Trends

Designer’s Diary: The Consignment Crisis

TrendsApr 05, 2016

Designer’s Diary: The Consignment Crisis

In her latest diary entry, Jacqueline Stone examines the thorny issue of consignment from all sides.


Consignment seems to be the topic of heavy debate these days, casually making its way into conversations that quickly get heated.  

Jacqueline Stone is the chief creative officer of her company, Salt + Stone, working primarily with private clients to build custom engagement rings and wedding bands.

The issue seemingly divides the jewelry industry into two camps. After doing a deeper dive on the subject, I started to wonder: Is consignment the subconscious reason for overall discord within the jewelry industry at large?  Why is this tactic causing so much strife?  And what can we all do about it?

Before we start to look at solutions, it’s always best to examine the situation at hand first. I did my best to reach out to both retailers and designers alike to gather their opinions.

Creative freedom
One thing that designers seem to love about consignment is the ability to create freely and not adhere to line sheets or merchandising plans. This sales strategy works out extremely well for artists who create one-of-a-kind work. As designer Cynthia Eid put it, “I make what I want to make instead of filling orders and that’s a lot more fun. Usually the store takes more (of my jewelry on consignment), and it creates a larger body of work in their store.” 

A great point: Minimums at trade shows have been created to help the retailer and designer partner together to create a story. We all know customers don’t buy matchy-matchy anymore, but ironically still like to see a cohesive collection in the case line.  

On the other end of the spectrum, some retailers prefer to stay away from consignment for it allows them to truly build their own brand aesthetic. Jeweler Tara Silberberg, owner of The Clay Pot in Brooklyn, does not consign from the majority of her artists. 

“I find it really important to curate my collections and I need to have the freedom to merchandise what I know will sell, not what can be easily provided on consignment. Buying jewelry from my designers provides me with the ability to buy multiples to handle volume, allows me to take educated risks and most importantly helps my emerging designers with cash flow. It's really important to me to support the jewelry community and emerging talent.”

Entry roadblock
Speaking to both retailers and designers alike, everyone seems to agree: Entry into this market is at a huge standstill.  

It’s
harder than ever for new designers to break into the mold due to material cost constraints (gold is currently at more than $1,200/ounce; it was less than half that 10 years ago), the change in buyer landscape (jewelry-focused versus hybrid stores) and the inability to compete with manufacturers importing items from overseas at a much more desirable price point.  

Bianca Lopez, owner of Bianca Lopez Studio of Jewelry Art and Design finds consignment disheartening as she mentors new students and craftsmen in New York City.

“What today is all about is capturing and holding the interest of the consumer. New undiscovered designers, with impressive and distinctive jewelry, are the goldmine of untapped revenue for retailers and consignment creates a barrier than many can’t cross,” she said.  

Sia Maravelias, director of Quadrum in Boston understands that struggle, but realizes consignment is a valuable part of any business structure. “[Consignment] is a risky business. In the same regard, it is a risky business for the retailer who has huge overhead. The retailer is responsible for carrying the weight of, at times, a very large, expensive lease, sales associates’ salaries, advertising and promotional expenses. Even when no one walks through the door, the retailer is working hard to reach out to customers, create new opportunities for sales and promoting new work.”  

It’s helpful to have Sia’s perspective as the jewelry store where she works is known for actually seeking and getting back to new talent. Her intent is not only to support her customers but also her artists.

Jewelry designer Todd Reed agrees: “It’s important if a designer is to use consignment, to do it in such a manner that will support both retailer and designer. New designers or experienced designers struggling to find reasonable distribution channels can get pied in the face by the promise of a healthy consignment door. Remember the un-turned inventory sitting on the books is still inventory even in someone else’s store. If consignment can work it’s good, but for a new or growing designer I think it’s a poor model to start with.”

The inventory issue
With the increasing cost of gold, many retailers have had trouble keeping up with inventory turn. Demand for product has increased steadily over the years, but not at the speed of the rising material costs.  

Instead of having extra cash flow to discover new talent, most retailers are crushed with trying to turn pieces they’ve had in stock. Keeping product on consignment allows them to tackle this hurdle while still supporting emerging designers. Jewelry designer Alexis Barbeau, who is part of the CJDG, has had many years’ experience with the ups and downs of the economy and the lessons that have come with each cycle. She understands the give-and-take that needs to be established with her retail partners.

“If done right, consignment can be an extremely beneficial arrangement for both parties. If the retailer is responsible, approaches the exchange as a partnership and meets their end of the obligation, it can help you expose your work to a new audience and actually can increase sales in the long run,” she said.

It’s also extremely important to see the inventory issue from the perspective of a designer. If a designer is sending out the majority of their work on consignment, it ties up their cash flow to build new product and the new product development cycle is halted.
 
Leeorah Betan-Hartman from Lulu & Shay realizes the focus needs to fall on the importance of communication between each party.

“I have been in situations where an owner may fall in love with some of my more expensive pieces and ask them to stock them in their store on consignment,” she said. “I then need to trust that the retailer will truly understand their customer and knows what will sell, otherwise at the end of the season I will be stuck with stock of highly expensive goods that have been returned.”  

Communication seems to be the much bigger lesson we could all benefit from as our industry is in trouble on both sides. The number of U.S. jewelers who closed their doors last year climbed 24 percent--not a good sign of things to come unless some serious changes are made.

Balance
As most of my previous articles can attest, I’m a big believer in balance. Shops that adhere to only one type of buying strategy are putting themselves and their talent at a disadvantage.

It should be noted that two reputable retailers I reached out to who only take work on consignment refused to comment for my article--perhaps they inherently understand that their model will only continue to run for so long before they need to implement a more balanced viewpoint.

In my opinion, consignment needs to be put back in its place: to be used only as a tool. If you aren’t buying any new inventory from designers, well I hate to break to you, but you are a part of the problem.  

I’ve been fairly open and honest about my struggles through the years. Do I have a huge wholesale business? Absolutely not, and a lot of that has to do with the financial constraints associated with entry into market. Some retailers have said they won’t even look at a new designer unless they’ve displayed their wares at three to four trade shows. Who is fronting the money for that expense?  

And just because a designer has only done one trade show thus far, does that make them any less talented? That is a huge risk that, unfortunately, new talent is expected to face and those like myself, without an angel investor or trust fund to cash out, have to build each collection organically and over time.  

I started my jewelry journey in 2005 and I’ll be ready to start wholesale trade shows this year, 11 years later. Is that the experience that new talent had to go through in previous years? Perhaps.  

The reality is that we are in a luxury business that is aesthetically challenged at the moment. While it’s true that established designers continue to push the envelope, it’s disheartening to watch new talent consistently water down their work in the hopes of building collections that sell. Even retailers have taken note. In many recent conversations I hear that they are “bored” and there is “too much of the same.”

I ask each jeweler to serious consider a massive spring cleaning.  

What has been sitting in your inventory in the back room or safe for more than five years that is just taking up space and has no sentimental value? What can be melted down for cash flow increases? When was the last time you made a new designer’s day?  

And to the designers I say much of the same. Are you truly treating your retailers as partners rather than a separate team? What are you doing to help them with their inventory constraints? Are you able to restock your product line at reasonable fees to give the store more variety each season? Do you have an annual budget devoted to consignment?

And to both, I ask them to consider trunk shows. It’s an excellent way to try out someone new and see in real time how your audience reacts to his or her work. Even if it doesn’t work out you’ve created an event that is worthy of both your customers’ attention: You’re trying something new.

Jacqueline Stone has a background in finance, marketing, advertising, product development, fine jewelry manufacturing, design and sourcing. She currently is the chief creative officer of her company, Salt + Stone, working primarily with private clients to build custom engagement rings and wedding bands. Stone can be reached at shine@saltandstone.com.
Jacqueline Stoneis a recovering jewelry designer who now works in marketing and runs her own e-commerce site, TotemsandTarot.com.

The Latest

Stock image of people shopping in a mall
SurveysApr 03, 2025
2025 Retail Sales to Grow More Slowly Amid ‘Uncertainty,’ Says NRF

The National Retail Federation expects retail sales growth to return to pre-pandemic levels as consumers continue to face inflation.

158.2-carat yellow diamond from Diavik
SourcingApr 03, 2025
Canadian Mine Produces 158-Carat Yellow Diamond

Rio Tinto unearthed the diamond at its Diavik mine in Canada’s Northwest Territories.

Buccellati Naturalia exhibition
CollectionsApr 03, 2025
Buccellati to Open Immersive Exhibition in Milan

The multisensory experience, open April 8-13, will feature the brand’s silver creations among dream-like scenes of natural landscapes.

bench jeweler 1872x1052.png
Brought to you by
The Heart of the Industry: Giving Bench Jewelers the Recognition They Deserve

Bench jewelers spend years honing their skills, Jewelers of America’s Certification validates their talents.

Jewelers of America logo
Policies & IssuesApr 03, 2025
Jewelers of America to Hold Webinar on Tariffs

The virtual event will take place April 7 at 3 p.m.

Weekly QuizApr 03, 2025
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Bea Bongiasca Animali Tarallo Collection Royal Blue Tang Fish “Dory”
CollectionsApr 02, 2025
Bea Bongiasca’s ‘Tarallo’ Collection Expansion Is a Zoo

The pieces in “Animali Tarallo” portray animals from stingrays to elephants through portraits and interpretations of their patterns.

Neiman Marcus Downtown Dallas store
MajorsApr 02, 2025
Neiman Marcus’ Dallas Flagship Will Remain Open, For Now

Parent company Saks Global said the iconic location will be open through the holiday season as it decides what to do with the space.

Facets-of-Fire-Difference-You-Can-See.jpg
Brought to you by
Natural Diamonds Should Mean More

Natural diamonds mean more than lab-grown, but when every cut is ideal, they all look the same. Customers want more—Facets of Fire delivers.

Natural color diamonds on display at Smithsonian National Museum of History
SourcingApr 02, 2025
Winston’s Collection of Natural Color Diamonds Now on Display in D.C.

Ronald Winston, son of Harry Winston, donated the diamonds to the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C.

Punchmark
Events & AwardsApr 02, 2025
Punchmark to Host Client Workshop

The educational event will take place in Charlotte, North Carolina, this May.

Bergman Jewelers family
IndependentsApr 01, 2025
Bergman Jewelers in Omaha Closing After 137 Years

The independent jeweler first opened its doors in 1888.

QVC Group Inc. logo
MajorsApr 01, 2025
QVC Group to Cut 900 Jobs in the U.S.

The layoffs come amid the TV shopping channel’s efforts to restructure and focus on live shopping through social media.

Coconut Grove Jewelry & Watch Show
Events & AwardsApr 01, 2025
U.S. Antique Shows Adds Fall Show in Florida

The debut event will take place in Miami’s Coconut Grove neighborhood this fall.

The Jewelry Symposium (TJS)
Events & AwardsApr 01, 2025
TJS to Host Discussion on Jewelry Industry’s Labor Shortage

The roundtable will take place May 17 ahead of the trade show’s welcome dinner.

Peanuts x Monica Rich Kosann Collection Bracelets
CollectionsApr 01, 2025
Monica Rich Kosann Says ‘Good Grief’ in Peanuts Jewelry Collection

The “Peanuts x Monica Rich Kosann” collection features the comic strip’s classic vocabulary across 10 bracelet designs.

Graphic for What Do We Mean When We Say “Recycled” Gold webinar
Recorded WebinarsMar 31, 2025
Watch: What Do We Mean When We Say ‘Recycled’ Gold?

Three industry experts dive into the complexities of the material often marketed as an “ethical” alternative for metal in jewelry.

Lashbrook ring
MajorsMar 31, 2025
Lashbrook Expands Into Luxury Golf Gifts With Acquisition

The Utah-based company known for making wedding bands has acquired Doubloon Golf.

Bulgari and LVMH Watches CEO Jean-Christophe Babin
WatchesMar 31, 2025
Bulgari CEO Jean-Christophe Babin Will Also Head LVMH Watches

The longtime luxury executive led one of LVMH’s watch brands, TAG Heuer, for 12 years before taking over Bulgari in 2013.

Surveillance footage of robbery
CrimeMar 28, 2025
2 Suspects Arrested in $1.7M Smash-and-Grab Robbery of NY Jewelry Store

Authorities said the robbers fled with jewelry and 70 Rolex watches, later taking pictures of themselves posing with big stacks of cash.

Nephrite and Jadeite by Heinrich Fischer, Richard W. Hughes
SourcingMar 28, 2025
19th-Century Jade Book Now Available in English

Lotus Gemology founder Richard W. Hughes has translated Heinrich Fischer’s 1880 book “Nephrit und Jadeit” from its original German.

LÖF The Valentine Ring
CollectionsMar 28, 2025
Piece of the Week: Löf’s ‘The Valentine’ Ring

The ring's design features contrasting lines influenced by work from architecture-inspired photographer Nikola Olic.

Eggs on a shelf
SurveysMar 27, 2025
Consumer Confidence Falls in March Amid ‘Gloomy’ Outlook

The Conference Board’s index fell as consumers continued to worry about the impact of tariffs, the labor market, and the price of eggs.

Richard Rainsford memorial ring
AuctionsMar 27, 2025
300-Year-Old Ring Linked to Witch Trial Judge Goes Unsold at Auction

However, two medieval jewels surpassed estimates at Noonans Mayfair’s recent jewelry auction in London.

Austin Butler
WatchesMar 27, 2025
Austin Butler Joins Breitling as Brand Ambassador

The Oscar-nominated actor debuted in the campaign for the new “Top Time B31” collection, which introduced Breitling’s Caliber B31.

ICA Congress Brazil 2025
SourcingMar 27, 2025
Susan Jacques, Gaetano Cavalieri to Headline 2025 ICA Congress

The Congress is scheduled to take place May 19-22 in Brasilia, Brazil.

Bailey’s Fine Jewelry storefront
IndependentsMar 26, 2025
Bailey’s Fine Jewelry Acquires Fellow NC Independent Jeweler

The family-owned retailer is the new owner of Morrison Smith Jewelers in Charlotte, North Carolina.

Bulova 150 Art Deco Miss America Watch, 150 Art Deco Pocket Watch
WatchesMar 26, 2025
Bulova Celebrates 150th Anniversary With Art Deco Watches

The “150 Art Deco” collection features a Miss America timepiece and a pocket watch from the brand’s Archive Series.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy