CollectionsAug 27, 2026
Pandora Expands ‘Talisman’ Collection as Lawsuit Continues MajorsSep 22, 2026
Foundrae’s Lawsuit Against Pandora Can Continue, Court Rules
A federal judge denied Pandora’s motion to dismiss Foundrae’s claim for copyright infringement of its medallions.
A federal court has denied Pandora’s motion to dismiss Foundrae’s lawsuit, which alleges the Danish jewelry company copied Foundrae’s medallion designs for its “Talisman” collection. Pictured is a side-by-side comparison of two medallions that Foundrae claims Pandora “copied nearly verbatim,” as per court documents. This photo was included in the initial complaint Foundrae filed in February.
New York—A federal court in New York has denied Pandora’s motion to dismiss Foundrae’s claim for copyright infringement earlier this month, allowing the lawsuit to continue.
New York-based jewelry brand Foundrae filed suit against Pandora on Feb. 17 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, alleging that styles from Pandora’s “Talisman” collection infringed on its copyright-protected medallions.
Pandora’s Talisman collection debuted in August 2025 with 12 medallions, featuring common symbols like a lion, a rose, arrows, and celestial motifs like the sun and moon, and recently was expanded to include new designs.
Foundrae stated in its complaint that the initial Talisman collection is “so similar in look and feel to Foundrae’s signature pieces, and the marketing tactics promoting the collection so reminiscent of Foundrae’s aesthetic, that Foundrae found itself fielding inquiries from customers pointing out the similarities between Pandora’s Talisman collection and Foundrae’s medallions.”
Foundrae called out two of Pandora’s designs specifically, the “Passion” and “Balance” medallions, seen at the top of the story, claiming that they copy “nearly verbatim the protected expression of the original designs.”
Related stories will be right here …
New York-based jewelry brand Foundrae filed suit against Pandora on Feb. 17 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, alleging that styles from Pandora’s “Talisman” collection infringed on its copyright-protected medallions.
Pandora’s Talisman collection debuted in August 2025 with 12 medallions, featuring common symbols like a lion, a rose, arrows, and celestial motifs like the sun and moon, and recently was expanded to include new designs.
Foundrae stated in its complaint that the initial Talisman collection is “so similar in look and feel to Foundrae’s signature pieces, and the marketing tactics promoting the collection so reminiscent of Foundrae’s aesthetic, that Foundrae found itself fielding inquiries from customers pointing out the similarities between Pandora’s Talisman collection and Foundrae’s medallions.”
Foundrae called out two of Pandora’s designs specifically, the “Passion” and “Balance” medallions, seen at the top of the story, claiming that they copy “nearly verbatim the protected expression of the original designs.”
On Sept. 10, a federal judge denied Pandora’s motion to dismiss, filed on April 20, and said the issue of whether or not copyright infringement was committed is better left to a judge and jury.
Neither Pandora nor Foundrae responded to National Jeweler’s request for comment on the denial.
Pandora agreed that Foundrae has valid copyrights on its medallion designs, noted the judge.
However, Pandora argues that “even if it did ‘actually copy’ Foundrae’s designs—which it steadfastly denies—Foundrae’s copyright infringement claim must fail because the designs are not substantially similar as a matter of law,” as per court documents.
“At the motion to dismiss stage, the court may assume that actual copying occurred and move straight to the issue of substantial similarity between the parties’ products,” federal Judge Colleen McMahon wrote in her ruling on the motion to dismiss.
When deciding on “substantial similarity,” the court can apply the ordinary observer test, which asks if the average person would say that one design is a copy of the other.
However, when an item has both protectable and unprotectable elements, the court will usually apply the “more discerning ordinary observer test,” which asks only if the elements that are protected are substantially similar.
Pandora wants the more discerning ordinary observer test applied, while Foundrae is asking that the ordinary observer test be applied.
The courts in this circuit have disagreed as to which test to apply in jewelry design cases, McMahon noted.
“But regardless of which test the court applies, I cannot conclude, on a motion to dismiss, that Foundrae’s medallions and Pandora’s charms are not substantially similar as a matter of law,” the judge wrote.
“Though the individual features of Foundrae’s medallions might not be protectible when viewed separately, they produce a specific ‘look’ when coordinated together.”
The judge noted that Foundrae is not claiming that the crossed arrows and sun and moon elements are individually protected, but rather that its “original selection, coordination, and arrangement of those individual elements is subject to copyright protection.”
Pandora has pointed to several dissimilarities between the two collections, but one could consider these differences to be minor, wrote McMahon, and “minor differences cannot overcome the more visually dominant similarities between the designs’ total concept and feel.”
Editors' Picks
Sponsored by
The Latest
AuctionsNov 02, 2026
197-Carat ‘Romanov Sapphire’ Heads to Sotheby’s GenevaThe rare jewel, which has links to Russia’s Romanov dynasty, is estimated to fetch up to $2 million.
CrimeNov 02, 2026
Customs Seizes More Than 400 Fake Audemars Piguet WatchesIt is one of several seizures of counterfeit jewelry and watches by U.S. Customs and Border Protection officials in Louisville this year.
CollectionsNov 02, 2026
Olympian Kristi Yamaguchi, Heller Jewelers Expand ‘Always Dream’ CollectionThe jewelry collection supports Yamaguchi’s Always Dream foundation, which provides reading and educational resources to families in need.
Brought to you by
How Overnight Mountings’ Bridal Builder Makes Custom Engagement Ring Design Easier to SellWith customization becoming more expected in engagement ring shopping, the Bridal Builder makes the process tangible.
Events & AwardsOct 30, 2026
Illuminating Carved Paraiba Pendant, Suite of Moonstones Wow at Spectrum AwardsSpectrum’s “Best of Show” honors went to a 101-carat Paraiba carved to look like Medusa that has a magnet-activated LED light.
Weekly QuizOct 29, 2026
This Week’s QuizTest your jewelry news knowledge by answering these questions.
TrendsOct 30, 2026
Edina Kiss’ Pendants Say ‘Eye’m Watching You’Our Halloween Pieces of the Week are four “Eye” pendants, each set with colorful gemstones.
WatchesOct 29, 2026
Bucherer Opens Rolex Boutique in Washington StateThe Rolex-owned retailer’s new 4,700-square-foot store’s façade honors the Pacific Northwest’s evergreen forests.
Brought to you by
A Diamond Is Forever Launches 2026 Holiday Campaign Championing Natural DiamondsA Diamond Is Forever's holiday campaign reimagines natural diamond icons for a new generation celebrating individuality.
TrendsOct 29, 2026
Amanda's Style File: All Treats, No Tricks Get into the Halloween spirit with this roundup of 13 spooky jewels.
MajorsOct 29, 2026
Gesswein Hires Longtime Bench Jeweler, Educator Ann CahoonCahoon was appointed strategic account and educational program manager at Gesswein, which recently joined Continental Buying Group.
MajorsOct 29, 2026
Amanda Seyfried Stars In Tiffany & Co.’s Holiday CampaignTiffany & Co.’s latest ambassador makes her debut in its “Love Is a Gift” holiday campaign.
EditorsOct 28, 2026
These Wicked Jewels Will Cast a Spell on YouFor her annual Halloween story, Senior Editor Lenore Fedow highlights bewitching jewels fit for a witch that go from day to unholy night.
CrimeOct 28, 2026
Man In Florida Who Swallowed Tiffany & Co. Earrings ConvictedJaythan Gilder was found guilty of robbery and grand theft after stealing and then ingesting nearly $800,000 worth of Tiffany & Co. jewelry.
SurveysOct 28, 2026
Consumer Confidence Up in October as Gas Prices EaseConsumer confidence remains on the long-term downward trend that’s persisted over the past few years, said a Conference Board economist.
MajorsOct 28, 2026
Stuller’s Holiday Campaign Lets the ‘Magic of the Moment’ ShineThe holiday campaign includes key jewelry trends, a curated holiday gift guide, and resources to help jewelers prepare for holiday shoppers.
SourcingOct 27, 2026
De Beers Celebrates the Holidays With New ‘Desert Diamonds’ CampaignThe “Icons” holiday campaign spotlights four classic diamond jewelry styles reimagined in “Desert Diamond” tones.
IndependentsOct 27, 2026
Solomon Brothers Acquires Mervis Diamond ImportersSolomon Brothers, which has three stores in the Metro Atlanta area, said it may continue to acquire other independent jewelers.
IndependentsOct 27, 2026
Gabriel & Co. Supports Charity Partner DKMS With Gala, New JewelsThe fine jewelry brand raised $2.3 million at its annual gala that supports the nonprofit’s fight against blood cancer and blood disorders.
Events & AwardsOct 27, 2026
JFC Announces 2027 ‘Facets’ HonoreesThe annual fundraising event is slated for June 6, 2027, at The Venetian Resort in Las Vegas.
CollectionsOct 26, 2026
Bliss Lau’s ‘Vantage’ Point Is the Hawaiian HorizonIn her “Vantage” collection, Lau explores heritage, identity, and inner strength through designs featuring blue-green Guatemalan jade.
MajorsOct 26, 2026
Tiffany & Co. Takes Consumers Behind the ScenesThe jeweler gave the public backstage tours of its flagship store and its design and innovation workshop as part of LVMH’s open house.
Events & AwardsOct 26, 2026
Support JFC’s ‘Monster Mash Challenge,’ If You DareVote for which jewelry professional should dress up as a monster to support Jewelers for Children’s annual Halloween fundraiser.
MajorsOct 23, 2026
PGI USA Set to Close at Year’s EndThe closure is part of a global restructuring that also includes PGI winding down its operations in Japan, South Korea, and Hong Kong.
SourcingOct 23, 2026
Rachel Chalchinsky’s ‘Survivor Tribute’ RingThe ring, our Piece of the Week, was designed by eight-year breast cancer survivor Rachel Chalchinsky of Color Source Gems.
TechnologyOct 23, 2026
JA Unveils New Website, LogoThe website offers enhanced member benefit access, industry directories, educational resources, a job board, and access to the MJSA Journal.
FinancialsOct 23, 2026
Kering’s Jewelry Sales Up Double Digits in Q3Boucheron and Pomellato had a strong third quarter, with Kering looking at jewelry as an increasingly important part of its portfolio.
CrimeOct 22, 2026
Jeweler Shot and Killed in His Suburban Cincinnati Store Tara Sinchuri was the owner of Everest Jewels in Fairfield, Ohio, and a father of three. He was found dead in his store on Tuesday.
