Nehal Modi Sentenced to 3-9 Years in Grand Larceny Case

CrimeAug 08, 2022

Nehal Modi Sentenced to 3-9 Years in Grand Larceny Case

He was convicted last month after falsely claiming he had a deal with Costco in order to obtain millions in diamonds from LLD Diamonds USA.

New York—Nehal Modi was sentenced to three to nine years in state prison for perpetrating a scheme in which he stole millions in diamonds from wholesaler LLD Diamonds, the Manhattan District Attorney’s office announced late last month.

Modi, 43, was the CEO of Gitanjali Gems-owned Samuels Jewelers, which filed for bankruptcy and ultimately ended up closing all of its stores in 2019 in the wake of the $2 billion banking scandal in India allegedly involving Modi’s uncle, Gitanjali Chairman Mehul Choksi, as well as his brother, Nirav Modi, among others. 

The case brought against Nehal Modi in New York involved $2.6 million of diamonds he obtained from LLD Diamonds USA LLC, also known as Lev Leviev Diamonds, over a six-month period in 2015. 

According to the Manhattan D.A., Modi first approached LLD Diamonds in March 2015 and obtained about $800,000 in diamonds from the wholesaler by falsely claiming he had a contract with Costco Wholesale Corp., which Modi said had agreed to purchase diamonds from LLD.

LLD allowed him to purchase the diamonds on credit but instead of selling them to Costco, Modi pawned them at Modell Collateral Loans Inc., pocketing $450,000 for personal gain.

In April and May 2015, Modi went back to LLD Diamonds three more times and obtained an additional $1 million-plus in diamonds that he allegedly was going to sell to Costco but instead pawned or sold for a discount. 

He did make payments but used most of the proceeds from the diamond sales for his own personal use and other business expenses, according to the D.A.’s office.

 Related stories will be right here … 

Modi returned to LLD Diamonds again in August 2015. By this time, his debt totaled almost $1 million.

LLD allowed Modi to take more diamonds but on consignment this time and under the condition that Modi could not sell these diamonds without LLD’s authorization.

The company also asked for partial payment upfront.

Modi, however, already had a plan in place to sell the diamonds to Modell Collateral Loans, said the D.A., and sold most of them to Modell for $300,000 on the same day he picked them up from LLD. He sold the rest to various retailers at a discount.

LLD eventually discovered the fraud and reported it to the Manhattan D.A.’s office, which handed the case to a team of investigators including Detective Joseph Metsopulos from the New York Police Department’s Major Case Squad, who received the John J. Kennedy Award for law enforcement excellence at AGS Conclave this year.

A jury convicted Nehal Modi of one count of grand larceny in the first degree, a Class B felony in the state of New York, on July 7.

He was sentenced on July 29 and is currently in custody.

His attorney, New York-based Roger J. Bernstein, told National Jeweler on Monday that he plans to file an appeal but declined any further comment on the case. 

Editor’s note: This story was updated post-publication to add a comment from Nehal Modi’s attorney.

The Latest

AuctionsMar 21, 2023
Marlene Dietrich’s Van Cleef & Arpels Bracelet Going Up for Auction

Expected to earn up to $4.5 million, the “Jarretière” bracelet is the star of Christie’s “The Magnificent Jewels of Anne Eisenhower” sale.

ColumnistsMar 21, 2023
Squirrel Spotting: Customer Retention Mindset—The New CRM

With jewelry sales coming down from their pandemic highs, retailers need to do all they can to retain existing customers, Peter Smith says.

Events & AwardsMar 21, 2023
ASJRA’s May Conference Examines ‘Iconic’ Jewelry Companies

Jewelry historians, authors, and experts will explore the works of Tiffany & Co., Oscar Heyman, Verdura, and more.

Brought to you by
Full Disclosure at Your Fingertips

Distinguishing natural diamonds from laboratory-grown stones – now more available than ever – has been difficult for jewelers. Until now.

IndependentsMar 21, 2023
Borsheims Executive Jennifer Johnson Retires

Johnson joined the retailer in 1987, establishing its first human resources department.

Weekly QuizMar 17, 2023
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge with this short test.
Take the Quiz
Recorded WebinarsMar 20, 2023
Watch: Lab Grown Diamonds: What's Now? What's New? What's Next?

Supplier Spotlight Presented by IGI

Events & AwardsMar 20, 2023
Gem Awards Shine Spotlight on Design, Dedication, and Family

The industry gathered to celebrate those who elevate the jewelry and watch industries.

Brought to you by
Bringing Over 130 Years of Diamond Expertise to Modern Grading

De Beers Institute of Diamonds provides the very best in diamond verification, education and diamond services.

CollectionsMar 20, 2023
A New Book on Chanel Is a High Jewelry Lover’s Dream

It highlights Gabrielle “Coco” Chanel’s lasting influence on modern design.

Recorded WebinarsMar 17, 2023
Watch: Lessons From Gems

Jewelers of America’s Amanda Gizzi explores the qualities and accomplishments that make this year’s Gem Award nominees shine.

Events & AwardsMar 17, 2023
JCK Industry Fund Announces Grant Recipients

Here’s what the nine chosen organizations plan to do with the funds.

TrendsMar 17, 2023
Piece of the Week: Anita Ko’s Award-Ready Earrings

The designer is nominated for a Gem Award for Jewelry Design.

FinancialsMar 16, 2023
Winter Weather, Declining Engagements Weigh on Signet’s Results

The jewelry giant’s full-year sales were essentially flat, brought down by fourth-quarter declines.

FinancialsMar 16, 2023
Brilliant Earth Took a Record Number of Orders in 2022

In its recent results, the company highlighted non-bridal jewelry sales and said its “inventory-light” showroom model may change.

Events & AwardsMar 16, 2023
Amanda’s Style File: Sparkling Gems

See 15 fabulous pieces from the 2023 Gem Award for Jewelry Design nominees: Anita Ko, Kirsty Stone, and Ron Anderson and David Rees.

WatchesMar 16, 2023
Citizen’s New Eco-Drive Watches Run for a Full Year

The new Cal. E365 movement doubles the running time of the current Eco-Drive models.

SourcingMar 15, 2023
Amid Uncertainties, India’s Diamond Industry Continues to Adjust

The mood among diamantaires is fairly optimistic despite the challenges brought about by sanctions and a cloudy economic outlook.

Lab-GrownMar 15, 2023
India’s Lab-Grown Diamond Industry Is Growing Up

The mood is bullish as more companies get into the business despite the dramatic drop in lab-grown diamond prices.

SourcingMar 15, 2023
Q&A: GJEPC Chairman Vipul Shah

Shah talks with National Jeweler about diamond demand, lab-grown, and why it’s difficult to make predictions about the U.S. market.

Policies & IssuesMar 15, 2023
When Diamonds Replenish the Earth

Hari Krishna Exports and the Dholakia Foundation’s “Mission 100 Sarovar” aims to create 100 lakes to help revive an area of Gujarat.

TechnologyMar 15, 2023
Sarine’s New Website Schools Consumers on Traceability

The educational resource will highlight the positive impact diamonds can make on their journey from mine to market.

SourcingMar 15, 2023
Canada’s Ekati Diamond Mine to Get a New Owner

Australian mining company Burgundy Diamond Mines announced plans to buy the mine in a deal valued at $136 million.

AuctionsMar 15, 2023
Antique Rings Discovered by Retirees Perform Well at Auction

A 17th-century gold seal ring and an 18th-century memento mori ring met or exceeded estimates at a recent Noonans auction.

Events & AwardsMar 15, 2023
JSA Announces Award Recipients

They will be recognized at the organization’s annual luncheon this weekend in New York City.

ColumnistsMar 14, 2023
On Data: How Did Independent Jewelers Do in January and February?

Sherry Smith breaks down the results so far this year, including which categories are the sales standouts and which are struggling.

MajorsMar 14, 2023
Dutch Historian Discovers Medieval Jewels

The 1,000-year-old find is now on display in the Dutch National Museum of Antiquities.

Events & AwardsMar 14, 2023
GemGenève Is Gearing Up for Its Biggest Show Yet

More than 200 exhibitors are scheduled for the May 11-14 event.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy