botswana President Duma Boko during 2026 State of Nation address
SourcingNov 10, 2026
Botswana in Line to Take Controlling Stake in De Beers, President Says

If the Global Diamond Consortium emerges as the top bidder for De Beers, Botswana’s stake will double to 30 percent, Duma Boko said Monday.

Emmanuel Raheb, CEO of Smart Age Solutions
ColumnistsNov 10, 2026
Who Checks the Facts When AI Writes Your Jewelry Copy?

An incorrect AI-generated ad or product description can cost your store valuable consumer trust.

Gem Awards Gala 2026
Events & AwardsNov 09, 2026
Here Are the 2027 Gem Award Nominees

These nine individuals and brands are up for a Gem Award in the Jewelry Design, Media Excellence, and Retail Innovation categories.

Stock image of crime scene tape
CrimeNov 09, 2026
Jeweler Pistol-Whipped, $900K in Jewelry Stolen During Home Invasion

The incident, which happened in Miami-Dade County, serves as a reminder to jewelers of the dangers of selling and storing jewelry at home.

Tourmaline inclusion in muscovite mica
GradingNov 09, 2026
GIA Acquires Thousands of Gem Specimens With ‘Extraordinary’ Inclusions

GIA Analytical Microscopist John Koivula curated the collection of 2,665 crystals, gems, and minerals over a 60-year span.

 Bibi van der Velden Eclipse Campaign Imagery
CollectionsNov 09, 2026
Bibi van der Velden’s Alligators Become High Jewelry

The “Eclipse” collection, the brand’s first high jewelry line, centers its alligator motif in diamond and spinel jewels.

Daughters of the Deep indicolite earrings
EditorsNov 06, 2026
The Spectrum Pieces I Can’t Stop Thinking About

From a Betta fish brooch to a “dragon’s trove” of zircon eggs, here are seven pieces that’ve stuck with Associate Editor Lauren McLemore.

Pat Pruitt Dragonfly Earrings
TrendsNov 06, 2026
Pat Pruitt’s DragonFly Earrings Take Flight on Election Night

Groundbreaking New Mexico Governor-elect Deb Haaland wore the earrings, our Piece of the Week, when she declared victory on Tuesday.

Colin Jost in Kay Jewelers holiday ad
MajorsNov 06, 2026
SNL’s Colin Jost Finds the Perfect Gift in Kay Jewelers’ Holiday Ad

Jost goes on an epic journey, traversing rough seas and encountering a cyclops, to discover the perfect holiday gift.

GCAL 8X_NJSB_1.jpg
Supplier BulletinNov 05, 2026
Winning With GCAL 8X®: What’s Working at the Counter

Sponsored by GCAL by Sarine

Wrapped holiday gift boxes
SurveysNov 05, 2026
What Retailers Should Know About Holiday Shoppers This Year

From shrinking budgets to AI elves, here are five takeaways from holiday reports by Bain, Adobe, Mastercard, NRF, and insights from YouGov.

Little Pet Portrait Pendants by Russell Jones & Judi Powers
CollectionsNov 05, 2026
Judi Powers, Russell Jones Unleash Joy With New Collaboration

The designers combined their talents for Little Pet Portraits, hand-painted miniatures of our best friends set in a piece of jewelry.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy