Policies & IssuesNov 04, 2025
Supreme Court to Hear Tariffs Case WednesdayAhead of the hearing, two industry organizations co-signed an amicus brief urging the court to declare Trump’s tariffs unlawful.
TechnologyNov 23, 2015
Retailer combats reviewers-for-hire
When Long’s Jewelers racked up 100 fake one-star reviews on Facebook in just a few days, they found some people are willing to post and profit from untrue reviews. Here’s what they did about it.
Boston--When it comes to online reviews, retailers may have more to worry about than customers who actually come into or do business online with their stores.
In a blog post published last week, Lynelle Schmidt, Long’s Jewelers digital marketing coordinator, detailed a recent experience the Boston-based retailer had with a batch of fake Facebook reviews that it believes were purchased online by a competitor.
In the post, she wrote that she came in one Monday to check the store’s social media channels and saw that the store’s rating on its Facebook page had dropped from 4.8 stars to 2.3 stars over the weekend.
The cause: more than 100 one-star reviews that were left on the Long’s Jewelers Facebook page with no comments, and each coming within minutes of each other from seemingly fake, and very similar, Facebook profiles.
After much back-and-forth with Facebook, Schmidt wrote that she finally was able to have the comment-less, one-star reviews moved from the page. The entire debacle, however, brought to light a larger problem: online marketplaces where people offer to post fake reviews of a product or business, good or bad, for a fee.
One place where this has happened is Fiverr.com. It’s an online marketplace where visitors can offer to do small tasks and services for $5 or more. The jobs range from writing and design to animation and advertising, but it also has become a place where users can find people willing to be paid to post false reviews and ratings, be they negative or positive. (There also are other sites that offer similar services, among them the blatantly named BuyAmazonReviews.com.)
Schmidt told National Jeweler that based on how the events unfolded, they believe the false, negative Facebook reviews posted to the Long’s page were purchased on Fiverr. “Fiverr is probably one of the most well-known platforms that allow this to happen,” she said. “It’s popular because it’s cheap and effective.”
When asked about the Long’s incident--and, more specifically, if it was aware that users were posting fake review services on its website and if it was removing them--Fiverr told National Jeweler that “Gigs may be removed by Fiverr for violations of the Terms of Service … Fraudulent reviews are a violation of Fiverr’s Terms of Service, and we promptly remove these services as they are reported.”
However, Fiverr’s simply removing the reviews doesn’t go to the
root of the issue--people feeling like they can offer to do fake reviews and get away with it. Amazon has acknowledged that, and is attempting to deter people from selling false reviews not by going after Fiverr itself but by filing a lawsuit naming the individual users engaging in the practice.
In Long’s case, Schmidt said she believes the negative reviews that appeared on the retailer’s Facebook page were paid for by a competitor. “There have been a few recent events that lead us to believe it was a competitor, another local jeweler, that we prefer not to share (the name of) publicly,” she said. “We are really looking to keep things positive with this story and take the high road by not outing or naming them in any way.”
Aside from contacting Facebook administrators to get the review situation sorted out, Schmidt and the Long’s Jewelers team also released a statement on their Facebook page that, despite “terrible organic reach,” garnered a lot of attention.
“Normally, I boost almost all of our posts because organic reach on Facebook is dismal,” she said. “But I felt like the message behind this post would really be compromised by us boosting it. Our hope was that it would go viral on its own without us having to pay.”
And it did. Thanks to Long’s “community of loyal followers and customers sharing the post,” she said it accumulated more than 14,000 views.
When asked what she would advise retailers to do if they find themselves in a similar situation, Schmidt recommended they turn to their own community for support and work with the online platform where the issue is taking place.
She said Yelp recently has dealt with legal action from businesses suing over defamation, “so they are much stricter about blocking negative or false reviews.” Facebook, however, is newer to the review game, and is beginning to garner negative attention around blatant acts of spam that are not subject to any kind of filtering system.
“The best course of action would really be to drum up as much attention as possible, take the high road, and focus on strategies to rebuild despite the damage done,” Schmidt said. “In the future, we predict that sites like Facebook will be much more regulated after stories like ours continue to surface, but in the meantime, there’s not much a business can do.”
More on Technology
The Latest
MajorsNov 04, 2025
Danny Clark to Become Stuller CEO, Succeeding Matt StullerStuller COO Belit Myers will take on the additional role of president, with all changes effective at the start of 2026.
ColumnistsNov 04, 2025
Peter Smith: What Do Birds Have to Do With the Price of Gold? Smith cautions retailers against expending too much energy on things they can’t control, like the rising price of gold.
Brought to you by
Jewelers of America Aligns New Mission to Create Meaningful Impact for MembersFrom educational programs, advocacy, and recent MJSA affiliation, Jewelers of America drives progress that elevates businesses of all sizes.
TrendsNov 04, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: Fall Colors for November BirthdaysCitrine and topaz are birthstones fit for fall as the leaves change color and the holiday season approaches.
Weekly QuizOct 30, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
IndependentsNov 04, 2025
Weston Jewelers Heads to Fort LauderdaleThe family-owned jeweler will open its fourth store in Florida in late 2027.
CrimeNov 03, 2025
Men Dressed as Construction Workers Burglarize Jeweler’s Home The NYPD is looking for three men who stole a safe and jewelry valued at $3.2 million from the home of a jeweler in Jamaica Hills, Queens.
MajorsNov 03, 2025
Matthew Rosenheim Takes Over as JA Board ChairThe trade organization also announced its executive committee and five new directors.
CollectionsNov 03, 2025
Muse’s ‘Have a Heart’ Collab Returns, Now With DDGThe “Have a Heart x Diamonds Do Good” collection is championed by model and humanitarian Flaviana Matata and will benefit her foundation.
AuctionsNov 03, 2025
Kashmir Sapphire Ring Tops Christie's Online AuctionThe ring, set with a nearly 17-carat Kashmir cabochon sapphire, sold for $1 million.
TrendsOct 31, 2025
Piece of the Week: A Spinner Fit for ‘Frankenstein’This “Mother Father” spinner necklace from Heavenly Vices Fine Jewelry draws inspiration from Victorian Era jewelry.
CrimeOct 31, 2025
5 More Arrested in Louvre Heist, Jewelry Still Missing The suspects were rounded up in Paris and its suburbs on Wednesday night, but none of the stolen jewels were recovered with them.
Recorded WebinarsOct 31, 2025
Watch: How to Master Google Reviews for Your BusinessExperts share top tips on how to encourage positive reviews and handle negative feedback.
Supplier BulletinOct 30, 2025
Protect Your Customers and Your BusinessSponsored by the Gemological Institute of America
CrimeOct 30, 2025
29-Year-Old Man Charged in Multiple Seattle-Area Smash and Grabs The suspect faces charges in the August robbery of Menashe & Sons Jewelers and is accused of committing smash and grabs at two pawn shops.
Lab-GrownOct 30, 2025
Alison Lou’s New Collection Uses Lab-Grown Diamonds and ResinThe “Lumière Fine” collection was born from designer Alison Chemla’s interest in the transformative power of light.
TrendsOct 30, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: A Haunted HalloweenShow off your spooky side with these 12 festive jewels.
Events & AwardsOct 30, 2025
Jewelers Mutual to Host Jewelry Panel at Frazier History MuseumThe “Brilliant & Beyond” panel coincides with the “Love & Marriage” exhibition curated by Davis Jewelers in Louisville, Kentucky.
Events & AwardsOct 29, 2025
October Brings Little Change to Consumer Confidence Consumers are feeling more optimistic about their present situation while the short-term future remains a little scary.
Events & AwardsOct 29, 2025
Couture Partners With Time to WatchesThe company, which organizes a watch show in Geneva every spring, will bring a selection of watch brands to the 2026 Couture show in Vegas.
TrendsOct 29, 2025
Beth Bernstein Releases Vintage Jewelry Guide“The Modern Guide to Vintage Jewellery” follows the evolution of jewelry design from the ‘30s to the ‘80s with buying and styling advice.
EditorsOct 29, 2025
Why Creepy, Crawly Bugs Inspire Beautiful JewelryFor her annual Halloween story, Senior Editor Lenore Fedow explores the symbolism behind spiders, beetles, and other eerie insects.
Events & AwardsOct 28, 2025
Meet the 2026 Gem Award NomineesNotable jewelry designers, members of the press, and retailers are up for an award at next year’s gala.
Recorded WebinarsOct 28, 2025
Watch: The State of the Jewelry Industry Leaders from Jewelers of America and National Jeweler discuss the gold price, tariffs, and more in this one-hour webinar.
CollectionsOct 28, 2025
Eriness Reflects on Life in ‘One of One’ CollectionAfter experiencing motherhood, growth, and loss, founder and designer Erin Sachse has created 10 irreplaceable jewels.
AuctionsOct 27, 2025
Napoleon Left This Brooch Behind, And Now It’s Up For AuctionIt is part of Sotheby’s “Royal & Noble Jewels” sale along with an ornate hair ornament and an old mine-cut light pink diamond ring.
