Events & AwardsJul 07, 2025
Applications Open for Ella Klein Internship The program, a collaboration between Julius Klein Diamonds and the Women’s Jewelry Association, is in its second year.
Policies & IssuesApr 18, 2018
Supreme Court Divided on Issue of Online Sales Tax
Some justices say the current structure for collecting sales tax for items bought online needs to be updated while others argue it’s an issue for the legislative branch.
The U.S. Supreme Court hear arguments Tuesday on South Dakota’s petition to overturn Quill, the decision made in the era of mail-order catalogs that governs how online sales tax is collected today.
Washington--The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday morning in the case that could, or could not, change Quill, the decades-old decision governing collection of sales tax online.
The case, South Dakota vs. Wayfair Inc. et al, pits proponents of online sales tax collection, including states and retail organizations like Jewelers of America and the National Retail Federation, against online sellers like Jewelry Television, Etsy and eBay.
At issue is Quill vs. North Dakota, the 1992 Supreme Court ruling that prevents states from collecting sales tax from sellers with no physical presence, meaning a store, a warehouse, etc., in the state.
Heading into oral arguments, two justices who often find themselves on opposite sides of an issue—Justices Anthony Kennedy and Neil Gorsuch—had publicly expressed support for overturning Quill, a decision that Gorsuch described Tuesday as “antiquated.”
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg indicated during oral arguments that she agreed with Kennedy and Gorsuch, stating that those opposed to overturning Quill make the case that asking an out-of-state seller to collect tax on goods shipped in-state discriminates against interstate commerce.
“But as I see it,” she said, “why isn’t it, far from discriminating, equalizing sellers; that is, anyone who wants to sell in-state, whether an in-state shop, an out-of-state shop, everybody is treated to the same tax collection obligation. All who exploit an in-state market are subject to the in-state tax. Why isn’t that equalizing rather than discriminating?”
However, Justices Sonya Sotomayor, Samuel Alito and Elena Kagan seemed to agree that while Quill is outdated, the issues of governing sales tax collection is best left to Congress due to the complexities involved.
“From this court’s perspective, the choice is just binary. It’s you either have the Quill rule or you don’t,” Kagan said. “But Congress is capable of crafting compromises and trying to figure out how to balance the wide range of interests involved here.
“Now, the general (South Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley, who spoke on behalf of the state in front of the court) said Congress hasn’t done that, but … Congress can decide when it wants to craft a compromise and when it doesn’t want to craft a compromise. And then Congress, if it decides it wants to craft a compromise, can craft a compromise in ways that we cannot.”
Justice Stephen Breyer mentioned that placing the administrative burdens of having to collect sales tax in every state could hinder smaller online sellers from entering the
market, thereby creating an oligopoly of a handful large players.
And Chief Justice Roberts indicated that the time to overturn Quill has come and gone.
“In terms of economic impact, I mean, the suggestion in some of the briefs is that this is a problem that has peaked in the sense that the bigger e-commerce companies find themselves with physical presence in all 50 states. So they’re already covered.”
This includes the biggest online retailer in the country, Amazon, which announced last March that it would begin collecting sales tax in all 50 states.
“And,” Roberts continued, “the workarounds that some of the states have employed are also bringing more in. If it is, in fact, a problem that is diminishing rather than expanding, why doesn’t that suggest that there are greater significance to the arguments that we should leave Quill in place?”
The issue of online sales tax collection ended up before the Supreme Court because of a law South Dakota passed in March 2016 requiring companies that make more than $100,000 in sales or have more than 200 transactions per calendar year remit sales tax whether or not they have a physical presence in South Dakota.
Three online retailers, Overstock.com Inc., Wayfair Inc. and NewEgg Inc., filed a lawsuit against the state and ultimately won, with the South Dakota Supreme Court ruling that the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1992 Quill decision, however dated, remains the controlling precedent on the issue of interstate tax collection.
South Dakota petitioned the Supreme Court to reconsider Quill in October 2017. In January, the court agreed to do so.
A complete transcript of Tuesday’s oral arguments in South Dakota vs. Wayfair Inc. et al is available on the Supreme Court’s website.
A decision in the case is expected before the court’s current term ends in late June.
And Chief Justice Roberts indicated that the time to overturn Quill has come and gone.
“In terms of economic impact, I mean, the suggestion in some of the briefs is that this is a problem that has peaked in the sense that the bigger e-commerce companies find themselves with physical presence in all 50 states. So they’re already covered.”
This includes the biggest online retailer in the country, Amazon, which announced last March that it would begin collecting sales tax in all 50 states.
“And,” Roberts continued, “the workarounds that some of the states have employed are also bringing more in. If it is, in fact, a problem that is diminishing rather than expanding, why doesn’t that suggest that there are greater significance to the arguments that we should leave Quill in place?”
The issue of online sales tax collection ended up before the Supreme Court because of a law South Dakota passed in March 2016 requiring companies that make more than $100,000 in sales or have more than 200 transactions per calendar year remit sales tax whether or not they have a physical presence in South Dakota.
Three online retailers, Overstock.com Inc., Wayfair Inc. and NewEgg Inc., filed a lawsuit against the state and ultimately won, with the South Dakota Supreme Court ruling that the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1992 Quill decision, however dated, remains the controlling precedent on the issue of interstate tax collection.
South Dakota petitioned the Supreme Court to reconsider Quill in October 2017. In January, the court agreed to do so.
A complete transcript of Tuesday’s oral arguments in South Dakota vs. Wayfair Inc. et al is available on the Supreme Court’s website.
A decision in the case is expected before the court’s current term ends in late June.
More on Policies & Issues
The Latest
Supplier BulletinJul 03, 2025
Protect Your Customers and Your BusinessSponsored by the Gemological Institute of America
MajorsJul 03, 2025
Brilliant Earth Names Tennis Star Madison Keys as Its New AmbassadorThe 2025 Australian Open champion is the jewelry brand’s first athlete ambassador.
Brought to you by
Investing in the Next Generation of Bench JewelersThe Seymour & Evelyn Holtzman Bench Scholarship from Jewelers of America returns for a second year.
MajorsJul 03, 2025
Muse Sets Up Shop in Nordstrom’s New Jewelry HallThe West Village jewelry boutique’s new shop-in-shop is the cornerstone of Nordstrom’s revamped jewelry hall.
Weekly QuizJul 02, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
SourcingJul 03, 2025
SRK Announces Its Natural Diamonds Are Now Carbon-NegativeThis past year, the manufacturer said it recorded below-zero emissions per carat of natural diamond.
CollectionsJul 03, 2025
Piece of the Week: A Firework of Diamonds From YepremThe brand’s “Golden Strada” statement necklace features round, marquise, and pear diamonds that sparkle like Fourth of July fireworks.
Brought to you by
Jewelers of America is Headed to Las Vegas for JCK 2025The countdown is on for the JCK Las Vegas Show and JA is pulling out all the stops.
CrimeJul 03, 2025
JSA Shares Holiday Weekend Security Tips Amid Spike in BurglariesJSA’s Scott Guginsky provided a list of nine security measures jewelers should observe while locking up for the long weekend.
MajorsJul 02, 2025
Boucheron Looks to LA for First West Coast FlagshipLocated on Rodeo Drive, the store’s design was inspired by Hollywood and Los Angeles culture.
MajorsJul 02, 2025
Marco Bicego Opens Milan FlagshipThe new location continues the brand’s celebration of its 25th anniversary.
WatchesJul 02, 2025
Chrono24 Revamps Brand, Launches New CampaignThe online watch marketplace’s “Time Is Our Thing” campaign highlights the importance of time.
SourcingJul 02, 2025
Bernadette Mack Joins Gem Legacy as Executive DirectorShe will oversee strategic planning, fundraising, industry partnerships, and the launch of the Gem Legacy Campus in Tanzania.
CrimeJul 02, 2025
Pandora, Amazon Partner to Uncover Counterfeit Jewelry NetworkWorking with Amazon’s Counterfeit Crimes Unit and law enforcement, Pandora helped to shut down a large-scale counterfeit network in China.
MajorsJul 01, 2025
Cast Closes Business, Plans for RelaunchThe jewelry company has closed its three California brick-and-mortar stores, as well as its online shop, for now.
Events & AwardsJul 01, 2025
William Goldberg Diamonds, FIT Partner for Apprenticeship ProgramThe company is providing the opportunity for an FIT student to work alongside master diamond cutter Willie Lopez in its workshop.
IndependentsJul 01, 2025
Elie Hannoush, Founder of Hannoush Jewelers, Dies at 73He is remembered for his successful entrepreneurship, generosity, and dedication to his family.
MajorsJul 01, 2025
Claire’s Is Looking for a Buyer, Report SaysThe jewelry store chain has reportedly been struggling with costs related to tariffs as well as tough retail competition.
TrendsJul 01, 2025
Amanda’s Style File: Red Hot RubiesWelcome warm summer days with red hot rubies perfectly chosen as July’s birthstone.
CollectionsJun 30, 2025
State Property’s New Jewelry Tells ‘The Story of Everything’Co-founders Afzal Imram and Lin Ruiyin brought their son’s story of a cosmic egg, toadstool, and railroad to life in their new collection.
ColumnistsJun 30, 2025
The Smart Lab: Why Q3 Is the Secret Weapon For Holiday Jewelry SalesThe best time to prepare for the holiday season is right now, according to columnist Emmanuel Raheb.
Events & AwardsJun 30, 2025
AGA Names Recipient of 2025 Gemological Education ScholarshipThis year’s winner is Morgan Keefe, who is currently studying at GIA to be a gemologist.
IndependentsJun 30, 2025
Melanie Grant’s New Book Explores 200 Years of Jewelry“The Jewelry Book” comes out this September.
TechnologyJun 27, 2025
Gemist Raises $6M in Funding to Scale Jewelry Tech PlatformThe company is focused on modernizing the custom jewelry buying experience with e-commerce tools like product visualization and 3D styling.
IndependentsJun 27, 2025
David Webb Announces New Hires, PromotionsFollowing its recent acquisition, the storied brand has updated its leadership team and regional managers.
Events & AwardsJun 27, 2025
AGS, GIA Announce Beatrice Shipley Scholarship Winner AGS also named the recipient of its “Women in Leadership” scholarship.
CollectionsJun 27, 2025
Piece of the Week: Buddha Mama’s ‘Monstera’ Wrap RingThe 20-karat yellow gold and diamond wrap ring is modeled after the Monstera plants in the garden of the brand’s Miami villa.
