AuctionsSep 17, 2025
Mythical Set of Patek Philippe Pocket Watches Expected to Sell for $10M+A set of four Patek Philippe “Star Caliber 2000” pocket watches is part of Sotheby’s upcoming auction in Abu Dhabi.
MajorsOct 03, 2016
Costco Ordered to Pay Damages in Tiffany Case
A federal jury in New York issued a $5.5 million partial verdict for unlawful profits but is still deciding on punitive damages.
The jury in Tiffany v. Costco awarded the jeweler $5.5 million damages for Costco’s sale of diamond engagement rings labeled as having a “Tiffany” setting that were not, in fact, made by Tiffany & Co.
New York--A federal jury in New York awarded Tiffany & Co. $5.5 million in damages last week in part one of a two-part verdict being handed down in its case against Costco Wholesale Corp.
Relatively speaking, it’s a tiny amount of money for a jewelry retailer that recorded $4.1 billion in global sales last year, and for a massive wholesale club that rang up more than $100 billion.
But it’s a big message for the jeweler that, like all retailers, is fighting for every consumer dollar in an increasingly competitive marketplace and that, perhaps, sees protecting its venerable 179-year-old brand as key to maintaining its edge.
It’s a case that’s been labeled a publicity stunt and called a “waste of time” but, in the end, ultimately has a two-prong effect for Tiffany.
Emily Miao, a partner at McDonnell Boehnen Hulbert & Berghoff LLP who specializes in intellectual property law, said the case sends a message to the jewelry industry about using the term “Tiffany setting.” That message is: Don’t use it.
RELATED CONTENT: What the Tiffany Ruling Means for the Jewelry IndustryTiffany essentially had already won this case more than a year ago when U.S. District Judge Laura Taylor Swain not only granted Tiffany’s motions for summary judgment on claims of trademark infringement and trademark counterfeiting, but also threw out Costco’s counterclaim that “Tiffany setting” had become a generic term that could be applied to any engagement ring setting created in the same multiple slender-prong style as a Tiffany ring.
It could have ended there, but Miao said that Tiffany is “using this case to un-do what has happened to their (trade)mark.”
“Now they have a way to segue into changing the jewelry industry’s behavior by using the Costco case. It is a publicity stunt, in that sense,” she said.
The case also has kept Tiffany & Co. top-of-mind for consumers, particularly those deciding if, and where, they’d like to buy a Tiffany ring.
The jury handed down its verdict last Thursday in New York federal court, putting Costco’s profits from the sales of rings with a “Tiffany setting” at $3.7 million and adding $1.8 million for what it determined as benefits that Costco derived from the ring sales.
In a statement shared with National Jeweler on Friday, Costco said it is not commenting on the decision because the jury’s deliberations are continuing.
The partial verdict is nearly, but
not quite, the last step in a case that’s now more than three years old and started when Tiffany was made aware of the fact that Costco was selling engagement rings labeled as Tiffany in its stores.
As of Monday morning, the jury was still deliberating punitive damages in the case; punitive damages are those that serve to punish the offending party in a case.
Miao said the bar for awarding punitive damages is high in New York state, and she put Tiffany’s chance of recovering any more money at 50/50.
But, again, “money’s not really relevant here,” she said. “If it was, Tiffany would have settled a long time ago.”
“This is a good decision for Tiffany. This will help them sell more rings and jewelry. (Because), if you want a Tiffany ring, you’ve got to go to Tiffany to buy it.”
As of Monday morning, the jury was still deliberating punitive damages in the case; punitive damages are those that serve to punish the offending party in a case.
Miao said the bar for awarding punitive damages is high in New York state, and she put Tiffany’s chance of recovering any more money at 50/50.
But, again, “money’s not really relevant here,” she said. “If it was, Tiffany would have settled a long time ago.”
“This is a good decision for Tiffany. This will help them sell more rings and jewelry. (Because), if you want a Tiffany ring, you’ve got to go to Tiffany to buy it.”
More on Majors
The Latest
TrendsSep 17, 2025
Silvia Furmanovich’s Book Tells the ‘Journey of a Jeweler’The Brazilian jeweler’s latest book marks her namesake brand’s 25th anniversary and tells the tale of her worldwide collaborations.
WatchesSep 17, 2025
Bob’s Watches Acquires Vintage Rolex Won on ‘The Price is Right’ The Submariner Ref. 1680 with a Tiffany & Co. dial came from the original owner, who won it as a prize on the game show in the 1970s.
Brought to you by
reDollar.com Is Rolling Out the Next Level Jewelry, Diamond & Watch Consignment ProgramWith their unmatched services and low fees, reDollar.com is challenging some big names in the online consignment world.
TechnologySep 17, 2025
Jewelers Mutual Launches Shipping Solution App for Shopify The new integration allows users to manage shipments directly from the Shopify dashboard.
Weekly QuizSep 12, 2025
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
EditorsSep 16, 2025
Out & About: 7 Great Quotes From Converge in CarlsbadAt Converge 2025, Editor-in-Chief Michelle Graff attended sessions on DEI, tariffs, security, and more. Here are her top takeaways.
CrimeSep 16, 2025
2 Robbery Suspects Killed in California Pawn Shop ShootoutSix people were shot last week at an Oakland cash-for-gold shop as employees exchanged gunfire with individuals trying to rob the store.
Brought to you by
Rallying Call for the Jewelry Industry on Tariffs and Other Key IssuesJewelers of America is leading the charge to protect the industry amidst rising economic threats.
CollectionsSep 16, 2025
Chopard Adds New Designs to Its ‘Ice Cube’ Capsule CollectionThe jeweler has expanded its high jewelry offering, which launched last year, with new pieces featuring its cube motif that debuted in 1999.
SourcingSep 16, 2025
Natural Diamond Council Launches Retailer Accreditation ProgramBen Bridge Jeweler and Lux Bond & Green were a part of the pilot program.
EditorsSep 15, 2025
Skipping the Necklace, Embracing Snakes: The Best Jewelry From the 2025 Emmy AwardsAssociate Editor Natalie Francisco shares eight of her favorite jewelry looks from the 77th annual Primetime Emmy Awards, held Sunday night.
SurveysSep 15, 2025
Resilient Shoppers to Boost Holiday Retail Sales, Says DeloitteIt’s predicting a rise in retail sales this holiday season despite economic uncertainty and elevated inflation.
SourcingSep 15, 2025
Gemfields Achieves $32M at High-Quality Emerald AuctionIt included the sale of the 11,685-carat “Imboo” emerald that was recently discovered at Kagem.
SourcingSep 15, 2025
AGTA Elects 8 Members to Board of Directors The newly elected directors will officially take office in February 2026 and will be introduced at the organization’s membership meeting.
EditorsSep 12, 2025
Out & About: Mining Sapphires in Rock Creek, MontanaAssociate Editor Lauren McLemore headed out West for a visit to Potentate Mining’s operation hosted by gemstone wholesaler Parlé Gems.
TrendsSep 12, 2025
Piece of the Week: Arunashi’s Fordite and Rhodolite EarringsFordite is a man-made material created from the layers of dried enamel paint that dripped onto the floors of automotive factories.
Events & AwardsSep 12, 2025
Al Gilbertson Wins 2025 Robert M. Shipley AwardGilbertson has worked as a researcher, jeweler, lapidary artist, appraiser, and business owner throughout his decades in the industry.
Policies & IssuesSep 11, 2025
Supreme Court to Hear Tariffs Case in November A decision likely won’t come until January 2026 at the earliest, and the tariffs remain in effect until then.
SourcingSep 11, 2025
Need to Sell More Natural Diamonds? De Beers Has an App for ThatThe new, free app offers accessible educational content, like games and podcasts, for U.S. retailers.
SourcingSep 10, 2025
Tech Meets Style in the New Loewe x Jacob & Co. HeadphonesJacob & Co. partnered with the German technology company on two pairs of headphones, one set with diamonds and the other with sapphires.
TrendsSep 10, 2025
Tiffany & Co. Archival Jewels Bring Life to ‘Frankenstein’Guillermo del Toro’s 2025 “Frankenstein” will feature 27 jewels and objects from the storied brand, including pieces from its archives.
MajorsSep 10, 2025
24 Karat Club of New York’s Banquet to Return to Waldorf AstoriaThe Waldorf Astoria New York’s grand reopening this past summer means a homecoming for the industry group’s annual event.
SourcingSep 09, 2025
Anglo American to Merge With Canadian Copper Miner Anglo plans to merge with Teck Resources Ltd. to form Anglo Teck. The deal changes nothing about its plans to offload De Beers.
AuctionsSep 09, 2025
‘The Mellon Blue’ to Return to Auction, This Time at Christie’s The 9.51-carat fancy vivid blue diamond, which set two world auction records at Sotheby’s in 2014, is estimated to fetch up to $30 million.
AuctionsSep 09, 2025
Phillips Names Dianne Batista Head of Jewels, New YorkThe industry veteran joins the auction house as it looks to solidify its footprint in the jewelry market.
MajorsSep 09, 2025
MJSA Education Foundation Announces 2025 Scholarship WinnersThe nonprofit awarded four students pursuing a professional career in jewelry making and design with $2,250 each.
IndependentsSep 08, 2025
Take a Look Inside the New Korman Store in AustinThe Texas-based jeweler has also undergone a brand refresh, debuting a new website and logo.
