CrimeSep 20, 2024
Oregon Jeweler Sentenced to 20 Years for Stealing From, Defrauding Customers CrimeNov 20, 2024
Sotheby’s to Pay $6.25M Settlement to NY State for Alleged Tax Fraud
The auction house was accused of helping clients avoid paying taxes on millions of dollars’ worth of art purchased from 2010 to 2020.
Sotheby’s will pay millions of dollars to New York State to settle a tax fraud lawsuit the state filed against it in 2020. (Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons/ajay_suresh)
New York—Sotheby’s Inc. has reached a $6.25 million settlement with New York State in a now 4-year-old lawsuit that accused the auction house of fraudulently securing tax breaks for clients purchasing artwork.
The auction house allegedly helped clients avoid paying taxes on tens of millions of dollars’ worth of art purchased between 2010 and 2020, New York Attorney General Letitia James said when announcing the settlement last week.
The lawsuit, brought by James’ office in November 2020, claimed Sotheby’s encouraged clients to use tax exemption forms known as resale certificates, which certify that a buyer is exempt from paying sales tax because the purchase is for resale only.
It then accepted these certificates, even though the auction house allegedly knew these clients were buying the art for themselves, not to resell it.
Sotheby’s did not respond to National Jeweler’s request for comment but a Reuters report said the company did not admit or deny wrongdoing, and said it “settled to avoid the time, expense, and distraction of litigation.”
James said one of Sotheby’s clients, referred to as the “Collector,” purchased $27 million worth of art from the auction house between 2010 and 2015 using these forms.
She said Sotheby’s accepted resale certificates from the Collector even though it knew they were not buying art for resale but for a personal art collection, some of which Sotheby’s employees helped to set up for display in the Collector’s home.
James previously had secured a settlement with the Collector’s company, Porsal Equities, requiring it to pay more than $10 million in taxes, penalties, and damages for being in violation of tax laws and the New York False Claims Act.
“No one should be allowed to cheat the system and escape paying the taxes they owe,” she said.
“Sotheby’s intentionally broke the law to help its clients dodge millions of dollars in taxes, and now they are going to pay for it. Every person and company in New York knows they are required to pay taxes, and when people break the rules, we all lose out.”
Related stories will be right here …
The auction house allegedly helped clients avoid paying taxes on tens of millions of dollars’ worth of art purchased between 2010 and 2020, New York Attorney General Letitia James said when announcing the settlement last week.
The lawsuit, brought by James’ office in November 2020, claimed Sotheby’s encouraged clients to use tax exemption forms known as resale certificates, which certify that a buyer is exempt from paying sales tax because the purchase is for resale only.
It then accepted these certificates, even though the auction house allegedly knew these clients were buying the art for themselves, not to resell it.
Sotheby’s did not respond to National Jeweler’s request for comment but a Reuters report said the company did not admit or deny wrongdoing, and said it “settled to avoid the time, expense, and distraction of litigation.”
James said one of Sotheby’s clients, referred to as the “Collector,” purchased $27 million worth of art from the auction house between 2010 and 2015 using these forms.
She said Sotheby’s accepted resale certificates from the Collector even though it knew they were not buying art for resale but for a personal art collection, some of which Sotheby’s employees helped to set up for display in the Collector’s home.
James previously had secured a settlement with the Collector’s company, Porsal Equities, requiring it to pay more than $10 million in taxes, penalties, and damages for being in violation of tax laws and the New York False Claims Act.
“No one should be allowed to cheat the system and escape paying the taxes they owe,” she said.
“Sotheby’s intentionally broke the law to help its clients dodge millions of dollars in taxes, and now they are going to pay for it. Every person and company in New York knows they are required to pay taxes, and when people break the rules, we all lose out.”
The attorney general’s office also claimed that from 2012 to 2020, Sotheby’s improperly accepted resale certificates from at least seven other clients on millions of dollars of purchases despite knowing they were buying art for their personal collections.
In several instances, Sotheby’s did not just accept the false resale certificates, but suggested its clients use them, said James, providing the forms and filling out portions of it for them.
“In this case, a prominent auction house went out of its way to help wealthy clients avoid paying millions of dollars in sales taxes on their art purchases,” said Amanda Hiller, acting commissioner and general counsel of New York State Department of Taxation and Finance.
“Thanks to the diligent efforts of Attorney General James and her staff, this fraudulent activity has been stopped and Sotheby’s is being held accountable.”
In addition to paying $6.25 million, Sotheby’s has to undergo reforms as part of the settlement, including creating new measures to ensure employees are educated properly on New York tax law and reviewing information about whether a client intends to resell the art being purchased.
More on Crime
The Latest
IndependentsSep 29, 2025
Nina Pugliese, Longtime Henne Jewelers Employee, Dies at 65She was remembered as a creative and generous woman of faith, who also had a sweet tooth.
MajorsSep 29, 2025
Overnight Releases New Bridal CatalogThe “Volume 7” bridal catalog features best-selling engagement rings, trending styles, and a new section highlighting anniversary bands.
IndependentsSep 29, 2025
Mark Henry Jewelry to Debut in CanadaThe New York-based brand is set to launch a limited-time offering for the holiday season at Holt Renfrew in Toronto.
TrendsSep 29, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: Ear FocusMove over neck mess, the ear story is the way to make a layering statement today.
Weekly QuizSep 25, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
SurveysSep 26, 2025
Online Shopping, Influencers to Drive Holiday Spending, Mastercard SaysHoliday sales growth is expected to slow as consumers grapple with inflation and tariff-related uncertainty.
Events & AwardsSep 26, 2025
Winners of Austin Jewelry Design Contest Announced Jamie Turner Designs is among the winners of the local “Austin Shines” contest, hosted by Eliza Page, a jewelry store in Austin, Texas.
Brought to you by
reDollar.com Is Rolling Out the Next Level Jewelry, Diamond & Watch Consignment ProgramWith their unmatched services and low fees, reDollar.com is challenging some big names in the online consignment world.
TrendsSep 26, 2025
Piece of the Week: Kwit Jewelry’s Square Signet Pinky RingThe red and azure colorway is one of many fun enamel pairings offered, bringing whimsy to the classic style of a monogramed signet ring.
Policies & IssuesSep 25, 2025
JA CEO Provides Tariff Update Following Annual Fly-InA trade deal with Switzerland seems probable, but reaching an agreement with India remains a challenge, David Bonaparte said.
SourcingSep 25, 2025
2 African Countries Aim to Take Stake in De Beers Botswana’s president said his country wants a controlling share, while Angola envisions multiple countries holding minority stakes.
Lab-GrownSep 25, 2025
Kira Jewels Expands Lab-Grown Diamond ProductionThe manufacturer is adding 1,400 chemical vapor deposition (CVD) reactors to its growing facility in India.
IndependentsSep 25, 2025
Alex Moss’ New Flagship Brings Bold Jewels to SoHoThe jeweler to the stars has worked with Drake, A$AP Rocky, Tyler the Creator, and other celebrities.
WatchesSep 25, 2025
Wilson & Son Jewelers Donates to the Horological Society of New YorkThe Scarsdale, New York-based jeweler donated a professional-grade watch cleaning machine.
Policies & IssuesSep 24, 2025
Tariffs Throw Diamond Trade Into DisarrayThe 50 percent tariffs on diamonds shipped from India to the U.S. have pushed midstream manufacturers to the edge.
SourcingSep 24, 2025
De Beers Adopts New Strategies to Drive Natural Diamond Demand in IndiaDe Beers’ refreshed, multipronged approach, which includes generic promotions and retail partnerships, is delivering positive dividends.
Policies & IssuesSep 24, 2025
For Jewelry Manufacturers, Higher Tariffs Create Long-Term WorriesThey are trying to balance the need to sustain well-established relationships with the pressure higher tariffs have put on margins.
SourcingSep 24, 2025
A Helping Hand: An Effort to Boost Inclusivity in the IndustryJewelry manufacturer Jewelex has partnered with JOSH, an industry training center, on a program for people with disabilities.
CollectionsSep 24, 2025
Greenwich St. Jewelers Goes Back in Time With First Estate CollectionThe collection includes pieces dating back to the Victorian and Art Deco periods as well as mid-century and late 20th-century designs.
Policies & IssuesSep 24, 2025
Diamonds Do Good Names Marcus ter Haar as President-ElectHe previously served as co-chair of the nonprofit’s beneficiary committee.
CollectionsSep 24, 2025
Brilliant Earth’s New Jane Goodall Collection Calls for PeaceIts second collaboration with the conservationist features jewelry with dove and olive branch motifs.
SourcingSep 24, 2025
SRK Launches Kriam PharmaThe diamond manufacturer’s new company will provide accessible and affordable high-quality medicines across India.
ColumnistsSep 23, 2025
Quiet Luxury: What Fall’s Top Trend Means for JewelersEmmanuel Raheb shares tips on how a jeweler’s showcases, marketing, and social media presence can whisper, instead of shout.
MajorsSep 23, 2025
Ames Watson Completes $140M Acquisition of Claire’sThe private equity firm has a plan to revive the mall staple.
SourcingSep 23, 2025
Super Smalls’ New Book Introduces Kids to Gems, Fine JewelryThe “Super Book of Gems” dives into the Mohs Hardness Scale, the Four C’s, and designs from jewelers like Cartier and Bulgari.
MajorsSep 23, 2025
Mattioli Names Kering Exec as New CEOClaudio Pasta will take the lead at the Italian fine jewelry brand, succeeding company founder Licia Mattioli.
CollectionsSep 23, 2025
Monique Lhuillier Adds Fashion Jewelry to Kay Jewelers LineThe new lab-grown diamond jewelry offering is the latest expansion of the designer’s “Bliss” collection.
