AuctionsDec 18, 2025
Audemars Piguet Reclaims Historic Pocket Watch at AuctionIt purchased the “Grosse Pièce,” an ultra-complicated Audemars Piguet pocket watch from the ‘20s, for a record-breaking price at Sotheby’s.
SourcingJan 07, 2014
Court tosses WB David claim against De Beers
A federal judge in New York has dismissed W.B. David & Co. Inc.’s lingering claim in its 10-year-old case against De Beers’ rough diamond sales arm, the last outstanding antitrust case against the diamond miner and marketer in the United States.
New York--A federal judge in New York has dismissed W.B. David & Co. Inc.’s lingering claim in its 10-year-old case against De Beers’ rough diamond sales arm, the last outstanding antitrust case against the diamond miner and marketer in the United States.
On Monday, U.S. District Judge Kimba M. Wood ruled that the now-bankrupt diamond company failed to prove that the sightholder system of De Beers’ Diamond Trading Co. (DTC) constituted a monopoly and constrained sightholders’ business practices.
She ordered the case dismissed with prejudice, meaning it cannot be reopened.
De Beers said in an emailed statement that it welcomed Wood’s decision, and noted that the judge also denied a request to file another amended complaint and ordered the case closed, marking the end of the last antitrust suit against De Beers in the U.S.
Yann Geron, one of the attorneys representing the Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee now handling the estate of W.B. David & Co., did not respond to request for comment made late Tuesday.
According to background provided in court documents, New York-based diamond company W.B. David was a De Beers sightholder for more than three decades, from 1969 until it was dropped in 2003.
In 2004, W.B. David filed a $100 million lawsuit against a total of 90 defendants, including De Beers and the DTC. Counts included in the original complaint were racketeering, violation of antitrust laws and unfair competition, among many others.
Over the years, the case was whittled down and, along the way, W.B. David was forced into bankruptcy, leaving its trustee to head the case.
In 2011, the case was thrown out of court entirely but the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York later ruled that one claim, the “sight claim” could proceed, court papers show.
The claim alleges that the sight system of the DTC, as well as its predecessor, CSO Valuations, violated antitrust laws and that De Beers and its diamond brokers conspired to control sightholders’ business practices. It was, W.B. David contended, an “unlawful vertical restraint, and that W.B. David incurred damages by purchasing rough diamonds from [the Diamond Trading Co.] at artificially inflated prices.”
In her ruling issued Monday, Wood stated that the sight claim does not adequately allege a conspiracy resulting in an unreasonable restraint on trade nor does it prove the sightholder system was a monopoly.
“Even assuming defendant possessed monopoly power
in the relevant market, the sight claim does not allege that defendant’s sight system was anticompetitive,” court papers state. “No assertion is made, for instance, that the sight system excluded potential competitors or impaired the opportunities of rival firms.”
The judge said the factors W.B. David said made the sight system harmful to competition--the fact that only certain companies were selected as sightholders, rough diamonds were pre-selected and sightholders were forced to take their boxes and communicate through brokers--do not suggest exclusionary or anticompetitive conduct.
“As a general rule, businesses are free to choose the parties with whom they will deal, as well as the prices, terms and conditions of that dealing,” the ruling states.
In May 2008, De Beers reached a $295 million settlement in the huge antitrust case brought against it here by diamond purchasers, including retailers, wholesalers and consumers.
Purchasers accused the diamond giant of monopolizing supply and conspiring to fix prices. De Beers admitted no fault in the settlement, and the closure of the antitrust case opened the door for De Beers to operate openly in the U.S. market.
Due to numerous appeals, payouts in the case were still continuing as of last year.
More on Sourcing
The Latest
EditorsDec 18, 2025
Terry Chandler Looks Back on 40 Years of Opportunity, Change, and FriendsChandler got his start at Michelson Jewelers and has served as DCA president and CEO since 2001. He will retire at the end of the month.
Supplier BulletinDec 18, 2025
Cell Jammers Are Targeting Your Business. Here's How to Beat ThemSponsored by Digital Monitoring Products
Brought to you by
Impacting Tomorrow TodayHow Jewelers of America’s 20 Under 40 are leading to ensure a brighter future for the jewelry industry.
WatchesDec 18, 2025
Bob’s Watches to Open Store in New York’s JFK AirportThe boutique is slated to open this week inside Terminal 8, offering pre-owned Rolex watches and more to international travelers.
Weekly QuizDec 18, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Lab-GrownDec 18, 2025
Kira Jewels Debuts Custom Lab-Grown Diamond Jewelry ServiceThe lab-grown diamond grower now offers custom engagement and fashion jewelry through its Kira Custom Lab Jewelry service.
CrimeDec 17, 2025
Man Pleads Not Guilty to Swallowing Fabergé PendantThe special-edition egg pendant ingested in a New Zealand jewelry store was recovered after a six-day wait.
Brought to you by
Roseco Releases New Full-Line CatalogRoseco’s 704-page catalog showcases new lab-grown diamonds, findings, tools & more—available in print or interactive digital editions.
EditorsDec 17, 2025
2025 Jewelry Rewind: The Best Piece of the Week PicksAssociate Editor Natalie Francisco plays favorites with Piece of the Week, selecting a standout piece of jewelry from each month of 2025.
CollectionsDec 17, 2025
Lucy Hale Stars in Jacquie Aiche’s Holiday CampaignThe “Love and Desire” campaign is inspired by the magic that follows when one’s heart leads the way, said the brand.
GradingDec 17, 2025
SSEF Announces 2025 Scholarship WinnersTwo awardees will receive free tuition for an educational course at the Swiss lab, with flights and lodging included.
MajorsDec 16, 2025
Pandora’s New CEO Will Step Up EarlyBerta de Pablos-Barbier will replace Alexander Lacik at the start of January, two months earlier than expected.
AuctionsDec 16, 2025
Suzanne Belperron, JAR Shine in Sotheby’s First Auctions at New HQSotheby’s held its first two jewelry sales at the Breuer building last week, and they totaled nearly $44 million.
Events & AwardsDec 16, 2025
TJS Now Accepting Scholarship Applications for 2026Winners will receive free registration and lodging for its fourth annual event in Detroit.
ColumnistsDec 16, 2025
Beyond Unboxing: Creative Reveals to Drive Reach and EngagementHere are six ideas for making more engaging content for Instagram Reels and TikTok, courtesy of Duvall O’Steen and Jen Cullen Williams.
Events & AwardsDec 16, 2025
Diamonds Do Good Names 2026 Award RecipientsThe honorees include a notable jewelry brand, an industry veteran, and an independent retailer.
CrimeDec 15, 2025
Men Receive Life Sentences in Home Invasion Murder of Jeweler Carlos Jose Hernandez and Joshua Zuazo were sentenced to life without the possibility of parole in the 2024 murder of Hussein “Sam” Murray.
Policies & IssuesDec 15, 2025
Sara Yood Named Co-Chair of RJC Standards CommitteeYood will serve alongside Eduard Stefanescu, the sustainability manager for C.Hafner, a precious metals refiner in Germany.
IndependentsDec 15, 2025
M.S. Rau to Open Store in AspenThe New Orleans jeweler is also hosting pop-up jewelry boutiques in New York City and Dallas.
AuctionsDec 12, 2025
13.54-Carat Paraíba Tourmaline Sets Records at Christie’sSet in a Tiffany & Co. necklace, it sold for $4.2 million, the highest price and price per carat paid for a Paraíba tourmaline at auction.
MajorsDec 12, 2025
David Webb Reveals Ice-Cold Holiday Window DisplayThe jeweler’s “Deep Freeze” display showcases its iconic jewelry designs frozen in a vintage icebox.
CollectionsDec 12, 2025
Piece of the Week: Oscar Heyman’s Sphene RingTake luxury gifting to new heights this holiday season with the jeweler’s showstopping 12-carat sphene ring.
Events & AwardsDec 12, 2025
IGI Jewelry Design Contest Now Accepting SubmissionsThis year's theme is “Unveiling the Depths of the Ocean.”
TrendsDec 11, 2025
Pinterest 2026 Trend Report: Brooches, Bold Gold, Cool BlueIn its annual report, Pinterest noted an increase in searches for brooches, heirloom jewelry, and ‘80s luxury.
GradingDec 11, 2025
GIA to Offer Origin Determination for 3 More GemstonesStarting Jan. 1, customers can request the service for opal, peridot, and demantoid garnet.
IndependentsDec 11, 2025
Look Inside Day’s Jewelers’ Ninth StoreThe 111-year-old retailer celebrated the opening of its new location in Salem, New Hampshire, which is its third store in the state.
MajorsDec 11, 2025
Americas Gold Releases New Gold Chain CatalogThe new catalog features its most popular chains as well as new styles.
