TrendsJul 18, 2025
Piece of the Week: CCWW Designs’ Shell Charm NecklaceThe charm necklace features six nautical charms of shells and coral that founder Christina Puchi collected on Florida’s beaches.
MajorsMar 11, 2014
Federal judge dismisses EEOC case vs. Sterling
A New York federal judge has thrown out the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s claim that Sterling Jewelers Inc. engaged in a nationwide practice of paying its female employees less and passing them over for promotions.
Buffalo, N.Y.--A New York federal judge has thrown out the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s claim that Sterling Jewelers Inc. engaged in a nationwide practice of paying its female employees less and passing them over for promotions.
In an order signed Monday in U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, federal judge Richard J. Arcara stated that after considering the report and recommendation filed by Magistrate Judge Jeremiah J. McCarthy in January, statements from both sides and oral arguments, he has opted to dismiss the EEOC’s claim with prejudice for “the reasons set forth in Magistrate Judge McCarthy’s Report and Recommendation.”
The EEOC filed suit against Sterling Jewelers in September 2008 in U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, accusing the jeweler of exhibiting a nationwide pattern of gender discrimination when it came to pay and promotions.
The suit was filed on behalf of some 44,000 female employees of Sterling Jewelers--making it the largest suit ever brought by the EEOC--and the EEOC said it had investigated, on a nationwide basis, claims of gender bias by the retailer.
Sterling denied the claims of discrimination and brought a motion stating that the EEOC investigated only one store in New York and two stores in Tampa, Fla. and did not conduct a thorough examination of the jeweler’s employment practices nationwide, as it had claimed.
In his ruling issued Jan. 2, McCarthy sided with Sterling, stating that the EEOC failed to prove it conducted a thorough, nationwide investigation of the retailer’s employment practices prior to filing the lawsuit, an assertion backed by Monday’s ruling by the federal court judge.
RELATED CONTENT: Judge calls for dismissal of EEOC case v. Sterling
The claim being dismissed with prejudice means the action is final at the district court level, though the EEOC could appeal, said attorney Gerald L. Maatman Jr., a partner at Seyfarth Shaw and the lead counsel for Sterling in the case.
“As defense counsel we are pleased with the ruling. We think it was well-reasoned and consistent with the evidence,” he said.
The EEOC said it has no comment.
A separate lawsuit filed by individuals charging Sterling Jewelers with discriminating against women in the workplace is still pending.
Originally filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York in March 2008, prior to the EEOC case, the suit is in arbitration.
Washington-based
attorney Joe Sellers, one of the lawyers representing the claimants involved in this case, said a hearing took place at the end of February on their request for the case to proceed as a class action, which would include about 40,000 current and former Sterling employees. They are awaiting the arbitrator’s decision.
The ruling in EEOC vs. Sterling has no impact on this case as it was based on the finding that the EEOC had conducted an insufficient investigation and not on the merits of the case, Sellers said.
Sterling has maintained throughout that it takes both lawsuits seriously and investigated the women’s claims thoroughly but found them to be without merit.
“We are confident they do not reflect our company’s environment, which is built on core values of fairness, opportunity, integrity and respect,” said David Bouffard, vice president of corporate affairs for Sterling parent company Signet Jewelers Ltd.
More on Majors
The Latest
TechnologyJul 18, 2025
Brad Campbell, John Liebler Join Clientbook’s Executive Team Campbell joins the company as vice president of business development while Liebler is the new vice president of operations.
CollectionsJul 17, 2025
2026 Winter Olympic Medal Design Symbolizes UnityThe medals feature a split-texture design highlighting the Games’ first time being hosted by two cities and the athletes’ journeys.
Brought to you by
Investing in the Next Generation of Bench JewelersThe Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship from Jewelers of America returns for a second year.
Supplier BulletinJul 17, 2025
The INSTORE Jewelry Show 2025: Your Holiday Preparations, All Wrapped Up! Sponsored by The INSTORE Jewelry Show 2025
Weekly QuizJul 17, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
SurveysJul 17, 2025
The Most Recommended Brands in the World, According to YouGovGlobally, travel and transportation brands reigned, while in the U.S., alcoholic beverage companies and a lingerie brand took the top spots.
IndependentsJul 17, 2025
Gina Ferranti of GiGi Ferranti Jewelry Dies at 59The Brooklyn-based jewelry designer is remembered as a true artist and a rare talent.
Brought to you by
Jewelers of America is Headed to Las Vegas for JCK 2025The countdown is on for the JCK Las Vegas Show and JA is pulling out all the stops.
SourcingJul 17, 2025
Rio Tinto Names New CEO, Production Rises at DiavikProduction at the mine in Canada’s Northwest Territories topped 1 million carats in Q2, the third consecutive quarter of growth.
Events & AwardsJul 17, 2025
JA to Hold Learning Workshops This FallA new slate of Learning Workshops will take place in Oklahoma, Mississippi, and Georgia.
SurveysJul 16, 2025
Signet Jewelers Falls Lower on NRF’s ‘Top 100’ Retailers ListThe middle class is changing its approach to buying jewelry and affordable luxury goods, the NRF said.
FinancialsJul 16, 2025
Richemont’s Jewelry Sales Up 7% in Q1It marks the third consecutive quarter of growth for Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, Buccellati, and Vhernier.
WatchesJul 16, 2025
The Top-Selling Rolex Models of the Last 15 Years, According to Bob’s Watches The reseller’s market trends report, based on its sales data, also shows exactly how much Rolex prices have jumped since 2010.
AuctionsJul 16, 2025
Christie’s To Honor Dinh Van With ExhibitionThe auction house will be hosting a retrospective paying tribute to jeweler Jean Dinh Van and his company’s 60th anniversary.
IndependentsJul 16, 2025
Clyde Duneier Ushers In Fourth GenerationJake Duneier and Danielle Duneier-Goldberg have stepped into the roles of CEO and president, respectively.
CollectionsJul 15, 2025
Boucheron’s New High Jewelry Calls Attention to Nature’s ImpermanenceThe “Impermanence” collection contemplates nature through the Japanese art of Ikebana (flower arranging) and philosophy of wabi-sabi.
MajorsJul 15, 2025
James Avery Expands to 2 More StatesThe Texas-based jewelry retailer has set up shop in Tennessee and Arizona.
Events & AwardsJul 15, 2025
Neiman Marcus Vet Joins Couture as Brand Director Eric Ford will step into the role, bringing with him decades of experience.
MajorsJul 15, 2025
Ben Bridge Jeweler Acquires Olympic ManufacturingIn addition to improved capabilities, the acquisition will allow the jeweler to offer support to other independent jewelers.
CollectionsJul 15, 2025
Guzema Debuts First Colored Gemstone JewelryThe “Celestial Blue” capsule collection campaign features Olympian Kateryna Sadurska.
MajorsJul 14, 2025
Nanis Opens First StoreThe seasonal store, located in Mykonos, Greece, offers exclusive events, personal styling, and curated experiences.
IndependentsJul 14, 2025
It’s the Summer of Love at Long’s JewelersThe New England jeweler is hosting a bridal event for the month of August.
SourcingJul 14, 2025
Ethical Gem Fair Heads to SeattleThe trade-only event will host its debut fair in the Emerald City later this month.
Events & AwardsJul 11, 2025
The Edge’s Annual Conference Returns in SeptemberIts sessions will focus on inventory strategies, staff performance, retention and acquisition, emerging market trends, and more.
CollectionsJul 11, 2025
Piece of the Week: Miseno’s ‘Arco’ EarringsFor its 10th anniversary, Miseno designed the “Arco” earrings based on the Arco Felice, an arch conceptualized in A.D. 95 in Miseno, Italy.
Policies & IssuesJul 11, 2025
James Avery to Donate $1M to Texas Hill Country Relief EffortsThe jewelry company is one of several contributing to relief efforts in the region after the recent floods.
TrendsJul 11, 2025
Kelly Osbourne’s Engagement Ring Is Sweet as HoneyInspired by fiancé Sid Wilson’s nickname for her, the white and yellow diamond ring features a unique honeycomb design.
