What Will Become of Retail Jewelry Stores?

IndependentsApr 12, 2016

What Will Become of Retail Jewelry Stores?

Peter Smith doesn’t claim to have all the answers but knows where the conversation should start. This is part one of a two-part column.

Peter Smith has more than 30 years of experience building wholesale and retail sales teams. He currently is president of Vibhor Gems.

In a study, 94 percent of respondents identified themselves as having an above-average sense of humor, wrote Rod Martin in The Psychology of Humor. It is a poignant reminder of the difficulty, perhaps even the impossibility, of being objective about one’s self or, for the purpose of this column, one’s business.

I was reminded of that earlier this year as I flew back from a few days in Arizona, where I met and spoke with large numbers of retailer and wholesaler friends at two different trade shows.

Amidst the usual small talk was an undercurrent of uncertainty--occasionally exciting, more often unnerving--about where our respective businesses and our industry is headed.

The very day that I started writing this column there was yet another announcement of a jeweler closing his doors (two doors to be exact) for good. When I arrived in this country in 1983, there were about 40,000 points of sale for retail jewelry. Today, depending on exactly what you count, I expect that number is closer to 16,000. We are clearly in the throes of a fundamental shift in retail and few should be surprised that jewelry stores are taking it squarely on the chin.

Before this year is out, there is every reason to believe that many more jewelry stores will be gone. Some of those stores will be multi-generational, others will have been founded by the current operators. Some will be branded and others still will have existed, until they no longer could, on the strength of their custom work and the promise of great service.

Despite the major contraction of retail jewelry stores, few seem to believe that they will be next to bow out having, in many instances, survived for generations. I can’t help but remember one North Carolina retailer who used to boast that his grandmother had steered his business through the Great Depression, only for the business to finally close on his watch. The lousy lighting, low-energy staff and his own continuous admonitions of doom-and-gloom long forgotten, as he unceremoniously and unknowingly crafted his own demise.

At the opposite end of the spectrum there exists a quiet, mostly unspoken delusion that somehow things will eventually get better. We’ll somehow manage to overcome the economic headwinds and the customers will surely come to their senses and realize that the web is just no substitute for the myriad of great things
that we can offer inside our brick-and-mortar stores.

Doug Stephens wrote a very compelling book last year, The Retail Revival. The book is a serious study of what retail might look like in the future and, quite honestly, it should be required reading for retailers and for any business that depends on retailers to make a living.

His basic premise is that retailers will have to make a very clear decision about what they want to be--either entirely and expertly price-driven, with all the attendant challenges of being the low-cost provider, or they must fully and completely embrace the high end of the landscape, with great quality, differentiated products delivered in a very focused way and a great customer experience.

Stephens argues that the space in the middle, where I believe the vast majority of retail jewelers reside, will, quite simply, go away. (On a trip to Ohio recently, I had one retailer tell me that his store’s mantra is to be “the best quality and the lowest price.” There isn’t enough head shaking to go around on that one, but he might be the poster child for that space in the middle.)

Whether Stephens is right in predicting that retailers will have to decide which end of the spectrum to operate, price or high-quality, is neither here nor there. Like him, there are a whole host of writers, academics, marketers and business people who will prophesize on future of retail and nothing but the future itself will reveal how right or wrong they were.

Fueled by my own endless curiosity on the topic, and by the many recent conversations about the future of retail jewelers, I felt compelled to write down some thoughts that you might find interesting as you consider your own business.

The list is not intended to be exhaustive; I will leave discussion of financials, real estate and the like to the many who are better informed than I on those matters.

And, I suspect, some of the topics may raise more questions than provide answers. They are, however, important discussion points, and if they provide some modicum of clarity on your strengths and/or weaknesses then I’ll consider the effort to have been worthwhile.

What do you want to be when you grow up (and why should I care?)
What is your vision for your business and how does that align with the realities of today’s retail landscape? If the best you can offer is “we provide quality and service,” than your vision is blurred. Not because quality and service don’t matter, because they do. In fact, I would argue that they have never been more important. However, you need a focused story (recognized brands and potentially your own branded story, which does not mean everything in the store that does not otherwise have a name) that will resonate with consumers.

If I were to sum up Stephens’s message in one sentence, I would say that if you are trying to be all things to all people, you are, or soon will be, in big trouble. Robin Lewis and Michael Dart write in The New Rules of Retail, “In the future, retailing will be about narrowing assortments and reducing vendors and wholesale brands to drive greater control, productivity and profitability.” The days of having everything are over.

If I am one of the 80 million millennials, why should I care about your business? Why would I want to work there or shop there? Why would I want to take selfies in your store, post pictures of me wearing your products on Instagram? Why would I want to WhatsApp my friends about how cool your store is? What makes your story relevant to me?

If you do not have a strategy to engage millennials as employees and customers your relevance is already on the wane and the trip down the hill will be fast and painful. According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, millennials wield $200 billion of direct purchasing power and $500 billion in indirect spending. By 2017, they will become the largest spending group, as they overtake the baby boomers.

Despite that sobering thought, I still meet retailers who tell me that millennials don’t spend, are still living with their parents, are knee-deep in college debt, etc. The oldest millennials are having children now and any business owner who believes he or she can thrive without engaging them is headed in the wrong direction.

Being a multi-generational business has a nice ring to it, but it has absolutely nothing to do with relevance. Our kids do not frequent Apple, Starbucks or Zara because they have been around for generations. I would even argue that they do not frequent Nordstrom or Tiffany & Co. because of their proud heritages. They frequent those stores because they have found a way to be relevant to them, not because they’ve been around for 115 and 180 years, respectively.

Being around a long time does not create entitlement to business or relevance. It didn’t help Woolworths or Montgomery Ward and it isn’t helping Sears. It also did not help many of the 750 retail jewelry stores that exited stage-left last year. If you can’t identify your reason for being beyond “we provide the best service” or “we’ve been in this community for 100 years” than you cannot reasonably expect your target customers to care enough to give you their business.

Kill your sacred cows
I am a huge fan of The Profit, with Marcus Lemonis, and I am a devotee of his simple mantra of people, product and process. If you’ve never seen it, I would strongly recommend that you binge-watch it on CNBC.

His genius, as with others of his ilk, is in his remarkable capacity for simplification. He identifies the challenges and opportunities and quickly sheds those elements (products, processes and people) that provide little value in the overall scheme of things. He wants the businesses that he invests in to be great at something and to clearly communicate that something through all aspects of their operation: people, products, processes, marketing, etc.

Have you been carrying less-than-effective people? Do they align with your vision and strategy? If your people can’t move the bar, they should be invited to engage in another line of work as soon as possible. For more on this, I unapologetically refer you to read my book, Hiring Squirrels, available on Amazon. It’s an easy read. Other great books on this topic include First, Break All The Rules (Marcus Buckingham) and Good To Great (Jim Collins).

Your people have to be great, and there is no excuse for not building a great team. It can be done and it should be done, but you just might have to change the way you have been doing it up to now.

I have long believed that those retailers who survive in our industry will be smaller and more nimble. They will not be buried under 5,000 feet of mostly irrelevant stuff, but they will have an energized and focused product offering that is clearly and consistently communicated to their current and prospective customers. It will more reflect a high-end duty-free shop in a great international airport than the standard jewelry store model. It will have a limited number of brands and stories and each will be deep and narrow in scope. The more stuff you show, the less people will see.

Again I would refer to Tiffany. We tend to think of them as having been born with their blue box and the birthright to the all things great in our industry. The reality is, of course, that Tiffany has grown from just a handful of stores in the ‘80s to almost 300 stores today. They didn’t get there by replicating what was then the Fifth and 57th flagship store in New York; they reinvented themselves with leaner, more focused stories that reflected the best of what they were doing (Elsa Peretti, Paloma Picasso, etc.) and by eschewing the areas of their business that were not as relevant, like tabletop and giftware. All the while, they focused on story-telling and great merchandising, two powerful elements that every retail store ought to embrace.

Ask yourself what finite number of stories (brands, including your own) you want to tell and stock narrow and deep (why would you ever be out of stock on a bestseller and yet I see it every single day?).

The second part of that story, unless you are just opening a new store, is to be merciless in eliminating products that do not align with your vision. They are a distraction for all the wrong reasons and despite your best intentions when you bought or made them, they are probably not going to be any more interesting a year from now or two years from now than they are today.  

The last part of this section is to kill all processes that are dated, unnecessary or unrelated to driving your business closer to your aspiration.

If I had a dollar for every time a retailer said “well, we’ve always done it that way” I would have at least $700.

Amazingly, there are beautiful stores out there that still write the tickets by hand. There are stores that require multiple touches to process a transaction. There are stores that have great salespeople working on vendor calls, repairs, watch straps, etc. Why? If they are great, keep them where they can do their best work and hire behind them so that you can take all non-sales-related activities away from them.

Kill any and all processes that do not make sense and streamline everything to maximize time, efficiency and the entire experience for both the customer and the store.

Get the customer out of your store
I read an article recently by a “retail expert” that offered insights into how you can keep your customers in your store for longer periods. He’s missing the boat. He’s living on another planet. You should be committed to fulfilling your customer’s needs in the shortest amount of time possible and allowing them to get on with their day and their lives.

When I want to hang around Nordstrom or Apple, I will do so if it suits my schedule. I will occasionally browse the stores and sometimes even kill time if I am waiting for my wife or one of the kids, but otherwise I want the retailer to respect my time and to get me in and out as quickly as possible.

If you want to give your customers an experience that is really about them, invite them into your store after hours. Hire a great musical act and provide a thank-you night, with cocktails and appetizers. Make it about your customer, not about filling out wish lists or trying to sell them. The sales will be there if that customer is emotionally engaged and the Gallup organization would tell us that those customers will deliver a 27 percent premium over customers who are not as engaged.

You might also think about inviting interesting authors to do readings and sign books, or artists to feature their work.
Perhaps you could invite nutritionists or other speakers of interest. Again, think about making your business less directly about you and more about your customer.

Howard Schultz talks about Starbucks being that “third place,” after home and work, and there’s no reason to believe that we cannot reshape retail jewelry stores into places that become more accessible and more relevant to your customers (and prospects) because they associate it with great experiences.

The sight of the exposed brick, carefully arranged cases and modern mix of lighting at Julz by Alan in Canton, Ohio, restored columnist Peter Smith’s faith in retail jewelers’ ability to craft a great environment.
Your physical space
Great retail spaces do not happen by accident. Whether it’s Apple, Nordstrom, Restoration Hardware or Zara, there is a huge amount of effort that goes into creating a special retail environment. There are numerous ways to infuse retail spaces with character, personality and energy; from the choice of colors on the walls, to the flooring selected, to the music choices, to your decision about whether to introduce a particular scent into your environment, to your use of technology, imagery and or video, to the lighting you use.

The aforementioned companies make very careful choices about how to execute their respective spaces and they are diligent in applying those choices in an effort to make their stores as engaging and experiential as possible. There is no absolute right way to create a magical environment but the one you establish should be deliberate and specific to you.

Last week I went into a retail store in the Midwest, and I was about as angry as one could be after the visit. From the moment I entered the store I was struck by how absolutely awful the environment was. Despite having some well-known brands, the energy of the team was non-existent, the lighting was atrocious, the cases were overstuffed and packed with irrelevant products and the glass seemed to be collecting fingerprints like there was a prize for it.

Later that day, I visited a small store in Ohio called Julz by Alan and the first thing I said to the owner was “faith restored.” His store was a testament to the very best of what retail jewelers can offer for all sorts of reasons.

We were warmly greeted by his salesperson Jodie when we entered and everything about the store and the experience was expertly crafted. The music was at just the right levels, so as to be enjoyed without drowning out conversation, the store had a beautiful combination of exposed brick and deco and industrial lighting. The cases were beautifully lit, with carefully orchestrated displays (lots of negative space and slate tiles inserted between the display fixtures to bring the exposed brick into play) and every detail seemed to have been considered, down to the store’s logo on the water bottles and, to top it off, a wonderfully cute personalization (with the store brand) of the coffee that they served.

In Impulse: Why We Do What We Do Without Knowing It, David Lewis writes about the powerful effect of music and aromas in your store.

While one can debate what music is best and what the preferred aroma should be (I know lots of people who love the smell of freshly baked cookies), a combination of the two, coupled with the right lighting, a well-considered aesthetic and great and friendly people, goes a long way.

Stay tuned for part two next Tuesday, which will include three more areas for business evaluation, plus a list of recommended reads for retailers.

Peter Smith, author of Hiring Squirrels: 12 Essential Interview Questions to Uncover Great Retail Sales Talent, has spent more than 30 years building sales teams at retail and at wholesale. He is president of Vibhor Gems and he has previously worked with companies such as Tiffany & Co., Montblanc and Hearts On Fire. Email him at, or reach him on LinkedIn.
Peter Smithis an industry consultant, speaker, and sales trainer, and author of 3 books on sales. Reach him at

The Latest

Pomellato Malachite Pom Pom Dot bracelet
FinancialsJul 25, 2024
Boucheron, Pomellato Post Double-Digit Growth in Q2

The gains come amid a tough time for parent company Kering, which saw sales slide 11 percent in the first half of the year.

Bulgari high jewelry campaign
FinancialsJul 24, 2024
LVMH’s First-Half Jewelry, Watch Sales Dip 5%

Tiffany & Co. is focusing on its “iconic” collections while the company has made changes at the top at TAG Heuer and Hublot.

Chaumet Paris 2024 Olympics medals
MajorsJul 24, 2024
See Chaumet’s Paris Olympic Medals Inspired by its High Jewelry

The Parisian brand is the first jewelry company in the history of the Olympic and Paralympic Games to design the medals.

Untitled design.jpg
Brought to you by
The End of an Era? Lab-Grown Diamonds' Journey Towards Price Stability

As the demand for lab-grown diamond jewelry may still be increasing, the most notable change we are likely to see is price stabilization.

Jewelers Mutual and Union Life and Casualty logos
MajorsJul 24, 2024
Jewelers Mutual Acquires Pawnbroker Insurance Provider

Union Life & Casualty will join JM Insurance Agency Partners, expanding the provider’s pawnbroker coverage.

Weekly QuizJul 18, 2024
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Bradlei Smith
MajorsJul 24, 2024
Ben Bridge Announces 2024 Lonia Tate Scholarship Winner

Los Angeles-based Bradlei Smith was selected for this year’s award.

National Jeweler columnist Peter Smith
ColumnistsJul 23, 2024
Peter Smith: The Case for Optimism in Sales

In his latest column, Smith shares multiple reasons why people who look at the glass as being hall full often make better salespeople.

1872 x 1052 Gemolite.jpg
Brought to you by
Meet Gemology’s Next Generation Microscope: GIA® Gemolite® NXT Professional Edition

GIA®’s most advanced microscope has new features to optimize greater precision and comfort.

De Beers rough diamond display
SourcingJul 23, 2024
De Beers’ Production Drops 15% in Q2

The company also reported the $150 million sale of an iron ore royalty right, part of its ongoing effort to divest “non-core” assets.

Sophia Moreno-Bunge of Isa Isa modeling Guzema’s Hidden Beauty collection
CollectionsJul 23, 2024
Guzema Debuts ‘Flower Power’ Campaign

The ad features three celebrity florists creating floral sculptures while wearing jewelry by Guzema.

Tresia Shituula, Monkgogi Moshaga, Mohamed Samu
Policies & IssuesJul 23, 2024
Diamonds Do Good Announces Its 2024 Entrepreneurship Grant Winners

The grant provided a total of $100,000 to support 13 entrepreneurs from diamond communities in Africa and India.

Ghazi “Gus” Michel Osta
CrimeJul 22, 2024
Florida Jeweler Shot, Killed Following Argument With Customer

Ghazi Michel Osta, or “Gus,” was killed Friday by an 83-year-old man said to be a frequent customer at his store, Volusia Gold & Diamond.

Elyssa Jenkins-Perez and Effie Marinos
Policies & IssuesJul 22, 2024
JVC’s Elyssa Jenkins-Pérez Joins RJC

The organization also announced Effie Marinos as its new specialist advisor for technical standards, as well as four other appointments.

Karen Rentmeesters
SourcingJul 22, 2024
AWDC Names Karen Rentmeesters as CEO

Rentmeesters has served as interim CEO since April following former CEO Ari Epstein’s resignation.

Tudor store in Denver
IndependentsJul 19, 2024
The 1916 Company Opens New Tudor Boutique

The 500-square-foot boutique is located in Denver’s Cherry Creek Shopping Center.

Messika’s So Move Max Necklace
CollectionsJul 19, 2024
Piece of the Week: Messika’s ‘So Move Max’ Necklace

Dance all night long with the “So Move Max” set’s necklace.

Julien Tornare and Antoine Pin
WatchesJul 18, 2024
TAG Heuer, Hublot Will Have New CEOs

Luxury giant LVMH is reshuffling the leadership in its watches division.

Etsy billboard rendering in NYC
MajorsJul 18, 2024
New Etsy Campaign Prioritizes Creators Amid Backlash

Sellers and shoppers have spoken out against a rise in mass-produced merchandise on the platform meant to highlight handmade goods.

Ariana Grande Modeling in Swarovski Jewelry
MajorsJul 18, 2024
Swarovski Names Ariana Grande as Its New Brand Ambassador

The celebrity will star in Swarovski’s holiday campaign.

Grizzly emerald
SourcingJul 18, 2024
Grizzly Emerald Auction Garners $32.5 million

The miner said an 835-carat emerald saw “stiff competition” in its July sale.

Tahnee Barbee, Gigi Sui, and Daniela Villacorta
Events & AwardsJul 18, 2024
MJSA Education Foundation Announces 3 Scholarship Winners

The winners were awarded $3,000 each to pursue a professional career in jewelry making and design.

Radhika Merchant’s Wedding Portrait
EditorsJul 17, 2024
6 Lavish Looks from the Ambani Wedding

Feast your eyes on the elaborate jewels worn during the wedding celebration of Anant Ambani and Radhika Merchant.

Smiling Rocks Haute Couture Dream Necklace
Lab-GrownJul 17, 2024
Lab-Grown Diamond ‘Dream’ Necklace Sells for $122K at Charity Auction

The piece, created by Smiling Rocks, was the top lot at the recent Ormeley Dinner.

Diavik Diamond Mine solar power plant
SourcingJul 17, 2024
Rio Tinto’s Diamond Production Down 28% in Q2

The company’s sole remaining diamond operation, Diavik, produced 702,000 carats of diamonds, down from 970,000 a year ago.

Buccellati high jewelry earrings
FinancialsJul 17, 2024
Richemont’s Q1 Jewelry Sales Up 2%

In contrast, the luxury giant’s watch sales fell 14 percent.

This year marks the 40th anniversary of the jewelry design contest.
Events & AwardsJul 16, 2024
2024 AGTA Spectrum Awards Open for Entries

This year marks the 40th anniversary of the jewelry design contest and the deadline for entries has just been extended.

Macy’s Herald Square store
MajorsJul 16, 2024
Macy’s Ends Buyout Talks

The retailer will not be making a deal with Arkhouse Management and Brigade Capital Management, opting to focus on its turnaround plan.


This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy