Policies & Issues

Colorado spill renews calls for mining law reform

Policies & IssuesAug 13, 2015

Colorado spill renews calls for mining law reform

The breach that turned a Colorado river orange this week has environmental groups and some lawmakers stressing the need to overhaul the 143-year-old law that still governs hard-rock mining.

081415_Animas-article.jpg
This aerial shot courtesy of Ecoflight shows the Animas River winding through the town of Durango, Colo. after workers for the EPA caused millions of gallons of mine wastewater to spill into one of the river’s tributaries, turning the water

Silverton, Colo.--The breach that turned one Colorado river into a ribbon of orange this week has renewed calls from environmental groups and lawmakers to reform the 143-year-old law that still governs hard-rock mining in the United States.

The trouble started Aug. 5 when a members of a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency cleanup crew who were, ironically, investigating ongoing water releases from the Gold King Mine broke a dam that was holding back wastewater, the EPA acknowledged in a statement.

The Gold King Mine was active from the 1880s to the 1920s.

The breach resulted in 3 million gallons of water contaminated by mercury, lead, arsenic and cadmium to spill into Cement Creek, a tributary of the 126-mile long Animas River, which runs from Colorado into New Mexico. The Animas empties into the San Juan River, which then flows west, eventually joining the Colorado River in Utah.

The pollutants turned portions of the river the color of mustard and, as of Thursday afternoon, had reached as far as Utah. 

In a statement released Wednesday, the EPA stated that the quality of the water in some stretches of the river had returned to “pre-event” levels but that it would continue to monitor it. A number of environmental experts have said it is too early to determine what the long-term impacts of the spill could be.

As the toxic orange water wound its way westward, environmental groups and the media renewed their calls for reform to the law that governs hard-rock mining on federal public lands in the U.S., the 1872 Mining Law.
 
On Thursday, both the Los Angeles Times and The New York Times published op-eds about the impact of mine spills on the environment, with the New York Times calling the 143-year-old mining law a “destructive relic.”

The law allows hard-rock miners, miners of materials such as gold, silver and copper, to extract minerals on federal public lands without paying any federal royalties, which is unlike other industries such as coal, oil and gas, said Bonnie Gestring, the Northwest program director for environmental group Earthworks.

This leaves the hard-rock mining industry in the U.S. without a dedicated source of funding for mine cleanup.

Earthworks, along with other environmental groups and some members of Congress, want to see a new law drafted that would put a royalty system in place, with those funds earmarked specifically for the

cleanup of abandoned and inactive mines.

The National Mining Association, a trade association representing the industry, is among those that have spoken out against proposed changes to the 1872 law in the past.

On Thursday, NMA spokesman Luke Popovich said that while it’s true the same law has been on the books since 1872, many environmental regulations that impact hard-rock mining have been passed since that time.

He said the mining industry feels that there is enough regulation and while it supports a “modest royalty,” one that is too high--such as the 8 percent royalty on new mines proposed in the most recent legislation designed to overhaul the old mining law, from U.S. Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.)--will drive mining companies out of the U.S.
 
Popovich said they would then mine much-needed minerals elsewhere, in countries with far fewer environmental regulations. 

“We favor a modest royalty. They (environmental groups and others in support hard-rock mining reform) have not favored the royalties we want,” he said.

When asked if the royalty funds should be used to clean up old mines, he said, “Whatever the government feels they need to use it for, that’s obviously up to the government.”

Grijalva’s bill was introduced in February and currently is in committee in the House.

Michelle Graffis the editor-in-chief at National Jeweler, directing the publication’s coverage both online and in print.

The Latest

Screenshot of Taylor Swift's "Elizabeth Taylor" music video
CollectionsApr 03, 2026
Taylor Swift’s ‘Elizabeth Taylor’ Video Puts Jewelry Front and Center

Iconic pieces, like the Mike Todd Diamond Tiara, appear in the superstar’s new music video for her song inspired by the actress.

Neiman Marcus store in Fort Worth, Texas
MajorsApr 03, 2026
Saks Global Says It Will Emerge From Bankruptcy This Summer

The luxury retailer, which went Chapter 11 in January, announced Thursday that it has secured $500 million in exit financing.

NouvelleBox logo
Events & AwardsApr 03, 2026
JCK Luxury, NouvelleBox Partner on New Designer Ballroom

The NouvelleBox ballroom will feature independent jewelry designers, including Lene Vibe, Wyld Box Jewelry, and Kiaia Limited.

GIA iD100®
Brought to you by
Protect Your Customers and Your Business

You deserve to know what you are selling–to protect your customers as well as your business and your reputation.

Buddha Mama Moon Locket
CollectionsApr 03, 2026
Buddha Mama Brings Its ‘Moon’ Locket To Dallas

The one-of-a-kind locket, our Piece of the Week, opens to reveal three hidden images to keep close to your heart.

Weekly QuizApr 02, 2026
This Week’s Quiz
Test your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
Take the Quiz
Pandora distribution facility Canada
MajorsApr 02, 2026
Pandora Opens New Canadian Distribution Center Amid Tariff Concerns

The new facility was also designed to better serve its growing customer base in Canada.

Michelle Yeoh Mikimoto
TrendsApr 02, 2026
Michelle Yeoh Fronts New Mikimoto Campaign

The campaign is a tribute to the year 1893, when Kokichi Mikimoto created the world’s first cultured pearl.

TopImageCrop.jpg
Brought to you by
Is This You? Every Jeweler Has This Problem; We Have the Solution.

Every jeweler faces the same challenge: helping customers protect what they love. Here’s the solution designed for today’s jewelry business.

GIA President and CEO Pritesh Patel at GIA Taiwan campus
GradingApr 02, 2026
GIA Debuts New Campus in Taiwan

It is the only GIA school to offer the GIA Graduate Gemologist program in Chinese.

DCA Second Spark Workforce Initiative Graphic
MajorsApr 02, 2026
DCA Launches ‘Second Spark’ Workforce Initiative

The initiative connects veterans and parents returning to the workforce with careers in jewelry retail.

Michael Angelo
MajorsApr 02, 2026
Hoover & Strong Names New National Sales Representative

The wholesale manufacturer and precious metals refiner has appointed Michael Angelo as its new national sales representative.

Pandora and Foundrae medallion jewelry
MajorsApr 01, 2026
Foundrae Sues Pandora for Allegedly Copying Its Medallion Designs

Foundrae also accused the jewelry giant of copying its mood board style of marketing.

John Jacob Astor IV's Patek Philippe for Tiffany & Co., Battin & Co. pencil case
AuctionsApr 01, 2026
John Jacob Astor IV’s Titanic Pocket Watch Heads to Auction

A Patek Philippe for Tiffany & Co. timepiece owned by the American businessman who died on the Titanic will be offered at Freeman's Chicago.

Stock image of a Shell gas station
SurveysApr 01, 2026
Consumers’ Outlook Improves Again in March

The Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Index edged up, with optimism about the present outweighing worries about the future.

Zach Bear and the Window Necklace Children’s Book from Zachary’s Jewelers
IndependentsApr 01, 2026
Zachary’s Jewelers’ Constance Polamalu to Release Children’s Book

The retailer’s Zach Bear gift comes to life in “Zach Bear and the Window Necklace,” which centers on curiosity, bravery, and helping.

Accredited Gemologists Association Logo
Events & AwardsApr 01, 2026
AGA Opens 2026 Gemological Scholarship, Research Grant Applications

Applications are open for the AGA Gemological Scholarship Program through May 15, and until June 2027 for the Gemological Research Grant.

National Jeweler columnist and Smart Age founder and CEO Emmanuel Raheb
ColumnistsMar 31, 2026
Q1 Clues That Reveal Where Your Jewelry Store’s Sales Are Heading

These customer behavior patterns say a lot about how successful your jewelry store is going to be this year, Emmanuel Raheb writes.

Mejuri Puzzle Collection Campaign Imagery
CollectionsMar 31, 2026
Mejuri Adds Silver to ‘Puzzle’ Collection

Mejuri’s popular collection of 18-karat yellow gold vermeil rings debuted in sterling silver alongside new “Puzzle” slider charms.

Ashley Longshore in Buddha Mama jewelry
CollectionsMar 31, 2026
Buddha Mama, Ashley Longshore to Host Pop-Up in Dallas

The Miami-based jewelry brand and the NYC-based artist will be in Dallas from April 9-11.

Natural Diamond Council world diamond day
SourcingMar 31, 2026
NDC Designates April 8 as 'World Diamond Day'

The initiative invites those in the industry to share stories on social media highlighting the meaning and impact of natural diamonds.

Jillian Wolk, the new CEO of Tracr
SourcingMar 31, 2026
GIA VP Jillian Wolk to Take Over at Tracr

Wolk’s first day on the job as CEO of Tracr, De Beers Group’s blockchain platform, will be May 1.

Tom Moses examining the “Motswedi” diamond
EditorsMar 30, 2026
Tom Moses Looks Back on His Decades at GIA

Moses, who will leave the lab in May after nearly 50 years, discusses his start in the business, gemstones that stand out, and what’s next.

Oscar Heyman Spring Catalog Aquamarine and Diamond Necklace and Platinum Opal, Sapphire, Emerald, Diamond Bracelet
TrendsMar 30, 2026
Oscar Heyman Debuts First Spring Catalog

The new catalog, which showcases 35 one-of-a-kind pieces of jewelry, is a compliment to the company’s popular holiday catalog.

Diavik Diamond Mine winter aerial shot
SourcingMar 30, 2026
Rio Tinto Hauls Last Load from Diavik

Production has ceased at the Canadian diamond mine, which has yielded more than 150 million carats of rough diamonds in its 23-year run.

Tanishq Westborough Massachusetts store
MajorsMar 30, 2026
Tanishq Opens First New England Location

The store opening marks the 10th United States location for the India-based jewelry retailer.

Saks Fifth Avenue door sign
MajorsMar 27, 2026
Saks Global Has Changed Its Mind About Closing These 3 Stores

Two Saks Fifth Avenue locations, one in Florida and one in California, and one Neiman Marcus store are off the chopping block.

Jimmy West celebrating 40 years with Leading Jewelers Guild
IndependentsMar 27, 2026
Jimmy West, Longtime LJG Executive Director, Dies at 72

West, who started in the art department at the Leading Jewelers Guild in 1979, is remembered for his patience, kindness, and dedication.

×

This site uses cookies to give you the best online experience. By continuing to use & browse this site, we assume you agree to our Privacy Policy