SurveysApr 24, 2026
Mother’s Day 2026 Jewelry Spending to Top $7B, NRF SaysNRF’s annual survey found that 45 percent of consumers plan to purchase jewelry for a loved one this Mother’s Day.
EditorsSep 19, 2017
South Dakota, Online Sales Tax and the Supreme Court
Last week, South Dakota’s highest court shot down Senate Bill 106. Here’s why it matters in the ongoing fight over internet tax.
Unless you’re one of the 800,000-plus residents of South Dakota, it’s unlikely you’ve heard much about Senate Bill 106.
Introduced in the state legislature by a bipartisan group of seven senators and eight representatives last year, S.B. 106 mandates that companies that make more than $100,000 in sales or have more than 200 transactions per calendar year in South Dakota remit sales tax, whether they have a physical presence in the state or not.
In introducing the bill, legislators argued that, first, the state needs the revenue it’s missing from online sales and, second, that the current law of the land, so to speak--Quill Corp. v. North Dakota--needs to be re-evaluated.
Quill is the U.S. Supreme Court ruling from 1992 that prevents states from collecting sales tax from sellers with no physical presence in the state; the overarching argument of internet tax proponents everywhere is that this 25-year-old law is now wildly outdated given how consumers shop today.
S.B. 106 passed both houses with little opposition and South Dakota’s Republican governor, Dennis Daugaard, signed it into law in March 2016.
It wasn’t long after the bill’s passage that three online retailers, Overstock.com Inc., WayFair Inc. and NewEgg Inc., pushed back and the case wound its way through South Dakota’s legal system, landing with the state Supreme Court in short order.
Salt Lake City-based Overstock.com sells a variety of merchandise, including fine jewelry, ranking among the $100 Million Supersellers in the 2016 State of the Majors report and, spoiler alert, in the soon-to-be-published 2017 edition as well.
WayFair, meanwhile, is a Boston-based online seller of furniture and home décor, and City of Industry, California-headquartered NewEgg is an electronics retailer.
In a ruling issued last Wednesday authored by Chief Justice David Gilbertson, the court sided with the e-tailers, stating that: “However persuasive the state’s arguments on the merits of revisiting the issue, Quill has not been overruled. Quill remains the controlling precedent on the issue of Commerce Clause limitations on interstate collection of sales and use taxes.”
Despite the court’s siding with the internet sellers, Chris Fetzer of Haake Fetzer, the firm that lobbies for Jewelers of America on behalf of the industry in Washington, said that the authors of the bill do not view the ruling as a failure.
It is, in fact, exactly what they wanted.
“It was fully expected that it (S.B. 106) would be challenged as illegal. This law was written to be challenged within
Editors' Picks
Sponsored by
the court such that that the challenge could serve as a vehicle for the U.S. Supreme Court’s reconsideration of the Quill decision,” Fetzer told me Monday, adding that similar actions are being taken in other states, including Indiana and Alabama.
What has compelled them is a recent statement from U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy in the DMA vs. Brohl case, which reads in part: “[T]he internet has caused far-reaching systemic and structural changes in the economy” so that “a business may be present in a state in a meaningful way without that presence being physical in the traditional sense of the word.”
He said that it is “unwise [for the U.S. Supreme Court] to delay any longer a reconsideration of the court’s holding in Quill.”
I reached out to Overstock.com, the lone jewelry retailer out of the three, for comment on the ruling and Kennedy’s comments late Monday afternoon.
The company was not able to respond by press time, but board Chairman Jonathan Johnson told Bloomberg that proponents of online sales tax are putting too much emphasis on that statement from Kennedy and have no assurances that the U.S. Supreme Court will take up the case or, if it does, rule in their favor and overturn Quill.
I think the statement from Justice Kennedy is pretty clear, but Johnson is right about one thing: There is no guarantee that the Supreme Court will decide to hear the case, though the chances increase if more states get involved.
Fetzer said typically, what most attracts the Supreme Court to take up a case is a “circuit split,” when multiple federal appeals courts have ruled in conflict on a given issue.
That is not at play in this instance, but what also can be attractive is when there’s an issue that multiple states are concerned about, which could happen here as more states could join South Dakota in petitioning the Supreme Court to review Quill.
Johnson also is right about another thing: There is no guarantee the court will rule to overturn Quill even if it does take up the case.
But, Fetzer points out, Kennedy’s comments indicate that he would be in favor of changing Quill and the court’s newest justice, Neil Gorsuch, also has expressed his support for the arguments that have long been put forth by internet sales tax proponents.
The court’s next term commences in October, so there’s a chance it could revisit the Quill decision between next month and June 2018.
We’ll keep you posted.
What has compelled them is a recent statement from U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy in the DMA vs. Brohl case, which reads in part: “[T]he internet has caused far-reaching systemic and structural changes in the economy” so that “a business may be present in a state in a meaningful way without that presence being physical in the traditional sense of the word.”
He said that it is “unwise [for the U.S. Supreme Court] to delay any longer a reconsideration of the court’s holding in Quill.”
I reached out to Overstock.com, the lone jewelry retailer out of the three, for comment on the ruling and Kennedy’s comments late Monday afternoon.
The company was not able to respond by press time, but board Chairman Jonathan Johnson told Bloomberg that proponents of online sales tax are putting too much emphasis on that statement from Kennedy and have no assurances that the U.S. Supreme Court will take up the case or, if it does, rule in their favor and overturn Quill.
I think the statement from Justice Kennedy is pretty clear, but Johnson is right about one thing: There is no guarantee that the Supreme Court will decide to hear the case, though the chances increase if more states get involved.
Fetzer said typically, what most attracts the Supreme Court to take up a case is a “circuit split,” when multiple federal appeals courts have ruled in conflict on a given issue.
That is not at play in this instance, but what also can be attractive is when there’s an issue that multiple states are concerned about, which could happen here as more states could join South Dakota in petitioning the Supreme Court to review Quill.
Johnson also is right about another thing: There is no guarantee the court will rule to overturn Quill even if it does take up the case.
But, Fetzer points out, Kennedy’s comments indicate that he would be in favor of changing Quill and the court’s newest justice, Neil Gorsuch, also has expressed his support for the arguments that have long been put forth by internet sales tax proponents.
The court’s next term commences in October, so there’s a chance it could revisit the Quill decision between next month and June 2018.
We’ll keep you posted.
More on Editors
The Latest
TechnologyApr 24, 2026
TwentyFour’s Digital-Age Locket Is a Virtual VaultThe “Vault” charm, our Piece of the Week, expands on the memories that can be stored in a locket by connecting to your phone.
Events & AwardsApr 24, 2026
Hamptons Jewelry Show to Return in JulyThe open-to-the-public luxury jewelry and timepiece show, in its second year, is slated for July 23-26.
Brought to you by
Discover Timeless Treasures: A Showcase of Antique Jewelry & Timepieces in Las VegasGain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.
IndependentsApr 23, 2026
Meet the Real Moms of Day’s JewelersThe jeweler’s Mother’s Day campaign highlights the women who work there—mothers, grandmothers, women who want to be mothers, and dog moms.
Weekly QuizApr 23, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Supplier BulletinApr 23, 2026
JM® Shipping Solution: Smarter Shipping for High-Value GoodsSponsored by Jewelers Mutual
Lab-GrownApr 23, 2026
Charles & Colvard May Sell Assets for $1.5MThe proposed agreement follows the moissanite maker’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection filing last month.
Brought to you by
Las Vegas Antique Jewelry & Watch Show: Showcasing the Most Collectible Merchandise from Across the GlobeGain access to the most exclusive and coveted antique pieces from trusted dealers during Las Vegas Jewelry Week.
AuctionsApr 23, 2026
John Jacob Astor IV’s Titanic Pocket Watch Fetches $1MThe Patek Philippe for Tiffany & Co. timepiece Astor brought aboard the ill-fated ship sold for double its estimate at a Freeman’s auction.
CollectionsApr 23, 2026
Adam Neeley’s High Jewelry Collection Steps Into Salvador Dalí’s GardenThe “Dalí’s Garden” collection was inspired by a surreal dream Neeley had after cooking a recipe from Salvador Dalí’s 1973 cookbook.
IndependentsApr 23, 2026
Windsor Jewelers Names New Buying DirectorNatalie Feanny has been appointed to the role.
CrimeApr 22, 2026
New Mexico Couple Pleads Guilty to Selling Fake Native American JewelryThe pair falsely claimed their jewelry was made by Navajo artists, but it was imported from Vietnam.
AuctionsApr 22, 2026
Roberta Flack’s Jewelry Is Going Up for AuctionJulien’s Auctions is selling the musician’s fine and fashion jewelry alongside her clothing, gold records, and other memorabilia.
CollectionsApr 22, 2026
British Museum Curator Pens Book on ‘The Tudor Heart’Rachel King’s book dives into the history of the pendant believed to have belonged to Henry VIII and his first wife, Katherine of Aragon.
Events & AwardsApr 22, 2026
Here’s What Sy Kessler Has on Tap for Las Vegas The company will have deals on precious metals testers as well as the latest in lab-grown diamond detection technology and security.
WatchesApr 21, 2026
Coco Chanel Enters the Game with New Watch CollectionGabrielle “Coco” Chanel is a character in the “Coco Game” collection of watches and the queen in its first haute horlogerie chessboard.
IndependentsApr 21, 2026
Meet Jewelers of America’s 2026 ‘20 Under 40’ ClassThe annual list honors rising professionals on the retail and supply sides of the jewelry industry.
CrimeApr 21, 2026
Customs Nabs 1,500 Pieces of Counterfeit Jewelry Bound for NYCSeized in Kentucky, the packages include fake Cartier, Tiffany & Co., Chanel, and Fendi jewelry.
CrimeApr 20, 2026
Queens Man Convicted in Bludgeoning Death of Pawn Shop OwnerRodolfo Lopez-Portillo faces 25 years to life in prison after being found guilty in the March 2022 beating death of Arasb Shoughi.
TrendsApr 20, 2026
Beth Bernstein, Sonia Esther Soltani Pen New Jewelry Book“Jewelry Creators: Dynamic Duos and Generational Gems” highlights the relationships among 22 influential designers, brands, and gem dealers.
Events & AwardsApr 20, 2026
Atlanta Jewelry Show’s Spring Event Is Hitting the RoadThe AJS Spring 2027 show will be held in Savannah, Georgia, with future shows taking place in other Southeast cities.
MajorsApr 20, 2026
Kendra Scott Names New CFO, Chief Business OfficerThe jewelry retailer plans to open 20 new stores this year and expand into new product categories.
TrendsApr 17, 2026
New (Groundbreaking) Floral Jewelry for Spring 2026Flower motifs are the jewelry trend blooming amongst the new collections that debuted this spring.
MajorsApr 17, 2026
QVC Group Files for Chapter 11 BankruptcyThe retailer reported an 8 percent decline in annual sales as it struggles under the weight of billions of dollars of debt.
CollectionsApr 17, 2026
Edina Kiss’ Earrings Are the Devil on Your ShoulderThe “Devil” drop earrings, our Piece of the Week, are part of designer Edina Kiss’ new namesake jewelry line that she will show at Couture.
CrimeApr 17, 2026
FBI Issues Warning to Refineries, Retailers Due to High Price of GoldThe alert states that burglary crews are targeting jewelry businesses and details how jewelers and refineries can protect themselves.
WatchesApr 16, 2026
Cartier Brings Back the RoadsterThe “watchmaker of shapes” debuted the reworked version of the vintage sports car-inspired timepiece at Watches & Wonders.
